r/AskAGerman • u/Pristine-Amount-1905 • Jul 31 '25
r/AskAGerman • u/Adorable_Director812 • Jan 30 '25
Immigration Why german party is against immigration when germany needs millions of work force?
r/AskAGerman • u/eye_snap • Sep 07 '24
Scared of racism
We are planning to move to Germany soon, I am originally Turkish and my husband is Indian. But we are coming to Germany from New Zealand.
We've lived in NZ for more than a decade, met here, had our kids here, studied and built careers here. This is where we lived most our adult lives. We are culturally mostly Kiwi as we both love and embrace the Kiwi culture.
My husband got a job at a prestigious university in Germany, he is quite sought-after for his skill set, his field is biomed. I will be following him hoping to be able to find work in my own field. He has a PhD, I have Masters..
And yet we are brown. And our kids are brown.
We haven't faced any racism in NZ before. Never had to worry about it. But now I am worried.
First of all, as I understand Turks have a terrible reputation there. I feel like when I am there, Germans will see me as Turkish and Turks won't. I read that even if I was coming from Turkey there is a gap between older Turks and newer Turks in Germany.
I can actually deal with this, I lived in other countries before NZ, I am an adult. But I am especially worried for my kids.
They are 4 year old twins and just starting to understand what it means to be from here and there.. But they have no notion of what a Turkish identity is. Nor an Indian identity. They know they are half Turkish half Indian but they are very Kiwi in understanding and behaviour.
So when they are lumped in with me as Turkish, they will be lumped in with an identity that they've never even encountered really. They can't even speak Turkish (despite all my efforts, because we don't speak Turkish in our home).
So what do you guys think is waiting us over there? Will I and the kids be seen as Turks? How much racism does that entail? What do Germans think about Indians?
And we are coming as highly skilled migrants, I am not to the degree of my husband, but my husband is definitely not taking up a job that any old person in Germany could fill right now, I do honestly believe that he is bringing value to the country. Yet he will be walking on the street, being all brown, and I am worried.
How bad is the anti-immgrant sentiment right now? Are we better off staying in New Zealand in our cushy, cozy corner?
Edit: Thank you all very much for your responses. Main couple of points that came across are that we need to learn German (we are very happy to do so), and it really depends on where we live (we are moving to Cologne).
A lot of people asked why we would choose Germany over NZ. I couldn't answer this individually, I'll talk about it here.
NZ really is an amazing country but it is very small and very far away from the rest of the world. My husband works in scientific research and funding is very limited in NZ. In comparison Germany, even on a downswing, invests so much more in this field and so my husband has much greater number of opportunities in Germany and generally being close to other European countries. The same goes for my career, to a lesser degree but just by being one of the biggest economies in the world, Germany has some great opportunities for us both that NZ doesn't have.
Secondly, our families are not in NZ and we wish to be closer to them. It is impossible to visit family for a few days or a week from NZ, it is just too far, one way journey takes 2 days and costs accordingly. We both have aging parents, and kids who are growing up without really getting to know the before we lose the chance. From Germany, we can visit our families quite often and this plays a major role in our decision.
I hope that makes sense. Thank you so much for all the welcome messages! I saw all of it and I very much appreciate every single one. Vielen dank!
r/AskAGerman • u/edlen-ring • Oct 04 '23
Do you think it’s weird that Germany tries to act so pro recycling and environment but then offers no refill stations anywhere thus forcing you to buy bottled water?
r/AskAGerman • u/Tamarasaurus-Rex • Nov 14 '24
Boss said he won’t hire foreigners
Background: I’m a foreigner doing an Ausbildung in the IT department which just started in September. I’ve been there 10 weeks. My German level is B1 speaking B2 understanding. I haven’t had any problems so far at work or at school. We only speak German at work but from time to time, while having private conversations, I speak English with two specific colleagues I have befriended. for example on lunch or when we are alone in the office. I share an office with my team leader, and another student. The team leader was promoted and began as team leader the same time I started. He was not involved in my hiring process.
Situation: yesterday my team leader was speaking on the phone to a head hunter (not confined, just assumed based on the conversation and We have a position that needs to be filled in the department) He said very clearly(in German) „I want the best person for the job but I absolutely don’t want anyone who isn’t a native German speaker on my team. It wouldn’t be a good fit for us because we do a lot of work with consultants and I don’t want any problems with communication. I’m not racist or anything but it’s just not going to work“
No I didn’t misunderstand. and our desks face eachother and He said this while I was sitting and working across from him.
I haven’t shared this information with anyone other than my partner, who told me to not take it personally. But I’m having a really hard time not taking it personally, as a non native German speaker and a foreigner, it’s made me really sad. I’m really disappointed because I thought I was doing really well in the job and My Ausbilder has never expressed any concerns about my German.
Question: Is there anything I should do? On the one hand I’m currently in the probation period so I’m not super keen to stir up anything and I’m also a non confrontational person. but on the other hand I feel really uncomfortable now working with this person who’s made it clear that if he was the team leader at the time of hiring - he wouldn’t have given me a chance.
r/AskAGerman • u/SafeCondition340 • Dec 31 '25
Warum jetzt schon Feuerwerk?
Es ist doch noch garnicht Mitternacht, warum knallen die hier in der Großstadt schon Rum wie wild? War das schon immer so? Ich kann mich nicht daran erinnern...
r/AskAGerman • u/Exciting_Agency4614 • Feb 08 '25
Is anyone afraid that a repeat of the 1940s just got a lot more likely? How can it be prevented?
I noticed the anti-immigration sentiment brewing in Germany 2 years ago from online activity (I am one of those who believes online activity is a reliable enough gauge for public sentiment).
But with AfD rising higher and higher and more open white supremacy comments and protests and then, we have what's happening across the Atlantic, I am still shocked at how quickly we got here. Is anyone else afraid that a repeat of the 1940s just got a lot more likely?
I am afraid that if a repeat of 1940s were to happen, the current US presidency would not be inclined to step in and might even support it. The current signs are extremely worrying for me as a person of color.
How can it be prevented?
r/AskAGerman • u/WanabeInflatable • Feb 11 '25
Politics Defeating AfD by taking their voter base and addressing some of their concerns?
I lived in Germany for quite a while. Part of my family is still there and sending me photos of political events against nazi.
I understood the reason of AfD growth like that:
There are some concerns that traditional established parties ignored. AfD are populists they claim to solve these issues, but they are a bunch of neonazi and nutjobs. So a large group of people are voting for them not because they are really nazi, but because they want to send a message and break complacency about migration issues.
Now a major established "old" party tries to do a seemingly rational move. Lets take some of the AfD agenda and address it. Maybe if we start resolving the mess or at least pretend to - it will make "not really nazi" voters reconsider...
... And people just call them fascist colaborators. Also calling for ban of AfD or more rallies against them. But that won't work. Probably even backfire. How is it supposed to people voting for them to think better of democratic system and supposedly good parties?
r/AskAGerman • u/OpeningOk9665 • Jan 15 '25
How likely is a CDU-AFD Coalition in the new Government?
I am a non-religious female from a Muslim Country currently working in Germany, got a job offer from another Eu member country. I would like to stay in Germany maybe a few years more then want to return to my country but I am really afraid of anything or anybody AFD related. I am considering taking the job offer because I feel like CDU will do a coalition with AFD. What do you think dear Redditors, how likely is a CDU-AFD Coalition in the new Government?
r/AskAGerman • u/Noldorian • Dec 02 '23
Culture As an American living in Germany, how do you Germans feel about Craft Beer from the rest of the world especially from America and Canada?
I am 37M American and am married to a 41F German. I have lived in Germany for 11 years now and had this feeling i should ask you all about this. When I first arrived in Germany, I loved German beer. I live in the south near Stuttgart, so weizen is very popular here. But after a time my beer taste grew, and as a big Craft Beer connoisseur, my taste changed from German beer to American craft beer again.
And I don't ever see it changing again. I honestly feel like the Reinheitsgebot makes solid beer, but it leaves no room for variety and experimentation . Now don't get me wrong, I love German beer, but I will anyday take my American or even other non American craft beer over any German beer.
My favorite two beer types are non existent in Germany. One would by German standards be not considered a beer, and the other is not a German type at all.
Currently my absolute favorite type are Sour Beers(Wild Ales/Wild Beers), and my second favorite are IPA's. Man sours are just so damn addicting. I also enjoy Stouts, Ales, Barley Wines,Fruit Beers. I love the variety, and for me Germany does not offer that!
Don't get me wrong I dig a good Kristallweizen from time to time and even a good Doppelbock. But German beer does nothing for me anymore.
Yes, its good beer and you have made for a long time. it just no longer entices me. I order craft beer from the netherlands from a company where I pay for American/non American craft beers!
And I don't have to abuse it to enjoy it! And for those who would like to know, my absolute favorite IPA from America, would be the classic Lagunitas IPA. I hail from the bay area in California and so their home brewery isn't so far away!
So Germans, how do you feel about beer outside of Germany?
r/AskAGerman • u/chutneyglazefan • Oct 31 '23
Miscellaneous what do you think about veganism?
r/AskAGerman • u/napusenii • Feb 25 '25
Why do people vote for Die Linke?
Im asking this purely out of curiosity, with no intent to provocate. From what I've seen their foreign policy is horrid, they advocate for a complete stop of german arms sale to any conflict region in the world, they want to stop supporting ukraine, and wish for Germany to completely leave NATO. On migration, they have no real plan—just ‘open borders good’ without addressing the social and economic consequences. Their economic policies sound good on paper but rely on massive tax hikes and government control. The only decent thing they push for is stronger labor rights, but I feel like that gets overshadowed forementioned stances.
r/AskAGerman • u/TheseMarionberry2902 • Mar 05 '25
Culture Are Germans uptight?
As a German do you think you are uptight? And as a foreigner living in Germany do you think Germans are uptight?
I do feel that the german mentality is so uptight and strickted and chained within laws, frameworks, and rules, that leaves no space for imagination or creativity.
Don't get me wrong, I am not saying this is bad, it definitely helps society that is governed by the rule of law. But for example in academia where I have my working experiance, it is even more uptight, that I don't think Germany will be able to compete innovativley whether in research or in industry.
This is relevant for example in the auto industry that is being challenged now. Or for example on the application and implementation of technologies compared to Scandinavian countries who are way progressive. Compared also to the US, or Singapore or Finland.
It always feel that I am imprisoned within boarders and if I try to think differently, Germans will not understand because "it is not how we do things here in Germany". Nothing wrong in being structured but when it is hindring creative output and hindring people's way of thinking and doing things then it can be a problem on the wrong term.
Please give me your input and your ideas.
r/AskAGerman • u/slothbear13 • Nov 09 '24
Can American firefighter paramedics transfer their credentials to Germany?
I have been an American firefighter for 14 years, an EMT for 4 years, and a paramedic for 2 years. I have long considered the possibility that it may be necessary to leave the United States due to the political situation. Now seems more prudent than ever.
Would any of my credentials transfer to Germany or would I have to attend a German school and receive new certifications?
Also, I understand that Germany is very similar to the United States and that many firefighters, EMTs, and paramedics are unpaid volunteers. Are there also a significant amount of professionally paid departments? How comfortably can someone live on that yearly salary?
Thank you for your patience and any words of advice you are able to provide.
r/AskAGerman • u/Round_Reception_1534 • Mar 08 '25
Immigration LGBTQ+ refugees
I'm really sorry if such topics are not allowed here! I can't find info about this in the rules. I'm not asking for legal or professional advice! It's only a genuine question!..
So I know that Germany takes refugees (including LGBTQ+). The thing is, I'm a queer person from Russia, where people like me are officially recognized as members of the "international terrorist organization" and transitioning is totally banned (I've been struggling with gender dysphoria for many years, and now I can't get officially any help; furthermore, I also can be sent to war regardless of my mental condition or health). I don't know whether I have at least a theoretical chance to request asylum in Europe (and Germany specifically) because, as far as I know, one can apply for political asylum only if PERSONAL persecution (so being arrested, threatened, assaulted, etc.) begins in the homeland. So even if there were a death penalty for being "queer", it wouldn't be enough to get refugee status, even in theory. Is it the same for Germany? ..
I would be really grateful for any information because I couldn't find anything specific on the Net! Even just your personal opinion is valid
r/AskAGerman • u/June_Berries • Apr 23 '24
Immigration Is AfD enough of a threat that I shouldn’t move to Germany?
I’m an American and want to move to a country in the EU some time after I graduate high school. Germany was my country of choice because they’re generally pretty progressive and LGBT friendly (I’m bi and trans, this is important to me) and it just seemed like a decent country overall. I also met a friend online that I’m really close with who lives in Germany, which makes switching my country of choice a harder decision. I’ve been learning German and I’ve planned to study in Germany then eventually move completely, but I’ve heard that AfD has gained a scary amount of support and I’m scared of what will happen as a trans foreigner if they win, since they’re against both of those things. Does it seem possible that they’ll win?
r/AskAGerman • u/PassengerNarrow2484 • Jun 16 '25
Deutschland-ticket - why not have it?
Dear fellow Redditors,
I have been living in Germany for a while now, but clearly I'm not able to understand a lot of things. In my opinion, the Deutschland ticket was a great concept. If you don't know about it, it is a monthly subscription which allows the user to travel in most non-IC public transport within the country. It's even cheaper than several monthly tickets for the local public transport services, at least in cities, making these services often quite obsolete, while allowing you to go outside the boundaries of such services without even thinking.
Then why doesn't everyone have it? Is it cost (around 60€)? Is it technophobia? Is it ruralism? Please, I need to know!
r/AskAGerman • u/redditzxcv • Dec 12 '24
Are racism serious in Germany?
Hi! I personally experienced racism in Germany many times years agon(from verbal racism to spitting). I also met some people not wanting to talk to me after realising I'm Chinese. I know the image of China is not good in Germany and some people got prejudice on non-German. I can see the German government wants to attract the foreigners to work in Germany but the locals are still not ready for that. I am wondering if racism are a serious matter in Germany? Or the people do not treat it as a matter to openly speak it out?
r/AskAGerman • u/[deleted] • Nov 04 '24
Politics For those of you keeping up with American politics, does Trump’s rhetoric concern you?
I was having a conversation with a German friend today and I mentioned that Trump’s rhetoric has closely resembled Hitler’s. I included the blood poisoning, camps for immigrants, and the bloodiness of those said camps. He told me I was exaggerating. Does Trump’s name come up in German conversations in this light?
r/AskAGerman • u/Ola366 • Apr 09 '24
Politics Today, Nicaragua took Germany to the World Court for its involvement in Israel's war, which Germany denied. What are your personal thoughts on the event?
nicaragua is seeking an urgent order to end all german military sales to israel. i realize this is a touchy subject so don't know if this post will be taken down, but i don't believe in burying my head in the sand either. any thoughts on germany's defense at the ICJ today?
r/AskAGerman • u/throwawaythatfast • Jan 26 '24
Politics What could be done to stop the growth of the AfD and to prevent it ever coming to power?
As an immigrant, I'm scared.
As someone who loves history, I know one shouldn't ever underestimate such movements. Hitler's NSDAP got only a bit over 2,6% in the 1928 elections. Lots of people thought they were insignificant and could never come to power.
What can actively be done now (by the government, by parties, by civil society and organizations) to prevent this?
r/AskAGerman • u/[deleted] • Sep 24 '23
Do Uber drivers in germany drive fast on the Autobahn? Is it normal to ask them to if they're in a nicer car?
r/AskAGerman • u/xxdanslenoir • Aug 16 '24
Language Is it still extremely common for Germans to use the word „Zigeuner/-in“?
After living here for a little over a year now, I noticed that people use the word casually, as opposed to saying “Romani”.
On menus, I’ve seen „Zigeunerschnitzel“ as a super common offering as well.
Is it not as offensive compared to in English?