r/AskACobbler • • Apr 02 '14

Welcome to Ask A Cobbler! Please read to familiarize yourself with a few rules.

172 Upvotes

First off, I'd like to thank everyone for stopping by and showing their interest & support for shoe repair. In one day, we went from almost no subscribers to well over 100. This is an incredible start!

As we gain more members, I feel there needs to be a few ground rules just to keep things in order.

  1. Discussing of prices. Pricing on repair work depends on MANY factors than just the damage alone. While we may say a job will or will not be worth the money, saying it will cost $xx is against the rules and posts will be removed.

  2. Be respectful. The cobblers responding to your post have numerous years of experience and are here to offer some of their extensive knowledge of the craft at no charge. If you have been helped, a simple thanks goes a long way.

  3. When posting a picture of a damaged product, make sure the photos are detailed enough so that we can understand the exact condition, brand and anything else you think will help us to help you.

  4. Users with the "SSIA Member" flair are verified cobblers.

Rules will be amended an updated as we progress. Thanks for reading!


r/AskACobbler • • 6h ago

Are these boots salvageable? A cobbler returned them in this condition

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’d really appreciate some advice from experienced shoemakers and cobblers here.
I bought these boots second-hand while I was in Texas. They weren’t in perfect condition, but I really liked them and thought they were worth restoring.
I took them to a cobbler here in Austria, hoping to have them cleaned up and brought back to life a little.
Unfortunately, this is the condition I got them back in.
The soles now have what looks like a plastic layer glued directly over the original leather/wooden soles, and there are several scratches and marks across the boots, particularly around the toe area and the middle sections. Overall, they look considerably worse than before I took them in.
I’m honestly quite disappointed with the result, but before giving up on them, I’d like to ask people with more experience:
Do you think these boots are still salvageable?
Could the plastic layer be removed and the original soles restored or replaced? And is there a way to repair the scratches and bring the leather back to a decent condition?
I’d love to hear your honest opinions, even if the answer isn’t particularly encouraging.
Thanks in advance!


r/AskACobbler • • 9h ago

Rain caused the patina on my boots to become ugly/bumpy. How can I fix it without ruining the patina?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Normally I'd just go Saphir Renovateur and then Saphir Pommadier. But there's been a patina applied on these by a shoemaker (according to the guy I bought 'em from).

I walked out in some light rain, stepped in the tiniest of puddles maybe. Toe got wet and when it dried (I dried it rather quick by dapping with a towel and putting it next to a dehumidifier overnight) it looked bumpy and a bit ugly.

How do I fix this without ruining the patina?

I don't really have any pommadier in the right color for these either - the closest I've got is Hermes Rouge that I use on my 1990's brogues.


r/AskACobbler • • 1h ago

Waxy Kudus ROM

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 3h ago

Will this glue be fine to use for a minor fix on leather boots’ loose edges, will it rip the leather when i reapply later on?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 5h ago

How can I repair this problem ?

Post image
1 Upvotes

It’s the second pair I buy and I always have the same problem is there any way to fix this ?


r/AskACobbler • • 6h ago

Warn? Get new shoes?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 6h ago

New Shoes But Shattered Lining?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi all! So I recently purchased a second hand pair of Oxford wingtip heels that are the brand "strictly comfort" on vinted and when they arrived the inner lining was flaking, turning to dust, and half of it was already off. Allegedly the previous owner only wore them once, but i cant tell if this was a lie or not anymore. Is there any way to fix or remove the lining without ruining the shoes? The actual outer shoe is really well made and comfortable, pretty too, it's just every time I wear them i take off like 2 grams of lining.


r/AskACobbler • • 12h ago

Strange wear on ALOHAS Rivet loafers after just a few wears, is this normal?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I’ve had my ALOHAS Rivet loafers for about 3 months, and after the very first wear I noticed an unusual wear pattern on the sole. At first I thought I walked through saw dust or something similar?! Did not really think much of it, until I wasn’t able to wash it off.

The worn area is sharply defined (not general wear across the heel), and the exposed material feels and smells more like wood than leather. The smell is kind of pungent, not really that bad but when I keep the shoes in a closet my whole closet smells like this wooden smell.

Has anyone experienced something similar with ALOHAS loafers? Is this normal, or could it be a manufacturing defect?


r/AskACobbler • • 8h ago

How can I repair these myself?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Sorry to send several photos, I’d like to repair a deep scrap, and chip(piece still attached) of the sole, cracked sole, broken lace and a hole on the bottom. Could someone recommend good products to use?


r/AskACobbler • • 8h ago

Is this fixable?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Used a suede cleaner on these a few days ago. The rest of the boot is fine but the toe box still looks like this after brushing/using eraser. Not sure what happened here, but any help is appreciated.


r/AskACobbler • • 8h ago

loose instep fix

1 Upvotes

hello, I recently bought a pair of vintage frye harness boots, and they fit perfectly in terms of length and width, especially compared to some other boots I have, but the instep is just a bit high so I get much more heel slip than is comfortable. I’ve tried insoles, but they crush my toes, and adhesive tongue pads off amazon, but they don’t help enough for the heel slip to not still be a bit uncomfortable. I really like the look and feel of the boots, they are otherwise very comfortable and I don’t want to give up on them; so I’m wondering if a cobbler would be able to help me somehow? Or am I out of luck?


r/AskACobbler • • 8h ago

Is this repairable?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 9h ago

Sperrys creasing/splitting

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • 10h ago

Can this be fixed?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Noticed that my wear pattern between my right and left feet for my office shoes is different. I wear regular athletic sneakers otherwise and none of them have this pattern. Can this be fixed? Thank you in advance!


r/AskACobbler • • 11h ago

How to find repairable walking boots

1 Upvotes

For context, I live in the UK and have large feet (size 12/13).

A few years ago my dad convinced me to buy a decent pair of leather shoes for work. After some shopping around I settled on a pair of Loake Chelsea boots, and I adore them. They fit extremely well, feel great on the foot, and they click when I walk, which turned out to be surprisingly pleasant.

The problem is that the soles are very thin, even when new, and I can feel every bump underfoot. In the office that's not an issue, but I'd really like to walk longer distances in them, and they're just not up to it. So I'm in the market for a pair of decent leather boots for walking.

What I'm struggling with is finding boots with heels that are easy to repair. I tend to wear a wedge into the heel over time, so I replace it every so often to avoid doing my ankles a disservice. But most of the chunky-tread boots I've looked at (for example DR Martin's 1460) seem to have a one-piece sole, so fixing the heel means replacing the whole sole. That turns a £20 repair into a £75 one.

TLDR:

How do I find leather boots that are thick and shock-absorbing for walking, but where the heel can be replaced without replacing the entire sole?

Budget is about £200 if you have any suggestions.


r/AskACobbler • • 11h ago

Can these be resole?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Any good cobbler you would recommend in LA ? How much these work will go for or average cost in LA?


r/AskACobbler • • 6h ago

Took brand new shoes for installing sole protectors and cobbler changed heel base and heel tops because the shoes did level? Now the shoes look diffeeent

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The cobbler explained why he changed the heel height, but only after the work was completed. I understand that adding sole protectors can affect the shoe’s pitch and may require a heel adjustment. However, I brought in a brand-new pair of Allen Edmonds specifically to have sole protectors installed, not to have the original heel bases replaced. I believe he should have explained the situation and discussed my options with me before making such a significant modification to my shoes. I would have preferred to preserve the original heel profile and appearance.

First three pictures brand new shoes and last two cobbler’s work. Heels now are high. He shouldn’t had mess the heels. Commend what you think.


r/AskACobbler • • 7h ago

Peeled Leather Fix?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Got these wedges from Plato’s Closet that I thought were cute. There was some obvious wear at the front of the shoe but it didn’t bother me much.

The back of the sole had a sticker with price and barcode that I peeled off and some of the leather came off too 💔.

I obviously cant “fix” the leather but can I save them a bit and not have them look hideous? I just don’t want them to look peeled. If I could put something on top of the peeled bits that make them look decent enough would be great. Any suggestions?


r/AskACobbler • • 19h ago

How to remove stains from this nubuck nd suede shoes

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Pleasee help me fix this! 😭


r/AskACobbler • • 16h ago

please convince me if these boots need to be laid to rest

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

these are my favorite pair and the first pair of boots that i love aesthetically AND fit me which has been so rare in the past. i must have gotten it repaired a dozen times. i feel though, that this time round, it is too far gone. yet, a part of me is still hopeful and haven't been able to throw it away. is there any hope at all or is it really time? thank you.


r/AskACobbler • • 17h ago

How can I restore my genuine UGG boots after repeated rain exposure? Dark water stains and rough, damaged suede.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi! I have a pair of genuine Chestnut UGGs that have been exposed to rain several times. Previously, the water stains disappeared after drying, but this time dark stains have remained, especially around the toes.

The affected areas also feel very rough, dry and matted, almost as if the suede nap has worn off. The texture looks noticeably different from the unaffected areas (see photos).

Has anyone experienced this? Are these just stubborn water stains, or is the suede permanently damaged? Can the original texture and colour be restored? Would UGG Cleaner & Conditioner help, or is professional restoration a better option?
I’d really appreciate any advice. Thank you!


r/AskACobbler • • 17h ago

Restoring semi vintage heels

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Found these beauties at a thrift store, they’re a semi known brand that are on the older side- decided that even though they’re slightly too big on me, and I’m usually a block heel girl, i wanted to restore them. I’m wondering if the stiletto could be turned into a block heel like i sketched in the image? I’d be willing to pay a real cobbler or do it myself. I wouldn’t wanna lower the height or add to it, any height is fine for me. I prefer the look and stability of block heels but I’ll learn to walk with stilettos just for these heels. Also, any tips on restoring this kinda leather shoe? The soles had to go so i need glue and sole recommendations :]


r/AskACobbler • • 1d ago

Fixing blemish on new shoes

Post image
2 Upvotes

I recently received a new pair of Solovair High Shine loafers, but there’s a strange mark on the toe that almost looks like they’ve been stepped on.

I understand that the leather isn’t particularly high quality and has a coated finish, but I’m wondering if there’s a way to repair the mark or at least make it less noticeable.

I can return them, but before going through the hassle, I wanted to see if anyone has had a similar issue or knows of a simple fix. Would something like gently applying heat help, or would that risk damaging the finish?