r/AskACobbler • • Mar 18 '26

Why are traditional shoes not foot-shaped?

Post image
5.8k Upvotes

I love traditional craftsmanship and am generally highly skeptical of miraculous claims about new technologies. But the whole “barefoot shoes” phenomenon makes a lot of sense to me, and I can’t understand why we’ve all been wearing shoes that pinch our toes for the past few centuries. I have a few pairs of gorgeous, hundreds of dollars stitched leather shoes that all pinch my toes, even when I size up, even when I order EE width (which are way too big everywhere except the toe btw). And then I buy some cheapo “barefoot” foot-shaped shoes, they’re shit quality and I can tell they won’t last long, but they are the only non-sneakers shoes I’ve ever owned which don’t hurt my pinky toes. I looked at a lot of foot measurement statistics, and I don’t even have particularly wide toes for my foot! So why do we do this to ourselves?


r/AskACobbler • • Jul 04 '26 WOW Bravo

Is it fixable? Yes. Yes it is! Another example:

3.1k Upvotes

Is it fixable?! Stumbled on this awesome example! Sergio Alberini fixes this wrecked pair of boots!

Fun fact you probably did not know: Calzolaio is Italian for Cobbler. The language however does not differentiate between Cobbler, Shoemaker, or Cordwainer like English does!


r/AskACobbler • • Dec 20 '25

Trying not to cry

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

Took my brand new boots to get a rubber half sole added but they scraped away so much leather behind the rubber sole that is now unprotected… it looks horrible. Not sure what to do 😭😫 can this even be fixed?!


r/AskACobbler • • Oct 01 '25 Bravo

A nice example of the fuss

1.0k Upvotes

Not my work but beautiful work


r/AskACobbler • • Nov 23 '23

Cobbler laughed my mom out of the store. Can these be salvaged?

Thumbnail
gallery
960 Upvotes

These Steve Maddens were my mom’s favorite shoes until they cracked like this. She says the cobbler just laughed at her when she took them in, but is there any possible way to fix these? I’d be willing to pay a pretty penny for it, I’d like to fix them as a gift.


r/AskACobbler • • Jan 17 '25

Local colber said sole can not be replaced

Thumbnail
gallery
878 Upvotes

Got these old pair of redwing boots went to a colber in the suburb he said these sole can not be replaced he can only attached some rubber to enforce the sole. I thought the redwing style boots is known for resolable?


r/AskACobbler • • Mar 16 '20

What is it like being a cobbler?

Post image
851 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Dec 01 '25

Dog chewed toe of Corral Cayman cowgirl boots from my late mom. Can these be fixed and if so does anyone here work with this kind of leather?

Thumbnail
gallery
774 Upvotes

I’m devastated because I’ll never get another gift from my mom, so I cherish the ones I have

Edit - I like the toe caps plan. If anyone knows any artisans they reccomend, let me know. I’m in New England, but will be in Arizona in a couple of months as well. I like that idea a lot, thanks for all the suggestions <3

Here’s the culprit, our coonhound Junebug Carter Cash: https://imgur.com/a/IL4mMod


r/AskACobbler • • Jul 28 '25

Literally every pair of shoes iv bought in the last ten years split like this on my right foot. Do I just walk wrong or is there something more?

Post image
737 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Aug 13 '25

What’s this construction called, and what should I buy to avoid this in the next belt?

Post image
730 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Jan 12 '26 Bravo

Another excellent example…

666 Upvotes

Hey everyone with the increased posts of “can this be repaired?” I thought I’d post this excellent example of a recraft/ repair by KW Shoe Repair in Canada. (ShopGoodsAndServices in Los Angeles also does this). It’s an excellent example of taking a very dead shoe not designed to be repaired and making it into something that can live on for decades.


r/AskACobbler • • Feb 20 '24

Any way to remove leather dye from varnished wooden floor? Or am I just completely screwed?

Post image
645 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Feb 22 '24

[Update] managed to pretty much remove the "leather dye" stain. Thank you for helping me get away with it!

Thumbnail
gallery
632 Upvotes

It was done with a combination of denatured alcohol, acetone-free nail polish remover, and elbow grease. Might still have damaged the varnish of the floor (hope not), but my landlord will have a look at it.


r/AskACobbler • • Jan 09 '24

could a cobbler add a steel toe like this to any converse shoe?

Post image
619 Upvotes

hi! Wondering, if i brought in a regular converse shoe, would they be able to replace the toe with a steel toe like this one? And if so how much would that usually cost? Not familiar with what cobblers can do.


r/AskACobbler • • Sep 04 '25

First time shoe repair, took a chance on local shop

Thumbnail
gallery
539 Upvotes

This is my first ever repair of shoes. I’ve done a little bit of research but not enough to really gauge quality, so posting here to see thoughts on this repair. I took a pair of Allen Edmonds McAllister shoes by a local shop for a quote and it was very reasonable ($58 after tax). I thought that was a good price so went ahead and left them.

Biggest thing that stands out to me is use of a different sole than what I’ve read about or seen recommended (Carolina Oak v JR) and use of a half sole vs a full sole? Are these things I should be concerned about? Anything I should consider in the future or ask about next time? Is this local shop good enough to continue supporting? TIA!


r/AskACobbler • • Mar 23 '26

Can a cobbler lengthen the strap?

Post image
443 Upvotes

just bought these margiela sandals! after I bought them and was walking around I noticed the 2nd strap was really digging into my right foot probably because it's slightly wider than my other one haha. is it possible for a cobbler to make it longer? I just spent $400 on these 😭


r/AskACobbler • • Nov 29 '23

Interview ready

Thumbnail
gallery
408 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Oct 02 '26

Did they screw up this resole?

Thumbnail
gallery
388 Upvotes

I think these do not look right at all, I asked for a lug sole to be attached to a pair of corcoran jump boots, which are flat. Cobbler said he’d just cut some soles to fit onto the heel and the actual sole. These look terrible and he scuffed the boots up.

Why would the tread go all the way to the center of the boots between the heel?

EDIT: I was sitting in the parking lot staring at the shoes. I went back inside and told him these literally looked terrible, and why would the tread continue all the way back up against the heel. Showed him PHOTOS OF OTHER SAME BOOTS BEING REPAIRED, and he argued with me that it doesn’t look good. Making me look dumb. I literally showed him other boots saying how no one has repaired it that way.

He then argued with me he tried to shine to boots and I said no way shining the boots would result in scratches. He then became quiet. I told him usually you need to blend the soles back into the original sole not just slap the whole thing on. And he said okay he’ll cut out the section and redo it and to pick it up next week. At this point I just let him redo it, but I have low hopes.

Charged me $100 bucks for this, I paid for service before seeing it because that’s their policy. Seemed like they had a lot of good reviews.


r/AskACobbler • • Apr 09 '26

Could a cobbler make these less pointy? Cut away the excess and resole I guess.

Post image
387 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Feb 19 '24

Earlier today I asked how I could darken these tan Birkenstock Lace Up Oxfords. Several of you suggested Mink Oil. It did the trick. These are before and after pictures. This was the color I was looking for. Thank you!

Post image
359 Upvotes

r/AskACobbler • • Aug 03 '25

Any hope of fixing this?

Post image
358 Upvotes

Asking for an old friend


r/AskACobbler • • Sep 27 '26

I tried polishing my Johnston Murphys and this happened. They looked better before. What’s going on?

Thumbnail
gallery
336 Upvotes

Steps I took:

  1. Wiped away visible dirt with a tiny bit of water and a cotton rag

  2. Applied black polish with a fresh cotton rag

  3. Buf

fed with horse hair brush

Initially they looked great, but after about 10 minutes this discoloration emerged. It’s interesting to me that it only happened on the toe box and not the back of the shoes.


r/AskACobbler • • Apr 26 '26

Why did this happen to my almost $300 boots?

Post image
322 Upvotes

These were my favorite boots, I’m devastated. Haven’t even had them for a year. 😔

Edit*** some people have asked me to provide the brand. These are the Vince Camuto Sangeti Boot.


r/AskACobbler • • 27d ago

Shop said these are irreparable

Thumbnail
gallery
314 Upvotes

The shop i went to wouldnt take these, he said they were made that way and couldn't be fixed. I would be willing to pay for the price of the shoe for the repair because im zero waste and dont want to buy brand new. Are these truly not salvagable and if so what could I do to reuse the remnants?