r/Aristotle • • May 19 '26

For the MODS. Please ban this user harrassing me.

Post image
0 Upvotes

This user is trying to cyber bully me, but I am a Enlightened Martial Artist, and his attack backfired.

But for the sake of protecting others who may not be as strong as I, please permanently ban this user from this VIRTUOUS reddit group.

I just investigated his comment history.

He goes around insulting others in spiritual reddits. Very abusive type behavior, not cool!


r/Aristotle • • May 22 '26

When led by desires, how far can people go

Post image
1 Upvotes

People need to be put in barriers!

Legal, social, religious. Whatever it is, there must be a limit. And limitations are rational distinction between good and bad, it's absence gives an opportunity for animalistic desires to control


r/Aristotle • • Dec 12 '25

Formal Statement of Logic Realism Theory (LRT) as a working global physical theory

0 Upvotes

Name: Logic Realism Theory (LRT)

Domain: Fundamental physics (applies universally to all physical systems, scales, and interactions in our universe).

Core Postulate:

The three classical laws of logic are prescriptive physical constraints on the actualization of any state of affairs:

1	Law of Identity

For any physical entity x, at any time t, in any inertial reference frame:

x ≡ x

(No physical system may instantiate an entity that fails to be identical to itself.)

2	Law of Non-Contradiction (LNC)

For any well-defined physical property P of a system S, at any time t, in any single reference frame and in the same respect:

¬ [ P(S, t) ∧ ¬P(S, t) ]

(No physical system may simultaneously possess and not possess the same property in the same respect.)

3	Law of Excluded Middle (LEM)

For any well-defined physical property P of a system S, at any time t, in any single reference frame:

P(S, t) ∨ ¬P(S, t)

(Every physical system must definitively either possess or not possess any well-defined property; no third ontological option is physically realizable.)

Physical Interpretation:

These are not axioms of mathematics, not rules of human reasoning, and not conventions of language.

They are universal boundary conditions imposed on the space of all physically possible states.

Any solution to any dynamical law (Schrödinger equation, Dirac equation, Einstein field equations, Yang–Mills equations, Wheeler–DeWitt equation, etc.) that assigns non-zero ontological weight (i.e., non-zero probability amplitude that becomes actualized) to a state violating (1), (2), or (3) is forbidden by physics.

Empirical Prediction:

Zero observable violations of (1), (2), or (3) will ever be recorded in any completed physical measurement, at any energy scale, in any reference frame, under any interpretation of quantum mechanics or quantum gravity.

Falsification Criterion (single, sharp, and experimentally achievable)

Produce and replicate one unambiguous event in which a physical system is observed to instantiate P and ¬P simultaneously and in the same respect, with no subsequent resolution, hidden variable, contextual dependence, or relational interpretation that restores consistency with (2) or (3).

A single confirmed instance suffices for falsification.

Current Experimental Status (December 2025):

•	Not falsified.

•	Zero confirmed violations across all regimes of classical, relativistic, quantum, and high-energy physics.

•	Strongest stress tests (quantum interference, entanglement, black-hole physics, high-energy particle collisions) consistently yield outcomes compatible with (1)–(3).

•	All apparent paradoxes dissolve upon closer inspection without requiring ontological violation of the laws.

Corroboration Status (strict Popperian sense):

Strongly corroborated: the theory forbids an easily conceivable class of events; that class has been searched for aggressively in the domains most likely to produce members; no member has ever been found.

Burden of Proof:

Until a reproducible violation meeting the falsification criterion is produced, Logic Realism Theory remains the only known universal constraint consistent with the entirety of physical evidence.

The burden lies entirely on any claimant who asserts that the laws of logic are not physically prescriptive to exhibit the required counterexample.

This statement is deliberately framed in purely physical and operational terms, not as a philosophical conjecture.


r/Aristotle • • Oct 05 '23

Aristotle’s politics

0 Upvotes

I am writing an essay for my philosophy class that disagrees with (and basically disproves) the points made in aristotle’s Politics. Other than his want for slaves and women to be under the higher classes and his deep hatred for women and slaves in general, what are some talking points that I could do some more research and thinking on? The assignment has literally zero foundation and I basically have to make the format up myself, so I could use some help.


r/Aristotle • • Jun 07 '24

Can I get a list of Aristotles topics?

0 Upvotes

I'm talking about the different topoi we use to construct arguments.


r/Aristotle • • Aug 05 '20

Aristotle's Irredeemable Ableism

Thumbnail
churchlifejournal.nd.edu
0 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • May 14 '26

I have completed the comparison. I will write up details for steps 2 through 8 in the next comming days or weeks.

0 Upvotes

I can now officially confirm that Lord Buddha and Lord Aristotelēs taught the SAME path to Enlightenment!!!! This is the Greatest "good!"

Virtue as a mean = The Middle way (THE EIGHTFOLD PATH FOR STOICS):

  1. Right view = Phronesis

  2. Right thought = Prohairesis

  3. Right speech = Aletheia (truthfulness) + Eunoia (Goodwill) + Sophrosyne (self-restraint)

  4. Right action = Andreia (courage) + Praxis (actions of deliberate desire)

Right action is a product of steps 1, 2 and 3.

5. Right livelihood = Diakaiosyne (justice)

6. Right effort= (Askesis: preventing and abandoning) + (Ethismos: cultivating and maintaining.)

7. Right mindfulness = Sophrosyne (reflection) + nepsis (watchful vigilance)

8. Right concentration = EUDAIMONIA = The state of AWARENESS and COMPASSION attained by Lord Buddha, Lord Christ, and Lord Aristotelēs

With love and embrace,

The Dharmapalalama

Om Shanti L'chaim, I and I, Amen

P.s:

I hearby command Stoics, Christians and Buddhists to intermarry!

This is the Truth and the Life.

This is the Path and the Way.

This is the Eye and the Light.


r/Aristotle • • Jan 17 '25

How Galileo used the telescope to refute Aristotle and Ptolemy (and got himself into trouble with the Pope at the same time).

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Oct 23 '19

Aristotle's famous conjecture proven wrong - "division of zero by zero"

Thumbnail vixra.org
0 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Nov 03 '22

Karuna as cultural theme

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Jan 03 '26

The Skill of Refuting Sophists (A Primer on Performative Contradiction)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Feb 11 '24

Aristotle’s Approach

3 Upvotes

I am writing a paper on Aristotle for my Business Ethics class and I am stuck on a few questions.

  1. What are two fundamental assumptions of Aristotles approach to ethics that are typical of most Ancient Greek philosophers?

  2. On the basis of Aristotles discussion of virtue, what appears to be the Greek conception of the good man? Does it differ from the Christian conception of the good man? If so, how does it differ?

  3. In what ways do you consider Aristotle’s moral philosophy applicable or inapplicable to present day problems and needs?

Thank you in advance!


r/Aristotle • • May 24 '26

Aristotle without the scholastics

6 Upvotes

The scholastics have contributed immensely to what is known as ‘Aristotelianism’. But due to the scholastic interest in Aristotle, many of the Aristotelian doctrines were coloured in favour of Judeo-Christian philosophy, and as a result the Aristotle that we read today in universities has a strong Judeo-Christian stench. The revolt of the 17th century philosophers against Aristotelianism, was a revolt against the scholastic’s Aristotle (at-least this is what I would argue).

I do not know to what extent it is possible, but were we to imagine an Aristotle without the medieval thinkers interpretations, what would we get? Which theories, apart from the notion of the ‘prime-mover’, do you think would be reading most differently than we do today?


r/Aristotle • • Jul 05 '25

Speak to Aristotle

0 Upvotes

I came across this site where you can speak to Aristotle 😄

https://www.askthesage.com/


r/Aristotle • • Nov 18 '22

Aristotle’s defense of slavery shows that even the most brilliant philosophers can succumb to the tendency to uncritically accept the practices of one’s own society.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Jan 25 '26

How to Destroy Philosophers

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Mar 19 '26

Poetics and Timothée Chalamet ??

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
2 Upvotes

Hey all - I’m a writer with a conviction that we can use literature to understand the hectic pace of our modern lives - most recently, I feel like Balletgate has been dominating the discourse so I wrote an article on how you can track Chalamet’s career thus far onto the greek tragedy and what that means for how we see him as a pop cultural figure.

If any of y’all can give it a read and a share, you’d make my day :)


r/Aristotle • • Jul 29 '22

I identify as an Aristotelian social democrat. Unfortunately reading material about this political philosophy is scant and or non existent please link me reading so that I might expand my knowledge of this political philosophy!

3 Upvotes

As above. Thank you!


r/Aristotle • • Aug 15 '26

If Aristotle argues that substance is primary because other categories depend upon it for their existence, what ultimately grounds the identity of a substance through change?

1 Upvotes

Is a thing’s form sufficient to explain its persistence through alteration, or does Aristotle’s hylomorphic framework leave us with a deeper question: what makes the same being remain itself while continually becoming something different?


r/Aristotle • • Aug 07 '26

Flute-tur's philosophy

0 Upvotes

Philosophy

  1. " you want to enforce your justice upon me, it has ever changing depending on who's in charge, i say good day, dear sense of morality, but before I go, I'll give you this"(he delivers a quick swift, brutal kick to the person's groin)

  2. "It was meant to prove a point that there are consequences whether they be good or bad"

  3. "the truth hurts, so the pain you're feeling right now must be true","see the gray in life"

  4. "i "I appreciate the effort. I was born from circumstance. I never asked for it, but I won't deny it either. Everyone lives as they see fit. As for me? I exist in an ever-changing fundamental state.""

  5. "order meaning how curious, that's a real head scratcher, frankly I don't care either way, if you wanna be my friend, be my friend.If you wanna be my lover, be my lover, i don't question it, i prefer that way"

  6. "my meaning is life, the journey and everything in between, whether they are fleeting moment or eternal, they are precious to me"

  7. "i'll gladly share my love friendship, philosophy, perspective and my journey, i am not greedy or glutton, except when it comes to certain matters"

  8. "your journey sounds fantastic, a being like myself, I acknowledge your desires,aren't we all ruled by our desires, i just use look elsewhere"

  9. "ever moving, ever changing, ever evolving, progress is moving forward, it is good to just slow down but if we stop well, you know, would that means"

  10. "a home you say, that's a very interesting question.And to answer that is, i prefer to let fate decide where my home is, well I choose to rest and put up my feet. We'll be up to chance, until then it's a mystery"

  11. " a place where i'm forced to break my own rules, you jess, my rules are more like guideposts, if that were ever to happen,well that's no skin off my bones"

  12. "Whether I'm the author or the passenger, I'd rather be both."

  13. "Analyze me. Dissect me. Diagnose me. Give me a label if you must. Does that solve anything? Am I the problem... or is your problem simply that I'm different?"

  14. " Now sit I cooked, food tastes better when it's being shared especially with drinks"

  15. "I keep my promise even if that person's dead"

  16. "I take full responsibility for my actions, but I choose not to be burdened"

  17. "I do not mourn death, but rather celebrate their lives"

  18. "Sometimes the light(good) can become too light but Darkness(Evil) can we be confused aimlessly wandering"

  19. " Sometimes you must flow or bend"

  20. " Building a foundation is good,Just remember wearing your build it"

  21. " I love a good fight,But I never look for it, whether it's Triumph victory or a devasta loss(even if I sustain injury small or great) I welcome it all"

  22. "You don't know if you're gonna wake up next too him/her or he/she is going to steal your pants"


r/Aristotle • • Jul 21 '26

The Republic and Ritam… Beyond the Politics of Right and Wrong

0 Upvotes

perhaps not every question finds its final answer in dharma… because dharma itself may not be the final layer of truth…dharma is about how we ought to live… how we understand our responsibilities…how we distinguish right from wrong… and how we conduct ourselves in relation to others and to the world around us…
but behind dharma lies something deeper…
ritam…if dharma is the path we try to walk… ritam is the order within which every path exists…dharma belongs to the realm of human understanding… and therefore its expression may change with time… place… circumstance… and consciousness…ritam does not change with our understanding of it…it is the deeper order of existence itself…the sun does not rise because we have declared it righteous to rise… the river does not flow towards the sea because a scripture has instructed it to do so…

the seed does not become a tree because society has agreed upon a moral principle…they simply participate in an order greater than themselves…

that order… that balance… that natural relationship between cause and consequence… between becoming and dissolving… between receiving and returning… is perhaps the simplest way to understand ritam…and once we understand this difference… perhaps many of our questions begin to look different…
when we speak of education… books are important… knowledge is important… reason is important…but education cannot end with knowing what has already been written…a truly educated mind must also learn how to observe… how to question… how to remain silent before something it does not yet understand…because information can tell us how the world works…but wisdom teaches us how to live within it…
and perhaps the purpose of education is not merely to fill the mind with answers… but to make the mind spacious enough to encounter questions without fear…the same is true when we speak of the constitution…

rights are essential… because without rights human dignity can easily become vulnerable to power…but rights cannot exist meaningfully without responsibility…if i demand my freedom while remaining indifferent to the consequences of my freedom upon others… i may possess a right… but perhaps i have not yet understood its dharma…

a healthy society therefore cannot survive merely by asking…what am i entitled to…it must also quietly ask…what do i owe to the world in which i wish to live freely…

the two questions are not enemies…they complete each other…and when we speak of nature… perhaps our first mistake is in imagining that nature is something outside us…we speak of protecting rivers… saving forests… conserving the earth…but the river is not separate from us…the water moving through the river will one day move through our bodies… the air passing through the forest will enter our lungs… the soil into which one life disappears will eventually nourish another…we are not standing outside nature trying to save it…we are nature becoming conscious of itself…and perhaps this is one of the clearest places where ritam can still be felt…
everything receives…everything gives…everything arises…everything passes…nothing exists entirely for itself…

democracy too must be understood with the same clarity…the voice of every person deserves to be heard…but hearing every voice does not mean that every voice becomes truth…numbers can decide who governs…numbers cannot decide what is true…a majority can make a decision… but truth does not become true because many people agree with it… nor does truth become false because only one person is willing to stand beside it…perhaps the deeper purpose of democracy is therefore not merely to count voices…it is also to cultivate minds capable of using those voices with wisdom…
and this brings us again to the difference between dharma and ritam…dharma is our attempt to live rightly within existence…ritam is the order through which existence moves whether or not we understand it…dharma asks something from us…ritam simply reveals something to us…dharma asks…how should i act…ritam quietly reminds us…

every action enters the larger movement of existence… and nothing remains without consequence…perhaps that is why we should be careful about looking at every question through the same coloured lens…

religion is one lens…science is another…law is another…politics is another…tradition is another…modernity is another…each may allow us to see something…but no single lens allows us to see everything…and wisdom may begin when we become capable of putting the lens down for a moment…and simply looking…then perhaps we begin to understand that not everything old is superstition…and not everything new is progress…not every desire automatically becomes a right…not every tradition automatically becomes wisdom…not every majority possesses truth…and not every disagreement requires an enemy…perhaps our greatest difficulty is not that truth has disappeared…perhaps we have simply become too noisy to notice the order in which truth quietly lives…

we keep asking which side is right…which ideology is right…which religion is right…which generation is right…but ritam does not belong to a side…the river does not argue with the mountain…the night does not defeat the day…autumn does not accuse spring of being different…each arrives…each performs its nature…each gives way when its time is complete…perhaps there is something profoundly peaceful in understanding this…we do not have to control everything in order to belong to existence…we do not have to possess every answer in order to live meaningfully…we do not even have to resolve every contradiction before we can find peace…

perhaps we only need to become quiet enough to recognise the larger order within which all our questions arise…dharma can then become our sincere attempt to walk consciously…and ritam can become the humility of knowing that the ground beneath our feet was here long before we began walking…

perhaps that is the relationship between the two…dharma is the lamp we carry…ritam is the dawn that does not depend upon our lamp…we may protect the flame… we may walk carefully by its light… we may even disagree about the direction in which it should guide us…but eventually… when the sun rises…we understand that the light was always larger than what we could hold in our hands…and perhaps this understanding does not leave us with another argument to win…perhaps it leaves us with something quieter…

the humility to listen…the wisdom to act…the courage to question…and the peace to know that we are not separate from the order we have spent so long trying to understand…

we are already within it…we have always been within it…and perhaps… for a moment… that is enough…


r/Aristotle • • Apr 18 '24

Guys did you see Plato's new anime?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • May 01 '21

Tragic Hero

1 Upvotes

What is Aristotle's theory about tragic hero ?


r/Aristotle • • Mar 29 '21

What does this mean. I'M confused by the use of the words contingent and variable at the end.

1 Upvotes

A Probability is a thing that usually happens; not, however, as some definitions would suggest, anything whatever that usually happens, but only if it belongs to the class of the ’contingent’ or ’variable’

From his book rhetoric,

end of page 11 to page12

http://www.bocc.ubi.pt/pag/Aristotle-rhetoric.pdf


r/Aristotle • • Sep 22 '23

Zaza got bro out here like the thinker NSFW

Post image
0 Upvotes