r/Aristotle • • Jun 12 '26

Aristotle's intended audience: ethical arguments can't be appreciated by just anyone. In the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle argued that young and immature people, in particular, aren't the right audience for ethics because they don't know enough about life and won't change their ways.

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
269 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • May 14 '26

Where Do I Start with Aristotle?

Post image
266 Upvotes

NOTE: I am currently reading Fragments by Heraclitus.


r/Aristotle • • May 02 '26

Aristotle believed that true happiness wasn’t simply about pleasure. Instead, he argued that the best life is one where people pursue purpose

Thumbnail
thewisestreetblog.wixsite.com
259 Upvotes

He believed that true happiness wasn’t simply about pleasure. Instead, he argued that the best life is one where people pursue purpose growth and virtue, Happiness happens in the moments, whereas meaning happens in momentum and pattern. Aristotle has changed his way from his predecessors (Plato and Socrates) teaching to attain happiness and goodness. 

Even scientists split the difference between the two types of happiness:

  • Hedonic Happiness depends on enjoyment, pleasure; and

  • Eudaimonia Happiness depends on meaning, values and reflection.


r/Aristotle • • Dec 30 '25 LOL

I regret to inform you that logic has been deployed to announce its own failure.

Post image
179 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Jun 08 '26

Most of ancient Greek literature is lost. This is an interview with Monte Johnson about how he, collaborating with Doug Hutchinson, reconstructed Aristotle's lost Protrepticus from papyrus fragments and quotations. This text dates from the 350s BCE, when Aristotle was still at Plato's Academy!

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
117 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Sep 12 '25

Meaning of "God is pure thought thinking about pure thought"

108 Upvotes

In the Metaphysics, Aristotle posits that "God is pure thought thinking about pure thought."

He then goes on to infer that God is thinking about himself.

In Christian theology, the pure thought that thinks is the Father, and the pure thought that proceeds from the pure thought's thinking is the Son or Logos, which is the self-expression of God.

"Thought", however, is an activity, not an actor. How can an activity also make an activity?

It's like saying "Motion moves" and when it does it, it also "moves Motion."

It's also like saying, "Love loves love itself."

This is pure activity doing pure activity.

There appears to be no actor in the description of the divine.


r/Aristotle • • Aug 14 '26

Aristotle thought that the goal of ethics was action, not knowledge. If someone isn't going to change their behavior, then there is no point in them learning ethics. And we need to re-adjust our expectations for precision: very often, the correct answer to an ethical question is 'it depends'.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
79 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Aug 08 '25

Ancient philosophers and scientists were puzzled by how and why some humans are born female and others male. Aristotle argued that the offspring is female only when the father's sperm is concocted badly due to a deficiency of heat.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
76 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Nov 25 '25

Can somone help me understand this?

Post image
72 Upvotes

When he talks about the souls rational elements, what does he mean by this? Also rational agency what does that mean? And Finaly can someone give me an example or explaination of what "activity of the soul that expresses our goodness."


r/Aristotle • • Dec 27 '25

Would you openly share your appreciation of Aristotle with others?

65 Upvotes

I'll admit at first I didn't really like Aristotle due to being exposed to his more controversial opinions early on, however, I've always been fond of Greco-Roman literature and philosophy, so I decided to give his actual works a try.

It was when I read On Politics that true appreciation began. I noticed that a lot of his opinions and advice held a lot of relevance in the modern despite being over 2000 years old. For example, he advised in measuring the success of a polis/economy by observing the health and quality of the middle class. This contrasts modern economists who measure it by GDP.

I'm currently at a state where even though I don't agree with him on everything I can still understand and respect the thought process that lead him to these conclusions.

But the main problem modern Aristotleans/peripatetics face is that it really is hard to separate yourself from Aristotle's more radical opinions (which seems to have caught mainstream media's attention). With Stoicism there's several writers to draw from, so if say Seneca says something controversial there's still Epictetus to fall back on. But peripatetics are going to have to rely on Aristotle's works most of the time.

So in short there's a real risk of you being alienated and closed off by sharing your appreciation with others. Or maybe i'm wrong, what are your experiences?


r/Aristotle • • Jul 18 '25

Ancient philosophers were intensely curious about the nature and possibility of change. They were responding to a challenge from Parmenides that change is impossible. Aristotle developed an important account of change as involving three “starting points” to explain the possibility of change.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
64 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • May 22 '26

One of Aristotle's most famous theories is that of the character virtues. He thought there was an objectively correct amount of an emotion to feel in each situation, and we are virtuous when we feel that emotion correctly. For instance, courage is the virtue we have when we feel fear appropriately.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
58 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • May 14 '26

Aether = Dark Matter

Post image
49 Upvotes

Aristotelēs had a Geocentric view of the universe only because this was a trivial detail at the time compared to the URGENT MORAL and POLITICAL teachings he provided us all.

Copernicus was a great scientist and astronomer. However, he was likely not quite as advanced as Lord Aristotelēs in understanding COSMIC LAW.

I will go as far as to suggest that Lord Aristotelēs even understood Dark Matter itself. This would again put him many centuries ahead of Copernicus, and almost every other human's understanding of TRUE COSMIC LAW. Lord Christ and Lord Buddha being the exceptions.


r/Aristotle • • Mar 13 '26

Aristotle argues that human nature is neither good nor bad. The same can be said for rocks, but what makes human nature different is that it is possible for humans to develop new character traits by repeatedly practicing actions. Aristotle called this "habituation."

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
46 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Jan 12 '26

Aristotle famously distinguishes between two kinds of virtues: character virtues, and intellectual virtues. One is about emotions, and the other is about knowledge. Both are crucial for happiness. (The Ancient Philosophy Podcast)

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
38 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Jan 30 '24

Found this on twitter

Post image
37 Upvotes

Im not really that familiar with Aristotle’s philosophy (yet) so could anyone that is familiar with his work say something on this?


r/Aristotle • • Oct 03 '25

One of Aristotle's major contributions to the development of science: the idea that sciences should be organized as sets of premises leading to conclusions. The premises are supposed to be conclusions of other, foundational arguments. The most fundamental premises are claims that cannot be doubted.

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
35 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Dec 01 '25

On the Soul online book club discussion

Post image
32 Upvotes

Deep Read Society is an online book club for literature, poetry and philosophy. With our ongoing schedule for prophet for Dec, crime and punishment for Jan-Feb, we decided to bring On the Soul by Aristotle.

Book I to be discussed on 7th Dec, 9:30 PM IST. Google form to join WhatsApp group

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeVEtvrJUxIjBKp9fwTbv4SuywzKabpCvFBnvGV-G-RNjY_Ww/viewform?usp=dialog


r/Aristotle • • Nov 14 '25

Euclid’s Elements achieved a level of mathematical rigor not surpassed until the 19th century. This ancient book of geometry, likely the most important work of math, was influenced by Aristotle’s arguments regarding how sciences should be organized. The goal: perfect certainty in every argument.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
32 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Sep 20 '25

"Hope is a waking dream" - Aristotle

32 Upvotes

This post was originally in askphilosophy but they removed it because it was "asking for personal opinions" even though the front page has so many questions asking for an opinion. Thought I'd try my luck here.

I'd like to have your interpretation of the above quote by Aristotle. I've been searching around on the internet but there doesn't seem to be a whole lot one of them was an AI post. Yuck.

From what I have gathered though the general consensus seems to be that it is a motivational quote. That hope is a source of inspiration to pursue dreams even if they seem impossible. Calling it a 'waking dream' seems like it's saying that hope is a thing used to turn your dreams into your conscious reality.

What's your interpretation?


r/Aristotle • • Aug 01 '20

Aristotle made me start flossing

31 Upvotes

By not flossing, you are less of a good person.

Yes, I truly believe this. By not flossing, you are showing that you are not choosing some of the easiest and smallest possible actions towards virtue. It does not make you a BAD person, but it makes you less of a good one.

For context, I recently began reading The Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle. This is the first book I’ve read in quite some time and my first philosophy book ever. I never took any philosophy classes in high school or college, but I recently discovered a passion for it after I graduated, so I’m starting to read as many books as I can.

The base concepts are relatively simple for anyone who has read it. In short, true happiness is the universal end goal for all humans; it is considered the “end good.” The only way to achieve that, according to Aristotle, is through achieving virtue; and virtue (again, according to Aristotle) is achieved through virtuous actions. For example, to become brave, you must do brave acts, to become healthy, you must do healthy acts, etc. I’m taking these as baseline truths, because to explain these concepts in full would take a whole series of posts. Just keep in mind that the end good is happiness and that is achieved through displaying virtue.

In Book III about Moral Virtue, Aristotle describes what are considered voluntary and involuntary actions. Particularly in regards to the amount of information you have on a choice before making it.

“Everything that is done by reason of ignorance is not voluntary; it is only what produces pain and regret that is involuntary. For the man who has done something by reason of ignorance, and feels not the least vexation at his action, has not acted voluntarily, since he did not know what he was doing, nor yet involuntary, since he is not pained.”

While he doesn’t explicitly state it (or I can’t find it anyways), I have taken this to imply the opposite as well; that no rational person would know exactly what is good for them and then not voluntarily do it. If you know exactly what is good for you, you can no longer claim ignorance if you choose not to do it. At that point, you have literally no excuse to not be doing it as long as you have the means to. Therefore, the person who knows what is good for them but does not choose it, is a fool.

He also says that we have complete choice in how we go about achieving virtue.

“For instance, we wish to be healthy, but we choose the acts which will make us healthy.”

That line really stood out to me. If you value your health, then you should choose actions that improve it or maintain it. As we mentioned earlier, to become healthy (which is a virtue), you must take healthy actions.

I recently began exercising and dieting for the first time in my life, and when I tried to conduct research on it, there was lots of conflicting data. They all shared some key points, but overall, it was very dependent on your body type, what your goals were, etc.

But do you know what doesn’t have conflicting data? Flossing. There is no debate or dispute on whether or not it is good for you. It is universally seen as good for your health. And it is very easy and simple to do.

So, bearing in mind the conclusions I made earlier, if you know for a fact that flossing is good for your health (which you do), and you have the means to do it (which you likely do), and you value your health (which you likely do), then you are ignoring the choice of virtue. And by choosing to not pursue the virtue of health in one of the most basic ways possible, you are no longer pursuing virtue to your fullest extent, which means you are no longer pursuing happiness to its fullest extent, which means you are no longer pursuing the human good to its fullest extent. Which makes you slightly less of a good person than someone who behaves exactly like you, but flosses.

Now, if any of those statements are not true then none of this applies to you, because missing any one of these steps ruins the argument. If you can not afford or do not have access to floss, you can not be blamed for not having the means to practice it. If you do not value your health in the first place, then flossing to improve it would not make sense. So these types of counter arguments are not that applicable to the overall idea. This is meant more to be focused in the logic of Aristotle.

You may say “it’s just flossing, it’s really not that big of a deal on its own.” But I would disagree. By choosing not to do the most basic of actions towards virtue that you know is good for you, assuming you are a rational person, this shows that you must not truly value virtue (or at least the virtue of health). Because if you truly valued virtue and were trying your best to pursue it, you would do what is universally accepted as creating virtue. Like flossing. More virtue makes you closer to being a “good person”, therefore, by not flossing, which is virtuous, you are less of a good person.

So, floss.


r/Aristotle • • Oct 17 '20

Aristotle's Superman

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Oct 02 '21

A Study group on Aristotle's Metaphysics

28 Upvotes

Hey there everyone,

I am currently somewhere in the everlasting middle of my path into reading, learning, understanding philosophy.

I have read Aristotle's Nikomachean Ethics, his Politics, Rhetorics and Poetics. I am also I am now interested in reading his Metaphysics. However, this time I would not like to do it alone. I think there is a great deal of profit for everyone involved when people come together and form a study group for a particular text.

This is how I envision this. We would ideally be between 8 and 12 in number. We would read a book of Aristotle's metaphysics per week. For every chapter we would think of a heading as well as write 2-4 sentences to sum up the gist of what we read. These would be our notes. On a mutually agreed tentative period (e.g. every weekend) we would come and all submit our chapter notes together, compare notes, learn from each other. I made a subreddit where we could post our notes r/Aristotlestudygroup

I held reading and study groups with friends when I was at university. With this, I hope to revive the good ole times, meet other lovers of wisdon and forge mutually beneficial friendships. For me this is a fun activity like being the gamemaster of a board or roleplay game.

Looking forward to reading with you. Once again, looking for 8 to 12 people who also feel "eros" towards "Sophia".


r/Aristotle • • Jun 06 '22

“Patience is bitter, but its fruit is sweet.” -Aristotle

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/Aristotle • • Dec 23 '23

Why do you think Penguin chose this artwork for The Nicomachean Ethics?

Post image
24 Upvotes