r/Anarchy101 • • 2d ago

How would one go about starting a political book club in high school?

10 Upvotes

A lot of you all are assumably more experienced in political activism than me. I am interested in the niche of Youth Liberation.

I've tried asking other students around me if they are interested in joining a book club, but most of them aren't fond of reading and those who are fond of reading aren't fond of starting a book club.

I'll also have monetary issues. Books are expensive where I live, so I'm inclined to make this book club based around online books, but I am afraid that people in the book club would simply lose the incentive to read online.

If I were to start a book club in high school, how would I recruit and garner the interests of those around me. Or would you all argue that book clubs are outdated, or maybe these people are hopeless...?

I always told myself that I'd start something someday, I always thought that I'd at least have something going on by December, but its been a year and I've never encountered anyone as passionate as me about this topic. No matter how much I talk or argue about it.


r/Anarchy101 • • 2d ago

Are there any anarchists that are skeptical of Marxian class analysis?

29 Upvotes

So, it seems to me in suppose of liberatory circles that Marxian class struggle so widely popular. And even a lot of anarchists use it i.e anarcho-communists.

But I wish to hear a different perspect from one who is critical of it.


r/Anarchy101 • • 2d ago

What do people mean when they say marxism is a totalizing theory.??? what do people

31 Upvotes

Hey there, for a little context, I've been in a reading group for a while, which I have been slowly distancing myself from. It's mostly made up of members of the authoritarian left, but there are some good anarchists there too, but in general, recently some of their opinions I've seen have come up really weird. We were talking about feminism. I had some strong disagreements with their opinions on sex workers, and that led to debate. After that, though, we started talking about different leftist currents and theories outside of Marxism, and one of them brought up feminism and said, "We shouldn't call ourselves feminists because Marxism is a totalizing theory that encompasses everything."

I then got very confused, as I think it's a pretty widely accepted take that you can be a Marxist and a feminist very easily, but they seemed to disagree. We then kept on talking, and they brought up other theories such as postmodern and social ecology. I really don't see why you can't be these things and be a Marxist, but they could just keep saying that Marxism was a totalizing theory and that these other currents and ideas lacked a material basis to understand the world and only Marxism could do that, and all other theories are products of the academy, which has got to be one of the dumbest things I think I have ever heard in my life. But I'm still very confused about what they actually mean by Marxism as a totalizing theory, so I thought I would ask.


r/Anarchy101 • • 2d ago

Questions Concerning Communization, Insurrection, and Practice

9 Upvotes

I’ve recently been reading texts by communization theorists and insurrectionary anarchists, and a few questions came up that I was hoping people here could help clarify.

While reading literature from both currents, I couldn’t help but notice that they seem to share a significant number of similarities. That said, there also appear to be some important differences, and those are what I want to focus on.

In particular, there’s a critique made in *Endnotes 1* of Alfredo Bonanno and insurrectionary anarchism more broadly. One of the authors writes:

>It should be noted that something like a communisation thesis was arrived at independently by Alfredo Bonanno and other ‘insurrectionary anarchists’ in the 1980s. Yet they tended to understand it as a lesson to be applied to every particular struggle. As Debord says of anarchism in general, such an idealist and normative methodology ‘abandons the historical terrain’ in assuming that the adequate forms of practice have all been found (Debord, *Society of the Spectacle* (Rebel Press, 1992), § 93 p.49). Like a broken clock, such anarchism is always *capable* of telling the right time, but only at a single instant, so that when the time finally comes it will make little difference that it is finally right.

Would this be considered an accurate critique that can reasonably be applied to certain tendencies within insurrectionary anarchism? If so, how widely do people think this applies?

Relatedly, is insurrectionary anarchism unique among anarchist currents in its rejection of formal organizations, workerism, and similar structures, or are there other anarchist traditions that take a comparable stance?

Another question I wanted to raise concerns whether insurrectionary anarchism shares any similarities with what I think of as “ordinary anarchism,” as articulated by figures such as Gustav Landauer, Colin Ward, and James C. Scott. By this, I mean an emphasis on everyday practices, informal social arrangements, and forms of autonomy or resistance that emerge within ordinary life rather than exclusively through explicitly revolutionary moments. Do insurrectionary anarchists meaningfully engage with this kind of perspective, or is it largely absent from, or even in tension with, insurrectionary thought?

Finally, I’m a bit confused about how violence is understood within insurrectionary anarchism. Is the argument that violence is the only viable means of struggle, or rather that violence should not be ruled out in advance? In other words, is the common portrayal of insurrectionary anarchism as immediately privileging violence over all other tactics a mischaracterization, or a fair critique?


r/Anarchy101 • • 2d ago

How is AnCom not a contradiction?

0 Upvotes

very new to ancom and anarchy in general but how does a communist society work in anarchy because you aren't forced to contribute


r/Anarchy101 • • 3d ago

do you believe that the state and capital can be abolished without significant technological and economic losses?

0 Upvotes

my take:

i assume we are heading back to the stone age sooner or later. and in that world, most of what we are currently doing is impossible, or unnecessary. i am trying to orient myself towards that world, if i make myself acording to a fleeting way of being, then i will be lost with that way of being.

the "stone age" is a stable-ish technological fallback point. different apocalypses have different technological fallback points. for example, a global market failure would also mean the failure of many complex technologies and industries, but it may not destroy industry entirely, whereas nuclear war may leave us at stone age in some of the best case scenarios. a major solar event could cause a collapse of electrical infrastructure, loss of global communication networks, and would cause general mayhem in most areas of life, but the technological fall back might be minimal, meaning people might get the lights back on in a couple decades or centuries.

as an anarchist, i envision what comes after we end the way we are currently doing things. and in pretty much every scenario where the state and market* are abolished/lost, i see technological fallback happening to various degrees depending on how that abolition/loss goes.

* note: i do not care for commerce, whether or not anti-commerce is a position adopted by most anarchists is irrelevant to me, commerce has no place in any world that i want to live in.


r/Anarchy101 • • 3d ago

What’s your favorite anarchy book

39 Upvotes

I would love to be more educated on this topic. What’s your favorite book about anarchism?


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

In a leftist anarchist society, how will supply chains for expensive medical technology/drugs/chemicals look to maintain a first world quality of life for the ailments that today are curable but were death sentences 100 years ago?

88 Upvotes

I consider myself an anarcho socialist, a proponent of de-growth, and a political radical. However this is truly the one place in our ideology, other than how we defend ourselves from invaders, that I cannot see a good solution to.

Capitalism, for all of it's exploitative evil, does do one thing I feel like we can't: extreme resource extraction which goes towards expensive but effective medicine that helps the chronically ill, eldery, pregnant, and heavily diseased survive far more easily than a subpar, tranistional, or less "exploitative" system could.

I want to write a book about a anarchist utopia, and I will include a subplot about how a massive porition of the elderly and chronically ill died due to the degrowth into a less exploitative society.

Or am I wrong? If I am, please do explain to me how we can create a degrown anarchist utopia without sacrificng advanced medical research, advanced medical technology, and the extensive supply chains, chemical plants, and organizations behind keeping them running.


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

Can you have anarchy and also money?

18 Upvotes

I say money not capitalism because in theory, money can exist without using it to invest as capital I think.

I know lots of us are very far left and we have our problems with how money works, and I agree, so this is more of a theoretical curiosity.


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

question for an internal critique of authority

9 Upvotes

yea basically im trying to find literature on a systemic investigation into the authority relation itself where i show how its produced, reproduced, transformed and negated. i think it would be useful to create a crisis theory for authority so i can also show that anarchism isnt an external ideal imposed outside of society, but instead a result of the failures of authority acting exactly as intended.

i havent really been able to find anything so far and its kind of annoying because anarchism needs to understand the very thing its against in order to be coherent.


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

understanding why we can't take control of state power

11 Upvotes

Been learning more and more about anarchism in the last few weeks and trying to step away from authoritarian leftism altogether. As I've read more and more I unfortunately ended up getting a little confused could someone give me a very simple breakdown summary on why it's impossible to see state power for the purpose of the liberation of the working class I do understand why in theory I'm just struggling to put it into easy words that I can digest


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

what survives the end of capitalism?

37 Upvotes

do schools survive? how about global trade? air travel? governments?

what sorts of institutions of our world are lost with capitalism and which survive? if they survive changed, how do they change?


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

How to prevent authority of the bootmaker from devolving into informal technocracy?

5 Upvotes

So it's widely acknowledged that expertise does not automatically equal hierarchy , and that experts can and should be respected in an anarchic system. But I can easily see a scenario where someone uses their expertise on a subject to create an informal hierarchy, especially if the thing you have expertise in is central to running one's community. An acquaintance of mine gave an IRL example of a founding member of an anarchist collective who became increasingly problematic and emotionally abusive--excluding dissenting opinions in group meetings by tearing his opponent down so viciously that they started crying. Nobody wanted to keep him around, but the problem was that everything in the building they shared, from the organization's budgeting software to the electronic locks, ran on code that this guy built. So without him and his expertise, they were dead in the water--this prompted my acquaintance to leave the group. Now apply that situation to a more self-sufficient community and, say, it's water purification system. Not so easy to opt out anymore. Having a strong culture of sharing knowledge could help mitigate the issue, but any society that requires people to "just do X" in order to work is not a functional society--which is why anarchy is the preferred option in the first place, because it involves little to no prescriptions on behavior. So, what do?


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

What libsoc/anarchist theory are the Zapistas closest to?

24 Upvotes

From my short readings on the Zapatistas I've come to understand they dont follow a political theory but are rather animated by their principles and "governing that obeys". So my question is what libsoc/anarchist theory are the Zapatistas closest to?


r/Anarchy101 • • 4d ago

Would there be rules in communes and similar settlements? And how would those be enforced?

10 Upvotes

(I'm not well versed in things like that since I've yet to read theory but I'm planning to once I finish the books I already have atm)


r/Anarchy101 • • 5d ago

I'm completely new to anarchism

27 Upvotes

Hi there,

I am looking for books to read at the entry level since I am completely new to anarchism.

Will the Conquest of Bread by Peter Kropotkin a good start and what other books will you recommend?

In advance, thank you very much!


r/Anarchy101 • • 5d ago

what differs left-wing market anarchists from anarcho-capitalists

9 Upvotes

i don't know but it feels like some left-wing market anarchists propose the same arguments that ancaps tend to use almost all the time, especially the argument that we don't have real markets and it is being supressed by state-backed corporations taxation and regulations and that a free society would look like in which free roaming individuals would trade with each other based on mutual benefit exchanging value for value etc etc which is frequently used by loads and loads of right anarchists, at one point i've encountered left wing market anarchists who is your typical anarcho-capitalist but just hate the word "capitalism", mostly agorists act like this, it's just that they all believe the same thing it feels like but use different terminology, i dont know

i am an individualist anarchist, first and foremost, what economic model anarchists should adopt is up to your preferences, i don't believe socialism should be the go-to for every anarchist and respect market anarchists for bringing something new to the table, at the end of the day, we all hate the state, but i'd love to hear more from left wing market anarchists lurking here. thanks


r/Anarchy101 • • 5d ago

Did Peter kroptkin have a grandchild?

16 Upvotes

I was researching Kropotkin's family a bit and I found some mentions of him having a grandchild who was an ambulance driver

I found the source mentioned "Peter Kropotkin" by Osofky Stefen which mentions a French book named "Kropotkine" by Planche, Fernard, and Delphy Jean

As I do not know French I would like to ask if anyone has any knowledge on this?

Does the Kropotkin blood line live on?


r/Anarchy101 • • 5d ago

Advice on Independent Studies?

13 Upvotes

It's been a while since I graduated high school and it's like I kind of forgot how to study? Been picking up and dropping Goldman's essays. Been annotating, summarizing, looking up unfamiliar words or phrases, trying to consider how her upbringing and the time period affects her viewpoint/add context to what she's saying.

I think I remember seeing an old post giving advice to consider internalizing and contextualization. Contextualization would be easy enough, like applying what I learned and viewing the world with that lense (uh like idk Hasan Piker has read communist theory, and uses that theory to analyze modern day USA politics). I've considered the idea of writing essays on what I've learned and writing short creative fiction to play out ideas. And of course rereading the works numerous times is also an option.

However, I feel like I'm never truly getting it. And it's frustrating learning alone without a teacher or peer to guide you or bounce ideas off of each other.

Is there any website or maybe general advice on learning by yourself and finding community? I'm sure I could come to this subreddit to ask about Goldman's The Tragedy of Women's Emancipation, or maybe find a discord server, maybe find ancient forums. I'm hesitant about reddit though because I can imagine the simple newbie questions have been answered a million times and it would be better to just use the search engine. It's less engaging when you're not discussing stuff though.


r/Anarchy101 • • 5d ago

anti-LARP as anarchist praxis?

0 Upvotes

i am not talking about LARPing that we recognize as such. nothing wrong with nerds battling with foam swords or even people LARPing different politics.

i am talking about all the LARPs that are not considered live action roleplaying. the barista, the governor, the police officer, and so on. these roles that people play and forget that they are playing roles.

i am still tasting this idea, but it seems that the role is an idealized form that we are expected to conform ourselves to. its for this reason i think that roles are not compatible with anarchic relations.

what do you all think about a rejection of playing roles in our daily lives as anarchist praxis?


r/Anarchy101 • • 6d ago

What should I read when I was from the maoist position?

11 Upvotes

I would say I was a rather firm marxist-leninist-maoist, and hold a lot of influences from it - however I would say that I now have my own thoughts in spite of the reading I've done and would like to engage with anarchist thought. However, I am not sure what books to begin with outside of the classics of Kropotkin and Bakunin.


r/Anarchy101 • • 6d ago

Repurposing existing institutions and systems

7 Upvotes

Hey! I very recently started getting into more theory but I've found only quite ambiguous answers to this point:

I myself have understood that the main point of anarchy is to reshape existing society to foster cooperation based on voluntary association and solidarity, as opposed to the systems of coercion that we currently have which rely on forcing cooperation.

Why I say it like that is because I've talked to a couple of people skeptical of anarchism who only think of it as a destruction of every previous system to build a new one on top of it, if not outright the neglecting of any new system all together but I've dismissed the latter argument. I feel like that's a bit of an overreaction. I have understood anarchism as predominantly a labor movement that seeks to transfer control over to the people that keep the systems running and are affected most by them (the workers, of course) rather than leaving power in the hands of the distanced owners. Because of that I imagine most functions and logistics of society and the economy don't need complete erasure but can actually stay relatively similar to what they were before, just with the change of who actually gets to be involved in managing them.

Of course everything would change very radically but I have come to this thought as a reaction to the "who will build roads?" or "who will make sure that the engineers are qualified?" types of arguments. The point being that the functional systems we already have working in our current society don't need to be switched out for something completely new and we can keep using the already existing institutions while changing them to benefit everyone. So "who will build roads?" I imagine that the same people that built them before, just now they base their work on cooperation with everyone that the construction of the road affects rather than the shareholders or CEOs trying to maximize their own benefits from that road.

I'm looking for any consensus on this or theorists who have addressed this point in greater detail.

I'm sorry if this comes off as too basic or I as ignorant in some way I am very new to the theory and have only just recently started looking into my local anarchist communities and organizing. If anyone has any reading that would address this point, or just advance my knowledge of anarchism overall I will gladly take recommendations.


r/Anarchy101 • • 6d ago

how do yall feel about anti-productivism (simply put - refusing to contribute to "the economy")?

36 Upvotes

r/Anarchy101 • • 7d ago

Ainarchy: Anarchism in a world of AI

0 Upvotes

Which anarchist thinkers have started to really grapple with the potential of AI to help bring about an anarchist or post-capitalist socio-economic order?

To help focus the conversation, let’s put aside our concerns about the massive concentrations of power and capital that currently dominate AI and instead explore alternative configurations More aligned with anarchist principles.


r/Anarchy101 • • 7d ago

How to prevent reformation of the state

7 Upvotes

I'm exploring my preconceptions of how a society can function and I'm curious as to how anarchism can prevent the reformation of the state.

My understanding of Marxist-Leninism is that a state is required to establish a new order within society, such that the withering of the state can take place. Now obviously this has problems and I'm still exploring that, but it does seem to solve a key issue that I haven't seen an anarchist address.

It seems to me that under anarchist conditions, there is nothing to stop groups forming that seek to oppose or overturn an anarchist society. I understand the theory of state-communism is that material needs will be met such that the desire to take more power would be muted, but the state would remain to ensure these needs were thoroughly established. Anarchism on the other hand seems to want to bypass the state phase, more or less dropping people made desperate and cut-throat by capitalist conditioning directly into a stateless (and to my eyes, vulnerable) anarchist society.

This is a genuine question BTW. And maybe I'm phrasing the question wrong because I can't find an answer, hence why I'm turning to reddit.