r/Anarchy101 • • Jul 06 '24

How do we push back against the MLs?

49 Upvotes

edit for the unfamiliar: ML means "Marxist-Leninist"

I've noticed a worrying trend on a number of leftist subs where the authoritarian elements of the left wing tend to muscle their way into power.

It's progressed to the point where they ban anybody who criticizes those ideas, and has contributed to alienation of the fence sitters and questioning folks open to being swayed left, as they see that behavior.

It's especially bad when the tankies are out in force, excusing war crimes and promoting figures like Stalin as heroic, a strategy I can at best describe as deeply flawed.

How do we push back against this in the future? What strategies for activism do we have to oust authoritarian figures like this from the leadership of popular lefty subs?


r/Anarchy101 • • Feb 02 '25

How do you prevent violence and crimes without a police force?

3 Upvotes

This isnt just about anarchism but all movements supporting an abolishion of the police force, how would you deal with crimes like assault, murder and other violent crimes? Like, ive been the victim of assault before and ik the system as it is cant protect everyone (i didnt file charges against the person that hurt me but that was for other reasons) but at least a lot of criminals are caught and prosecuted. If we didnt have a police force to enforce the law, how would we deal with someone assaulting somone else, how would we catch serial killers and stop violent criminals. How would a state without the police stop someone like ted bundy?


r/Anarchy101 • • Sep 22 '23

Red fascists are organizing at my brothers school and I was visiting

10 Upvotes

I argued with them but not super well and they just got mad, how do you argue with MLs? They're such slippery liars or just dumb


r/Anarchy101 • • Sep 05 '24

Is it bad that I just bought Nike shoes as a teen trying to incorporate anarchist beliefs into my life? More context in post

3 Upvotes

I listen to a bunch of grindcore, which has brought anarchism to my attention and I've been trying to incorporate more anarchist concepts into my life. Recently I've outgrown all of my shoes, and my parents offered to buy me a new pair, and I love the style of Nike Dunks (though some of my friends think I'm selling out since I dress more alternative lmao). Is it bad to buy new shoes or atleast shoes from a big company? I do buy a lot of things cheap and secondhand through sites like depop or ebay.

Edit: Some of the things ive tried to incorporate when i have the chance are volunteering, and not letting people be indebted to me

I can't really debrand the shoes without destroying them. I do plan to beat the shit out of them though, Beat up shoes look amazing


r/Anarchy101 • • Nov 16 '23

Is there any merit in saying that MLs are worse than fascists? And where MLs states actually more murderous than capitalist states?

1 Upvotes

r/Anarchy101 • • Aug 04 '24

How does Anarcho-Monarchism work?

0 Upvotes

I Saw it on a reddit post, if i know correctly, anarchism advocates for the abolishment of the head of state, but monarchism is the complete opposite.


r/Anarchy101 • • Oct 09 '25

I agree with your criticisms of the concept of the state, but what are your models of replacement?

0 Upvotes

Whenever I read Anarchist or even Communist literature, I found myself agreeing with much of the criticisms of the current system and the very nature of it. But I cannot bring myself to agree with your replacements. To me, it always falls into chaos or libertarianist private control. You seem to fundamentally misunderstand human nature.

I haven't read or debated other Anarchists outside your literature, so I am open to your responses. As these sorts of forums are ways to expand upon the literature.


r/Anarchy101 • • Mar 06 '25

Looking for a type of anarchism

4 Upvotes

I’m looking for a more social anarchy.

I say “communal anarchism,” but I don’t want a communist (I have several issues with communist theory.) Is there a difference, or do I need to look for a different type of anarchism?

I don’t want anarcho capitalism or individual anarchism.

Is there something similar to small communities working together without a central authority, but isn’t communist?

Edit: My problems with communism:

I want to start off that I grew up in a more conservative and republican household and only recently start being blue pilled.

More importantly, I read lots of critical theory (sociology) outside of economics such as Communism and Marx. As such, I often find communism insufficient or harmful in race theory and disability theory. It is either insufficient in dealing with racism or downright harmful to people with disabilities.


r/Anarchy101 • • Aug 25 '24

Can I be really into big rock bands while also being an anarchist? Is it contradictory?

9 Upvotes

Ok, I know it's a consumerist obsession, but I am really into Phish. I've seen them 11 times this year already. It gives me the peace of mind necessary to organize, and I know a lot of good comrades at Phish who do good work. The scene is super LGBTQ+ friendly as well and generally always has been. But am I just ignoring DIY bands and the local anarchist punk/folk scene at my peril?


r/Anarchy101 • • Mar 16 '24

Can anarchists actually answer this question?

0 Upvotes

For the longest time, I have seen many people ask this question in r/DebateAnarchism, yet most anarchists choose to dodge the question rather than provide their own alternatives which is the main reason I don't consider myself a full anarchist.

That question is: How would anarchists deal with murderers, rapists, and other actors of harm in the moment?

What usually happens is anarchists bring up prevention, however; that isn't enough for me since prevention is never foolproof, especially when dealing with complex topics such as murder or rape.

I recognize that with prevention, we'd have a lot less anti social behaviors, but even then, there will always be people who fall into bad influences and deal extreme harm to other people.

To deny that is unrealistic, and to go all in on prevention and not preparing for the worst is naive.

However, there are those who provide their own solutions which I greatly appreciate but their solutions just bring up more questions and concerns.

Those who actually provide their own solutions say something along the lines of: if someone murders or rapes either a mob or vigilante will kill them unless they voluntarily enter rehabilitation.

This "solution" worries me since, because prisons arent an option, it seems like in an anarchist society it's either you follow the majority or die.

How is forming a posse a better alternative if it has been shown that herd mentality can cloud a groups rational and critical thinking, leading to blind acceptance of potentially false or harmful information?

With nothing more to go for but word of mouth and intense emotions, it is more than likely that a mob would make an irreversible mistake and kill the wrong person. Whether their target was truly the perpetrator and not a victim of false allegations should also be considered.

Even then, the threat of mobs give perpetrators a greater reason to organize themselves for defense and before then a bloodbath ensues.

Of course, this is all hypothetical but realistically I can't see mobs as being a stable solution as it'll incentivise ordinary people to form gangs with each other and engage in violence in order to achieve true justice with the absence of a prison/police force.

Overall, are there any other anarchist alternatives when dealing with those harmful to society around them?


r/Anarchy101 • • Jul 22 '22

What's so bad about Anarcho-Capitalism?

0 Upvotes

I've seen so many posts on this sub and others, talking about the invalidity of 'AnCap'. To me, in part due to the way I was raised, Anarcho-Capitalism seems to be a completely possible and in most theories, the more utopian form, of anarchy. Can someone please explain to me why everyone seems to invalidate it?

Edit: Thank you all for your input, it has been an excellent resource to further my understanding. I will not be replying or interacting with this post any longer. Have a nice day.


r/Anarchy101 • • Feb 08 '25

What is anarchism's answer to cancer

13 Upvotes

Not cancer as a metaphor, but the actual disease. How would anarchism allow for the development of research and dissemination of education and treatment to allow for the management of complex disease? Advancements in technology sometimes require consolidation and concentration of resources to harness research momentum. How could a system without hierarchy promote adequate research, education, and equitable dissemination of treatment? Genuinely curious.


r/Anarchy101 • • Jun 02 '26

How would we have MRI machines in an anarchist world?

0 Upvotes

Hi guys title says it all. Im vaguely pro anarchism and socialism and wanna learn more.

If you’re setting up your perfect anarchist world I still don’t see how you could get complicated labor intensive specializations such as MRI machines. Especially if you don’t have money or a money equivalent.


r/Anarchy101 • • May 06 '25

Authority can sometimes be good for suppressing bad traditions, what's the Anarchist alternative?

1 Upvotes

A lot of societies have harmful and regressive practices that top down authority can be effective in erasing.

Like in the American Civil war. Where force was used to free the slaves. and a lot of other examples around the world, child marriage, domestic violence, honor killing....

It seems that active use of top-down force is the best way to deal with them, does Anarchism offer a better solution?


r/Anarchy101 • • May 20 '26

Hey (anarcho-nihilism)

4 Upvotes

So yeah, I'm pretty much a self-identified anarchist who's fed up with the world and wants to enact change. And before you tell me to partake in Food Not Bombs, I would like to do something with my hands, something that's a bit less mechanized and more spontaneous. Please treat me seriously and not engage with what I have to say with irony. I see myself as an egoist and an anarcho-nihilist, especially after having read Fumiko's history, and want to find people in NYC who don't believe that charity and reading in bookstores with safely-curated rhetoric is enough. I'm tired of rhetoric. Too much talking. Too much saneism. Too much logic. Not enough doing. I'm in New York. I want to do something beyond the mundane field of rhetoric. Breadtube video essays are sure as hell not enough. I'm too angry to be satisfied with a shoddily-presented video essay knowing that I have to repeat the cycle after the video is over. Where are these underground networks? The insurrectionists? Those who don't think protesting or deliberating about the greatness of men like fucking Stalin or whatever is enough. Where the hell are yall? I know I sound like a fed but I, a black male in my 20s, am fucking desperate to find my union of egoists, to find fellow anarchists who want to cause some fucking damage.


r/Anarchy101 • • Mar 26 '24

How will Anarchism abolish organised religion?

7 Upvotes

Private beliefs are fine, I'm specifically talking about organised religion. How would Anarchism or more accurately libertarian socialism abolish organised religion, especially hierarchal organised religion? If possible you can give contexts in both islam and Christianity:)

edit: GUYS I'M TALKING ABOUT ORGANISED RELIGION NOT personal religion. people should be free to believe in what​ever they want but organised religion generally had control over society, societal policies and morality. People having personal religion is fine but it having an effect on public life or civic life is what I'm talking about. IT'S CALLED SECULARISM.

edit: guys y'all. I meant abolishing in the sense of it withering away on it's own,or to create structures in a way that religion wouldn't have any hierarchal power in society. i don't mean we should force people to be irreligious. *i literally said personal beliefs are fine but that seems to get over y'all heads i guess*

guys read iranian-afghan critique of religion (islamic clergy and theocracy in general and it's relation to capital): https://asranarshism.com/1402/12/20/funeral-theocracy-religious-capital-en/


r/Anarchy101 • • Jun 16 '25

I can't see a society without prisons

0 Upvotes

I agree with you that most people in prison wouldn't be there if we had more functioning societies. Drug dealers wouldn't exist if poverty wasn't an issue and alcoholism would be far less prevalent if people didn't have so many mental issues

But it's impossible that at some moment, someone will do something horrible that deserves punishment. For example, it doesn't matter how good our society becomes: a psychopath at some point will kill someone. I don't even have to talk about psychopaths, even a regular person with huge anger issues might kill someone.

What do you do with these people? Personally I don't think they deserve to die but they also shouldn't be allowed to be near other people for safety reasons


r/Anarchy101 • • Nov 21 '24

Why do we think all cops are pigs?

0 Upvotes

I want to understand why there's a basis that every single cop out there is bad. In all honesty though, I understand why people think so. Cops have committed various hypocritical actions that directly go against a lot of the humanitarian ideals. But why would we hold every single cop accountable? We've seen cops prevent suicides, we've seen cops do good stuff as well. I'm not defending cops, or justifying their actions, but I find it a lot counterintuitive to put (for example) your average cop in some suburban area to a cop in NYC that maced a protestor. Especially because I thought anarchism was based on equity. I don't mean this question in hostility, I just want clarification.


r/Anarchy101 • • Apr 19 '25

Nonviolent revolutionist groups?

5 Upvotes

I've been thinking for a while about joining a local anarchist group/party/organisation. The problem is that I can't find any group with nonviolence or pacifism as part of their goals and aims. Whenever I read or listen to communist/anarchist podcasts, pacifism is usually referred to as optional at best, naive and theist at worst. Why is that?

I am a pacifist before anything else. I am not religious, a theist or an idealist. I think that nonviolence IS the material position. Whenever revolutionists say, as 'the ruling class will not relinquish their power without their use of armed force, this revolution will be a time of violence as well as liberation, I ask myself: do you really think we can beat them with force?

I feel there is almost a knee-jerk response whenever I bring up the question of violence; 'the revolution doesn't have to be violent, but it might need to be'. But it never seems to be seriously considered. If the ruling class use their armed force against us, how in hell will we resist? with sticks and stones? Even if we somehow manage to gather some sophisticated weapons, we could never match their strength. All we'll gain is a few more dead capitalists.

It seems to me that the question of violence should be considered as seriously as the question of bread. If the people are hungry, the revolution will fail. If the people resist through violence, the revolution will fail.


r/Anarchy101 • • Apr 17 '26

Is every kind of preference a kind of hierarchy?

0 Upvotes

I know this question is very abstract and theoretical but it came up to my mind and cannot find a way out.

The thought process I have undergone is the following: anarchy is the absence of any hierarchy. Preferences, though, are a type of hierarchy. Let me give you an example: if I prefer pizza over hamburger I am placing them in a mental hierarchy based on my taste, and, the same, can be said of any other thing. If, for example, you are a leftist you prefer leftist ideas, thus building a hierarchy of ideas or ideologies.

I just want to hear other opinions about this, I am not looking for a definitive answer.


r/Anarchy101 • • Feb 11 '25

Replacement of police in anarchism

1 Upvotes

After abolishment of police in a anarchist society, what would be the alternative?

And for important projects that need heavy investigation like murd*r , sexual crimes , damaging nature or society in any way or blackmailing and other crimes that need deep investigation, how would it be done ?

(I'm learning anarchists perspective)


r/Anarchy101 • • Oct 12 '23

Can stress and sadness be completely vanished under anarchism by allowing people to do whatever they want?

2 Upvotes

r/Anarchy101 • • Feb 13 '22

Why are so many Anarchists against private property?

0 Upvotes

Aren't just private means of production a problem? And what about small and medium-sized businesses? They don't seem to oppress anyone.


r/Anarchy101 • • Mar 23 '24

Question from a Neo-Luddite: How do you think anarchy will be upheld?

1 Upvotes

Simply put, if an anarchist society is successfully established, how will you make sure no authority reemerges? How will you stop some random guy from getting a load of guns & some loyal men, and starting his own government? Sure, you can argue that individual people will also own firearms, but they won't be organised enough to protect themselves against an unified, efficient group aiming to gain power.
I say this as an Neo-Luddite / anti-industrialist -- I argue for anarchy too, but I believe the only way to achieve it would be by destroying industrial technology as well. With no industry, there can be no guns. With no guns, along with other technologies, there will only exist small, local governments, at least for a good while.
I disagree with a lot with many anarchists. But I do agree with the overarching idea that a government, as it has existed within the last couple of millenia, is a detriment to human freedom.


r/Anarchy101 • • Mar 04 '25

Meta question: how does a anarchist subreddit handle moderation

5 Upvotes

Like the title says. It could be argued that what we have here on r/anarchy101 is a form of society with certain laws.

Now, by nature of how reddit works, we are forced to accept a "king". Regardless, how is anarchy applied on anarchy forums? Do we vote on new rules? How do we select the mod team? Do we accept the way this society works or leave to form our own? Do we hold public court when it comes time to exile someone?

This may seem frivolous but really, y'all would have to have this discussion with your neighbours after the revolution/when the CHAZ is established.