For the longest time, I have seen many people ask this question in r/DebateAnarchism, yet most anarchists choose to dodge the question rather than provide their own alternatives which is the main reason I don't consider myself a full anarchist.
That question is: How would anarchists deal with murderers, rapists, and other actors of harm in the moment?
What usually happens is anarchists bring up prevention, however; that isn't enough for me since prevention is never foolproof, especially when dealing with complex topics such as murder or rape.
I recognize that with prevention, we'd have a lot less anti social behaviors, but even then, there will always be people who fall into bad influences and deal extreme harm to other people.
To deny that is unrealistic, and to go all in on prevention and not preparing for the worst is naive.
However, there are those who provide their own solutions which I greatly appreciate but their solutions just bring up more questions and concerns.
Those who actually provide their own solutions say something along the lines of: if someone murders or rapes either a mob or vigilante will kill them unless they voluntarily enter rehabilitation.
This "solution" worries me since, because prisons arent an option, it seems like in an anarchist society it's either you follow the majority or die.
How is forming a posse a better alternative if it has been shown that herd mentality can cloud a groups rational and critical thinking, leading to blind acceptance of potentially false or harmful information?
With nothing more to go for but word of mouth and intense emotions, it is more than likely that a mob would make an irreversible mistake and kill the wrong person. Whether their target was truly the perpetrator and not a victim of false allegations should also be considered.
Even then, the threat of mobs give perpetrators a greater reason to organize themselves for defense and before then a bloodbath ensues.
Of course, this is all hypothetical but realistically I can't see mobs as being a stable solution as it'll incentivise ordinary people to form gangs with each other and engage in violence in order to achieve true justice with the absence of a prison/police force.
Overall, are there any other anarchist alternatives when dealing with those harmful to society around them?