r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 08 '26

Advice I wish that I was butch, but I don’t think that’s how it works

0 Upvotes

Idk. It’s probably not good to care about labels so much but I want to fit myself in a box. The thing is, I don’t look butch and never will.

It’s hard to describe, but I want to fill a ‘male social role’ as a lesbian, if that makes sense. I want to be kind of a Prince Charming, hold doors open for women, be more handsome than pretty, etc. I also feel that I relate way more to men than to women.

I know that short hair doesn’t necessarily mean butch, but I’ve always wanted short hair. I cut my hair when I was like 13, and I loved it so much.

But everyone says that I look better in long hair since my hair is very thick. I’ve been told that my hair is beautiful, and I want to appear attractive to women so I’ve been growing it out. I think I like it sometimes, but I just love short hair so much. Even a short haired lady at my work today said that it’s my choice but that I look better in long hair.

I get that a butch can have long hair, but any time that I’ve seen a butch online with long hair, they naturally have masculine features.

I have a feminine facial structure, a high pitched voice, large breasts, curves, and am very short. I think I’m fine with having large breasts (used to want a reduction) but it makes any baggy clothing look absolutely terrible. I just hate how the cloth leaves a big tent in front of me.

I feel like even if I dress masculine, I won’t look butch (I heard that butches look butch in any clothing). At best, I’ll look like a little boy if I cut my hair. 

I don’t mind wearing feminine clothing, which is another reason that I’m likely not butch. I own a lot of dresses and blouses, and I don’t hate wearing them. Sometimes I even enjoy wearing them. I just feel so much better in masculine clothing. I love suits. But I look bad in them, everyone says I pull off dresses better.

For some mock trial of a dead president in my History Class a few years ago, I dressed up ‘as a man.’ I told my mom that I had to dress like a man because there weren’t female lawyers back then, but I mean, none of the other girls did that. I just wanted an excuse to wear a full suit and tie. I took so many pictures, I loved it so so much. A male friend called it a ‘pantsuit’ and that annoyed me. Why should the outfit have a different name just because of my gender???

My big sister criticized me since I acted like it was some life changing event, which was weird of me. I anyway won’t have any occasions to wear a suit since I don’t go to church anymore.

Idk, I have my own money now so I could get short haircuts if I wanted. But I don’t want women to find me unattractive. Society asides, I want a girlfriend, and might have more romantic success if I continue to dress feminine and keep my long hair.

Sorry for the long incoherent rant. I’m not like, asking for permission to be butch or anything cause that’s dumb, I just wanted to ask for advice idk what I should do.

Is there a word for a woman who doesn’t present gender non conforming (I’d like to be gender non conforming but I think it’s a bad idea), but takes a ‘male role’ in relationships?


r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 21 '22

There was a post on here about top surgery being popular among butch women; is bottom growth not as popular? NSFW

7 Upvotes

A couple of months ago, a gay friend expressed interest in wanting bottom growth. She doesn't identify as trans or even non-binary but just wanted bottom growth, so as to experience what it would feel like to be inside of a woman. Her clit was also extremely small that sex wasn't the best for her. She went to a LGBT clinic, saw a doctor, and was prescribed a chemical compound and within one month, she said she saw growth of about an inch and predicts/desires to gain an inch, or more by the time the fourth month comes around.

For a while since she started this process, I wondered why bottom growth didn't seem as popular among those who are butch and/or more masculine leaning. Or maybe it is and I just not know. I wouldn't really call this friend butch; if anything she's more of a stem/average woman.

Have any of you ever desired bottom growth so as to feel inside of another woman, is it popular among the butch and/or masc presenting women...is it not?


r/ActuallyButch • • Jun 16 '24

Book Club 📚 Stone Butch Blues Audiobook - Chapter 1!

20 Upvotes

Hello my loves,

I am a voice actor , and it’s with great pride that I am sharing these news; I’ve finally created a Tumblr of my ongoing recording of Leslie Feinberg’s iconic book; I’ll post the link below, and I am very open to suggestions, feedback and all in between :)

Make sure to heed the trigger warnings I put on my pinned post.

I am not paid for this work, it’s all made with love; if you would like to share widely or tip, I would love that!

Take care of yourselves today, will cross post in other relevant communities.

Happy pride butches, I love you 🌈

https://www.tumblr.com/stonebutchblues-audio/753441024224919552/chapter-1-sbbm4a


r/ActuallyButch • • May 20 '23

I would like to invite you to a Butch4Butch dating sub

16 Upvotes

Hey folks ! I’d like to invite whomever is interested to a Masc WLW dating subreddit. it’s exclusive to mascs who are attracted to other mascs.

r/Butch4Butchdating

If you aren’t interested here is a popsicle for your trouble 🍭


r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 19 '24

Casual Chat Butch Troubles

46 Upvotes

EDIT: No advice, please. This includes well-intentioned voices of concern I don’t need. If it were that serious, I would go to my folks irl who give me plenty already.

So, for the unaware, I'm a hard butch -- not only a woman, and not completely a man. I wear men's clothes, I certainly behave almost like a man. I pass as a man more often than not to the untrained eye.

At my mma club, which is mostly guys, most people know me as male. The only one who doesn't is a girl who I told I was a butch when she was having a particularly bad day, and I sensed she wanted another lesbian to connect to.

Here's where it gets interesting. I was training with the guys (getting gear on, some wrestling warm ups) when one of them spots my boxing shoes poking out my gym bag. Not to brag -- my boxing shoes are VERY COOL LOOKING I ASSURE. He reaches into my bag to get them. I get anxious -- my cluster of pads are in full view. I dress how I please and live how others care to find me, and a positive to that is people largely leave me alone. The moments where people notice the contradiction that I am --maybe the softness in my face, the angle of my hips, a break in my voice -- things tend to go very terribly. People do not like feeling deceived, and I'm the 5G cell tower that's been Frankensteined into passing as a fake tree. I've been jumped and attacked before by men, and more times than I can count women have called me a predator or a child molester before finding their boyfriend/security to deal with me. And, to be both frank and ironic, I've found that the vast majority of today's lesbians are massively under-socialized with butches and can't spot one in the wild. It's a side effect of being butch that just sucks, but I just truck on and deal with it.

My training buddy just sifted past my pads and pulled out my shoes to show off to everyone. No one noticed the pads (I may have had a sports bra in there too?). All is good, all is well. He probably didn't think too hard about them. Butches, who are me, have found that gender fuckery really points out the folks who are suggestible and notes all the quirky ways our brains fill in the blanks to resolve perceived contradictions.

While it stressed me out in the moment, I laugh about it lots now.


r/ActuallyButch • • 17d ago

Grooming/Style I finally did it!

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

I wanted to be more visibly queer so I always wanted to shave my head. I’m from Canada and the winter is coming in so I knew I would put it off as it got colder, so I did it! Hope you like it! less


r/ActuallyButch • • Oct 12 '26

Discussion I really think I want to start trying to date more masculine women

10 Upvotes

ive dated masculine women in the past but always felt like had to perform femininity to do it, so i‘d switch to be fem. but i think i want to try dating masc women as a masc woman myself. genuinely extremely burned out from dating femmes in a way i honestly cannot explain. ive never been this jaded about women. my most fulfilling relationships have been with masc women and i don’t see why I’ve been suffering myself trying to date fems and receiving even less than the bare minimum. Just a lil rant


r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 16 '25

Serious USA Butches and studs, how have Elon and Trumps changes been affecting you?

43 Upvotes

Especially any of us that are feds. As a fed on probation, I’m currently interviewing for private sector jobs in case I need to jump ship.

How are y’all affected if at all?


r/ActuallyButch • • May 14 '22

Butchness

33 Upvotes

First I wanna say that I was so excited to see this community! My girlfriends straight friend asked what it was like to be Butch, and I’d like to share:

Butch is when a woman looks like me. It’s the clothes, but it’s not just the clothes. If someone acted like me but still wore makeup and dresses, they wouldn’t be butch. If they dressed like me but didn’t have the vibe, well. I’m not sure. The clothes aren’t everything. But they’re not nothing.

Butch has its roots in the blue-collar early lesbian bar scene, and butches back then were defined in contrast to their femmes. There is a strain of old school chivalry from back then that still exists within anyone for whom this label fits, whether they know it or not. We were born gentlemen, regardless of whether our collars are blue or white (or Hawaiian, if you work at Trader Joes). Butch carries a pocket knife, knows how to treat her femme, and is probably into one of the following: camping, cars, home improvement, cocktails.

Butch was a tomboy as a kid and had one (or more) early role models that stuck with them (yes, it’s that damn fox from Robin Hood). Butches tend to be protective of their girls; regardless as to whether or not you were born that way, you became that way. I blame men. I leave my jacket draped on my chair when my girl and I are out, that way, everyone knows she’s with me, even when I’m not there.

Bow-tie gays are not automatically butch. They can be, but they’re usually not. Butch most likely wears a straight tie, knows how to tie at least two knots, and knows how to polish her shoes. Butch might also wear a bolo tie and cowboy boots, if that’s her thing.

We do not carry purses.

Butches aren’t trans men. Rather, we occupy womanhood through the lens of masculinity rather than eschew womanhood altogether. Or at least I do. Others might disagree.

Not all short-haired queer women are butch. Not all butches have short hair. Not all non-binary queer women are butch. Some can be, but most aren’t.

Important: Butchness is an inherently lesbian identity. Butchness is defined by lesbianism and by our proximity to other lesbians, femmes especially. If a straight woman was masculine, she’d be just that, a straight masculine woman.

Also important: The butch-femme dynamic does not imitate heterosexual relationships.

I enjoy existing within the tension of being a woman in a masculine space. I used to be conscious and timid of being GNC in public spaces but now I just walk right through it with my head held high. If I had to deal with coming to terms with who I am, then so can everyone else.


r/ActuallyButch • • Nov 24 '23

Grooming/Style Do you think butches can have long hair?

22 Upvotes

I've always wondered. I want to know what y'all think!


r/ActuallyButch • • Jan 22 '25

Discussion Question for all the butches/ studs that switched types

40 Upvotes

Hey y’all. I’m curious about all the butches and studs that only went for femmes but then switched over to dating masculine folk. Is the grass greener on the other side? 👀


r/ActuallyButch • • May 24 '25

Discussion How do y’all greet your masc acquaintances?

16 Upvotes

Just curious whether everyone is dapping each other up (that’s what I do) or do y’all go for a hug? Even the new stud friends I made, we dap each other up, but always give hugs to femmes.


r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 04 '22

Are we allowed to post links here?

5 Upvotes

I made a discord server and posted the link but it got removed. Wasn't told why.


r/ActuallyButch • • Jan 30 '23

How do we get this subreddit to be more active?

17 Upvotes

Its really dead right now


r/ActuallyButch • • Oct 30 '23

Discussion Thoughts on non butch women calling themselves butch?

46 Upvotes

It’s something I’ve noticed a fair bit while scrolling through other “butch” subreddits. I’d like to clarify that I’m not talking about women who dress butch but have more ‘feminine’ features because that can be out of your control, but I’m talking about women who straight up wear full faces of makeup and dresses etc. What are your thoughts?


r/ActuallyButch • • Dec 02 '22

Do you have ear piercings?

19 Upvotes

I never got mine pierced as a kid because I thought it was too girly but now I think it's hot actually, so maybe I will get them pierced


r/ActuallyButch • • Oct 03 '24

Grooming/Style Butch lesbian with cerebral palsy

19 Upvotes

So yes, I am butch.

The problem is, I'm losing function in my legs, and skirts are easier to get on, along with leggings. Is there a way to incorporate (occasional) skirts and leggings into the aesthetic? I am not femme at all, but at the same time...There are days where I legitimately cant get pants on.


r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 24 '21

Pick your bird spirit!!

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 04 '25

History The Homophobia of Queerness

Thumbnail
substack.com
55 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 24 '22

how many of you embrace being "bearded ladies"?

21 Upvotes

I've grown a small patch of natural facial hair on my chin since I was around 17/18, probably from PCOS (though I've never been officially diagnosed). I used to pluck it for *years*, and only this past year decided to let it grow (I do keep it neatly trimmed, but it's still noticeable). Notably, about half of my lesbian friends also admit to growing facial hair, but I'm the only one of us who lets it grow at all. I'm curious if anyone else in this group embraces this part of themselves? How does it your facial hair make you feel, and what's your relation to it?


r/ActuallyButch • • Nov 17 '23

Nothing fucks you up more than when a butch you like turns out to be.... STRAIGHT...😭😭😭

39 Upvotes

I overheard her talking to her friends about guys. I'm still not over it gripping my chest with one hand leaning on the table with the other !!!


r/ActuallyButch • • Dec 29 '24

Do you like stone butch blues?

79 Upvotes

I don't. I read it when I was young and all I can remember were all of the graphic rape scenes and then the main character getting with a man at the end.


r/ActuallyButch • • Oct 29 '25

Casual Chat 🎃Halloween Pick-up Lines👻

10 Upvotes

I know some us are going to some Halloween parties this weekend. For the singles (and I guess polyam folk 👀) what are some Halloween themed pick-up lines you have in your arsenal?

Cringier the better.

I’ll start…

(Dressed as a spider) “Hey girl, do you want to get caught up in my web?”

Pray I don’t get pepper sprayed with that line 😂.

Let’s see what y’all got


r/ActuallyButch • • Jun 13 '23

Casual Chat hii

11 Upvotes

hi i am new here


r/ActuallyButch • • Dec 17 '25

There Is No Such Thing As A "Masc Shortage"

Thumbnail
sistaseparatist.substack.com
33 Upvotes

On Lesbian visibility day, Robyn Exton of the so-called "HER" dating app said "there's no such thing as a real Lesbian". She then complained that there weren't enough butch & stud Lesbians using her dating app.