r/ActuallyButch • • Apr 18 '22

Stop. Erasing. Butch. Lesbians. This is absolutely infuriating.

Post image
136 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Jul 12 '22

pronouns

129 Upvotes

I hate it when people ask me my pronouns. I get asked at least twice a week at work, almost always in group settings where I am the only one explicitly asked because they look at me and see a fucking "qu**r"... Once, a woman asked me my pronouns in a group meeting (singling me out, yet again), and when I said "she/her," she had the audacity to ask with a smug grin, "Are you sure you don't use any others?" When I was a kid, I was held down and "inspected" by girls at camp because they didn't believe I was a girl, that I belonged in the bunks with them. When I was still trying to perform femininity as a young adult, I constantly had people either asking me outright or spreading rumors that I was actually a trans woman. Now that I'm just trying to be myself as a butch woman, it just fucking kills me inside every time someone asks. I don't want to answer. It just makes me want to turn heel and never interact with that person again.


r/ActuallyButch • • Nov 29 '21

I can't do it anymore. Lesbians cannot have anything.

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 28 '23

my pronoun manifesto i'm going to bring to HR because my coworkers keep asking my pronouns or straight up calling me they/them

119 Upvotes

Hot Take Tuesday
tl;dr - Using "they/them" for people who don't fit gender stereotypes and asking pronouns are both harmful, and we should go back to the model of letting trans/nonbinary identified people correct you if they want you to use different pronouns.

  1. asking pronouns
    - can pressure someone to "come out" before they're ready, or in the company of people who might not approve ("what are your pronouns?")
    - targets neurodivergent and disabled people--especially women--who are frequently gender nonconforming due to health, sensory, and fatigue issues
    - can further traumatize gender nonconforming people with a history of being bullied ("what are you?")--assuming a trans identity especially targets butch lesbians, who often have complex social trauma around homophobia and misogyny associated with not being feminine ("girls don't like girls" and "why are you trying to be a man?")
    - in theory, advocates say to ask everyone's pronouns, but in practice, only gender nonconforming people are asked, which singles them out and others them

  2. using "they/them"
    - "they" often feels dehumanizing and othering to people who don't specifically identify that way--feels very similar to "it"
    - we live in a misogynistic society where women are pressured to go to extreme lengths to be perceived as "feminine"--women should not be punished for rejecting this
    - sends the message "if you don't perform gendered expectations, you aren't man/woman enough to be recognized as such"
    - pressures gender nonconforming kids to identify as nonbinary or trans "if everyone assumes i'm trans, maybe i am?"
    - men can have long hair and like wearing skirts, women can have short hair and prefer loose and comfortable clothing--this doesn't make them trans

  3. let trans and nonbinary identified people correct you and tell you their preferences
    - lets them disclose on their terms, in their time, without singling out gender nonconforming people
    - avoids "group pronoun sharing," which trans-identified people often see as performative virtue signaling and targeted anyway ("everyone say your name and your preferred pronouns...")
    - it is not up to you to deduce or investigate who identifies as trans!


r/ActuallyButch • • Oct 10 '21

Top surgery and butchness? Why is it so popular

107 Upvotes

In other butch subs it seems extremely common to want top surgery or to have already had it. I at one point struggled with my body and wanting a flat chest but that went away for me personally when I accepted my lesbianism. I used to be ashamed for being attracted to boobs but there's nothing wrong with that. I think sports bras look hot and I want to experience my body with my partner.

I don't know why I feel kind of defensive of butchness and boobs. Like in other places it seems to me people are using hating their chest as proof of butchness. There's always the list "I cant relate at all to women, I was always one of the guys, I wear mens clothes, I hate my chest, I want T..." I just get really defensive about it when I read these lists. Like being butch isn't a competition. Wanting top surgery is not evidence of being a butch lesbian. Getting top surgery doesn't make you more masculine, butchness is who you are not what body you have. If top surgery is right for you than that's great too.

I guess I have some privilege in that my chest is mostly flat in a sports bra and I don't have to deal with back pain. I also understand how completely horrible it is to grow up with a body like this in a society that sexualizes the fuck out of women's chests. But for me, I don't think removing them will help anything. Yeah maybe my chest won't be sexualized by men anymore, but that isn't a solution to the larger problem at hand that women's bodies aren't respected. Furthermore I actually do want my chest to be sexualized but only by women. Again, that's my perspective on my body.

I just don't get it. To me there is nothing that prevents having boobs and being masculine. Boobs can be masculine too, it's all how you use what you have. Like how is it NOT competely butch and completely lesbian to partner with someone who has the same body parts as you? like hello what? if having boobs isn't butch anymore then I guess I'm out

Not to mention, I think people are seriously underestimating how serious it is to have that kind of surgery. I support people making their own decisions and prioritizing their health and mental health but like wtf I think the community should take a breather and think about why so many of us are getting serious surgery. Who is profiting from making lesbians feel dysphoric about their chests? If that makes me a youknowwhat then whatever.

To any butch lesbians reading this who have gotten top surgery, you're obviously still a butch lesbian, and I wasn't trying to insult you at all. I preemptively apologize for hurting anyone's feelings if I did. All that matters is that you're happy. I can see how having a body that reflects how you feel inside is a good thing. I guess I just feel the need to defend boobs.

I guess I just need to reflect more on why what other people are doing is making me feel less confident about myself and my place in the community.

Does anyone else feel similarly or have any wisdom on this?


r/ActuallyButch • • Nov 11 '21

Thought you all would appreciate this.

98 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 23 '21

What does butchness mean to you?

88 Upvotes

To get the ball rolling on this new sub, I thought it'd be fitting to ask a foundational question: what does being butch mean to you?

To me, butchness is about manifesting female masculinity in the context of loving other women. It's inextricably bound up with the ways I desire, pursue, and make myself visible to women (in my case, more feminine women). It's also about self-acceptance and the refusal to modify or override my natural instincts, in the name of patriarchal social scripts.


r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 01 '22

“Butches can wear dresses and skirts too!”

86 Upvotes

So came across a typical post on the main sub of someone asking if they’re butch enough to be butch. One commenter replied saying how dresses and skirts are comfy and you are butch if you say you’re butch.

Please tell me if I’m wrong, but being visibly GNC according to current standards of gender roles seems CENTRAL to being butch and the butch experience. Of course, there’s a lot of ways we can deviate and vary within that—some butches have longer hair (but you won’t find them getting blowouts or braided updos). Some love bright colors and floral printed things.

This is all fine, but if someone is wearing dresses and skirts on a regular, I just can’t see them as butch. It feels like our identity is becoming meaningless with ideas that anyone can be butch. Bisexuals can be butch, you can have a literal husband and be butch. And now you can present like a quirky fem and be butch. At this rate, why not call high fems butch? Or straight women? There has to be a limit somewhere.

I’m a younger butch so I’d love to hear perspectives of others on this.


r/ActuallyButch • • Dec 29 '24

Do you like stone butch blues?

79 Upvotes

I don't. I read it when I was young and all I can remember were all of the graphic rape scenes and then the main character getting with a man at the end.


r/ActuallyButch • • Jan 04 '25

Grooming/Style Almost filled up my patch vest after my last one was stolen at SF pride

Thumbnail
gallery
73 Upvotes

I made the heart-shaped pins and the amazing back patch was screen-printed by a lesbian woman in Joshua Tree. Other patches are places I have worked at/traveled to.


r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 24 '21

Discussion Why do so many younger butch lesbians go on T?

73 Upvotes

3 posts in the past 24 hours on the other butch les sub are young people who did & regret or want to go on T in the future. Why is this such a big phenomenon? Hoping someone, perhaps a younger butch with more insight, can explain it to me.


r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 27 '23

as a butch woman in community mental health, i do kinda wonder if this would help my coworkers...

Post image
69 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 29 '21

Discussion How do you feel about discussions of "toxic masculinity" among butches?

68 Upvotes

Personally, I strongly dislike it. The implication that GNC women uphold and contribute to patriarchy to the degree that gender-conforming men do is really just ridiculous. Actually, we're hurt by patriarchy, no matter how masculine-presenting, foul-mouthed, or tough we happen to be.

From what I've seen, I also feel like all this hubbub about "toxic masculinity" in lesbian spaces has led to a kind of anxious overcorrection in young butches. They're worried about coming off as too aggressive, too brash, etc, simply because of their masculine presentation, so they instead default to being timid in ways that limit them (socially and romantically). There's nothing wrong with being straight-forward, assertive, and blunt, however you dress. There's also nothing wrong with bravado and competitiveness, as long as you don't go around acting like an asshole.

I can't but feel like the "toxic masculinity" charge is just a new-fangled way to shame butches into femininity and police gender-conformity. Yeah, I'm sure there are some butches who genuinely hold some internalized misogyny, but let's call it what it is: internalized misogyny. It has nothing to do with the masculinity that we have to fight for, against the grain of patriarchal pressure.


r/ActuallyButch • • May 28 '22

People who want to be seen as a "dyke" or "butch" but not a woman or man

67 Upvotes

So just saw a post in the main sub where the person talks about how they hate being seen as a woman and after top surgery and T they rarely are, but now are uncomfortable being seen as a man too. I feel for them and I don't know the full picture, but I strongly suspect there is internalized misogyny at play here causing such revulsion toward being perceived/referred to as a woman. It's sad because clearly they aren't comfortable being seen as a man either. They want to keep connection to the "dyke" part of themselves instead of being seen as some straight man, which I fully understand. Being a lesbian is awesome and part of who we are.

Does anyone also think these are cases of internalized misogyny? I was in a similar to place as them at one point...hated being seen as a woman but uncomfortable as a man too. I was one of those "my gender is butch" people. But I've completely gotten out of that, the physical and social dysphoria I felt, from getting into feminism and working on my internalized misogyny and shifting how I viewed gender and sex.

Curious what y'all think.


r/ActuallyButch • • Mar 22 '22

My mother texted me recently saying that I remind her of Dr. Mary Walker. I think she finally gets the concept.

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 06 '22

Media/Culture Because we all need to be "fixed"

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Feb 04 '22

Discussion Has the diminishing "supply" of butch woman had any impact on your own dating life?

64 Upvotes

I'm no longer on the market, but back when I was going on dates and flipping through profiles, not so long ago, I noticed that I was having a much easier go of it than the last time I was single. There were a number of women ready to basically just pounce me, mostly thanks to my generally masculine presentation, it seemed.

It got me thinking: because butches who haven't modified their female bodies are rare these days, thanks to the heavy influx of transitioners, we must be something of a hot commodity in the gay dating world. The supply has gone down, if you will, but the demand has stayed the same. Has anyone else noticed this effect? How has it shaped your dating life?


r/ActuallyButch • • Aug 18 '25

lets get this subreddit vibing again!

60 Upvotes

Anyone still here?


r/ActuallyButch • • May 05 '23

Discussion butch4butch loneliness

57 Upvotes

i‘m so lonely lately. i’m into butches while being a butch myself. now most butches i knew transitioned. the others are into feminine women. my opinions on lesbianism and it’s role within the lgbt are also pretty controversial and against the mainstream. so my dating pool is small to non-existend. do i have to die lonely?


r/ActuallyButch • • May 19 '22

Media/Culture Does social media advertise transitioning to you? Here's a few they continually show me!

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 04 '25

History The Homophobia of Queerness

Thumbnail
substack.com
55 Upvotes

r/ActuallyButch • • Oct 11 '21

Discussion Weirdest context in which someone has randomly "asked your pronouns"?

52 Upvotes

Things have been on the heavy side here as of late, so I thought I'd lighten the mood. As butch dykes, I think we're all used to getting aggressively singled out in group settings and having people demand to know our pronouns, simply because we're GNC. Recently, though, I had an encounter that takes the cake in terms of absurdity. A girl asked me what my pronouns were right after we had sex for the first time (LOL). I'm not stone but I am particular about the way I like to 'get it on,' so, I guess that raised some questions for her. Not exactly the pillow-talk I was expecting though haha


r/ActuallyButch • • Mar 22 '24

Discussion It's always something.

51 Upvotes

Have you ever noticed that political affiliates of all stripes, even those that claim no affiliation at all, all feel some type of way about masculine women? Pretty interesting coincidence if you ask me! If it's not me shirking my duty as a woman of god, it's my rigid and old fashioned sexuality, my problematic aping of the male sex, the implied "judgment" my appearance suggests to women who participate in femininity, my masculine "privilege" that came with the extra buttons on my dress shirt, or sometimes, it's my audacity to exist in front of a man while looking oh-so undesirable. Is anyone else tired of this yet?


r/ActuallyButch • • Mar 14 '23

Vent Being compared to men

51 Upvotes

I just need to rant.

A while ago I talked with a male relative about getting a haircut. Now it's a outgrown buzzcut and I like really short hair, cause it's low effort and practical. I just want something that looks like I put a little more thought in my appearance, so I decided to get a fade (i think the style is called boxer cut). He has a similar haircut, top a bit longer and fade, like every other guy in my area basically.

He accused me of wanting to look like him and wanting to look like a man, copying him, etc. I still get the haircut I want, but I am bothered by his assumptions. We look alike because we are related and have both short hair, but very different clothing choice.

I don't want to be a man or look like one, all my style icons are butch women. I am bothered that I can't find many pics online of the exact haircut I want on women. Fades are in rn with short "womens cuts" too and it's not my fault many men like the same hairstyle I want. Why do so many people think masculinity in women is a copy of men? Why do men think they are the default? Masculinity in women has nothing to do with men imo.

Edit: I love how you all roast him.


r/ActuallyButch • • Sep 23 '21

Oh, hello there.

51 Upvotes

Yes, I was joking, but then I decided I wasn't and went ahead and created this. I'll be happy to add whoever as mods or just hand it over to AL community members.