(Spoilers for Investigations 1+2, and PWAA)
No, this is not ragebait. I just finished playing the Investigations duology for the first time. Investigations 1 was fine - like most people, it’s definitely my least favourite AA game so far, but I do think it’s a tad overhated. I really enjoyed cases 4 and 5, and 2 was pretty fun too. Anyway, that’s irrelevant.
After being a little disappointed by the first Investigations game, I was very excited to learn that Investigations 2 was apparently a huge improvement. In fact, most people see it as a top 3 Ace Attorney game, if not the very best. And upon completing the game, I… disagree.
Don’t get me wrong, it’s not bad. It’s good. But I’d hesitate to call it any more than that. I am very much in the minority here, and I completely recognise that I am probably objectively wrong. That being said, I thought it would be fun to write down my thoughts on the game, and I’d love to discuss them with others. My goal here is to just have fun and compare my very mixed feelings towards the game with the feelings of those who enjoyed this game more than I did. So then, let’s go case by case.
CASE 1: TURNABOUT TRIGGER
Yeah, didn’t enjoy this one at all to be honest. I found the setting boring, the logic weird, and the characters (Tabby and the President) very annoying. I think it’s fair to say that you appreciate this case more in retrospect, knowing what happens later in the game. On my first playthrough though, I wasn’t impressed. De Killer’s sudden departure of course makes sense five cases later, but it feels very weird when you don’t know what’s happening.
The saving grace of this case for me is the culprit, Bronco Knight. I like this guy a lot - he’s a super memorable villain with a great design and a super cool “Objection!” voice. Frankly, if Bronco wasn’t in this case, it would be a contender for the bottom 5 cases in the series for me. Luckily though, he is in this case. As a result, in my opinion, Turnabout Trigger goes from downright bad, to tolerable. 3.5/10
CASE 2: THE CAPTIVE TURNABOUT
Wait, most people see this case as the weakest in Investigations 2? That honestly blew my mind, because I loved this one! The setting is incredible, the characters are all super fun, and it does a good job of introducing the core cast and main themes of the game. This one’s great! 8.5/10
CASE 3: TURNABOUT LEGACY
Don’t worry. I may be a little weird for not loving Investigations 2, but I’m not THAT weird. This case is fantastic - in fact, I would argue it’s basically perfect. Incredible case, enjoyed literally every minute, no notes. 10/10
CASE 4: A TURNABOUT FORSAKEN
Hey, cool, I loved the last two cases! Unfortunately, that trend ends here. I don’t dislike Case 4, it’s alright. But I was shocked to see how highly this one usually ranks on case tier lists. In the beginning, this case had me hooked - Kay has amnesia? Raincoat guy is back? Edgeworth must face the Committee? This case is gonna be incredible, right?! … right…?
I wanted to love this one. I really wanted to love this one. But I couldn’t. I don’t have any MAJOR problems with this one, rather a bunch of minor problems that stack up to make this case really frustrating for me.
Personally - and I want to emphasise “personally”, because it appears I might be alone in this - the setting of this case was kinda boring to me…? Investigating the top floors of a colossal luxurious skyscraper should’ve been a blast, but… I dunno man, I was kinda uninterested. I can’t really explain why, I just found it kinda boring. Maybe it’s just because it’s directly following two cases which both had settings that I really loved? I don’t know.
Ema is back! Let’s go, one of my favourite characters! It’s so good to see her! I was disappointed that she had such little screen time in The Kidnapped Turnabout, so I’m super excited to see more of her in this - wait, what? She’s gone? She’s in the case for like forty minutes and then disappears? Oh…
Lotta is back too… this is most definitely just a me problem, but I personally find Lotta insufferable. The mere fact that she’s on my screen so much in this case drags it down for me. Again, just a personal thing.
And let’s talk about this case’s culprit, Excelsius. Oh, Excelsius. Where do I even begin? Maybe I’m wrong, but this guy seems to be beloved as one of the greatest villains in all of Ace Attorney. Gonna be honest, I don’t see it at all. This guy is just Damon Gant but less interesting. His “emptying his tears from his goggles” gimmick gets old quick, and despite being one of the most powerful villains in the entire series, I found it genuinely impossible to take this guy seriously. That scene where he reveals his true colours to Edgeworth in the detention center is supposed to be a super tense moment where you’re supposed to find Excelsius super intimidating. All I could think about during that whole Mind Chess sequence though was how much I dislike Excelsius’s design and how much I don’t care about him.
Again though, I don’t HATE this case, as much as it may seem like I do. Kay’s amnesia thing was pretty interesting, Gavèlle turning on Excelsius was a genuinely incredible moment, and I absolutely loved Niedler and Hertz - they were such a fun duo and honestly they were probably the highlight of the case for me. Alright case, not bad, but to be honest I really don’t understand the love for this one. 7/10
CASE 5: TURNABOUT FOR THE AGES
Ready for my hottest Ace Attorney take? I think Turnabout for the Ages is the weakest finale case in all of Ace Attorney. I promise I’m not ragebaiting or anything. I know this case is absolutely beloved in the fandom. But oh my God, I was SOOOO bored when playing it.
Let’s start with something that I think even lovers of this case can agree on: this case is a little all over the place when it comes to pacing / structure. I think there’s simply WAYYYY too much happening in this case. I appreciate that they wanted to make the final case have such a big scope, but I think they were overambitious. You start this case investigating the President’s death, then you need to scramble to tie up loose ends from Case 2, then you need to solve a kidnapping, then you need to solve another murder from years ago, and then, FINALLY, you can actually focus on the murder of the President again.
There are so many parts to this case, and frankly, I don’t really care about ANY of them. The President’s murder was too goofy for me to care about, honestly. The fact that the game keeps insisting that monsters are real feels like an insult to my intelligence. I love Ace Attorney wackiness, but the whole monster plot was a little too ridiculous for me.
The kidnapping / Laguarde plot was probably my favourite part of the case. I absolutely loved Case 2, so I was excited to see characters / plot points from that case become relevant again. I think Eustace’s “redemption” falls kinda flat for me though. It’s rushed and doesn’t feel earned, and right when things are getting interesting, he’s gone. I thought he’d just be absent for the middle of the case but then come back for the final act, but no, he straight up doesn’t appear ever again after this. That was kinda crazy to me - this guy’s on the cover art for this case, I thought he’d play a huge role! Instead though, he gets a rushed arc and is quickly pushed aside once it reaches its climax.
Investigating the SS-5 incident was definitely the weakest part of the case for me. I love Lang and it was great to see him play a role again, but his inclusion in this game really feels like an afterthought. While the SS-5 incident does have some important details, it ultimately feels like an unnecessary one hour detour. Did we really need to waste ALL this time just to reveal that the current President is an imposter? Don’t get me wrong, it’s a fun twist, but the overly long route we have to take to uncover this REALLY hurts the case’s pacing for me. I don’t care what part of the orphanage garden Rosie Ringer’s boyfriend was killed in…?!?
Before I talk about the culprit, let me just briefly discuss this case’s characters real quick: -> Gavèlle: Honestly, I think she’s a bit of a downgrade in this case? I loved where Case 4 left her character, with her betraying Excelsius. In this case she just feels very flat and uninteresting - a caring mother who would do anything for her child? Woah, never seen that before! Maybe that’s unfair idk, I just didn’t love her in this case. -> Tabby and Lotta: Why are they here? This case already had way too many characters. I hate these characters. That’s just me. -> Kanis: Cool! Liked what they added to him in this case. -> Shawn: I’m sorry, I don’t care about this kid at all. My lack of interest in his character probably hurt the case for me.
Alright, culprit time. I have a love-hate relationship with Simeon. I love his theme, I’ve been listening to it non-stop since I finished the game. I love his design and his animations, especially the one where the squirrels are jumping from his hands. He’s a fun villain.
I didn’t find him particularly compelling though. He felt a bit too cartoonishly evil for me, which I realise is probably a stupid complaint, this is Ace Attorney, but still. He just doesn’t feel intimidating in the slightest, and doesn’t feel believable - you’re telling me he orchestrated all these events this perfectly, this flawlessly? It’s cool, don’t get me wrong. The premise of him having a role to play in basically every case in the game is very unique. But like… I don’t know man. I’m not sure if I’m getting my point across, it’s hard to put into words. He just… doesn’t work for me. He feels less like an intimidating manipulative murderer and more like a villain from an Illumination movie or something. “Ooooh, he’s an animal trainer, he can control animals. He’s such a good manipulator that he can control people too!” I dunno. I’m not sure if I’m articulating my point correctly here, it’s hard to put it into words.
People complain about Alba’s confrontation dragging on for too long. Yeah, it probably does, but I wasn’t bothered by it to be honest. Simeon, on the other hand? I assume Simeon’s confrontation is shorter than Alba’s, but boy, it definitely didn’t feel like it to me. And I realise I may very well be the only person on the planet who thinks that. But the way you take Simeon down feels so stupid. You have to present the balloon, what, is it three times? That’s just kinda poor game design. His breakdown is pretty great though, I’ll give him that.
That final confrontation scene really shows just how stupidly overambitious this case is, though. While Edgeworth is arguing with Simeon, there are a dozen other characters there that are completely irrelevant, and serve no purpose other than to occasionally butt in and cheer “You got this Edgeworth!” Some make sense - of course Kay, Gumshoe and Fender make total sense. I guess it makes sense for Lang to be there too, despite how poorly handled I think his inclusion in this case is. Regina makes sense too, given the setting.
But Tabby? Was she really necessary? Also, Gavèlle and Shawn - Gavèlle, take that kid home! He’s a CHILD, he doesn’t need to see this! Also, Ema’s here, for this one scene. No idea why. Good to see her again, but seriously, why? Gumshoe or Lang couldn’t have taken care of the fingerprints? Franziska’s here too. Makes sense, she’s an important character, although she’s totally irrelevant in this game. Seriously, remove her from Investigations 2 and nothing changes.
I think this just really proves this case’s failure (in my opinion) to justify its needlessly large scope. You’re left with so many characters that are completely irrelevant, because you cannot tell a story that gives all these characters their time to shine. The image of Edgeworth confronting Simeon with a parade of almost a dozen people just watching them is absolutely hilarious to me. 5.5/10
FINAL THOUGHTS
I don’t dislike Investigations 2. It’s good. There’s so much good stuff in this game that I didn’t touch on. I just wanted to focus on the negatives more, because there’s nothing good I can say about this game that a thousand people haven’t said already. It’s a good game. I just unfortunately didn’t enjoy it quite as much as everyone else seems to. I’d say it’s a mid tier Ace Attorney game for me. Here’s my rankings of the games I’ve played so far, just to prove that I’m not COMPLETELY insane:
Trials and Tribulations
Dual Destinies
Phoenix Wright
Spirit of Justice
Investigations 2
Apollo Justice
Justice For All
Investigations
I’d love to discuss stuff with people in the comments, if anyone’s crazy enough to actually read all of this. This rant is way too long to proofread so I apologise for the many typos that are likely scattered throughout.