r/AceAttorney • • May 29 '25

Phoenix Wright Trilogy Why is there so much pedophilia in the game Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I am just playing through Justice for All and like the magician (whos 21) is in love with Regina who is like 16. And the puppet who is controlled by a 31 year old guy is also in love with her? But I guess if the puppet is like its own "character" there are other surreal issues there. Plus the song he sang about her had sexual undertones even though she is a child.

Also just the sexualisation of Maya when she channels Mia with unnecessary exposed cleavage makes me uncomfy but maybe its just me 😭

Idk if this is just a japanese games issue like persona, which has a lot of it too


r/AceAttorney • • Aug 10 '25

🎨 Original Fanart Phoenix & Maya in an arab-islamic clothing!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

(sorry for bad quality, i don't know why its is like that) me in the left and my friend in the right, I'm just a hobbyist, while he's an artist lol


r/AceAttorney • • Jun 22 '25

Investigations Duology Do you see Shi-Long Lang as furry representation?

1 Upvotes

Idk what it's like to be one but I'm genuinely curious on what the furry community's opinion is on Lang. For me, it's easy to read him as a furry with his wolf themed character mannerisms and design. Do any furry ace attorney fans feel the same way, and would you consider Lang to be good, bad, or okay representation in that regard?


r/AceAttorney • • Oct 07 '23

Discussion Abuse is not funny (slight spoilers for post-trilogy stuff) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Sorry for the rant, but this has been bothering me for a while now.

Like, I get it. The prosecutors act agressively because secretly they know the defense attorney is a serious threat and act tough to try and scare them off.

But seriously, the "haha violence" jokes are WAY too frequent and are not funny at all. Be it prosecutor, witness or even client, this trope is a constant in basically every game. No, I don't think having Phoenix be whipped until he's unconscious after winning an almost impossible case is funny.

No, the thousands of death threats from Blackquill and Nahyuta aren't funny either.

And honestly, sometimes it's even outright sickening. The Garridebs thing is just straight up domestic abuse and is played for laughs for some reason. Haha woman slaps, burns and throws knives at her defenseless husband. Hilarious! And might I remind you the entire case is based on this, because unjustified violence is an endearing character trait apparently.

I'm also sick of the "underdog" trope, Phoenix Wright is supposed to be a veteran, a name to be (rightfully) feared. Yet everyone constantly verbally and physically abuses him and his subordinates. Even Pearl, an actual child, is guilty of this. Why? How is this funny?


r/AceAttorney • • Oct 04 '24

Apollo Justice Trilogy I simply don't care for Athena and Athena Cykes: Ace Attorney is my worst nightmare Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I expect this post isn't going to get much love, and that's fine. All I want to do is give my perspective in good faith without being called sexist or a troll

I feel for Athena fans, I really do. Because I know what it's like to love a character that just gets dunked on by the creators time and time again. I also understand the frustration with constantly having male protagonists/main characters, and I do think a female protag could be a breath of fresh air. But Athena is not it

I'm a hater, and proud. For every passionate Athena fan, I'm drinking as much haterade as I can to balance it out. And contrary to what many Athena fans believe, it has nothing to do with her being a woman. Because if there was a Susato/Ryutaro led game, or the Ema Cykes led AAI game, or a reboot with a compelling female protagonist, I'm sure it would be loved as long as she and the game were compelling

To start with, introducing her was a mistake to begin with. Apollo got shafted in his very own game and by the time DD rolls around he has to share the spotlight with not just Phoenix but a new playable character. He gets the worst, most irrelevant case in the game and Phoenix/Athena get much larger chunks of narrative significance. Then SOJ rolls around, and Apollo isn't particularly relevant until the final case of the game. And messiness of Apollo's backstories aside, I like 6-5 a lot. But to me it would be a waste to abandon Apollo when it's finally been proven he can lead the franchise, with popularity polls reflecting that. But instead fans want to say that Apollo's story is "done" and it's time to move on to Athena. And what's often ignored is that her inclusion didn't just sideline Apollo, it sidelined Trucy as well

Athena's story in DD isn't even remarkable or interesting. It's a retread of tired franchise tropes we've seen before, and ultimately just feels like a watered down version of Turnabout Goodbyes. Throw in Simon and it's basically a Frankenstein monster of 1-4/1-5 together. And not only is her backstory cliched and uninteresting, it inherently limits what can be done for her character in future entries

I'm not going to call Athena a Mary Sue because I know I'll get paraded with comments like "you don't know what that means!!" But she very much feels like a "meet my OC!" character. She grew up in a space center, has a special ability to hear the voices of the heart, knows martial arts, is basically a prodigy to become a lawyer by 18, is adored by the supporting cast despite not earning it at all, and the writers basically force you to try and like her by giving her the same backstory as Edgeworth. It's transparent garbage and I'm not buying what the writers are selling. If Athena didn't exist and any fan came up with this idea they'd be laughed off of Reddit

She's a gimmick character who just comes off as more cringey than enjoyable to me. People give Kay so much shit for having so much dialogue around stealing when Athena is just as bad, except she's just overemotional and leans way harder into being a Maya-clone than any other character accused of being that has before

(The Mood Matrix is also extremely easy, is obtuse to the normal courtroom mechanics/story, and I don't like it)

And now fans insist that she just has to be the protagonist of AA7 because uhhh... she exists? Like yes I agree that logically that should be the move if you observe the series in a vacuum. "Ah yes, Phoenix and Apollo got a trilogy so Athena must get a game as well!" But this is ignoring she shouldn't have been introduced in the first place, and I think the writers are aware of it. This leaves them in a very awkward position to either abandon her character by going to a soft reboot or having to write another game around her

I like that she was relegated to a filler case in 6-4, and I even like that case. I'm giddy whenever I see her being excluded from Capcom's promotional material, because it shows me Capcom doesn't want anything to do with her anymore. We'll only know for sure when AA7 comes out so I won't celebrate too prematurely... I'm hoping eventually Capcom just rips the band-aid off and says she flew back to Europe


r/AceAttorney • • Sep 18 '25

Question/Tips Why does Maya x phoenix get so much hate??

0 Upvotes

I ship it and I don’t get it


r/AceAttorney • • Aug 04 '25

Discussion Turnabout Big Top is stupid and not thought out. Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I know this topic has been discussed a bunch, but I want to emphasize every key point and go into detail about how everything turned out, as well as discuss some new points people have not thought about.

  1. The most important point is the pedophilic writing. Sure, nothing is illegal out of every statement said, but it's still just weird, and I honestly wanted to stop playing because it was making me uncomfortable. Enough said.

  2. The murder was absolute bullshit. I know you can't expect every murderer to be a competent mastermind of the craft, but this case was by far the hardest one I played, simply because of it's bullshit logic. In no way should a player know that the cape caught onto the bust, or that there was an emergency search conducted, or that Acro had the murder weapon, or that the Ringmaster would naturally go out wearing Max's clothes. It's one of those things you think is a joke, and there's no way it actually happened until it does. This trial was just completely unfair, and there's no way anyone expected this to be figured out without the game outright telling you.

  3. So many of the characters are just really annoying, weird, creepy, or straight up pedophilic. Max is a bit of an arrogant asshole who believes fame is the only determining factor to someone's worth. Ben is a creepy dude who has some form of DID. He's extremely hard to talk to, and his act with Trilo is just obnoxious and annoying. Moe is a manchild. He was my favorite out of the group, since he had real character development and a story to tell, but he also doesn't know how to be serious, and the fact that Phoenix practically had to fucking "babysit him or get penalized" is just absurd. Regina is just annoying. She has no idea how the real world works, and although it's not her fault entirely, it's really annoying and hard to be around her.

  4. Acro's character tries to be too many things at once. He is portrayed as an intelligent and quick-witted person in court, keeping Phoenix on his toes, yet his entire murder was based on pure luck. If the cloak had not fallen onto the bust, Acro would have been suspect #1. He literally says that he thought of either killing himselfor turning himself in. His murder was not thought out at all, and it goes to show how ridiculous this episode was.

  5. The penalties. Holy shit, the fucking penalties. Tell me why I am getting penalized half my confidence meter for one mistake. Tell me why Franziska von Karma gets to control when I am penalized. Tell me why Phoenix uses the stupidest answers any time the evidence is slightly off. (Used the scarf for the conclusive evidence instead of the pepper bottle. Phoenix, like a true lawyer, decides to tell the judge he was "spring cleaning" the court record. Are you fucking kidding me.) Combine that with bullshit logic and it's impossible to blind playthrough this without losing at least three times.

Overall, this case was pure garbage. It had potential, but obviously it was not thought out at all, and that's why it turned out so bad.


r/AceAttorney • • Sep 21 '25

OC Fanart Hey, how come no one ever talks about Godot's assistant, Guillermo M. Acchiato? I thought their dynamic with Godot was really fun, and I'm glad they were there to explain where he got the coffee during a trial.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Behold: my new OC that started as a one-sentence headcanon to the question of "who the hell is serving Godot coffee during a trial?" and rapidly spiraled into a full-fledged character that lives in my head rent-free! A genius artisan barista on a strict liquid diet, Guillermo's practically glued to Godot's side out of a mad infatuation with him for being one of the few men to understand and empathize with their medical history.

Caffeine Crash songclaim

Don't Toy with My Heart songclaim


r/AceAttorney • • Dec 12 '24

OC Fanart And here is the mysterious kisser of Lana Skye (art by me)

Post image
3 Upvotes

And you were Wright if you said "Miles Edgeworth"!

Source: https://www.tumblr.com/scuderiagorobets/769618572432621568/miles-edgeworth?source=share


r/AceAttorney • • Aug 27 '25

Apollo Justice Trilogy Robin Newman: Character discussion Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So I don't usually do this that much but genuinely I needed to discuss this.

I fucking hate this character, but it's not her fault.

As she is she's harmless if sometimes a bit annoying (Especially in the first half when she's acting as a guy) but I despise her twist and what the game is trying to do with her.

So I'm saying this as a homosexual myself with multiple trans friends so I might be biased here but she absolutely should have been a Trans coded character or even just a male into crossdressing. Absolutely nothing makes any sense whatsoever with her simply pretending to be a male.

For starters the school board would absolutely have some form of record on their students, they have to get them registered somewhere and must be properly documented. The fact that absolutely NO ONE knew that she was a woman, including her close friends to faculty, makes any sense for starters. And having her parents force her to be a man doesn't give any credence either since why would you even have that be a twist or a plot point in the story if it's never explained or furthered on in any way.

Two: her switch up is really forced? Like she's pretending to be a man and desperately is trying to avoid the fact she's a woman because of her parents and I understand the implications of her being pressured but again it doesn't feel like they gave her any time to talk about any of these messages or struggles and rather used it as a plot beat to be skimmed over. This game is rated M for Mature (The only in the series) so why not do anything with that?!

Also the fact it's so over the top with hyper masculinity to once she's outed in court (Which honestly feels really wrong in retrospect especially since you're using it as a way to pin her as a murder suspect) only to then immediately become hyper feminine because she's now revealed to be a woman (Aside from retaining small moments) feels dirty as well since "She's a girl now we got a make her act like one".

It feels corporate and honestly just rubs me the wrong way in its entirety since the entire situation would've had nothing be changed had she just been either a cross dresser or trans especially since the character is completely coded as one.

And yes, the game came out in 2013 they couldn't write characters in like that but that doesn't write off the fact that it still feels incredibly dated by today's standards and genuinely irks me because of how it doesn't make any sense and just feels gross since she completely changed in the exact opposite direction when she's outed (Because it's 2013 and we can't have queer coded characters).

Edit: The game literally has Apollo say the line "I for one have never seen a girl shout like a maniac all the time." When confronted on it.

Also for reference I'm finding issues with her immediate mannerisms like holding up Highheels and fainting in the stereotypical fashion among many, MANY other female streyotypes.

Great fucking writing.


r/AceAttorney • • Feb 09 '24

Tier/Poll My ace attorney game and case tier list (not updated =)

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

I'm open for discussion, ask me anything!


r/AceAttorney • • Nov 13 '23

Chronicles Do people really like the Great Ace Attorney? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I finished the first trilogy recently and loved it, so I wanted more, and decided to play the other games in the serie. So I'm currently playing ace attorney investigations (it's great) and yesterday I started the great ace attorney chronicles.

Before buying the game I searched for multiple opinions and spoilers-free reviews and it seemed like people really liked this game and tougth it was a renewal of the franchise.

I am currently at the start of the fourth case of the first game, and to me this is clearly the worst game of the serie I played so far. The 3 cases I played are, in my opinion, the weakests and most uninteresting I have seen.

(Please excuse my bad english)


r/AceAttorney • • Jul 14 '26

Full Series (mainline and spinoffs) It's annoying that the translation created a misconception about the von Karmas' nationality

0 Upvotes

They're supposed to be a Japanese family. It's important because it means that it was just Fransisca who grew up in America, and not where her family's from, so it's her unique achievement. It never specifies the circumstances, so technically she could have lived there with her mother, but either way, her career in America is her own acheivement, even though she was taught by her father in Japan, it shows that she's actually independent even by game 2. The way I've seen fans talk about it is that her father and Edgeworth 'left her behind' by going to a different country, but it's not supposed to be like that at all. She was really insecure because of her father's acheivements, but other than being immature and young she wasn't actually behind. Changing it was actually detrimental to her character.

There's no indication that Manfred ever lived in America, bevause it's always mentioning his 40 year career and fame in Japan. And in gk1.4, it mentions Fransisca coming to visit him in Japan on the holidays, so she obviously lived with other relatives or a boarding school in America. (Though Gumsho mentioned her being 'born and raised in America', so it's possible that maybe her mother moved there and Manfred just stayed there for a short time, or maybe Gumsho was wrong and she actually just went to school there, because she was taught by her father, alongside Edgeworth).

By the way there's also no indication that Edgeworth grew up overseas, and it's sort of contradictory. His career immediately started in Japan, and studying abroad before the first game is never mentioned, even though it's mentioned for a lot of other characters. But it's mentioned that he goes to study specifically in America after game 1, to get a new perspective on different justice systems, which wouldn't really make sense if he'd already studied there. In gyakuten kenji it also mentioned he got the opportunity through a connection with Manfred's old friend who was also Japanese. If he'd already studied in America he wouldn't have needed that connection.

Edit: this has startedsteadily being downvoted, I was just trying to civilly point the changes out and express my opinion, but looks like everyone here fucking hates me. Well, let's see if we can get to -30.


r/AceAttorney • • Jun 08 '24

Chronicles Spicy take... The Chronicles games just did not do it for me in the same way as the mainline series? Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Anybody who loves these games, please don't let me yuck your yum or whatever, I just gotta speak my truth. Spoilers.

I LOVE the original Phoenix Wright series. I know they were created a long time ago, but there's something special to me about that late 90's Japan, Detective Conan flavor murder mystery in the suburbs that scratches a deep nostalgic itch for me. I don't know what it is, but the setting, the sheer ridiculous nature of the characters, is so good. I've played and replayed the original three games like a confort show a zillion times, as I'm sure have many of you in this sub. That said, I never found my footing in this side story. I just finished the second game today.

A few things that I felt bothered me all the way through:

  • Herlock Sholmes. I... legitimately hated this character. His sequences where you correct his deductions were definitely a highlight of the whole series (in spite of you having to do so making 0 sense), but honestly, I couldn't stand him otherwise. I just thought he was, frankly, kind of a prick most of the time? And not in an endearing way.

  • Abrupt character deaths/returns. This guy's childhood friend just dies in the second case of the games... Is it just kind of glossed over? Everyone gets over it in what feels like a few minutes. Similarly, when he mysteriously returns an entire game later, no one is really freaking out. After they spent the entire time talking about my poor dead role model... How is anyone playing supposed to care about this guy? I cared more about Gregson, and they killed him offscreen. No one seemed to really care at all, not even characters like Iris who had a meaningful relationship with him. It's like they just killed off Gumshoe.

  • Susato honestly was just so bland to me. Stereotypical Japanese woman #6. I'm not gonna harp on it, but compare to Maya...

  • Am I losing it for feeling like the two games are really missing that supernatural edge? There's always something "magical" going on the background, the Fey's spirit stuff, even just Apollo's bracelet nonsense, something weird and bizarre and over-the-top. I feel like it was all much more muted here. ...Until someone is stabbed through a thick coat from a knife falling out a window, and my suspension of disbelief is shattered in the wrong way.

  • I did like the jury system a lot in concept, but the re-used character models honestly kinda broke my immersion there. Am I really supposed to believe that in this entire city, the same dude from the previous case got called back onto the jury coincidentally? I get that no studio has unlimited time and budget, but it I just felt like it was really lame. I was wondering, "Okay... I wonder who on the jury is going to be a witness to murder in the next case..."

That's it, I just had to get it out of my system. Honestly, the only game I haven't played now is Spirit of Justice, and I'm really nervous about it. I hope I'm able to enjoy it just like I did they older mainline games...


r/AceAttorney • • Dec 13 '25

Chronicles (No spoilers please) Dissapointed by Great Ace Attorney 1 so far Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I hate to be making this post not gonna lie. But so far I have beaten the first two cases of the first game and jeez,its been a drag so far.

First case was just obvious. Which would be fine,since ya know, first case. However its just SO DAMN LONG.

Second case was like a tinyy bit better but to be honest it just felt super stupid. Like seriously? Our main mentor died because he was pushed over a cat for no reason? Also it dragged too,you had to prove what you already knew like 10 times.

Does it get better? Please tell me it does. Ive been sticking around since I heard the last case is an all timer so I hope thats true,also that the second game is better.


r/AceAttorney • • Apr 20 '24

Apollo Justice Trilogy Apollo Justice Is The Worst Main Series Title (I Haven’t Played The Spin-Offs Yet), But It’s Still A Damn Good Game

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hot take? Idk, I’m not on this subreddit too often; curious to see what others think.


r/AceAttorney • • Aug 11 '26

⚖️ Phoenix Wright Trilogy Farewell, My Turnabout is by far the most overrated case in Ace Attorney imo Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Now, I wanna preface this by saying: Overrated ≠ Bad

I like Farewell, My Turnabout; it's a solid case, I just do not get why I often see it mentioned when talking about the best case of all time!

Here are some of my issues with the case in no particular order:

-I hate how Franziska gets sidelined in favor of Edgeworth. I love Edgeworth, but it feels very unfair to have him hijack the final case of the game.

-It uses Maya as a "Damsel in Distress"...for the second time in this game alone! It's a bit much, innit?

-The whole kidnapping plotline feels very contrived and feels like it's just a cheap way to add tension/stakes.

Like, what stopped Shelly from just sending a letter to the police with his card, saying that he is behind the murder? Only the police and Shelly know about the card, so they can be very sure the letter is actually from Shelly. Even if it's possible for Shelly to be lying in order to cover someone else, the police in Ace Attorney are famously incompetent and gullible. I don't see why it wasn't even worth a shot.

Also...why kidnap Maya at all? To force a defense attorney to take the case so he *might* win? Why not kidnap someone close to the judge or the prosecutor? That seems like a far safer bet if you wanna get someone acquitted! Or even kidnap someone close to one of the other witnesses or suspects, force them to admit to the crime. Shelly clearly doesn't care about hurting innocent people or getting them imprisoned.

-I think the mystery is rather weak. The twist that the defendant is actually guilty for once is fun, but apart from that, there isn't much here. The actual plan is very simple, and far from the fun and invented murder plans the other finales have you figure out. Also, the answer just being "Oh, it was a professional assassin" is a major cop-out imo

-Matt is just...plain stupid? Sure, you could argue that it's the point that he is stupid, but I think it's fair to expect that the final case of an Ace Attorney game should have a smart culprit.

-The case also does not feel like a finale at all. Ace Attorney 1 at least had Edgeworth's character arc make the final case feel like a worthy finale. The only thing that stops this case from being pure filler is Edgeworth showing up out of the blue.

That all being said, I still think it's a fun case! Adrian Andrews' whole character is just great, and as said, I do love the twist of Matt being the killer! But for me, those positives do not outweigh the negatives.

Please tell me if I'm stupid in the comments. I genuinely don't get why people love this case so much.


r/AceAttorney • • Feb 08 '23

Discussion Case Quality throughout the Main Series

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/AceAttorney • • Jul 20 '25

Phoenix Wright Trilogy Terry Fawles is one of the worst characters in Ace Attorney (Serious discussion) NSFW Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I understand why his death scene is tragic, and it is a good scene, however I strongly believe that Terry Fawles’ character is one of the most outdated and worst parts in the original trilogy, and he is a contender for least favourite character in my eyes.

Firstly, the fact nobody mentions how he and Dahlia had a relationship when he was 20 and she was 14 is deeply disturbing, not only that, he was her personal tutor aswell, I want to ask anyone reading this, disregarding all the context we know about Dahlia later in life, if someone told you that a 20 year old man was dating his 14 year old student, you’d obviously be repulsed, as you should be, and the fact they try to pain the relationship as if SHE had the power is also really weird, she was 14, what power did she have over her adult teacher? Despite all the evil shit Dahlia did later in life, she is absolutely the victim in the relationship.

Secondly, Terry Fawles’ character is a very abeilist stereotype of mental disorders, having a very obvious “child like” mindset and stunted mental development. Some people use this as a defense, but I think this makes it even worse, as it adds some underlying subtext that people with mental disorders are more likely to be pedophiles because they “Can’t comprehend” that its wrong to do so. What makes this case so much worse than some of the other creepy characters, is that Terry is objectively written to be empathetic, every other character who acts like this is atleast treated like a douchebag. Sal Monella is treated as creepy, Director Hotti is whipped by Franziska, Max Galactica is seen as a stuck up (altho they should have cut the marriage part out completely) and Trilo is seen as annoying (again, they should have cut him out) But Terry is seen as objectively good, and Dahlia objectively evil, not only that, but the implication is that Dahlia, since childhood was evil, and that its in her nature, withought delving into why she may have turned out the way she has. In conclusion, fuck Terry Fawles, I love Trials and Tribulations but I hate his character.


r/AceAttorney • • Oct 11 '25

Discussion Would it be wrong for a collection re-release to make major changes such as increasing Regina's age?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I briefly discussed this once before but I want to know what people's opinions on this are.

At what point does it become wrong to do this? I never hear anyone complaining about the wording changes surrounding Robin Newman, which were likely made to make the game more conclusive. I'm also sure no one else would complain if they'd changed Dr. Hickfield's lines in the AJT release to be more... benign. Neither of these are cornerstone elements of the case, and why have unnecessarily uncomfortable stuff that doesn't enhance the story when you could instead... not have these elements?

That being said, what about something major? What if they changed Regina's age to be 18 in the PWT remaster? I mean it'd be great if all the new players didn't have to witness this (I'm aware this wouldn't solve all the problems because Max and Bat clearly have more real-world experience, but it'd still be better). But it's also, for better or worse, the case's legacy. It shows what the developers' flaws were at the time, and I've heard some people argue that changing the material 24 years later is just inherently wrong.

What do you think? It's not actually going to happen, but if Capcom said they were George Lucas-ing 2-3 and 3-4 to make them less creepy, would you support this?


r/AceAttorney • • May 03 '21

Capcom... Why? Is nobody going to acknowledge this? What the hell, Capcom?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AceAttorney • • Sep 11 '25

Full Main Series What’s the gayest AA game? Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I’ve only played 5 of the 11 games (PWAA-DD) but I think dual destinies takes the cake for me. What do you guys think?


r/AceAttorney • • Sep 01 '25

Investigations Duology Investigations 2 was Disappointing (An Overly Long Rant) Spoiler

11 Upvotes

(Spoilers for Investigations 1+2, and PWAA)

No, this is not ragebait. I just finished playing the Investigations duology for the first time. Investigations 1 was fine - like most people, it’s definitely my least favourite AA game so far, but I do think it’s a tad overhated. I really enjoyed cases 4 and 5, and 2 was pretty fun too. Anyway, that’s irrelevant.

After being a little disappointed by the first Investigations game, I was very excited to learn that Investigations 2 was apparently a huge improvement. In fact, most people see it as a top 3 Ace Attorney game, if not the very best. And upon completing the game, I… disagree.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s not bad. It’s good. But I’d hesitate to call it any more than that. I am very much in the minority here, and I completely recognise that I am probably objectively wrong. That being said, I thought it would be fun to write down my thoughts on the game, and I’d love to discuss them with others. My goal here is to just have fun and compare my very mixed feelings towards the game with the feelings of those who enjoyed this game more than I did. So then, let’s go case by case.

CASE 1: TURNABOUT TRIGGER

Yeah, didn’t enjoy this one at all to be honest. I found the setting boring, the logic weird, and the characters (Tabby and the President) very annoying. I think it’s fair to say that you appreciate this case more in retrospect, knowing what happens later in the game. On my first playthrough though, I wasn’t impressed. De Killer’s sudden departure of course makes sense five cases later, but it feels very weird when you don’t know what’s happening.

The saving grace of this case for me is the culprit, Bronco Knight. I like this guy a lot - he’s a super memorable villain with a great design and a super cool “Objection!” voice. Frankly, if Bronco wasn’t in this case, it would be a contender for the bottom 5 cases in the series for me. Luckily though, he is in this case. As a result, in my opinion, Turnabout Trigger goes from downright bad, to tolerable. 3.5/10

CASE 2: THE CAPTIVE TURNABOUT

Wait, most people see this case as the weakest in Investigations 2? That honestly blew my mind, because I loved this one! The setting is incredible, the characters are all super fun, and it does a good job of introducing the core cast and main themes of the game. This one’s great! 8.5/10

CASE 3: TURNABOUT LEGACY

Don’t worry. I may be a little weird for not loving Investigations 2, but I’m not THAT weird. This case is fantastic - in fact, I would argue it’s basically perfect. Incredible case, enjoyed literally every minute, no notes. 10/10

CASE 4: A TURNABOUT FORSAKEN

Hey, cool, I loved the last two cases! Unfortunately, that trend ends here. I don’t dislike Case 4, it’s alright. But I was shocked to see how highly this one usually ranks on case tier lists. In the beginning, this case had me hooked - Kay has amnesia? Raincoat guy is back? Edgeworth must face the Committee? This case is gonna be incredible, right?! … right…?

I wanted to love this one. I really wanted to love this one. But I couldn’t. I don’t have any MAJOR problems with this one, rather a bunch of minor problems that stack up to make this case really frustrating for me.

Personally - and I want to emphasise “personally”, because it appears I might be alone in this - the setting of this case was kinda boring to me…? Investigating the top floors of a colossal luxurious skyscraper should’ve been a blast, but… I dunno man, I was kinda uninterested. I can’t really explain why, I just found it kinda boring. Maybe it’s just because it’s directly following two cases which both had settings that I really loved? I don’t know.

Ema is back! Let’s go, one of my favourite characters! It’s so good to see her! I was disappointed that she had such little screen time in The Kidnapped Turnabout, so I’m super excited to see more of her in this - wait, what? She’s gone? She’s in the case for like forty minutes and then disappears? Oh…

Lotta is back too… this is most definitely just a me problem, but I personally find Lotta insufferable. The mere fact that she’s on my screen so much in this case drags it down for me. Again, just a personal thing.

And let’s talk about this case’s culprit, Excelsius. Oh, Excelsius. Where do I even begin? Maybe I’m wrong, but this guy seems to be beloved as one of the greatest villains in all of Ace Attorney. Gonna be honest, I don’t see it at all. This guy is just Damon Gant but less interesting. His “emptying his tears from his goggles” gimmick gets old quick, and despite being one of the most powerful villains in the entire series, I found it genuinely impossible to take this guy seriously. That scene where he reveals his true colours to Edgeworth in the detention center is supposed to be a super tense moment where you’re supposed to find Excelsius super intimidating. All I could think about during that whole Mind Chess sequence though was how much I dislike Excelsius’s design and how much I don’t care about him.

Again though, I don’t HATE this case, as much as it may seem like I do. Kay’s amnesia thing was pretty interesting, Gavèlle turning on Excelsius was a genuinely incredible moment, and I absolutely loved Niedler and Hertz - they were such a fun duo and honestly they were probably the highlight of the case for me. Alright case, not bad, but to be honest I really don’t understand the love for this one. 7/10

CASE 5: TURNABOUT FOR THE AGES

Ready for my hottest Ace Attorney take? I think Turnabout for the Ages is the weakest finale case in all of Ace Attorney. I promise I’m not ragebaiting or anything. I know this case is absolutely beloved in the fandom. But oh my God, I was SOOOO bored when playing it.

Let’s start with something that I think even lovers of this case can agree on: this case is a little all over the place when it comes to pacing / structure. I think there’s simply WAYYYY too much happening in this case. I appreciate that they wanted to make the final case have such a big scope, but I think they were overambitious. You start this case investigating the President’s death, then you need to scramble to tie up loose ends from Case 2, then you need to solve a kidnapping, then you need to solve another murder from years ago, and then, FINALLY, you can actually focus on the murder of the President again.

There are so many parts to this case, and frankly, I don’t really care about ANY of them. The President’s murder was too goofy for me to care about, honestly. The fact that the game keeps insisting that monsters are real feels like an insult to my intelligence. I love Ace Attorney wackiness, but the whole monster plot was a little too ridiculous for me.

The kidnapping / Laguarde plot was probably my favourite part of the case. I absolutely loved Case 2, so I was excited to see characters / plot points from that case become relevant again. I think Eustace’s “redemption” falls kinda flat for me though. It’s rushed and doesn’t feel earned, and right when things are getting interesting, he’s gone. I thought he’d just be absent for the middle of the case but then come back for the final act, but no, he straight up doesn’t appear ever again after this. That was kinda crazy to me - this guy’s on the cover art for this case, I thought he’d play a huge role! Instead though, he gets a rushed arc and is quickly pushed aside once it reaches its climax.

Investigating the SS-5 incident was definitely the weakest part of the case for me. I love Lang and it was great to see him play a role again, but his inclusion in this game really feels like an afterthought. While the SS-5 incident does have some important details, it ultimately feels like an unnecessary one hour detour. Did we really need to waste ALL this time just to reveal that the current President is an imposter? Don’t get me wrong, it’s a fun twist, but the overly long route we have to take to uncover this REALLY hurts the case’s pacing for me. I don’t care what part of the orphanage garden Rosie Ringer’s boyfriend was killed in…?!?

Before I talk about the culprit, let me just briefly discuss this case’s characters real quick: -> Gavèlle: Honestly, I think she’s a bit of a downgrade in this case? I loved where Case 4 left her character, with her betraying Excelsius. In this case she just feels very flat and uninteresting - a caring mother who would do anything for her child? Woah, never seen that before! Maybe that’s unfair idk, I just didn’t love her in this case. -> Tabby and Lotta: Why are they here? This case already had way too many characters. I hate these characters. That’s just me. -> Kanis: Cool! Liked what they added to him in this case. -> Shawn: I’m sorry, I don’t care about this kid at all. My lack of interest in his character probably hurt the case for me.

Alright, culprit time. I have a love-hate relationship with Simeon. I love his theme, I’ve been listening to it non-stop since I finished the game. I love his design and his animations, especially the one where the squirrels are jumping from his hands. He’s a fun villain.

I didn’t find him particularly compelling though. He felt a bit too cartoonishly evil for me, which I realise is probably a stupid complaint, this is Ace Attorney, but still. He just doesn’t feel intimidating in the slightest, and doesn’t feel believable - you’re telling me he orchestrated all these events this perfectly, this flawlessly? It’s cool, don’t get me wrong. The premise of him having a role to play in basically every case in the game is very unique. But like… I don’t know man. I’m not sure if I’m getting my point across, it’s hard to put into words. He just… doesn’t work for me. He feels less like an intimidating manipulative murderer and more like a villain from an Illumination movie or something. “Ooooh, he’s an animal trainer, he can control animals. He’s such a good manipulator that he can control people too!” I dunno. I’m not sure if I’m articulating my point correctly here, it’s hard to put it into words.

People complain about Alba’s confrontation dragging on for too long. Yeah, it probably does, but I wasn’t bothered by it to be honest. Simeon, on the other hand? I assume Simeon’s confrontation is shorter than Alba’s, but boy, it definitely didn’t feel like it to me. And I realise I may very well be the only person on the planet who thinks that. But the way you take Simeon down feels so stupid. You have to present the balloon, what, is it three times? That’s just kinda poor game design. His breakdown is pretty great though, I’ll give him that.

That final confrontation scene really shows just how stupidly overambitious this case is, though. While Edgeworth is arguing with Simeon, there are a dozen other characters there that are completely irrelevant, and serve no purpose other than to occasionally butt in and cheer “You got this Edgeworth!” Some make sense - of course Kay, Gumshoe and Fender make total sense. I guess it makes sense for Lang to be there too, despite how poorly handled I think his inclusion in this case is. Regina makes sense too, given the setting.

But Tabby? Was she really necessary? Also, Gavèlle and Shawn - Gavèlle, take that kid home! He’s a CHILD, he doesn’t need to see this! Also, Ema’s here, for this one scene. No idea why. Good to see her again, but seriously, why? Gumshoe or Lang couldn’t have taken care of the fingerprints? Franziska’s here too. Makes sense, she’s an important character, although she’s totally irrelevant in this game. Seriously, remove her from Investigations 2 and nothing changes.

I think this just really proves this case’s failure (in my opinion) to justify its needlessly large scope. You’re left with so many characters that are completely irrelevant, because you cannot tell a story that gives all these characters their time to shine. The image of Edgeworth confronting Simeon with a parade of almost a dozen people just watching them is absolutely hilarious to me. 5.5/10

FINAL THOUGHTS

I don’t dislike Investigations 2. It’s good. There’s so much good stuff in this game that I didn’t touch on. I just wanted to focus on the negatives more, because there’s nothing good I can say about this game that a thousand people haven’t said already. It’s a good game. I just unfortunately didn’t enjoy it quite as much as everyone else seems to. I’d say it’s a mid tier Ace Attorney game for me. Here’s my rankings of the games I’ve played so far, just to prove that I’m not COMPLETELY insane:

  1. Trials and Tribulations

  2. Dual Destinies

  3. Phoenix Wright

  4. Spirit of Justice

  5. Investigations 2

  6. Apollo Justice

  7. Justice For All

  8. Investigations

I’d love to discuss stuff with people in the comments, if anyone’s crazy enough to actually read all of this. This rant is way too long to proofread so I apologise for the many typos that are likely scattered throughout.


r/AceAttorney • • Jul 16 '24

Discussion LGBT Characters in Future Games Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Do you think there's a possibility AA7 (or any other games) might have at least one canon LGBT character? Ace Attorney naturally doesn't have so much explicit representation, with the only canonically queer character being an outdated stereotype and the others not being 100% confirmed or shown. While they're not forced to include that kind of thing and there's still no telling anything AA7 will even possibly have at all, I think some aspects could work on this theory's favor:

1. The Massively LGBT Fandom

Ever since the very first game AA has had a significant amount of queer fans, and as many know, has even been partially Based On Gay Manga, with that number of fans only increasing with time to the point Narumitsu shipping might be the most recognizable aspect of the series/the fandom. Capcom has been well aware of this for a long time, with some people in production acknowledging it in the past, and more recently the official account making a rather obvious reference to, again, Narumitsu. This means it's a perfect series to have some LGBT representation and even capitalize on it, with the positive feedback it would get being much more significant than any possible backlash they might face.

2. Unconfirmed LGBT Characters

As previously stated, there are some characters in AA who, while not directly and explicitly confirmed, can indeed be considered queer. While some of them are kinda technicalities (Uendo Toneido, Herman Crab, Aromantic Edgeworth), there are two examples that stand out: Aura Blackquill and Rei Membami, who are very obviously attracted to women: Aura loved Metis, which is what drives her very plot relevant actions in DD, and Rei is very gay for both "Ryutaro" and Susato, which makes her a bisexual icon. Aura specifically means the writers are clearly open to having LGBT characters, with the only reason for her not being confirmed likely being prejudice, both by players and possibly by Capcom. Having confirmed and explicit representation that a character is assuredly queer would be even more precious than these.

3. AJ Trilogy Dialogue Changes

In the Apollo Justice Trilogy release of Dual Destinies, some of the dialogue during the third case is changed due to the original 3DS version having some... weird wording that aged pretty badly, specifically due to several interpretations regarding it as transphobic. The new dialogue is more accepting, and while this may seem minor, it reflects Capcom itself being a more accepting company, and in the 11 years that passed they're likely more open to the idea of having that kind of representation. For example, Disney is another company that used to stop writers from adding LGBT themes, no matter how minor, while nowadays they're all for having such things in their works. I don't necessarily think Capcom was super homophobic and is now super accepting, but the fact they had extra effort put into removing these lines from DD at least shows some things have changed.

Again, while they're not forced to have queer characters in the next games, it would certainly make some people very happy, me included. I can't say I particularly believe they will have queer representation or that it's even likely they will, but I wanted to talk about the idea and share my thoughts. Feedback is naturally welcome.