r/ATLAtv • • May 21 '24

Discussion Controversial but …

0 Upvotes

I already know this is going to be a controversial opinion but I really hope this turns into a discussion than anything else. I LOVE the fact that when the show was announced that it was going to be an Asian/Indigenous cast. It’s something that happens so rarely in America and when it does there does tend to be a large amount of Wasian actors part of the projects. I was hoping for people to be kind of more open and forthcoming on how their cultures and such impacted them and their way of growing up. You see actors of other minorities talk about these things or people in their communities that inspire them. The only person who’s really made an effort to connect with their community is Kiawentiio. No one else seems to speak their language, know about their culture or have any interest in talking about their Asian-ness or in Asian spaces closely aligned with their community. Then I realised a lot of the actors don’t seem to know or speak a lot of their own languages/cultures. The only thing really is that we look somewhat similar. Then the project kinda felt empty, that there wasn’t like a shared culture or anything like when other communities have film projects. Maybe I expected too much.

EDIT: Very sad times that me saying it would be nice to have members of the cast speak more about being Asian+their individuals cultures as - “Omg he’s 14, you want him to be an expert on Filipino food” “They’re not Asian enough for you, why must we gatekeep” “They’re just children” I literally said that I had my own expectations and therefore that’s on me. I’m not bashing them or denying them being their own race 💀


r/ATLAtv • • Mar 12 '24

Discussion Saw something that said piss off the fandom using the arrow picture so here I go 🌚

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

In terms of book 1 I prefer the Netflix version to the og. 🤷🏾‍♂️ while I have my gripes, I just had a much better time with the Netflix version. I could go more into detail but as of right now I’m lazy


r/ATLAtv • • Dec 12 '24

Humor I mean

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ATLAtv • • Apr 21 '24

Ian ousley you beauty

Post image
1 Upvotes

No one talking about sexism anymore. He's that good


r/ATLAtv • • Jul 06 '26

Discussion Katara weird acting in season 2?

2 Upvotes

I'm not saying the actor Kiawentiio is awful or anything but she hardly has any drive in her voice or line delivery. One of the most jarring things in my opinion is this weird thing she tends to do where it always looks like shes about to smile or laugh by pulling up the corners of her cheeks. Once you notice this quirk you cannot unsee it. The writing and direction also plays a part too because this version of Katara feel so... passive.

I just don't see how some of these takes of what seems to be Kiawentiio holding back a laugh made it through? All characters don't have these issues, I think Toph and Sokka do an amazing job. Zuko and Iroh though, are absolutely perfect. Whenever Zuko is on screen it feels like I'm watching a high quality feature film, not a college play.


r/ATLAtv • • Mar 31 '24

It’s gonna be a little odd for Gordon Cormier to continue playing Aang while in the middle of puberty

0 Upvotes

But that’s reality. Because he can’t stay the way he looked in the first season especially after turning 14. It’s a miracle how as a kid Zach Tyler Eisens voice barely changed by the end of the series after three years of voicing Aang.


r/ATLAtv • • Sep 13 '24

Humor Always cracks me up

Post image
0 Upvotes

I thought you were the 40th. I hope they don't do these silly mistakes in s2


r/ATLAtv • • Jul 31 '26

Discussion Legend of Korra NEEDS a Netflix live action adaptation

0 Upvotes

TLOK has so many fumbles and missed opportunities, but overall had such a good vision and heart. I think most if not all of the sins of TLOK cartoon could be rectified by a Netflix reimagining.

I have been loving NATLA, I love that they take a fresh perspective of the story while still holding true to the key values and themes, but I understand why many fans feel the NATLA isn’t living up to the original. It can be unsettling for lots of fans to see changes made to something so beloved, but I think some adaptations to the story telling of TLOK would be welcomed by most if not all of the fans. Even people who love TLOK often admit there are notable missteps in the writing.


r/ATLAtv • • Apr 29 '24

Gaang accepted Zuko too quickly in the original IMO

0 Upvotes

New changes I’d actually like then to do is actually make it tough for Zuko to be accepted into the Gaang in season 3. Like i felt like it was only katara who actually had a grudge. J get took not caring as much but at least Sokka would’ve had the same level grudge if not more. I get they didn’t have much time in season 3 to drag and even in the live action i don’t imagine they’ll wil have more time to flesh it out seeing as tho it’ll be less episodes but if there’s one change I’d like to see it’d be that. A bit more animosity between them and Zuko before he gets fully accepted


r/ATLAtv • • Dec 05 '25

Discussion Getting kind of annoyed

3 Upvotes

So they announced they’ve wrapped filming for season 3 right? But that was nearly a month ago. By this time in 2023, we had first looks, a teaser, and an official release date for season 1. Season 2 is supposed to premiere next year and we’ve got nothing so far? All we’ve gotten is Miya saying toph is gonna be slightly more feminine and atla fans already went insane over that when that wasn’t even saying much. It’s just I feel like promo should’ve started long before now? Cuz the rate this is going, we not gonna have a first look til January 😵‍💫


r/ATLAtv • • May 28 '24

Discussion Zuko almost winning the Agni Kai breaks the show.

12 Upvotes

I realize that I’m a bit late to this but i only watched the show recently.

But seriously that fact that a thirteen year old kid who is known as a fairly good but not a prodigious bender was able to nearly beat Ozai in a fight robs him of any kind of Fear or intimidation and the show of Any kind of tension.

Why does Aang need to even worry about mastering the elements if Ozai is so easily beaten.

It just seems like a really dumb decision just to have a cool fight scene.


r/ATLAtv • • Apr 23 '24

Discussion No Martial Arts Training in NATLA Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I posted this in the wrong thread on accident so now I'm posting it here.

just finished watching the entire first season of NATLA and I…have so many thoughts.

It was good enough, respectable adaptation. There were a lot of things that I liked but there were a lot of things that I didn't. One of them being this...

But is it just me or did Aang do absolutely ZERO waterbending training? Like actually less than zero because the time that he could spend training, he spends walking around with a silly grin and giving Katara pep talks about waterbending. Like Aang, she’s literally trying to practice waterbending...couldn't you join here? And not a single soul in the North Pole stresses the importance that Aang learn and master waterbending; or any other element for that matter.

And the gag of it all is that Katara is surrounded by masters and she doesn’t even do any formal training herself. Not healing and not combat. Nothing at all!!! But suddenly, in the finale, she's pulling off these impressively crazy waterbending tricks. What really pissed me off about it was this exchange...

Zuko: You little peasant! You found a master!

Katara: Yes, I did. I'm the master.

I rolled my eyes so hard I almost passed out.

The only person that we see really training in this entire season is Azula. But that's a completely different topic that deserves its own thread...

And the show actually addresses that the Avatar is the master of all elements. But what were they playing at? Way too much time was spent on sequences where Aang is either talking with his past lives or where Aang is attempting to learn about and meet his past lives. Is this the only part of the Avatar’s training that they are planning to focus on? And why have they overemphasized Aang’s need to be in special, specific shrines to contact them?

And now, as of the end of the final episode, he can go into the Avatar State whenever he wants?

Part of the magic and joy and adventure of the original series was that it was also a martial arts training adventure. But that's completely gone in this adaptation.


r/ATLAtv • • Apr 01 '23

News TRAILER COMES OUT TODAY! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hahahahahah you just got April Fooled


r/ATLAtv • • Feb 02 '24

Discussion Don’t crucify me please

0 Upvotes

As I’m sure all of you know, there’s been a large backlash to some of the perceived writing changes that the producers seem to be making based off recent interviews, and that backlash has been pretty harsh.

A problem I’ve seen in response to this is that in this subreddit, there seems to be a reaction in the opposite extreme. It seems that people who post anything about their concerns with the potential writing changes get mass downvoted/dogpiled

While I agree that we should all wait and see for the final product to release, I feel like in the meantime we should be able to have healthy and reasonable discussions about potential writing changes without going too extreme like we have been.

TLDR: don’t shit on people for expressing any concerns with potential writing changes, it’s not very nice


r/ATLAtv • • May 22 '22

Speculation/Suggestion Any Updates on #Recast Sokka? It’s been over a year since that hashtag was making its rounds off that allegation. With that amount of time, social media attention and the seriousness of the allegation you’d think some breakthrough would have been posted by some media outlet site. And yet nothing

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ATLAtv • • Jun 30 '24

Plot changes

2 Upvotes

Anybody else honestly liking the plot changes over the originals? Like nothing major just things I thought were weird anyway in the original. Like Yue having broken off her arranged marriage long before team avatar got there. Vs the original that had this clearly powerful leader of the tribe trapped in an unhappy relationship, which I always thought was strange. There's been other little things like that, that I'm happy to see done differently


r/ATLAtv • • Mar 01 '24

Netflix ATLA Only I’m gonna say it Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I want them to make Zutara a thing in the show, not Kataang


r/ATLAtv • • Apr 23 '24

Some changes

1 Upvotes

Some of the changes were not for me. Like bumi “hating” aang. Idk that’s was weird. Also can Zuko do some fire ending. He’s just doing kicks. Can we get some hand to hand like it the shows. I hope they don’t change too much or change the character’s personalities. And yes the bending needs more work. As in make it more “interesting” like the tv series. More hand to hand not zuko doing a kick 3 times in a row.


r/ATLAtv • • Mar 01 '24

Discussion After watching it twice, Netflix should've done more.

1 Upvotes

Rambling rant incoming

I think Netflix should've leaned into this as much as they possibly could. This should've/could've been their Game of Thrones. Some would argue Stranger Things is their GoT but that's on its way out.

I just feel like I'm having major deja vu of missed opportunity from when the last time a live-action was made. There was a void to be filled. Harry Potter was ending. ATLA hype was palpable. Only for the movie to be the biggest disappointment known to man. Now we're here. Netflix has a gold mine but decided to seal it off.

There could've been 4 live-action seasons. Five if I was in charge. Enough to also allow room for side quests and stories and fluff. They decided to go a more dark route. Cool. Even the darkest of shows have moments of reprieve. Moments to breathe.

Basically, if I was the CEO of Netflix, this would be my big swing. I think I read somewhere the budget was big. If it was, I would've gone bigger. There's no way this couldn't have been a major cash cow if they got it right. Obviously, there is still a chance for that to happen but it's...it's looking flat. It feels flat. Flat isn't bad. The vision is there. It just feels like at moments they didn't believe in it.

It ain't about money but you need it to make art. I feel like Netflix isn't seeing the potential they have.


r/ATLAtv • • Feb 23 '24

Discussion Azula actor didnt feel like Azula at all Spoiler

6 Upvotes

was anyone else disappointed with the Azula actor, not only not looking like Azula but also not even acting like her?


r/ATLAtv • • Jun 29 '26

Strange dialogue Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Does anyone else find the dialogue sounded like it was written by aliens? I am only 15mins into the first episode and the awkward phrasing and word choice keeping ripping me back to reality


r/ATLAtv • • Mar 25 '24

Started the series with an open mind, stopped watching half way through

0 Upvotes

I want to emphasize that I started watching the live action series with an open mind. I heard some good things, and some bad things, so I thought “ok this show is probably somewhere in the middle”.

First couple episodes were fine. Casting and costumes were great. I also didn’t mind that some plot lines were tweaked. Of course I had my criticisms but I still thought it was good overall. Then comes episode 4 (the Omashu episode) and I’m just rolling my eyes.

Like I said I don’t mind that plot points are changed, but come on the Omashu episode was doing too much. Combining Jet, the mechanist, king Bumi, secret tunnel all into ONE episode?? Way too much going on. And don’t even get me started on the dialogues. Katara confronting Jet was just so cringe I rolled my eyes. Aang immediately recognizing Bumi pretty much killed the entire value of that arc. I literally just stopped watching the episode at that point (though I came back and finished it the next day out of boredom lol)

I liked the first 3 episodes but man the Omashu part really dragged. May or may not be continuing the series, haven’t decided.


r/ATLAtv • • Nov 26 '23

Discussion I hope that Netflix’s live-action reimagining of Avatar: The Last Airbender makes Firelord Ozai / the Phoenix King an empathetic main antagonist...

9 Upvotes

Note: Yeah... Yeah... Yeah... I know..., you're probably confused and bewildered by the title of my post and probably saying, "What is the point of trying to create empathy for a character that's into mass genocide and is an elitist and is basically a dictator who is the equivalent of Adolf Hitler and Vladimir Putin with the added bonus of being able to conjure fire and generate lightning...," but just hear me out... The purpose of this post is for me to discuss something that I think Netflix’s live-action reimagining of Avatar: The Last Airbender could change and fix and do better than the original animated Avatar: The Last Airbender series. I might make some other posts on the subreddit discussing the other few problems and issues I had with Avatar: The Last Airbender's overall story that I think the Netflix series could fix and improve upon.

Look, I feel Avatar: The Last Airbender is as close to perfect as you can get, but upon reflection there are a few small things I think would have been cool to see in the show that I hope the Netflix adaptation changes and does differently by adding and expanding more on certain elements of Avatar: The Last Airbender, whether it be characters or storylines. Case in point, Firelord Ozai / the Phoenix King...

Let's be real here..., Firelord Ozai, Avatar: The Last Airbender's main antagonist, is a pretty one dimensional and one note villain who basically has no development... Heck..., Fire Lord Sozin, who only makes a major appearance in season 3 in a mostly flashback episode titled "The Avatar and the Firelord", gets better development and is a better character than Firelord Ozai honestly... Throughout Avatar: The Last Airbender we're basically only told and not shown that Firelord Ozai is "the baddest man on the planet" and it's constantly implied by other characters that Firelord Ozai is an extremely powerful Firebender and that Aang is going to have a tough time beating him, but like I just said, the show only just implies and tells us this and never actual shows us how powerful he is which is definitely a problem because it's actually really important for a story to actually display its main antagonist as threatening... I mean..., yeah..., I get that the point of Firelord Ozai was to be a "means to an end" in Avatar: The Last Airbender and he isn't supposed to be a character with great depth, but I'm not sure that's gonna exactly fly in live-action..., especially when you have an actual great and badass actor, Daniel Dae Kim, playing him => https://variety.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/AVTR_Unit_00950R.jpg... It would be a huge waste of potential to just have Daniel Dae Kim play a bland character that lacks any depth or development.

That's why I'm proposing the idea of Netflix’s live-action reimagining of Avatar: The Last Airbender to make Firelord Ozai an empathetic main antagonist / villain... The most important thing that an audience should feel for your characters is empathy. When it comes to villains, especially the main antagonist, you need that empathy in order for your antagonist to feel like a real character and not just as an obstacle for the heroes to overcome like the animated Firelord Ozai... The audience doesn't need to feel sorry for the villain because sympathy isn't half as potent as empathy is. Understanding is always way stronger than pity when it comes to storytelling. The perfect example of this can be found in Thanos from the MCU, primarily in Avengers: Infinity War. You don't necessarily feel sorry for Thanos when you watch that movie, but you understand where he's coming from, you understand his motivation, and you can see why he feels justified in his actions and thinks and genuinely believes he's changing the world for the better... That's the most important thing when it comes to building a great main antagonist that's empathetic and that has actual depth.

I think that Netflix’s live-action reimagining of Avatar: The Last Airbender should show more from the perspective of Firelord Ozai where we see in his twisted mind he's just trying to make the world a better place and the Avatar is stepping in the way of that and preventing his plans... Also, I think they should touch on the relationship between Iroh/Ozai a little more as I think it could offer some cool parallels between the Zuko/Azula relationship as well as give even more depth to Firelord Ozai / the Phoenix King for the live-action adaptation.


r/ATLAtv • • Jun 30 '26

Discussion I am SO confused Spoiler

44 Upvotes

I love this live action show, especially the second season. I have never watched the animated show. I went into this not knowing much and not expecting much. I saw a cast interview and thought the kid/teen actors were so fun and lively, I decided to give it a shot just because of that. I loved how they interacted with eachother and how happy they seemed to be cast in this.

I am extremely surprised at all the hate this show is getting online. I realized the animated show has a very interesting fanbase, and that they want everything super similar to the original etc. Ok that's fine but as someone who doesn't care for the original, no offense, I am looking at this show as its own thing, and the writers can make whatever changes they want and I am fine with it.

But another thing that surprised me is...the romantic endgames...WOW. I just found out very recently, after I had already finished season 2 of the live action, that Katara ends up with Aang, and Zuko ends up with Mai. I AM SHOCKED/CONFUSED. Watching season 1, I would have never guessed that cute little boy was supposed to end up kissing the character of Katara, whom in season 1 looks and feels like his older sister, almost a guiding figure to him etc. I know the characters are supposed to be 2 years apart, but visually and character development wise, it is giving triple that.

And in season 2 the Aang actor is noticeably older, but he still looks and acts a lot younger than her. It is weird and awkward to me. Maybe if the show was going to have 5+ seasons etc then ok maybe somehow? But season 3 will only have 7 episodes (my biggest issue with the show sigh Netflix why </3) and then it is done.

I swear I thought they were going to do Katara and Zuko. Even in season 1 because I saw that Zuko had potential to be on their side, and they seemed complementary, and then in season 2 I was all "OMG THEY ARE DEVELOPING THEM FOR REAL NOW" multiple times, and then I got spoiled and learned that these ship wars are a huge thing that have spanned decades. And that the "zutara" pair was extremely popular and invented "ship weeks" and is this whole iconic thing etc. Wow. Ok it's really that deep.

But now I am thinking. This is an adaptation. So it will have lots of similarities but not everything will be the same. I am genuinely confused because I can't see Katara ending up with Aang. And Zuko and Mai are supposed to be a thing too??? What...

Also apparently some writers for this live action liked the Zuko/Katara pair more and got harrassed like crazy for it by fans of the original. Again, what. So are they going to be like "ok we will stick with the original pairings so we don't get bullied more"? Or will it be "muahahaha we will take creative liberties and follow our hearts!"?

Am I just dumb and misinterpreting what the writers are trying to portray between the characters? Are the writers just doing fan service? Are the writers actually changing the pairings? WHAT IS GOING ON 💀

UPDATE: STARTED WATCHING THE CARTOON TO SEE WHAT THE HYPE IS ABOUT...


r/ATLAtv • • Apr 02 '24

Is it just me or was Zhao done dirty? First off, Ozai sent him on a mission he knew would never succeed. Secondly, he was just one of Azula's pawns. I feel like he had a more lasting impact in the OG show. What are your thoughts?

Post image
0 Upvotes