r/ATLAtv • • Jun 30 '24

Plot changes

Anybody else honestly liking the plot changes over the originals? Like nothing major just things I thought were weird anyway in the original. Like Yue having broken off her arranged marriage long before team avatar got there. Vs the original that had this clearly powerful leader of the tribe trapped in an unhappy relationship, which I always thought was strange. There's been other little things like that, that I'm happy to see done differently

2 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

28

u/MRnibba_ Jun 30 '24

the original that had this clearly powerful leader of the tribe trapped in an unhappy relationship

What do you mean "leader"? Yue wasn't the chief of the Northern Water Tribe, her father was. She was "trapped" in the unhappy relationship because it was arranged by her father, aka the chief.

And it seemed like she wasn't even really trapped, but rather she was willing to go through with it out of loyalty to her father

11

u/Mr_Porcupine Jun 30 '24

“Leader trapped in an unhappy relationship” Yea that was the indication of that plot point. Its telling a tragic story of the shittiness of arranged royal pairings. It portrayed the dilemma of a young girl torn between her own desires, and her loyalty to her people.

Kind of like a foreshadowing to the Avatar’s whole “should I be true to my self or responsible to the world I’m supposed to protect?” and “should I kill the firelord because its what the world needs, or should I follow my own teachings and beliefs of morality?”

Sometimes a story is tragic. Sometimes writing is good.

8

u/seriouscrabgrass Jun 30 '24

I think the change to first contact with the Avatar spirit happening with Kyoshi on her island makes more sense than sneaking into the Fire Nation so early.

Also quietly adding the Mother of Faces was a nice touch.

7

u/TigerFern Jun 30 '24 edited Jun 30 '24

The Northern Tribe still being institutionally sexist and Yue being allowed to just break her engagement to the tribes Most Goodest and Handsomest Boy is far weirder than the common story of a girl being forced to bear the burden of her family's political alliances by marrying an asshole who doesn't care about her.

In the original Sokka was a kind sweet boy who made her laugh vs her dick fiancé. In this one, Hahn is comically attractive and kind. And Yue dumbs him after meeting Sokka for 2 minutes as a fox? There's not even time to make this a "even if your betrothed is a nice person, freedom in love is important" thing.

3

u/AtoMaki Jul 03 '24

This might be a hot take but I liked the new Sukka more, I absolutely loved how it rooted in Sokka's insecurities about being a warrior. Tho it does have a different feel than the original, but I guess I prefer the NATLA version.

Speaking of which, the extra Suki lore was nice. Yukari was a pretty good character.

The change of Katara being directly responsible for her mother's death and it serving both as a block and inspiration for her waterbending was really good and probably my favorite part in NATLA.

9

u/Canahedo Jun 30 '24

I think the one thing they did better was the earth soldiers escorting Iroh. I can't think of a single scene or moment (ok, Zhao was great, but I don't think one was better than they other, both versions are great for different things) where the Netflix version improved on the original.

Yue in particular was a really bad change IMO. The original wasn't perfect, but there was at least some conflict which mirrored what Katara was going through. We see another angle of the mistreatment of women, and we see how that impacts even the daughter of the chief. It also allowed Han to actually be a character, when he was absolutely non-existent in the remake. It set up the "We can't be together" line for the Sokka and Yue relationship early, even if that later shifts from "...because I'm engaged" to "...because I'm the moon". And I see absolutely no benefit to making Yue able to hop into the spirit world, other than to give a character with almost no screen time just a few seconds more.

They could have really improved on her character. Instead she is just another woman whose only importance is to be sacrificed to motivate the other characters (even more so than in the original), and Han is an absolute nothing of a character, for the whole 20 seconds or so of screen time he gets pre-death.

3

u/JakeTiny19 Jul 01 '24

Personally I like Ozai more than the original. Actor did great , still an evil dude but a bit more depth to him which I really like . There isn’t really a huge plot change that I personally like more . There’s some small stuff they did that I liked that changed (like Yue being a waterbender) but nothing huge . Idk if this is a plot change , but I do kinda like the fact to talk to another avatar u have to be around their statue which to me kinda makes sense if u wanna talk to them specifically. But I still wish he can still call on Roku whenever , if he can’t then that personally changes my viewpoint here

3

u/Canahedo Jul 01 '24

to talk to another avatar u have to be around their statue

Except Kuruk just showed up to tell Aang "Oh, by the way, they're gonna kill the fish". The original had past avatars just showing up after making a whole deal about being at Roku's statue on the solstice, so it's a thing both did, but it's still not great writing. If you're going to say that he can only talk to past lives in certain circumstances, stick with it.

7

u/untablesarah Jun 30 '24

I liked that Yue could waterbend but the girlbossification was not something I felt was necessary. If anything it sorta took from her character. Yue wasn’t happy with the marriage but was willing to do it because it was deemed necessary for her tribe she was the kind of person who put aside her personal wants and needs for others.

Not to say there isn’t at all a way to make her go against that but the way they made the change felt lazy and with Han being a better person in NATLA it didn’t even have the same impact.

It also did a disservice to showing us that the northern water tribe was stuck in old ways- we were told it was but at nearly ever turn we were shown the opposite

2

u/jeffreykare Jul 02 '24

I thought certain plot points, stakes, and character motivations were successfully beefed up a bit. One of them being how Katara and Sokka were more in danger while Aang was captured by Zhao as opposed to just being sick.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '24

I thought it was a nice detail that the soldiers on the boat with Zuko were the 41st division who would have otherwise been sacrificed.

3

u/Massive-Machine6200 Jun 30 '24

Idk I really liked hahn and yue in this change