Hey everyone! I’d appreciate some outside opinions on a comment I received on one of my longfics.
I’ve attached screenshots of the comment with all identifying information removed as well as my A/N. For context, this is a reader who has regularly commented on this particular story, so they’re not someone who’s unfamiliar with it.
The part that rubbed me the wrong way was:
“At least you were able to write more than 3k words of yet another idea that will be left unfinished in the end.”
I’m trying not to take this the wrong way, because the rest of the comment is actually quite nice. They say they enjoyed the chapter, mention wanting to reread the story, and thank me for sharing it. So I’m not sure whether this was intended as a joke, a dig, or just an awkwardly worded expression of concern.
But that particular sentence really bothered me, especially the assumption that the story will be left unfinished.
For some additional context, this is a niche pairing fic, and I’ve written 55 works for this particular pairing. Technically, only four of those are unfinished aside from my current longfic, and none of them are necessarily abandoned. One was always intended as a one-shot that I might continue someday, one was my second fic ever for the pairing, and two are longer projects that I eventually lost motivation for because they received virtually no engagement. One of those is around 95k words, and the other is around 150k words. I may return to them someday.
Also, the last time I actually stopped working on a fic for this pairing was August 2025. It’s now November 2026.
And the story this person is commenting on? It’s currently over 735k words uploaded, with approximately 1.2 million words written and a planned total of around 2 million words when it’s finished. I have absolutely no plans to abandon it or slow down.
Before AO3 went down, I was updating consistently, anywhere from every day to every five days, depending on my schedule. The longest I ever went between updates was nine days, and my chapters generally range from 7k–12k words. I’ve been able to maintain that consistency because I write so far ahead before I start uploading.
I also just returned from the recent AO3 shutdown and specifically mentioned in my author’s note that the story was still ongoing, that I had a backlog of chapters ready, and that I was excited to get back to sharing updates.
I think that’s part of why the comment caught me off guard.
I’ve worked incredibly hard on this story and have put a lot of time and effort into maintaining a consistent update schedule. I’ve also been trying very hard to avoid burning myself out. Writing is something I genuinely love, and I have a lot of other projects that I’ve worked on during the shutdown, too.
I’ve had insecurities in the past about unfinished projects, and I’ve made a conscious effort to keep myself motivated, finish what I can, and not turn writing into an obligation. So perhaps this particular comment hit a nerve because it felt like someone was dismissing all of that effort.
I’m not looking to start drama, identify the commenter, or have anyone contact them. I’m genuinely just curious how other authors and readers would interpret this.
Am I being too sensitive or reading too much into the wording? Would you interpret this as passive-aggressive? And would you respond to it, or just leave it alone?
I usually respond to all my comments, so I’m also a little unsure how to handle this one without sounding defensive if they genuinely didn’t mean it that way.
Thanks for reading! ❤️