r/AO3 • • Aug 16 '25

Proship/Anti Discourse Geniunely hurts to see this kind of anti rethoric on somewhere where I'd normally be vibing and hanging out... NSFW

Post image
106 Upvotes

On an 'Are there any types of OCs you refuse to make?' post in r/OriginalCharacter.

Fucking god. You are allowed to dislike something without declaring it illegal.

'But illegal--" Shut. No, no it fucking isn't. Do you know what CSEM stands for? Child Sexual Abuse Material. You know what isn't being abused when people write underage characters? Real. Fucking. Children.

It geniunely makes me so annoyed because... they're on a subreddit that, based on the premise at least, I'd absolutely love! Except no, no I wouldn't because it's absolutely infested with antis (and also children, which I imagine has something to do with how many antis there are on there).

While I may personally prefer yaoi and the such, I don't mind or go out of my way to attack people who like lolicon--because it's not fucking real.

These people can't differentiate fiction from reality. And to quote this guy: 'If you ask "Why?" Seek professional help."


r/AO3 • • Sep 11 '25

Discussion (Non-question) My most unpopular opinions: delete more often...

0 Upvotes

... and you cannot complain about an author deleting/no longer updating if you don't comment.

This is my hottest take - writers should delete their works more often. Not orphaning (you lose control of your writing that way), deleting. It's more freeing that you think, and if people care enough about the fic, they would've already downloaded it. If it's no longer serving you, delete that fic and don't look back. You can always reupload it later if you truly regret it. Am I sorry to the eight fandoms I've victimized by doing that? A little. Do I regret it? Absolutely not.

I write for myself, I share for others, and if that sharing ever gets in the way of my writing/personal enjoyment, it's time to delete. I've deleted many works for many reasons. I'm no longer interested in the fandom and I don't want people to have access to my writing? Deleted. I wanted to take some lines, scenes, concepts, or whole plot lines for an original piece I'm writing and don't want to face plagiarism allegations? Deleted. I stepped away from the fic for too long and I want to continue working on it privately, but it needs a complete overhaul because my writing style no longer meshes with the original? Deleted. There's absolutely no engagement despite the amount of hits/reads and it's bothering me too much? Deleted. It's haunting me that this WIP is out there and it's preventing me from working on other things? Deleted. My fic has somehow become popular outside of the insular fandom space I intended it for (and reached people who have no idea what fandom etiquette is) and it's poisoned the entire piece of work for me? Deleted.

You are sharing your creative work for free, don't feel guilty about that deletion. You've already done enough and this is one of the few things you have control over. Will some people be disappointed? Possibly, but they'll move on. There's hundreds of fics out there that they can continue reading. Before you ask if I've ever been disappointed by an author deleting their work - the answer is no. If I cared enough, I downloaded the fic to a hard drive and my e-reader, and I don't mind WIPs.

My second hottest take is that if you don't comment, you don't get to complain if a writer doesn't update or deletes their work. If you didn't care enough to comment even a single emoji (emoji comments are way more valid than pls update ones, imho), I don't see how you can care enough that their work is no longer being updated/deleted. Readers don't owe authors comments/interaction, just like authors don't owe readers their work - I truly believe that.

However, every comment is a vote for an update or against deletion (but, not a coin that goes into a vending machine that gives you content). If I loved a fic enough, I've left comments that require three comment boxes worth of replies just to let the writer know that I'm enjoying it and I'm rooting for them and their updates. It's synonymous with the whole 'if you want a village, you must be a villager'. If you want your favourite fic writers to continue updating, make the effort to comment so you foster a space where they feel good about updating. If you've ever actively engaged with a fic through commenting, and it gets deleted or stops updating, your disappointment/upset feelings are more valid than someone who is just lurking. I would rather hear you complain than anyone else and as a writer, I'd probably e-mail you the PDF/EPUB if you asked.

[An aside: I know people are going to hate the last one, but this is why fandom culture is dying and some of your favourite fics are not being updated. Your favourite writers don't feel that their work is being appreciated - simply expected, so they won't expend the effort to share. The constant influx of wanting more and more content for less community or engagement will not balance out in the end. Something will have to give and I truly see it being the side that provides versus the side that consumes because without engagement/interaction, fic writers get nothing at the end of the day, not even paid. If there isn't any engagement/interaction, what's so different about simply keeping their work in a word processor or cloud? Nothing, really.]


r/AO3 • • Oct 09 '26 Thanks

Discussion (Non-question) Let's talk about Harry Potter

168 Upvotes

If we can do it without insults, please.

I'm still active in the fandom, I'll admit it. There's a growing amount of vitriol I've seen recently that makes me feel incredibly unwelcome here on the AO3 subreddit every time there's a post related to the fandom.

I get it. Rowling is trash. She's literally the worst. I don't give her any money, and I haven't since her views became known. I never will. But Harry Potter was a huge part of an honestly shitty childhood for me, and it was one of my favorite escapes for a long time.

So I gotta ask, why am I being insulted for not letting her take away one of the few things that still gives me joy in this hellscape of a world? Why do I have to let her terrible behavior take away something that's mine? The fact is that the property is a juggernaut, and fanfic is never going to do anything to change that. Treating people who still engage with the fandom like we're monsters for doing it makes no sense to me.

And again, please, can we keep it civil? I'm very aware of the sentiment towards members of the fandom.


r/AO3 • • Jan 08 '26

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting Authors, do not do this!

Post image
0 Upvotes

Stop self-deprecating at the literal top of your fic. This was literally the first sentence in the description! Don't put it in the tags, the description, the A/N, just stop putting it in your fics! I'm not gonna read your stuff if even you don't think it's good! Nothing makes me scroll past faster than "I shouldn't have written this, might delete it later teehee~"


r/AO3 • • Jun 30 '26

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting Why do so many F/F fics have GP? NSFW

0 Upvotes

Before I start, this sort of complaint does not refer to fics where one character is trans and it makes sense for the plot. I'm talking about just your average F/F gp fanfic. I can understand it in some sense for very explicit fics, but what happened to the beauty of puh on puh?? I don't always avoid them, but it's such a large majority of works that include it. F/F is already such a relatively smaller ship tag, so sometimes it just feels lazy that we're making every story gp just for the sake of an "easier" smut scene


r/AO3 • • Dec 13 '24

Complaint/Pet Peeve Authors don't owe readers tags

21 Upvotes

Prefacing this by saying as an fic writer, I DO tag.

However, I truly disagree with the expectation that fic should be 'appropriately' tagged. First of all that varies by opinion.

IMO, tagging serves more to protect the author than the reader. You can opt out of archive warnings and rating, but if a reader complains about something happening, it's like a fall-back to say, well I tagged it and you chose to read it, that's on you!

For the reader, tagging is protective in the way of avoiding things that you dislike/make you uncomfortable but otherwise it mostly exists for easy browsing, to help you find fanfic you enjoy and to make finding a fic to red easier if you're looking for a certain niche.

Not tagging may simply reduce visibility for the author but I don't see it as a requirement.

However, I think getting strict about tags is pointless, especially if it may be a spoiler or simply something you dislike ...similar to trigger warnings for random things like water or something.

My opinion stems from the fact that media like books, films etc, are not expected to be tagged with so much detail (aside from age rating, significant trigger warnings) and we generally pick stuff to read/watch based only on a summary + idea of the genre.

So then why does fic have to list out all these tags and why do some people expect it? Like, why is it different for fic?

And mostly, why do some people think the author owes them tags?

ie 'I dont like seeing this but you didn't tag it' - yes unpleasant, yes it 'wasted your time' but I don't think the author has a moral duty to tag things.

If a book or show goes in a direction you don't like people just drop it, they don't usually contact the creators saying 'Why didn't you make it obvious this was going to happen?'

Thoughts? Like, I appreciate tagging and use it myself because it helps me find stuff I like and filter what to avoid, but I just disagree with saying authors NEED to tag for readers.

edit: seems most people are saying points I've already addressed. I literally pointed out for the author it only reduces visibility and if they don't care that's on them.

Some of you also didn't seem to read all of this, because I stated twice I tag everything I write and also use the tag system as a reader. Never did I personally say I disagree with their existence or usage. I regularly discard fics if I dislike the tags or exclude them.

I also never said I disagree with ratings and stuff for common triggers similar to books and films and people should follow ao3 conditions obviously.

A lot of comments are just proving my point of reduced visibility 'Well I wont read this if you don't tag it appropriately', then just continue leave those tagless writers and just read well tagged fics instead. I'm sure you not reading their fic is not a huge loss to the author.


r/AO3 • • Mar 27 '26

Meme/Joke I don’t know why some of yall do this to yourselves

Post image
4 Upvotes

please stop setting yourselves up for disappointment 😭

Not every bookmark is gonna be positive if a couple rude bookmarks are enough to ruin your whole day, why risk looking if you know you can’t handle it.


r/AO3 • • Feb 14 '25

Complaint/Pet Peeve Why "Bookmarks are for readers" is a load of bull

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I know this discussion is common around here, but I wanted to throw this in the mix as an example of why public bookmarks 'for reviews' is a dumb fucking idea.

A little background on me - I have severe ADHD and writing isn't something I've been able to consistently do since I was off work in 2020, though I miss it terribly.

I tend to check my bookmarks because tbh I get overwhelmingly positive comments. If I'm struggling to write, sometimes this can help.

You'll hear the argument that bookmarks are the readers' space, if you can't handle it don't look, it helps others find what to read, etc.

Well, here's a few of my bookmarks - the first one? Fantastic. Makes me feel great, makes them feel great, probably convinces people because it's passionate.

The second? Hilarious and I just wanted to include it, it's not a helpful bookmark but one of my faves anyway.

Now, the other day I was doing the "hmm should I try to write?" thing again and decided to see if anyone was digging my works - I've found friends like this, too. Had a bunch of wonderful comments I hadn't seen. But I saw this one single bookmark - unhelpful in the extreme, to anyone looking - and you know what I did? I closed out of the fic I was trying to write and said fuck it. It's not even negative, necessarily, in fact it's quite nonsensical, but it was enough to ruin my day.

Look, as far as I'm concerned, putting anything negative out there attached to something someone does in their spare time as a hobby is not just dickish, it's going to mean you have less fic to read. And inb4 "you're too sensitive!!!" Okay. About a hobby I pour my soul into and provide to you for free, yeah. Yeah I am sensitive. And whether you think that or not, the bottom line will be less fic in the world. Is that actually what you want?


r/AO3 • • 21d ago

Meme/Joke Brah. Don't think cat's tail work like that bub. Spoiler

Post image
43 Upvotes

I'm all for creativity but This is like show an entomologist a tarantula's 'skeleton'. Freakin hilarious thou.

(This work is not set in fantasy, sci fi or monster au what so ever. That made it even more funny!)


r/AO3 • • Aug 14 '26

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting Untagged Cheating

1 Upvotes

to the fic author who added surprise untagged cheating between my ship on chapter nine of their fic, i hope your pillow is forever warm. i hope you step on a lego. i hope your crops don't thrive. i hope your skin is never clear. i hope your internet is slow forever. i'm so upset 😭😭😭

i left a polite comment telling them they should add "cheating" to the tags of their fic but man i wanted to curse them out 😭 PLEASE TAG YOUR FICS PROPERLY I'M BEGGING

Edit: Guys, this is a vent post. Obviously, I'm not wishing for actual harm on the author. That's why I said silly stuff like "i hope your crops don't thrive" or "i hope you step on a lego." I just wanted to vent. It was an incest fic btw. I have no problem with kinks and I'm not the prudish type. I just think it's annoying to not tag cheating or at least mention it in the notes of the fic at the start of the fic if you're really worried about spoiling people (you can put a spoiler warning using details/summary html). Isn't it common courtesy to tag properly so people can filter out the things they don't like? I'm not expecting every single little thing to be tagged, but cheating isn't some little thing in the fic. It affects the plot and dynamic significantly. It's frustrating to be deep into a fic and then have something unexpected pop up. I stopped reading and I didn't spam their comments. I just asked them to add cheating to the tags, but ofc, they don't have to. It was just a suggestion. I know it's not actually a huge deal, I just came to vent 😭 I don't think it's a huge deal to just suggest they add the tag or complain a bit on an anonymous subreddit to get it out of my system, like damn. I'm also not leading a harassment campaign against them.


r/AO3 • • Jul 13 '25

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting why authors delete.

23 Upvotes

recently migrated from tumblr to reddit and am honestly a little shocked at how many people i see hurt over authors deleting their works.

as an fic author of over a decade who deleted everything, it was because no one cared. no one talked to me about it. i got the kudos and the hits, but the comments and the bookmarks? maybe once every other month or more. despite having over 40 works, 600k words, hosted fic challenges, exchanges, fandom events, all of it. i was active in the fandom, i had friends who read my stuff. i got maybe two comments on it, but the moment i tried to have actually conversations?

silence. stolen ideas and lines. expectations of writing THEIR ideas when they felt they couldnt execute it.

so why would i care if i deleted something if i didnt think anyone liked it? no one told me they liked it. it got no traction besides a bump in hits. i got frustrated writing my heart and soul out for people, for a series that saved my life, only to get nothing back. maybe I'd find out a month later that someone reread it or printed it out and bound it. but was i ever told that someone loved my writing that much? never.

and i dont want someone to tell me that writing should be for me, that i shouldn't have focused on comments. because thats not what I'm talking about here. it's about the interaction. the relationship you build, author and reader, and the use of the fic as the medium. writing to me was a way to say i love you, i care for you, let me share this love, and getting nothing back is an equivalent to it getting stomped on.

i deleted everything associated with fandom and my writing on a whim and no one reached out despite having other ways to contact me. those accounts were over a decade old. most of the friendships were as well. i have no remorse.

so yeah. why the hell would i keep that stuff up if no one cared enough to ask what was going on. at least, that's my point of view.


r/AO3 • • Dec 19 '25

Meme/Joke And having to wade through the garbage to find the good stuff gets tedious

Post image
118 Upvotes

r/AO3 • • Jul 05 '26

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting Do you ever read a fanfic and think an author might be unpleasant IRL?

0 Upvotes

I know there’s been plenty of fanfic red flags before. But does anyone else have author red flags? I.e. things you read in a fic (that might even be a great fic) that makes you certain you wouldn’t want to be friends with the author?

Some of mine are not about the trope (which could be really interesting) but the way it seems to be glorified:

  • when a canon character is bashed to justify a ship AND the ship can no longer be friends with that character since they’ve gotten together, this is treated as good and self-evident

  • we’re told a character is very cool and BAMF for being horrible to other people

  • as an extension of the above: telling someone else all the ways they’re horrible then stalking off without letting them answer is treated as admirable


r/AO3 • • Jul 29 '26

Stats/Hit Counts/Word Counts Ao3 ship stats summer 2026. All hail to the fujoshis absolute domination🙏

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/AO3 • • 29d ago

Questions/Help? Anyone else find the whole malfoid trend weird?

279 Upvotes

I'm trying to fundamentally understand why r/malfoid blew up. I really am. I mean I've been in this fandom since 2009. But all of a sudden with an AI video and animation female draco malfoy is everywhere. I really don't get it.

Now don't get it wrong. I'm the guy who loved daphne greengrass and harry potter smut fics back in the early to mid 2010s. But I didn't see the virality of it back then.

Now all of a sudden the whole internet has gone crazy for this premise that has been around for at least 17 years and I'm think 'what the hell is going on?'

UPDATE: I think I've finally worked out why the Malfoid trend bothers me, and it isn't because I hate the character.

I've been writing fanfiction for more than a decade. I've been using AI privately to help develop my fictional worlds for the last year or two. I enjoy genderbending, alternate universes, morally grey romance, tsunderes, smut, wish fulfilment, and attractive, powerful female characters.

So I'm not looking down on any of those things.

In fact, that's the problem. Female Draco is remarkably close to the kind of romantic character I like.

A beautiful, wealthy, proud, aristocratic woman with a sharp tongue, questionable family loyalties and the potential to become a fiercely devoted romantic partner? Absolutely. I've written women like that for years.

But there's a catch.

Most of my stories begin where the popular Malfoid romance is trying to end.

My characters are already in relationships. The question isn't whether they'll confess, kiss, have sex or marry. The question is whether they can build something together afterward.

Take my Mass Effect fanfiction. Male Shepard and Miranda Lawson are already romantically involved before Mass Effect 1. Neither knows the full extent of the other's professional loyalties. She's secretly connected to Cerberus, and he's about to become a Spectre. The relationship exists first. The conflict emerges from what they discover later.

Result: Miranda realizes 'oh shit' when she has to revive her husband but the Illusive man doesn't trust her to manage him after revival.

In another story, Jane Shepard discovers her boyfriend has unknowingly been positioned as a romantic intelligence asset against her. She believes he didn't knowingly agree to it, but still investigates the security implications. They love each other. That doesn't eliminate accountability.

Result: She puts him in a holding cell for a week while thinking about what to do with their relationship.

Or take my One Piece fanfiction. My Semi-self insert OC is married to Charlotte Galette and Charlotte Smoothie. Big Mom arranged the relationships for political purposes, and Smoothie was originally meant to execute him if he betrayed her mother.

So what happens when those marriages become genuine relationships? What if their children, household, businesses and shared future create obligations that conflict with Big Mom's instructions?

That's the actual story I want to explore.

Here's an easier experiment.

Give Harry and female Draco $20,000 and establish that they're already married. Now tell me what happens.

Do they invest? Save? Spend? Disagree? Start something? What happens if Draco's father interferes? Can they make an ordinary financial decision without turning everything into romantic insecurity?

I want to know how they function as partners.

My ideal love interest is an independently capable, intelligent, sometimes morally grey, imperfect woman who chooses lasting partnership without surrendering her identity. She can be sarcastic, dangerous, arrogant and even tsundere. But she must remain consistent, loyal, competent and capable of holding her partner accountable.

I don't need her to agree with the protagonist. I need her to judge him fairly. Don't blame him for something genuinely outside his control; do hold him responsible for things he knowingly chooses. And he owes her exactly the same.

I'm interested in established relationships involving people who can cooperate, disagree, make mistakes, raise children, manage resources, have intellectual conversations and construct a shared future. The romance doesn't disappear. It becomes part of their lives.

That's why the Malfoid trend feels like an uncanny valley to me.

She resembles the kind of romantic heroine I want, but the most visible content often concentrates on attraction, jealousy, blushing, romantic denial and the eventual promise of marriage.

I want to see what happens after the marriage.

And I'm irritated by the cultural inconsistency. Female Draco, Drarry, enemies-to-lovers, genderbending and romantic wish fulfilment have existed for decades. Suddenly one attractive anime interpretation explodes and some people talk as though they've discovered something revolutionary.

I'm glad people enjoy it. I'm glad it introduces newcomers to fanfiction. But I'd like the same respect extended to the writers and readers who've been enjoying these tropes for twenty years.

I'm not saying Malfoid can't become a complex character, or that short romantic comics are obligated to be twenty-year marriage sagas.

I'm saying that the viral fantasy is almost perfectly designed to catch my attention, but often stops just before the part I personally find most interesting.

I don't hate the fantasy of Harry getting the girl. I prefer the fantasy of Harry and the girl actually building a life together.

Final Update since I need to make it clear for my sanity:

I've written fanfiction for more than a decade. I don't dislike female Draco, tsunderes, genderbending or romantic wish fulfilment. I dislike the way a familiar, often shallow romantic premise is suddenly being treated as revolutionary, particularly by people who dismiss comparable fanfiction. I prefer stories where the relationship begins early and the characters must actually live with the consequences of loving each other.


r/AO3 • • Mar 26 '26

Discussion (Non-question) HOT TAKE!!! In SOME case critique comments are not that bad.

12 Upvotes

I know y’all hate critique comments. And I agree with the whole “we write for free” and AO3 etiquette thing. But sometimes I’ll see a comment that’s actually polite and trying to be helpful, like pointing out a small issue or giving feedback, and people still get super defensive about it.

Idk, to each their own, but if you’re a writer wouldn’t you kinda want to know how to improve? Or actually talk to readers beyond just surface level “omg I loved this” comments? Again, this is just my opinion, but I believe people should stop looking at every comment that isn’t pure praise as an attack. Your story can still be good and have flaws at the same time.


r/AO3 • • Dec 10 '23

Complaint Wishlist: upgraded blocking

0 Upvotes

(Disclaimer: I realise this is unlikely to happen and would be difficult to implement. This is a mild complaint for a personal peeve that acknowledges it’s unlikely to ever be resolved.)

I’m gonna be real with you guys, I was excited by the introduction of block/mute functions but it genuinely doesn’t go far enough for my tastes. I wish we could flat out block a specific user from seeing our works at all.

If someone has waved their rancid clown ass at me enough that I don’t want them allowed to comment on my works and don’t want to see them, why should they continue to be able to see my stuff? If I was baking pies and someone was vile to me I would refuse to give them a slice, not just turn around and shut my eyes while they dig their nasty hands into the product of my hard work, so why should my stories be any different?

‘If you are a jackass to someone, you are not entitled to what they create’ is just common sense.

But then, I prefer ‘blocking keeps them from seeing you’ options in general and am not a fan of the style of many websites where the people you block can still see your content or messages just fine…

(Disclaimer repeated for people who ignored it the first time: I realise this is unlikely to happen and would be difficult to implement. This is a mild complaint for a personal peeve that acknowledges it’s unlikely to ever be resolved.)


r/AO3 • • Aug 30 '25

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting made a mistake of checking bookmarks

Post image
0 Upvotes

so recently there was a post here, where op realized bookmarks are public it reminded me that, in fact, yes, they can be (iirc you can set them to private while making or editing the bookmark), so decided "hey, wonder if people are writing anything about my fics?" so i checked the bookmarks found this in a fic from 2020 and... idk, it was... like... why? ofc i went on a stalk session, bc now i have to know if it's directed or what, and it looks like that person just, literally, treats bookmarks like review and critic blog or whatever?

like... i know that specific fic has some iffy writing, i noticed it when i re-read the fic after a few months since posting, but why the hell would anyone bookmark like that, it makes zero (0) sense to me tbh. also for obvious reasons made me sad :/

i blocked them since, goodbye mr whateveryournicknamewas

i know i could rewrite the fic, i thought about it, too, but also... i kinda just don't want to. i was very proud of it when i posted it, changing sth kinda takes away from that imo


r/AO3 • • Feb 07 '23

Meme/Joke Kinda sad those are among the more famous fics

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AO3 • • Sep 05 '24

Resource AO3's Contact Support Page is currently closed! Here are other avenues to let AO3 know your thoughts and feelings about 'All Media Types' removal, and it's negative impacts. (+ updated list of issues)

0 Upvotes

UPDATE: One fandom appears to have been fixed. However a ‘pause’ is not any real news. Other fandoms are still impacted. A maybe is NOT a yes.

WHAT'S HAPPENING?
For those who don't yet know: AO3 and the Tag Wranglers have begun to slowly remove the 'All Media Types' tag for older fandoms. Aka, removing the 'umbrella' tag for many franchises, and forcing franchises to be split by media, or to be shoved under one umbrella that does not accurately reflect the types of fics or source medias they come from.
This has been slowly occurring with no official announcement, under the pretense that things will be 'easier' to manage, or that some users claimed that the 'All Media Types' tag was confusing. This has begun in secrecy, without genuine input from the userbase, and without any public announcement. (As of 9/5/2024 9:30 AM PST)
Many of us are pretty confident in AO3 staff's decisions, but the fact that this decision is not only incredibly impactful, but made without public input, has deeply violated the condition of the site as an archive... an archive of OUR own.
(UPDATE: There has been an announcement on tumblr that the AMT removal is 'on pause', and the the Sherlock tags have been restored. However, this does not appear to be a full restoration of AMT tags.)

Current seen issues and active risks:
1- Removal of 'All Media Types' automatically makes fics from different sources in the same franchise a 'crossover', forcing users to consider non-crossover fics 'crossovers'. So, any fanfic that spans or implements elements from multiple pieces of media in a franchise are now considered a 'crossover', despite being from the same franchise and not a crossover.
2- Removal of 'All Media Types' forces users to manually search for the fics and ships they want one by one through each fandom tag in a related franchise. (Imagine looking through all the separate DC or MARVEL movies one by one).
3- The 'include crossovers' and 'exclude crossovers' filters are now useless, and removing genuine crossovers (crossovers between franchises) must be done manually through the filter system, which can take upwards of half an hour, if not longer, with the amount of one-off genuine crossovers that exist.
4- Slightly smaller franchises are being shoved under the umbrella of a single, super popular fandom.
(See, Sherlock Holmes. All Sherlock Holmes media has been relegated to the tag 'Sherlock TV', which confuses users, as the tag now includes not only BBC Sherlock, which is the umbrella tag, but any works based off of Arthur Conan Doyle's original works, the 2009 Sherlock Holmes films, and the 16+ Sherlock Holmes adaptations and international TV shows... none of which are BBC Sherlock.)
5- Anime and manga fandoms (especially smaller ones) are being automatically split by media type, without regard to the fact that many anime and manga adaptations are very similar, and/or authors tend to often implement elements from both anime and manga.
6- As far as we are aware, no one is going to be correcting any improper sorting resulting from this.
7- Accounts that are no longer active/accessible, memorial accounts, and orphaned fics and no longer be corrected by their original authors and are at risk of being misplaced into incorrect fandom tags. Unfortunately, no one can fix this but the tag wranglers, who were supposedly removing 'All Media Types' in the first place to prevent MORE work. Counter intuitive, isn't it?
8- Already, fandoms are being improperly split, others being improperly merged, and still more being far more confusingly sorted. This deeply damages AO3's integrity as an ARCHIVE.

WHAT CAN I DO?
As soon as it's back up again, make sure to stop by the Contact Support page!
There, you're able to let them know exactly how you feel about this, and what fandoms your fear will be impacted by these changes. Many already have been.

In the meantime, make sure to contact AO3 on Twitter (or X):
ao3org (AO3's general twitter page), ao3_wranglers (AO3's tag wrangler page), and OTW_news (the parent host of AO3).

There is also tumblr:
ao3org (AO3's tumblr page) and transformativeworks (OTW's tumblr page).

And finally, the Organization for Transformative Works contact page.

If you are aware of any additional medias, please add them below to ensure that AO3 thoroughly understands the negative impact of this decision, especially the violation of trust resulting from making such a massive choice without impact. Be sure to share this information elsewhere, share the links, and make a stink.
Furthermore, if you are able, letting AO3 know that you are no longer comfortable financially supporting them in the future.


r/AO3 • • Jul 24 '25

Stats/Hit Counts/Word Counts I care about your AO3 stats ❤️

15 Upvotes

Ignore the haters


r/AO3 • • Mar 20 '26

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting Telling people not to post if they’re sensitive isn’t helpful

4 Upvotes

Look I get it, people who post and vent about comments/bookmarks/etc and can’t take feedback can be annoying.

They are sensitive and having a harder time with things that others might brush off.

But it’s also annoying to see at least one comment on a post say that people shouldn’t post if they can’t handle criticism, even if the comment in question is extremely rude and most of the others agree.

Some people are just born sensitive. It’s not something they can exactly control, just learn how to handle. And as a sensitive person myself, it is a rough journey to be able to handle it. Especially when people around you mock you for crying over things they find silly.

You just don’t know what’s going on in a persons life either. Maybe they’re sensitive because they’re a teenager who has never been confronted with *that* kind of negativity before or maybe they didn’t expect it. Maybe the person posting has no support system to turn to, no one who will gently vibe check the comment and point out what is actually being said.

It’s also possible that the sensitive person has no emotional regulation skills- I didn’t start learning until 19 and had bottled everything up until I had a meltdown at the drop of a hat (I do not recommend).

We just don’t know their background and life experiences.

It’s not helpful to tell them not to post. Yes, it’s good to be aware of the realities of posting on the internet. Yes, they are likely overreacting. Yes, it’s annoying. But it’s still not really helpful.

If I had been told that 15-20 years ago when I was a teen without a good support system and no emotional regulation skills, I don’t think I would have ever posted fanfics. I don’t think I would have been able to use fandom spaces to push my own boundaries and build up confidence. I’m not sure where I would be now without having pushed myself to keep at it despite overreacting and crying a lot.

I think telling people not to post if they’re so sensitive means that they will have harder time learning to handle it and how to not overreact despite the emotions. It could mean isolating them; especially for teens, fandom can be the only safe space people have to put themselves out there and at risk.

Of course it’s also good to be able to take a step back if it’s really causing distress but they will never learn if they don’t try at their own pace. And it can be incredibly isolating to never be interacting because you know you can’t handle the negativity.

Yes, they should be aware of what they’re getting into. Some people just aren’t kind on the internet (and others use that as an excuse to be harsh and mean). That doesn’t mean it doesn’t hurt even if one is prepared for it.

Even now, in my 30s and a parent, I still have bad days where getting a bad comment makes me want to throw a fit. Fortunately my spouse is excellent at letting me vent while also being a good reality check so I never have to show my messy emotions publicly, but not everyone is that lucky. And sometimes I do have slip ups and argue more than I should and I have regrets once I calm down. I hate being so sensitive but nothing I’ve done has changed that initial stab of hurt I get when I see someone saying something not so nice about my fic. So instead I just… control my reaction and attempt to regulate my emotions. But I would have never gotten to this point if I didn’t keep trying with comments on.

And just because I can handle it now doesn’t mean I can’t have sympathy for those who are just starting out, who are just learning or have never had the chance to learn before. I remember what it’s like. It’s not fun. It can be humiliating.

Just… be kinder to those who are sensitive. It’s not going to help them be less sensitive to scold them for posting publicly where anyone can comment. It’s not going to help them learn if they do take the advice and never post again. A step back, breaks sure. But never posting until they aren’t so sensitive? Then they might never meet that threshold.


r/AO3 • • Jun 04 '25

Complaint/Pet Peeve My T4T fic bombed :(

7 Upvotes

I am used to not getting many kudos because I write for two pairings with small audiences, but this one is really stabbing at me.

I'm a trans man and wrote my first T4T for a pairing that is normally a cis man and cis woman. So essentially they swapped. I KNOW it's a good fic, I'm proud of myself for it and the 3 comments I got on it lifted my spirits.

BUT.

I can't help but feel bummed that it's getting such little hits and kudos compared to the stuff I normally write for this pairing. I get that T4T is not everyone's cup of tea, but I still kept the character's personalities and genders in tact. They just... had the opposite genitals from what they normally have.

I guess what is kind of irking me most is that the male character is often portrayed as trans in the fandom, but VERY feminine and always bottoming for a cis man. So I can't help but feel like my take on his trans-ness (relating him to myself) is just not acceptable. Which in turn, makes me feel really icky.

I don't know where I'm going with this. Just venting my frustrations, I guess.


r/AO3 • • Nov 26 '25

Complaint/Pet Peeve/Venting We Should Be Free to Delete Our Own Works

297 Upvotes

Maybe this is an unpopular take, but I’m very much baffled by the idea that deleting a work from AO3 is somehow “wrong.” It’s wild to me that people treat AO3 fics like some sort of sacred communal artifact, whereas it’s perfectly okay to delete any tweets, blogs, or TikToks.

AO3 is not some fundamentally different internet space. It’s still my account, my space, and my work. Curating my own profile is how I engage with fandom. It could mean publishing something, or orphaning something, or deleting something. None of these actions removes the work from the entire internet, nor is that my goal or expectation. If someone downloaded it, saved a copy? That’s great. But the work on my profile is mine to manage.

Yes, readers would be disappointed. But their displeasure should not override a writer’s autonomy. Maybe instead of channeling their disappointment into complaints, they could have engaged with the work in the first place and give the writer a reason not to delete their work.

AO3’s entire philosophy is built on supporting creators and giving us control over our own works. That includes the right to unpublish them. And honestly, if someone believes they are entitled to perpetual access to someone else’s free hobby project, that, in my opinion, is a bigger problem than an author deleting a fic.

Nothing about being in fandom means I owe anyone permanent hosting of something I no longer want associated with my profile. If I want a fic gone from my AO3 page, whether hidden, orphaned, or deleted, I should be free to do exactly that.

At the end of the day, the archive is for sharing works we want to share. And if I no longer want something up? That’s the end of the conversation. —————————————————— TLDR: Authors have the right to delete, orphan, hide, or unpublish their own works on AO3. Curating our own profiles is our choice, and reader disappointment doesn’t override creator autonomy.

EDIT: this is not an “absolution” seeking post as one person suggested, I have deleted and most likely will delete my own fics. I believe that it’s fine for readers to express disappointment, only that they should not harass or abuse any authors. Anyways, that is not what this post addresses. Instead, this post is a response to a plethora of posts attempting to “educate” authors by telling them not to delete their own works or that the act of deletion is somehow “wrong”.


r/AO3 • • Apr 10 '25

Stats/Hit Counts/Word Counts Unpopular opinion: I don’t like comments all that much.

0 Upvotes

Well first, I don’t like when people take my ridiculous stuff i do for funsies too seriously, so every time I get some analysis I’m like wellll it wasn’t intended or thought out but thanks? Second, I don’t know how to answer not saying these exact things lol. Except for thank you.

I always answer to my comments because I believe it’s a must. Like saying thank you when somebody does something nice for you. But unlike rl interactions it’s still a chore.

I like kudos though. I appreciate all the shy and introverted readers out there who take time to read my stuff and like it, even a little bit.

I wonder if there are others like me, because I’ve never encountered such a person.

ETA: I believe turning off the comments comes off as a bit rude. Condescending. Being superior. You name it. “Go away you annoying people” vibe.