r/AITA_Relationships • u/Typical-Mobile-47 • Jun 15 '26
YTA AITA for planning to confess my feelings to my married manager?
I (27F) feel like I am losing my mind. My best friend just called me delusional and threatened to distance herself from me if I go through with this, so I need an outside perspective.
For my own personal sanity, all names have been changed.
For the past year, I’ve worked closely with David (38M). He is the assistant manager at the retail pharmacy where I work as a pharmacy technician. He is married to Sarah and they have two toddlers. His locker is covered in drawings from his kids, and he talks about his family constantly. On paper, he is the ultimate family man.
But over the last six months, I feel like our relationship has changed. It started in November when my dog passed away. He noticed I was crying in the breakroom, went down the street, and brought me a vanilla latte and a muffin. He sat with me for ten minutes and just listened to me vent. No one else at work even noticed I was upset, but *he* did.
Since then, we’ve developed a routine. Whenever we pass each other by the stockroom, he gives me this specific, warm smile. A few weeks ago, during a hectic Monday rush, I made a joke to a difficult customer that fell flat, but I looked across the pharmacy counter and David was smiling and shaking his head. It felt like an inside joke just between us.
Then there was the team dinner last month at a packed, deafening restaurant. Because it was crowded, David sat directly across from me. At one point, the room got incredibly loud. David leaned all the way across the table to hear what I was saying. While I was talking, he looked directly at my lips, smiled, and nodded along. A few of our coworkers at the end of the table actually stopped talking and just stared at us because it looked so intense. It felt like the rest of the room completely melted away.
The biggest thing happened last Friday. We were staying late to finish checking in an inventory shipment. The store was closed. He walked over to check my progress, and as he leaned over my shoulder to look at the terminal, his sleeve brushed against my arm. He didn't pull away immediately; he stayed there for at least three seconds. Before he clocked out, he looked at me and said, "Don't stay too late, Shelby. We need you around here."
I felt a physical spark. I am convinced that he is trapped in a passionless marriage, and his kindness is his subconscious way of crying out for a connection. He always remembers exactly how I take my coffee. Men don't pay that much attention to a woman unless they are deeply attracted to her.
My plan is to ask him to grab drinks after our shift this Thursday and gently lay my cards on the table. I want to tell him that I know he feels the connection too, and that I'm willing to wait for him.
My best friend snapped at me saying, “Shelby, he is a nice guy. He brought you coffee *once.* You are being delusional and you’re about to ruin your job based on a sleeve brushing against your arm!”
Am I misreading this or AITA if I say how I feel?
UPDATE: Hi Reddit. I definitely didn’t expect this post to blow up so much. Many of you definitely had similar insight that my best friend had shared with me beforehand. Prior to making this post, I had already begun searching for a new job to remove myself from this environment as I have no desire to be the “other woman” or much less make a move on someone and become a home-wrecker. Within the last month and a half I have been able to secure a new job working as a pharmacy manager, the same as David. When I left, I felt assured that this Reddit would not need an update since I had removed myself from any and all contact with my previous coworkers, David included. How wrong could I could be…
Two nights ago, my phone lit up at 11:30 PM with a text from an unknown number. It turned out to be David. He started off by saying he tracked down my private cell number by going through old company shift logs. He congratulated me on my new manager role, but then the tone shifted into something completely predatory, and my stomach absolutely dropped.
David: "Honestly, Shelby, the store is completely miserable without you. I miss looking at you across the counter. Now that you don’t work under me anymore, we don’t have to worry about HR. My wife is taking the kids to her parents' house this weekend. What Sarah doesn't know won't hurt her."
I sat there in absolute, horrified shock. I wasn't delusional after all, the "spark" was real, but I had completely misjudged his character. He wasn't some noble, honorable family man. He was a textbook creep who deliberately used my vulnerability when my dog died to groom me for an affair, calculatingly waiting until I left the company so he could pursue me without getting fired by HR.
I refused to protect a liar. I didn't reply to him at all. Instead, I immediately screenshotted the texts, found his wife Sarah on Facebook, and sent them directly to her. I explicitly told her that I wanted absolutely nothing to do with him and believed she deserved to know exactly what her husband was doing behind her back.
Yesterday morning, David completely snapped. He sent me a string of furious, unhinged texts calling me a "psycho," a "home-wrecking liar," and a "vindictive b*tch" because Sarah had apparently packed her bags, taken the kids, and left him. He tried to claim I ruined his life over a "harmless joke" and that I took things too far.
To make it even crazier, two of my former coworkers who are buddies with David actually texted me, defending him! They claimed I was "cruel" for destroying a marriage and a family with two young kids, saying I should have just blocked him and minded my own business.
I am completely baffled by anyone defending this guy. I didn't destroy his marriage, David did that all by himself the second he decided to cheat on his wife and hunt down an ex-employee's phone number. I feel entirely justified in protecting a mother and her children from a manipulative liar, and I refuse to let him flip the script and make me the villain for exposing his toxic behavior. I’m really confused though and don’t know if I took the appropriate steps or if I jumped the gun. AITA… again?