r/30ROCK • u/IsaiahTrenton • Oct 01 '23
What Are Some Moments You Cringe At?
I love 30 Rock and I'm a huge fan of Tina Fey but man oh man do I cringe sometimes at what I guess was acceptable back then. I'm rewatching it now and while I love the Liz story in a lot of Season 3, I never really liked how the show handled the character of Elisa.
It's funny because I actually don't mind the episode where she goes crazy in a vacuum because honestly it was around the latter half of Season 3 where they really got the juice. That wild madcap feeling I think a lot of people associate with 30 Rock popped up sometimes around the episode she left for Puerto Rico but was in full swing by the time she got back. But even outside of that, her handling was just kinda off. Salma Hayek is a very funny and talented actress and I think she did the best with what they gave her. But somehow she went from being a working class down to earth nurse to being every single Latina stereotype I can think of. Unlike how the show treats it's Black characters, there's no subversion here or joke about flipping your expectations. She's not secretly the smartest person on the show or has some hidden depths we haven't seen. She goes from normal albeit kinda stereotypical to being a black widow seductress and it just doesn't work for me. They were already kinda pushing it by making her this hyper Catholic superstitious type which was meh to begin with.
The Generalissimo episode is another one where I'm like 'maybe you needed to go back to the drawing board'. Something about how they infantlized the grandmother character and that whole plotline was kinda slipshod. I'm a comedy writer myself and oftentimes I will have a really good idea for a joke. I'll try to stretch out that one gag into a 5 to 7 minute sketch but oftentimes I wear the premise thin because the sketch is essentially just that one joke. Generalissimo feels like a case where someone had a really funny idea of Alec playing a telenovela character and tried to justify an entire 30 minute episode around it. Alec's funny as always but the gag wears itself thin pretty quick. They don't really do much with the concept besides the most obvious gags possible. I got a kick out of some of the tropes they made fun of. I mostly watch for Liz and Tracy's storylines in that episode. I think they honestly didn't know what to do with her and maybe Salma wanted to do other stuff, idk. Maybe Tina needs to hire more Latino, Black and Asian writers or consultants because this is a consistent problem for shows she produces.
Paul is another character that makes me go 'hmmm'. I love everything that Will Forte is bringing to the character and he has some funny moments. But there's times like when he refers to himself as a 'schman' that just feels off in today's current climate. That was definitely progressive for back then and I don't think they meant to purposely offend anyone. But I kinda wish they was someone in the room who said 'maybe we're defeating the point if we keep inferring his crossdressing makes him less of a man'. I actually do like that it kinda evolved more into overall hedonistic and not strictly crossdressing. Paul gets quite a few sweet moments with Jenna and I really did love how he becomes as much of a real person as he is a kook by the end of it. Again, so much of that is Will Forte making some really uneven jokes land. My roommate who is in his early 20's watches this with me. To him, this whole subplot is very cringe worthy. For me, I see what they were going for and I think it worked at certain points but it's a definitely a product of its time.
Again, on the whole I really do love it but there's moments where I just kinda have to skip through some iffy stuff. Part of media literacy is being able to understand things in the context of when they were made but also understanding how times have changed. Something being a comedy doesn't mean everything is okay forever and amen. Standards change, values change and it's important to pinpoint these shifts within our media so we can learn. Some things you do eventually grow out. But these are the things that personally made ME cringe. If it didn't for you then you don't have to agree but feel free to share your own opinion.
EDIT: Everything with Lynn Onkman is just weird and creepy and wrong and I'm not sure whose idea that was but omg that was bad. It's one of the things about the show I can say was a complete misstep. I don't know what they were thinking there. When Frank starts genuinely getting emotional and says 'maybe something happened to me that made me want to never grow up!' it stopped being even kinda humorous. Maybe I'm sensitive because I've been raped and sexually assaulted multiple times. But even back when those episodes first aired, I thought they were big mistakes. I think they wanted to try something edgy and risque and still stick the landing but it fell flat for me. I love Susan Sarandon but she's wasted in these episodes.
2nd EDIT: Sending me abusive messages mocking my sexual assault is not the way you defend your favorite show y'all. I'm just blocking and reporting at this point.