r/30ROCK • u/LostByway • Feb 26 '26
Question[s] Trans stuff?
I’ve been rewatching the show with my girlfriend who is trans and has never seen it before. We just hit the episode where Tracy talks about getting trans prostitutes into computer school. Someone used the word “shim.” Yikes.
She is a really good sport and wasn’t super bothered, but now I am wondering what else is in store for us transphobia-wise beyond Liz throwing around the t-slur.
I of course remember Steve Buscemi’s character, but I feel like she was actually handled pretty well. Paul is an edge case in my opinion and I am expecting some of those jokes to be tone deaf but not super offensive.
Anyone remember anything else particularly bad, or on the other hand particularly good?
8
u/Stupidbloodfart2020 Feb 26 '26
There’s an episode where Tracy talks about helping trans sex workers get training for professional jobs or something. But he uses a term that’s probably not great. There’s a lot more. Im pretty sensitive to this stuff, but i think ultimately nothing is jaw-droppingly offensive. Like the Paul stuff. He also uses some bad terms. But most of the show is saturated in satire so its meant to make the bigoted stuff sound dumb.
3
u/Stupidbloodfart2020 Feb 26 '26
Sorry i totally missed you bringing up what i brought up. My brain is flerm.
2
8
2
u/TheMainTony Feb 26 '26
I think a big part of is whether you're judging the freaky-deakies or if you simply identify or take the side of the freaky-deakies. I'm in the latter camp. I recognize it as problematic, but minor problematic in the grander scheme so we'll move on.
50
u/AncientSky69 Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26
Steve buscemi's character actually realizes his true nature and marries a woman as a woman. Pretty progressive for the time and the tone. Paul is a crossdresser, and while they make a lot of jokes, I don't think anyone has much issue with drag art conceptually. My edit- this is someone who loves 30 Rock and also is very involved in the lgbtq community. If you have any issues with my comments, I'd love to discuss it. I don't claim to know everything
26
u/Pitiful_Ad2397 Feb 26 '26
Paul also mentions being gender-dysphoric and “pansexualle”.
8
u/AncientSky69 Feb 26 '26
Oh my God thank you. I couldn't remember the actual phrase. But Jenna actually says that
4
8
u/Late-Coconut-8356 parry with an elegante primo Feb 26 '26
I would heartily enjoy a Jan the trans lesbian teacher spinoff
38
u/karamojobell Feb 26 '26
There are some moments that haven't aged well but shoutout to baby-crazy Liz saying "You're a beautiful little boy... or a girl, if that's what's inside you!"
34
u/Pitiful_Ad2397 Feb 26 '26
I see myself in Jeffery Weinerslave, as I am also an overweight transgender.
27
u/Satellite6 Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26
Freaky deakies need love too.
I am also a trans gal and it’s one of my desert island shows, so…
Context matters, I think. To me, anyway.
6
u/fionsichord Feb 26 '26
It’s all a bit dated and makes me cringe a little now, but nothing super horrible. All quite good natured and meant to be funny or affectionate. “Shim” pops up a couple of times, and the episode where Tracey and Toofer get put in HR class with Rachel Dratch for using the N word is probably better skipped unless your partner is really feeling ok about overlooking stuff that wouldn’t fly today.
6
14
u/TheMainTony Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26
There are a bunch of 'shims' and 'he/she & she/him' as well as the great but so wrong line: "freaky deakies need love too" when he was caught with a (trans prossy) in his car but it's ok because he was trying to get (shim) to go to computer school.
Not cool. Problematic. But funny. But "it's of its time" isn't a great argument, either. I guess sometimes a joke can be wrong and funny.... depending who you are in the audience.
5
u/lucasssquatch Feb 26 '26
Liz said something like "he, or she, or it" when talking about a hypothetical child, but the context was that she would love that child regardless of gender. That was about a decade before we sort of collectively settled on "they" as the default non-binary pronoun in English, so I guess it counts as a swing-and-miss attempt at affirmation?
2
u/FX114 Feb 26 '26
They do throw out a lot of casual transphobia on the show, unfortunately. Most of it is just a gag that moves past, unlike a more ingrained philosophy like How I Met Your Mother.
3
u/LostByway Feb 26 '26
I like your point about ingrained philosophy. I don’t remember much of HIMYM, but my girlfriend’s favorite show is Friends and the treatment Chandler’s trans mom is never amazing, but also doesn’t feel outright hostile. We both love Twin Peaks though and Denise is really an incredible character, and not just “for the time.”
3
u/FX114 Feb 26 '26
How I Met Your Mother has a lot of moments where the worst thing a woman could ever say is that she used to be a man.
Friends, I feel, stumbled into accidentally being kinda good trans representation through the writers' own ignorance of the subject. The Drew Carey show does similarly. I've incorporated "I'm not a man, I'm a rough and tumble tomboy" into my lexicon when I'm dressed less femme.
4
u/hiptobesquare18 Hotshot at boinking Feb 26 '26
S04e17: "You're going to juggle them? No, even you can't pull this off, Jack. Mrs. Doubtfire shimself could not do this."
4
u/bucketfoottatoo Feb 26 '26
The language is not what you would see on TV today, but I don't think it is hateful. Some jokes may be at the expense of trans women, but even more at Black people and women in general, it's that kind of show
7
u/daganfish Children's Soccer Heckler Feb 26 '26
Tone-deaf is the right word. Everyone in 30 Rock is a joke to some degree, and none of the jokes are outright hostile, but they do make me go oh, maybe that could have been better.
3
u/funnyhbv Feb 26 '26
Well you’ve got Weinerslav the Human Resources rep coming your way
Jack also uses someone as being “a post-op transgender” as the reason a marriage didn’t work, though he does not specify what specifically about it
Paul L’astname is probably…not great.
2
u/SipoteQuixote Feb 26 '26
I think you have to factor in that it's Tracy. His character is to just be shocking sometimes, it's his shtick. You gotta remember, his high school's rivals was just a family of possums.
3
u/radogdad My twin is dead Feb 26 '26
Unsure but I'll add it here, Liz says to jack Mrs. Doubtfire shimself couldn't do this. Talking about Jack dating Nancy and Avery
3
u/Plenty_Structure_861 Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26
Yeah, it's not great regarding us. I still love the show, but those parts make me wish they weren't there.
Lot of bigots out and voting hard.
1
u/itallik 11d ago
I mean, you gotta take it with that 2007 perspective. I don't think there was any particularly derogatory language apart from Tracy (who's unhinged outlook was the whole joke), and sometimes Jack (who, again, is often funny for being wildly out of touch or nonchalantly prejudicial)
I'm a trans gal, and through the 2007 lens, it felt fine, to be honest. From my memory, any real life media coverage of anyone really being trans was Kaitlin Jenner (and, yes, im not exactly a 'fan' but, again, was the first time many of my peers were made aware of the concept beyond being a punchline or an outcast), so, I think it's okay, on the whole.
1
14
u/therealrowanatkinson Feb 26 '26
Trans guy & 30R lover here- I have so many thoughts about transness on this show. Mostly fun but also a few things I’d flag for your gf-
The Steve Buscemi plot line mentioned above is a mixed bag. The character herself is written with dignity and they’re not weird about it, but some people’s reactions (and punchlines) are discomfort/disgust which sucks to watch. It’s only discussed in 2 scenes though, is mild for the time, and I don’t think it would ruin the show for most people.
Also- it’s worth talking about Liz’s relationship to gender. There are jokes made where people are skeptical of Liz’s gender assigned at birth, but it also flips back and forth on whether it implies she’s a trans woman or man. Examples:
“Wait, why haven’t I seen any pictures of you as a baby?”
Liz revealing she fantasizes about living life as a man, with a wife. Even has a name picked out- Peter Lemon (classic trans guy thing to do)
Her & Criss roleplaying handymen, when Criss questions it Liz nervously dismisses it
My friends and I love analyzing Liz- the ftm jokes are weirdly accurate- to the point that I wonder if a trans guy egg (egg=unrealized trans person) was on the writing staff.
There are also a lot of wonderful plots/jokes in the show that are LGBTQIA+ informed. Overall, the show is thoughtful in its depiction of the queer community- even when it misses the mark, the aim is usually to challenge old ideas. The Paul stuff was A+ for me, I can’t recall any bad jokes there.
Sorry for the long post, I love this topic and wanted to give you data on stuff that might be harder for cis folks to see. Happy viewing!
5
u/LostByway Feb 26 '26
This is an awesome response, thank you! My gf has a theory that Chandler on Friends is an egg, so Liz as a trans guy bits are definitely something we will be watching for!
68
u/meeemawww Feb 26 '26
Freaky deaky’s need love too.