r/zayn • u/Remarkable_Web4595 • Feb 06 '26
Discussion maturity is realizing Zayn and Liam should’ve taken over with their ideas (no offense to Louis, but he’s the reason their music became “bland”)
I used to be a huge Louie, so isn’t shade towards Z Louis. But I’m realizing that this take about him giving life to 1D is ridiculous.
Zayn and Liam had better sounds and ideas for the band that got dismissed because it was “too mature”. They ended up going down this folk/indie route that Ziam thought was rightfully boring. (Personally, I think it’s unfair that only a few members got to control their sound while others had to deal with it. They should’ve taken creative turns).
I’m not saying their music got bad after Midnight Memories, but it is boring. I can understand why the masses didn’t care for it and still don’t.
I don’t know if this was a rumor, but Zayn’s new song ‘Die for You’ was written in 2014 for 1D, right? Well, that upset me because it proves that they could’ve experimented in 2014 instead of using the same pop rock sound. It probably would’ve been considered their best album to date.
(Then again, I don’t know how an album like that would sound with Harry and Niall since they’ve never made alternative rnb like Zayn or trap like Liam before. So maybe it was for the best to stay pop rock.)
Anyway, this isn’t shade towards Louis. I’m just annoyed with this take that he was the only writer and creative one in the group. I’m sure they would’ve been fine or reached another peak after MM if Zayn and Liam took over.