r/ynab • • Aug 13 '24

Good bye YNAB, Hello Actual Budget

14 Upvotes

I struggled justify continuing my subscription the last time they increased it. This time I really can't. it's gone up by 23% and still doesn't have automatic Bank Sync in Australia.

Before people start replying with how much they have saved using YNAB, I obviously don't earn anywhere near as much as you. Many such replies manage to save more money in one year than I make, so it's not a convincing "real world" argument for me. My rent increased by 35% last year and will likely increase again this year with everything else.

YNAB don't seem to care enough to offer discounts. At the very least they could offer a discount for not implementing Bank Sync in Australia. But they don't.

So, I'm moving over to Actual Budget.


r/ynab • • Oct 10 '25 Hehehe

Can't wait for the next UI update!

9 Upvotes

Sick and tired of all this bitching about the home screen. Looking forward to the next update so we can start crying over something else. Home screen got enough attention already folks. Maybe can we go back to the "Plan vs Budget" cycle? it was WAY more fun.


r/ynab • • Feb 20 '25

General As a european wanting to boycott YNAB, are there any european alternatives?

0 Upvotes

r/ynab • • Mar 18 '25

Change my mind - Connecting YNAB to banks is wrong

0 Upvotes

I think the whole point of budgeting and sticking to a budget is to be very conscious of how you allocate and spend your money. I think there is value in doing everything manually, and small mistakes more than compensate for the forgetfulness that comes from automating a large part of the process. I have never even looked into connecting YNAB to my local banks (Finland) because I feel it defeats the purpose of me paying attention to my finances. Yes, it does take a strong habit, but I enter transactions regularly and it's now a matter of seconds. Change my mind :)

EDIT: I feel this is important, linking is not supported in Finland so I (clearly) don’t have a good grasp of how things look in the UI if you link the accounts.


r/ynab • • Dec 02 '23

An open letter to YNAB

0 Upvotes

I have been a user of YNAB since the YNAB 3 days. It has generally served me well as a way to keep an accurate picture of my finances, and has also helped my kids learn monetary discipline.

However, as others have also expressed, the constant changes for the sake of change are really getting frustrating. Going to YNAB 4 and then to new YNAB both took away features that I appreciated and added nothing I found useful. However, I want to support Jessie and the love and care he has put into this product so I have kept up with it, and for many years I encouraged others to do so as well.

I have to admit that I no longer recommend it. The number of times that I find myself at a loss until I figure out how to work with some new nonsensical change has me leery of sending anyone else down that path who doesn't already have the experience in dealing with the constant manipulation in the background. I also get feedback from friends I introduced to YNAB years ago who have stopped using it out of frustration over similar reasons.

YNAB has basically become the equivalent of what I imagine it would be like to have a cleaning service that comes every month and straightens, organizes, dusts, and scrubs and leave my house immaculate, with every kids toy sparkling and placed exactly where it belongs, all the clothes washed and put away, including the ones that were left outside in the woods that I might not have spotted for weeks, but also randomly changes stuff without permission and I can't put it back. One day I might come home and find my clothes in the pantry and the food in the closet, a few months later the dining room table ends up in the bedroom, and in the spring the sofa is facing the kitchen stove instead of the family room TV. I can't put anything back the way I want it, but I also can't find another cleaning service that cleans my house acceptably, and I enjoy the time saved not doing it myself too much to fire anyone.

What might be the final straw is the way that negative balances in a category are handled at the end of a month. I have been annoyed by this for quite a while but changes in my role at work have made it a much bigger source of grief and frustration than previously. If I have left a category in the negative, I did so for a reason, and I don't appreciate YNAB lying to me about the status of that category when the month rolls over! I can google and find dozens of folks thoroughly confused by how to handle reimbursements with this convoluted behavior. Despite all the folks tying their brains in knots trying to explain away the choices that were made to force this behavior and various complicated "workarounds" to make everything work out in the ever elusive end, this is a bug that was consciously introduced and can be just as consciously fixed if YNAB chose to see things from a rational users point of view. If I have spent money for work, I want that category to stay negative until my employer pays me back and I put those funds back in that category. This way I can easily see how much has not been reimbursed yet at any point in time. It's not rocket science. Having to tag/flag transactions, and basically lie to myself by taking funds from other categories to pretend to cover those costs is ridiculous.

Another frustration of mine is that support doesn't really want to help with issues that cannot be explained away as undesirable but intended behavior unless they are given access to the budget itself, which many users including myself are not comfortable doing for financial privacy reasons.

I know some will say I should just suck it up or take my business elsewhere, and pre-kids I had the time to sit down and write my own program to replace this, but life is short and time with family is precious and I'd rather see YNAB improved so I hope this feedback can be taken seriously.


r/ynab • • Dec 29 '24

Looking forward to your downvotes

Post image
0 Upvotes

You can add the Add A Transaction function to your iOS Control Center! Sweet!


r/ynab • • Feb 27 '25

Ynab subscription is up

0 Upvotes

I have been a subscriber since 2016, back when the price was like $45 per year. The price now along with inflation doesn’t make sense in my budget. You know, I need to eat eggs!

What alternatives are there. I tried liquid budget but it is an alpha project with no mobile app, good budget seems like it just open source now. Are there any other good alternatives which act in the same way as ynab? Every dollar just sucks.

Edit: We were promised $45 per year for life and then they double the cost. When they did this, there was no alternative, so each year I look for something new.


r/ynab • • Feb 28 '25

Seriously?

199 Upvotes

I defend YNAB increasing their prices, defend them and try to help people who think it doesn't make sense or have other criticism. I've been using ynab for the better part of 2 decades because it makes sense to me and I'm better with money because I use it.

Today they pissed me off.

I am not cool with being advertised to inside of software that I pay full price for.

I've not given ANY other softwares much consideration but now I'm evaluating other tools. AFTER 18+ YEARS.

Not cool YNAB team. Not cool.

I'm not even opposed to your "fan fest" event. I hope people go and it is of value to them and that you make some money from it. But I do not want it advertised to me in my budget.


r/ynab • • Sep 09 '24

Rant It is A-OK for someone to use YNAB differently than you do. There's no right or wrong way to benefit from a software program. Lets endeavor to avoid giving unsolicited advice or being hostile and instead just scrolling along if we disagree with someone's take / use of the YNAB.

0 Upvotes

Basically the title.

I've seen a number of posts lately where the OP gets attacked for not using YNAB "the right way" or in a way that suits the people doing the commenting. I'm specifically referring to occasions where the OP DID NOT ASK FOR ADVICE and IS NOT SEEKING SUPPORT, but rather is sharing a win or information about how they use YNAB / think about YNAB.

If someone says "Here's this thing I do that I like and really works for me!" You do not, for any reason, need to comment and tell them how wrong they are. First, they didn't ask for your advice. Second, it's perfectly fine to use YNAB in varied ways. Third, attacking people for sharing something that works for them is counterproductive to the purpose of a community subreddit.

I think we need to step back and ask ourselves, "Why does whatever this other person do with their own money or YNAB budget make me mad enough that I want to preach at them about it? Does how this person manages their own life actually affect me? Did they ask for my opinion? Am I just fired up because I don't like what they do with their own finances?" And then tae a breath and just scroll on by.

While I understand that there's a philosophy that underscored the creation of YNAB, it's also simply a fact that the software/app is now "out in the world" and up for interpretation. Someone needn't subscribe directly to every aspect of YNAB's marketed design to benefit from using the software. Someone could have downloaded the app not even knowing what it was or that there are "rules" etc and why are they less valid than anyone else?

Also, there are many people (I'm one of them) where precision accuracy is not really the end of the world with this app.

I don't mind using myself as an example here.

I don't really care if the accounts match exactly; I don't need them to; I am comfortable in my finances and use YNAB as a practical tool -- not as an iron-clad finance machine. I assign my money to my varied bills and flexible expenses as a general sort of estimate for each thing. I move stuff around when I need to. I don't have debt outside of mortgage, car payment, and student loans and my wife and I are very comfortable and saving thousands a month. So really, we are fine. We are fine even if I don't reconcile or even if I don't care if an account was off last month and don't care to let it suck money out of this month. We have income enough to absorb that flexibility and we return to our desired targets as we move forward. This is how YNAB works for me, and it DOES work for me, and I am content with it. If I overspend on Events one month, I just cover the spending and move on. Or maybe I don't directly move money to cover it and I just let it be and start the next month anew. I don't really care. My wife and I are on track with our retirement and savings goals and we are meeting our needs and we are not taking on more debt. So our budgeting is working for us. Someone else's approval of whether or not I am, like -- what would I even call it -- "a real YNAB-er" or something -- does not matter to me.

Also, of great importance: My bank account is what matters. Not what YNAB says. If my bank account is fine and dandy but YNAB has gotten messy, that just means an app I use is cluttered -- not that my finances are in despair.

And if you don't like how I use YNAB, for example, then really: ask yourself why it's any of your business, as long as I am not asking you for advice. Maybe I'm sharing what I share so someone else whose lifestyle is similar can see a new way of thinking/using YNAB; maybe I'm just offering up something I'm happy about; maybe I'm just sharing something anecdotal in case it's helpful to somebody. But if I am not directly asking for advice... why would you think I want to be attacked, told I'm wrong, pushed into defending my own financial choices, etc?

Lets just live and let live, ok? If you don't like what someone says or how they use YNAB, just keep scrolling. If they have ASKED whether or not you approve, feel free to go off. But more often than not, if a person is just sharing something, feel free to NOT offer an unsolicited opinion and to just move on. This should be able to be a productive, supportive space for folks to discuss the varied ways they engage with YNAB -- not a place to get attacked for varying from dogmatic adherence to a few YouTube videos.


r/ynab • • Nov 06 '21

Am I the only who who imagines Todd this way?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ynab • • Nov 05 '21

Somewhat disappointed in this community

77 Upvotes

I've been thinking about the... thoughts related to the YNAB price increase since it was announced, and I have to say, some of the vitriol and straight up anger towards YNAB just seems misplaced and a little unfair to me personally. While I understand that nobody wants to pay more for a product or service, and some small subset of long time users feels personally slighted and betrayed by their artificially low price disappearing, there is a degree of grace and humility that I would hope members of this community would display that seems absent from some of these posts.

Businesses (and that's what YNAB is, a business, not a charity or non-profit) have to make choices to run their business, and those choices will often be disliked by some subset of that company's user base. While I think it's totally fair to voice displeasure, some of these posts have seemed a bit disconnected from reality, to the point where you would think people are being charged thousands of dollars a year, or their accounts are getting deleted instantly.

A few other random thoughts:

  • If you don't like the new pricing, I get it. Go find something else to use instead.

  • To those that think YNAB is such simple software that it's insane it's so expensive... nobody is stopping you from building or paying someone to build a competitor. I wish you all the luck in the world, and if you make something truly amazing, perhaps I'll come use it instead!

  • I sympathize with those that want to recommend YNAB to friends and family, but feel like they can't because of the high price. That being said, as I mentioned before, YNAB is a for-profit company, and thus has to set prices that they feel comfortable with. I also wonder how many of these folks would be willing to pay to budget at any price.

  • Comparing the price of YNAB to Office 365 or Netflix is pretty bizarre and non-sensical to me. O365 and Netflix have massive economies of scale that YNAB will absolutely never have at any price (the number of people in the world that need to edit an Excel file or want to watch Squid Game will always massively outnumber the number of people that want to create and manage a budget).


r/ynab • • Nov 05 '21

Value

2 Upvotes

We synergistically increase our holistic value by providing synergized cross channel value-add with our white-glove service and our bespoke educational materials. We hope to continue delivering this value to you by increasing your subscription fees. We may need to continue delivering value in the future and may increase our subscription fees to continue delivering the best value in the value industry.

value


r/ynab • • Oct 28 '23

Wait 10 seconds Splitwise

0 Upvotes

Anyone else as lucky as me to get the new great feature which makes me wait 10 seconds before adding expense? Unless I buy pro ofc.

Time to look for a different app…


r/ynab • • Nov 22 '24

Switched to Actual Budget Server and have not looked back!

0 Upvotes

TLDR: I've been a dedicated and loyal YNAB user for 4 years. Actual Budget has pretty much all the major features of YNAB when you go the server route and even does many things better in my opinion. It is well on its way to not only being a viable replacement, but surpassing YNAB's features. For those of you who aren't afraid to tinker just a tiny bit and are looking for a replacement, I would recommend looking at Actual Budget.

Overview of Actual's features:

  • Targets (called templates)

  • Zero-sum, category (or envelope) style budget system

  • Multi-month budget view

  • Mobile optimized version (accessed through web browser)

  • Offline mode (will still work if connection can't be made to server)

  • Automatic sync to server

  • Automatic bank import using SimpleFIN bridge (most banks supported)

  • Transaction rules

  • Hold for next month feature

  • Separate income categories

  • Reports

  • Scheduled transactions

  • Payees

  • Direct YNAB import

  • Blazing fast to load and use

  • And a whole lot more

Just to preface this post, I've been a dedicated and pro user of YNAB since Jan. 1st, 2021. I have every transaction logged since then. I use Targets religiously. Bank imports. You name it, I know the feature and have used it heavily. YNAB has helped me through good times and bad. It's been a constant for me through many of life's changes. So believe me when I say, I don't take switching from YNAB lightly at all and am grateful for its existence.

I have been using Actual for almost a month now and have not even touched YNAB since. I have never had an issue and it simply just works. It's seriously a viable replacement if you aren't afraid to setup a small Docker container and a domain (more on that at the end).

Someone already mentioned this a year ago in this post, but it has progressed A TON since then. Here's Actual's own comparison if you don't want to take my word for it.

If you use the server version, it works exactly like YNAB where you just access it in a web browser. Yes, it even has a mobile-optimized version that does allow entering transactions and making changes.

My favorite part of Actual, it works whether you're online or not or whether the server is connected or not. They've got a way of downloading everything the app needs to run locally. This does two things. 1. It's fast. Like unbelievably fast. I'm talking editing hundreds of transactions at once in the blink of an eye fast. 2. You ALWAYS have access. Regardless of your internet connection or server status. This makes the app incredibly reliable and dependable.

Targets are a thing, Actual calls them templates. It's a simple, plain text structure just written into the notes of the category. They even color code the categories and everything. They also support setting the average amount based on a set time period, something YNAB does not do at all. Their documentation is very detailed on how to use it and how it works. Actual Templates. They do note that the feature is "experimental" but it's been around for over a year and is very stable.

For me, my total cost to run my Actual server is $15 a year. $15 for SimpleFIN bridge, I already have a server, and I use a domain I already own and use for plenty more than this. If this is all you want, you can do it with something like a RaspberryPi 3B+ and have power to spare. You can use PikaPods if you just want it up and running fast without your own hardware, that would only add $1-2 a month and includes a domain name. Actual has all the documentation you need to setup your own server (whether your own or a cloud server), import your YNAB transactions, and fully privatize you financial data.


r/ynab • • Feb 28 '25

Time to Move On From YNAB

0 Upvotes

NOTE: I'm aware that some people dislike these goodbye posts. Scroll past if you're one of those people and sorry to have intruded on your day..

After 13 years of being reasonably happy with YNAB, it's time to move on. I won't give you a long laundry list of missing features or something similar as to why I chose to stop using YNAB, but here are a few relevant points:

  • The price now converts to about $160.00 Canadian dollars. That's almost twice as much as a subscription to Microsoft 365. YNAB isn't responsible for the currency conversion factors, but they do impact customers outside of the USA.

  • YNAB is an American company - like other Canadians, I'm doing what I can to boycott American products and services until the Trump administration is defeated or they stop this bull$hit about annexing Canada. Today is "Boycott US Companies Day" in Canada, so today seemed to be an appropriate day to do so. (Sorry American friends - I wish things weren't the way they are right now.) (sorry about the politics, but it's a valid reason.)

  • Because my banks all use 2FA which I cannot disable, direct import fails every time that YNAB's service provider for scraping banking transaction tries to connect; basically, part of the subscription price for direct import is useless to me and I can't opt-out of it on YNAB.

  • I can easily afford the annual subscription price, but in my opinion, it no longer represents good value for money due to the lack of enhancements (beyond GUI).

  • As a company, I feel YNAB is overly focused on attracting new customers instead of keeping the current lot happy with new features and enhancements and fixes -- i.e. how about figuring out how to give users the ability to import CSV files without having to export to Sheets, Excel or a text app or use a third-party app, then reimport back to YNAB. Other similar programs do this easily!

  • Up until now, I wasn't aware of any other app or software that did "envelope budgeting" as well as YNAB does. I came across Actual Budget on several threads here in the YNAB sub. I've been running both in tandem for about a month and find that AB has more features and handles some tasks better than YNAB. And AB is free. All that I am now paying is $1.50 US per month to use PikaPods for hosting (which took all of 5 minutes to set up). Yes, Pikapods is an American company, but there's no alternative for me to use, so I'm willing to give them my whopping $1.50/month. By the way, that only kicks in once you've used up the $5.00 credit you get when you create a PikaPods accounts.

  • Today was the last test of AB versus YNAB. AB's templates updated March's budget perfectly. YNAB continues to have problems with targets, despite having taken the advice from YNAB to delete and redo all of my targets due to new logic introduced a few months ago. Today, the automatic budget replenishment on YNAB didn't do what it was supposed to do requiring me to go back and manually adjust several categories. This has been an ongoing issue for many users based on posts here in the sub. It's a waste of time to have to go back and double-check what YNAB was supposed to have gotten correct.

Although most of you may say "Who cares? Good riddance!", I think this quiet migration should be concerning not only YNAB, but to other customers. There's a poll running in the AB sub right now asking where AB users came from before using AB, and as of now, about 72% of users have migrated from YNAB4 or nYNAB. The total respondents is about 200, so we're talking about 150 users who have left YNAB. That's just from one small, unscientific survey, but if we assume everyone is paying about $100/year, that's a loss of $15,000 in revenue per year for YNAB.

Current users don't require any real marketing dollars to hold onto. Most happy users will resubscribe each year, but it costs YNAB real marketing dollars to acquire new customers and hold onto to them for the first year or so. (Why do you think YNAB offers users a discount for bringing in new users? It's much cheaper to absorb that cost than to what it costs to go out and find a new user.)

That's also $15,000 less to spend on enhancements and new features.


r/ynab • • Nov 11 '21

General After 7 years, my time with YNAB has finally come to an end. Thank You All!

8 Upvotes

The recent very sudden price increase that doubled my subscription price has made me question YNAB's future intent and loyalty to it's customers. YNAB has changed my life in more ways than finances and I am eternally grateful for it. After all this time I am going to be cancelling and managing my budget myself. For anyone interested, this is how I am doing that, for free.

A lot of people on YNAB use it for debt management, I am using the free variant of Goodbudget to manage outstanding debts, the 10 free "envelopes" is enough for me. I found over my years with YNAB that i've developed a routine of expenditures in common categories such as subscriptions, gas, dining out etc. So I use my available envelopes for debt, savings, investing, travel plans, and short term goals. I combined those short term goals with goals I have set within Betterment, which I use for Long Term Emergency Savings Goals, as well as Short Term Goal Accounts. Highly recommend this approach.

Next I use Personal Capital for net worth management and seeing where my money goes in the big picture. It's worth it even if you will remain with YNAB.

I am going to miss how simple it was to pull out my phone every time I sign a receipt at a restaurant or get gas, but those are honestly the only two things I did on the YNAB app outside of sitting down each week and manually going through all my accounts with YNAB on my side monitor. So maybe the program just isn't for me anymore. I wish you all luck! Maybe you'll see me back soon if this all blows up in my face!

If all fails, i'll honestly try Buckets before coming back to a subscription service again.


r/ynab • • Sep 16 '25

UX design

2 Upvotes

just wanted to say that i really like the recent design changes, like the home tab. i think it gives a good quick glance at your immediate financial situation. i have my top priorities added so i see right away how much is left to spend on groceries and eating out.

the plan overview is literally a single tap away, so no big deal imho. adding transactions works from both the home and spending tabs. neat !

it‘s a nice first start at a ynab dashboard and i‘m sure they‘ll expand on it with more customization options. so let‘s all take a deep breath and relax 😉


r/ynab • • Jun 17 '26

Women at YNAB??

0 Upvotes

Maybe it’s too soon to tell but I haven’t seen a woman content creator on YouTube, social, or their blog since the layoffs. When I first started YNAB 7 years ago, I really appreciated how inclusive and diverse they seemed…now I’m wondering if the Middle-aged-white-guyification of tech and finance has hit YNAB too. Publically, it seems to only be Jesse, Ben and Ernie, and the guy that writes the Substack…am I wrong?


r/ynab • • Mar 01 '23

YNAB has not been shipping meaningful updates for months

2 Upvotes

Is it just me that sees this? It just feels like I´m paying 99$ a year for a product that barely evolves over time.


r/ynab • • Oct 09 '25

Rant Desperately Seeking Susan (or Why I am About to Punt this App into the Stratosphere)

0 Upvotes

I have been using YNAB for approximately 4 years. There are certain features of the app that are automatic and unwelcome. For instance, when I make a transfer from savings to checking, the app decides this is somehow related to a credit card payment. I have been unable to figure out how to fix this problem. Nor can I change the "to be assigned" designation, when i don't want to assign it anywhere. i just made a transfer from one account to another.

Also, and this is not YNAB's issue exactly, my primary credit card is just a PITA to use with YNAB. I need the app to import my transactions, and randomly they just stop because i have to "reauthorize" the card.

Related to the card -- when i have had to get a new card due to fraud, i have run into roadblock after roadblock in keeping good records and making sure my YNAB numbers are current and correct..

i'll grant you there is plenty of user error on my part, but i am finding YNAB to be less and less helpful. Of course, i am welcome to delete the app or not renew my subscription, but i'm curious if anyone has any suggestions on how to make YNAB work better for me.


r/ynab • • Nov 01 '21

Meta [Meta] YNAB Promo Chain! Monthly thread for this month

1 Upvotes

Please use this thread every week to post your YNAB referral link. The first person will post their ynab referral code, and then if you take it, reply that you've taken it, and post your own -- creating a chain. The chain should look as follows:

  • Referral code

    • Referral code

  • Referral code

    • Referral code

    • try to avoid

  • doing too many

    • subchains

The code will be emailed to you shortly after purchasing. Subsequent people will grab the previous referral code, and supply their own.


r/ynab • • Jul 02 '24

Rant We get it, you don't like the price increase

133 Upvotes

Please, mods, can we put a stop to all the posts about this? Can it be turned into some megathread or something? I'm so tired with the complaining. We get it, you don't like the price increase. Cancel your membership and move on.


r/ynab • • Nov 07 '21

Rant Get a grip

0 Upvotes

The whining and complaining over the price increase is laughable. You guys are taking this way too personal. YNAB is a for profit company. Price increases happen. If you want a cheaper or free alternative, you’re going to pay for it through a lower quality user experience and/or tons of ads. I’ve tried them all and I’d much rather pay the increased YNAB all year long than use the other options. IMO, YNAB is the best budgeting app out there and it’s not even close. If you think there is better value out there and you want to save a few bucks, take your dollars elsewhere. Or go back to using a spreadsheet 😂 Google Sheets is free.


r/ynab • • Jun 28 '25

Built an to chat with my YNAB Budget (Yess!) - ask, move cash, convert FX, add transactions, all in plain English

1 Upvotes

Hey folks, long-time YNAB user here.

I’ve always wondered why the most repetitive actions in YNAB and reports couldn’t be done with one simple line of text. So I built ChatBudget (link in first comment): an app where I can literally talk/chat to my YNAB budget and make things happen.

Powered through the official YNAB API and lets you ask plain-English questions or run one-liner actions.

🗣️ Things you can do for example!

  • “How much did I spend on Dining Out this month?” → instant total + tiny chart

  • “Move $50 from Dining Out to Groceries.” → categories patched

  • “Convert my Europe-trip(Vacation) expenses from € to $.” → FX applied with historical rates based on transaction date

  • “Add a $45 gas purchase to Chase Checking.” → transaction created, warns if you’ll go over budget

  • “Show spending vs. budget for every category.” → quick bar-chart summary

...and the possibilities are endless!

I’d love to hear what questions or actions you would automate first. Fire away with ideas, concerns, or brutal feedback!

Community tool built on top of YNAB API, totally unaffiliated with them.

(Wait-list link & feature-request thread are in the first comment to keep things tidy for the mods.)