r/yellowstone • u/Maximum_Bee2288 • Jul 31 '24
I spent three days in Yellowstone and must’ve done something wrong because my experience was meh.
My husband, 17 yo son and 13 yo daughter traveled to YS and GT last week. We stayed in West Yellowstone the night before and felt like I was in Gatlinburg, TN with all the touristy stores and eateries. The food was marginal. We went to all the big ticket places in the upper and lower loops - Artists Paintpots, Norris Geyser Basin, Mammoth Hot Springs, Grand Canyon of Yellowstone, Grand Prismatic, Black Sand, Old faithful, Yellowstone Lake, Hayden Valley, and Lamar Valley. We hiked to Fairy Falls and several other trails. Not only were all the hot springs and geysers filled with tourists (with fighting, screaming, and unruly kids), but the places all started looking the same. And I was SO looking forward to seeing the animals, but we only saw a couple of deer near the hotel/cabin area. We stayed in the Canyon Village one night. That evening we went to Hayden Valley at dusk and was only able to see a handful of bison from so far away they looked like specks in the fields. Even with binoculars they were slightly larger specks. I rallied the fam at 5:00 am and we drove to Lamar Valley and finally saw the bison - and loads of them. Some extremely up close. It was awesome! We stayed at Old Faithful Snow Lodge the next night (warning - the roof is under construction and the scaffolding and related awnings block any airflow from coming into the room so even with a fan and the windows open the room will be 90 degrees. We had to get a second fan and prop the door to open let in some the cold air from the AC in the rest of the building - but then had construction fumes from a vent across the hall sneak in too). Our time there was just meh. The food at the hotels was essentially the same and it was all marginal and expensive. I get Xanterra is the government contractor runs all the lodges and food service in YS, but one would think the company would TRY to make visitors’ experience better than just marginal. (The food at Canyon Ranch was barely edible.) The whole experience - other than the bison at Lamar valley was meh. Were my expectations too high? I mean, this was a bucket list trip for me and I was disappointed. Should I go back to give it another shot but stay off the beaten path? If so, what else should we do? Also, I realize my privilege of being able to go on a trip like this, and I am grateful for the opportunity to have gone.