r/xkcd_transcriber • • Feb 16 '14

Stop showing the alt-text!

0 Upvotes

I link to xkcd comics because I want people to read them, possibly for the first time. When xkcd bot replies to "transcribe" it, all the person sees is the alt-text which is completely out of context to someone who hasn't read the linked comic yet. It's even possibly misleading about what the comic will be about.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Apr 25 '14

Why even have this stupid thing? It's just annoying as fuck

0 Upvotes

r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jan 23 '14

Why?

2 Upvotes

I don't get it. Comics are funny because you experience them all at once. This bot adds nothing. Can I please have a way to delete the bot's comment?


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jun 26 '14

Just a suggestion for the stats

0 Upvotes

Currently, in the stats section of the output, the bot reports what percent the comic is referenced out of the total, like so:

Stats: This comic has been referenced 126 time(s), representing 0.5169% of referenced xkcds.

The number on it's own doesn't mean much unless you know the average percent of referenced comics (currently sitting at 1/1386, or 00.0722%, because there are currently 1386 comics), so if we were to put it compared to an average or median (like standard deviations on the stats website) it would be more useful.

A potential problem with this is that older comics have more of a chance to be referenced than newer comics simply because of time, so maybe the algorithm could include a time metric? Something like (references per day) / (average references per day)?


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Apr 27 '14

Please delete downvoted posts

3 Upvotes

Some people like bots. Others don't. I would like the XKCD bot more if you changed it in the following way.

  • Please delete posts as soon as they are downvoted to -1.

  • Please make the text less verbose. There is no need to spend 8 lines citing 3 lines from an XKCD comic. One idea is to redirect the interested reader to a wiki with the remaining info.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Aug 08 '14

/r/xkcd has been liberated.

3 Upvotes

/u/soccer is gone. We're back in control of /r/xkcd. /r/xkcdcomic is going to shut down. You should update the bot to remove the "kerfuffle" link and have it direct to /r/xkcd as the xkcd sub.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Mar 14 '15

[Suggestion] Use ssl/https version of image.

1 Upvotes

I've recently noticed that when expanding the image with RES, the Reddit page's security icon drops from the usual blue-background "Verified" padlock to the gray "This website does not supply identity information." warning icon.

Interestingly enough, when I open the image in its own tab, HTTPS Everywhere redirects me from the http://imgs.xkcd.com/ address to a https://sslimgs.xkcd.com/ address that's otherwise the same, so I know that an ssl/https version does exist.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Feb 09 '15

It only has a link to the image for the first referenced xkcd in a comment and not subsequent ones.

1 Upvotes

See here for an example. Ignore the stuff about my lady problems.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Mar 20 '14

List of subreddits /u/xkcd_transcriber is able to to post/not post in?

2 Upvotes

Would it be possible to get like a general list in the sidebar here or something to see if he's be banned from any subreddits? You know, for science, and general referencing.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Aug 19 '14

Why not show relative post frequency?

2 Upvotes

E.g. instead of posting how much this individual comic is represented, why not show how much relative to average, or possibly the percentile (e.g. "This post is referenced 5.61x the average post." or "This post is referenced more than 83% of referenced post." I guess the stat website shows std deviations from the mean, that could work too.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • May 11 '14

Add a link to the page's ExplainXKCD wiki

3 Upvotes

Just a feature recommendation, would save people the trouble. If they run into an XKCD linked that they don't quite follow they can click on the link without having to google for it (if they even know about explainxkcd.com )


r/xkcd_transcriber • • May 03 '14

Reposting when comment with comment is quoted

0 Upvotes

The bot will continue to post the comic information if someone quotes the post with the comic in it.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jun 18 '14

Title text printed twice, once with incorrect formatting

0 Upvotes

r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jan 06 '15

[Bug report]

0 Upvotes

This transcription was incorrect


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jul 26 '14

Messes up the title of #1137

0 Upvotes

Comic 1137, RTL, has nonsense characters before its name in the bot's comments.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Aug 25 '14

Why not have the bot show post frequency rankings?

5 Upvotes

Percentages are kinda confusing. Ten Thousand is the most referenced XKCD comic, but it's only about 6% of the total. It's big if you think about it, but it sounds kinda small, so why not add (or replace with) a "this is currently the 5th most often linked comic" type of counter?


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Feb 18 '15

Bug Report: Transcription Glitch ['] = [â]

1 Upvotes

Saw a post where the transcription had an â substituted for every apostrophe.

Link to comment. http://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/2w8qwg/ineffective_homeopathic_alternatives_to_vaccines/cooxhsq


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Apr 26 '14

Unicode transcription errors

0 Upvotes

http://www.reddit.com/r/AnarchyChess/comments/240dcf/next_level_chess/ch2ofmn

The downward arrows in the alt-text have been replaced by â characters.

(it's ok, I have written code that deals with Unicode too)


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Dec 17 '14

Can we get the data?

1 Upvotes

How many xkcd references are made per day, and which one most often? I'm sure the people over in /r/dataisbeautiful would appreciate it.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Nov 12 '14

Could a mobile link be included?

1 Upvotes

A lot of people use Reddit on their phones, and it's annoying to manually go to the mobile version.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Sep 29 '15

Any way to disable it for images?

0 Upvotes

It makes sense for xkcd post links (saving users the effort of having to click them), but when I'm hotlinking an image, I think its pretty self-sufficient (especially for those using RES) and the bot reply doesn't contribute anything.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jan 13 '15

[Suggestion] Add the mobile link

1 Upvotes

I'd like a mobile link in the body of the transcription for when I'm on mobile please.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Jan 13 '15

Rewrite

2 Upvotes

I've rewritten the bot, and I'll be testing it out over the next few days, ensuring it works as normal and such.

It should work pretty much the exact same as the current one, but it will include:

  • Vote monitoring (auto-deletion if it's downvoted 3 times or more)

  • Simple anti-spam (by detecting chained responses)

  • Revised what was included in the "transcription"

If you notice any problems or inconsistencies, or have any suggestions, let me know.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Feb 19 '15

[suggestion] Add the np prefix to your subreddit link

2 Upvotes

Currently, your "Problems/bug" link (that goes in this sub) causes moderator bots to delete your comments because it lacks the np prefix. And that's a shame, this bot is pretty cool :)

Have a nice day.


r/xkcd_transcriber • • Feb 27 '15

[Suggestion] Get actual xkcd transcriptions from Oh No Robot.

2 Upvotes

Oh No Robot is a site that transcribes webcomics, including xkcd, and using their text-descriptions would be better than just a link called "Image." (It would greatly improve the experience of using, say, a text-only interface e.g. cortex, I think.) :¬D