r/xfactor • u/Shackleford98 • 4h ago
Discussion If you were an act on the live shows, who would you hope is your mentor?
Probably a fairly standard answer but Gary or Simon would seem like a safe bet.
If I got Louis or Sharon, I’d be worried.
r/xfactor • u/Shackleford98 • 4h ago
Probably a fairly standard answer but Gary or Simon would seem like a safe bet.
If I got Louis or Sharon, I’d be worried.
r/xfactor • u/Brit-Crit • 6h ago
There is a lot of discussion on here about famously bad song choices - Maria singing "Brown Sugar" (Season 2), Scott singing "Yeh Yeh" (Season 5), Rachel singing "With Every Heartbeat" (Season 5), John singing "Zoom" (Season 7), etc, etc...
Given the "negative" focus of the X Factor format and the way it focuses on eliminating weaker acts rather than rewarding successful ones (Ignoring Season 14 as we all tend to do) It's only inevitable that we focus on the failiures and the risks that didn't work out. However, this can often seem like acts getting punished for choosing unusual songs, and reinforce the stereotype that you can only succeed by covering "Feeling Good", "Somebody To Love", "I Have Nothing" etc over and over again...
To counter this, can you cite instances of acts choosing unusual song choices that WORKED and allowed them to stand out or even establish themselves as frontrunners?
r/xfactor • u/Hassaan18 • 7h ago
Every year seemed to have an act that, despite getting criticism constantly, stuck around in the live shows, but they were definitely getting a rough ride. Off the top of my head:
2004 - Steve (from Sharon and Louis)
2006 - The MacDonald Brothers (from Simon), Ray (from Louis and Sharon)
2007 - Same Difference (from Louis), Leon (from Simon and Louis)
2008 - Daniel (from Louis and Simon)
2009 - Jedward (from Simon and Dannii), Lloyd (from Simon and Louis)
2010 - Wagner (from Simon and Dannii), Katie (from Louis and Dannii)
2011 - Johnny (from Gary)
2012 - Christopher (from Tulisa), Rylan (from Gary)
2013 - Sam (from Gary)
2016 - Ryan (from Simon)
2017 - Sam (from Simon)
I'm trying to think of the judges that were the harshest towards them.
r/xfactor • u/Hassaan18 • 7h ago
Aside from the obvious ones like "first group to win" etc, I'm thinking of lesser known ones.
2005 - first time an act performed an original on the live shows
2006 - first double elimination in the live shows
2007 - first time groups were put together by the judges
2010 - first time there were wildcards for the live shows
2012 - first time acts could sing with an instrument before the live shows, first time acts with an existing management deal could audition, first time an act performed in the live shows with an instrument and nothing else, first time an act that was in the bottom two won
2016 - first rap act in the live shows that didn't (really) sing
2019 - first time an act performed in the live shows with zero backing track at all
Any others?
r/xfactor • u/Serious_Meaning5220 • 2d ago
r/xfactor • u/Serious_Meaning5220 • 2d ago
r/xfactor • u/GurLess7822 • 5d ago
@ The X Factor
r/xfactor • u/Hassaan18 • 6d ago
r/xfactor • u/Due-Oil8955 • 9d ago
r/xfactor • u/Hassaan18 • 9d ago
r/xfactor • u/Unhappy-Air3861 • 12d ago
@ The X Factor
r/xfactor • u/Due-Oil8955 • 13d ago
@ X Factor Global
r/xfactor • u/Hassaan18 • 15d ago
They've gotten a load of criticism over the years for a number of reasons, but I do wonder how many of them could be attributed to people not understanding that they are making a TV show.
It's not some fix that they've scouted people or that Simon's got this persona, that's just telly. I don't understand how people still don't know that there's several rounds before you get to the judges - it's not some conspiracy.
Of course, there's good and bad ways of going about it, and they've definitely gone a bit too far in a quest to make good TV at times, but within the context of the time (and how much they had the tabloids basically in a chokehold) I'm not surprised.