r/ww2 • • Dec 06 '23

Why didn’t the allied navy barrage the bunkers of Normandy?

0 Upvotes

My best guess they were so committed to keeping it a surprise they did not want ships seen in the channel.

Edit to add: all I could find were bombers overshot their targets. Glad to know this sub is the way it is.

Thank you for the responses I have much to learn on the topic.


r/ww2 • • Dec 07 '23

Discussion Why did hitler think people would just let him get away with mass extermination?

0 Upvotes

Listening to the rise to power podcast and learning a lot I didn’t know about the third reich. But one thing really sticks out. How long did it take for the US to find out about concentration camps? Was hitler able to keep it a secret or something? I feel like if the US WOULD have known right away, that they would have intervened ( like we always do)

Also did Hitler have any solid evidence against leaders of the SA during the night of the long knives? Specifically against Ernst Röhm?


r/ww2 • • Apr 04 '24

Discussion An entire fucking nation gone..

58 Upvotes

First off, what is the dominant religion in Poland? Christianity (Catholicism). (around 80%, the rest mostly undeclared)Okay. Is there religious diversity? No. (how did we get to that point?) Is there any other MAJOR religion? No. Take a look at Judaism in Poland. Currently, Poland's Jewish population is stands at 0.01%. So around 3-5 thousand people. THREE FUCKING THOUSAND. And there used to be (more than) THREE MILLION!! AN ENTIRE FUCKING NATION GONE! Poland had the LARGEST Jewish population in Europe. Jews have been living in Poland for more than thousand years. They owned shops, businesses etc. (although of course antisemitism was still present) 10% of Polish population was Jewish. Poland was also a JEWISH land.

(oh also I forgot to mention the rest Jews after WW2 immigrated and also were forced to leave under communist rule)

That's an absolute fucking loss, an absolute fucking tragedy. It should NEVER be forgotten or denied. Anybody who denies the atrocities committed by the Nazi regime during WW2 has reached the absolute fucking height of moronism.


r/ww2 • • Dec 09 '24

My grandfather, top row third from the left, back when men were really men.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ww2 • • Jun 16 '24

Was D-Day necessary?

4 Upvotes

Just to play devils advocate and get into a hypothetical discussion. I'm not saying it was unnecessary or disparaging the soldiers or Allied commanders. I personally think it was 100% necessary and the correct decision.

But,were the Normandy landings necessary to defeat Germany? Were other options available?


r/ww2 • • Feb 22 '24

Discussion What battles or events in WW2 do you personally think aren’t really talked about?

0 Upvotes

r/ww2 • • Jun 13 '24

Why did Germany invade Poland WITH the Soviet Union?

0 Upvotes

It just makes little sense to me. Hitlers end goal was soviet territory, why “team up” with a non-negotiable energy within the future.


r/ww2 • • Sep 23 '26

Video This is how Hitler dismantled democracy in just 8 weeks. My convo with historian of Nazi Germany, Timothy Ryback

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm a r/ww2 lurker and a huge history nerd who runs a small podcast, usually hosting historians who've just released a new book...

In the latest episode I interviewed renowned historian of Nazi Germany, Prof. Timothy Ryback who just released an amazing book called "53 Days: How Hitler Dismantled a Democracy."

It details the intense 8 weeks during which Hitler destroyed the Weimar Republic without firing a single shot, making himself dictator in the process. It's pretty gripping stuff.

I apologise for the shameless plug, but I honestly thought some of you might be interested.

You can find the episode here:

https://youtu.be/m7dMSBnUDM0

P.S. Appreciate the mods approving this post!


r/ww2 • • Sep 08 '24

Just out of pure dumb curiosity, are there any jewish SS?

6 Upvotes

r/ww2 • • Jun 07 '24

How long were the Germans engaged in combat before the U.S. showed up?

2 Upvotes

I saw a video that said the Germans had been fighting the other countries for awhile before the United States showed up. Were the Germans already war weary?


r/ww2 • • Jul 13 '24

Discussion What was the Nazis fatal mistake during the battle of Berlin , or was it doomed before it started?

10 Upvotes

r/ww2 • • Sep 10 '24

Discussion The Treatment of LGBT+ People in Nazi Germany NSFW

0 Upvotes

Introduction

I find it frustrating that LGBT+ victims of Nazi Germany are often left out of discussions surrounding Nazi Germany and World War II in general. I have spent a decent amount of time researching the persecution of LGBT+ people in Nazi Germany, as well as in allied countries during the early 20th century, as I feel it is important history that is often overlooked. In this post I will aim to spread some lesser known information surrounding LGBT+ people and culture in Nazi Germany.

About me

I am a 25 year old LGBT+ person in western Canada. My interest in the persecution of LGBT+ people in Nazi Germany was piqued when I asked what happened to gay people in Nazi Germany while in social studies class in high school, and my teacher couldn't give a satisfying answer. This has lead to several years of interest in the topic of LGBT+ people in Nazi Germany, as well as LGBT+ history in general. I only speak English and some Russian, and as such I am unable to cite sources written in German. My sources for this post will mostly be articles written in English by historians.

LGBT People in Weimar Germany

Homosexuality and other gender and sexual minorities became surprisingly accepted in Weimar Germany. Prior to the 1933 Nazi government, gay clubs were a somewhat common sight in German cities, with some sources citing about 100 establishments catering to LGBT+ people in Berlin alone.. Paragraph 175 of the Weimar legal code determined sex acts between men illegal, though there were attempts made to strike down this legislation. Such attempts ultimately failed, though by 1933 public acceptance of LGBT+ people was higher than anywhere else in Europe.

This rise in acceptance in Weimar Germany is commonly known as The First Homosexual Movement.

Institut für Sexualwissenschaft and Magnus Hirschfeld

Magnus Hirschfeld was a physician in Weimar Germany, who himself was a gay Jewish man. He specialized in researching human sexuality and gender identity, and on July 6th 1919 opened the Institute for Sexual Research. This was a private clinic that aimed to broaden the understanding of what we now call LGBT+ people, promote sexual education, and support LGBT+ individuals. This clinic revolutionised gender conformation procedures. The institute housed a significant library of literature written about human sexuality and gender identity.

The Raid of Institut für Sexualwissenschaft

On May 6th, 1933, Nazi soldiers raided the institute, and performed a publicized book burning of over 20,000 books in the institute's library. Voiceovers in the footage of the burning deemed the literature "the intellectual garbage of the past".

Most of the individuals involved with the institute fled Germany, though one individual involved at the institute, a physician by the name Gohrbandt, joined the Luftwaffe and became a chief medical advisor.

The Nazi Regime

LGBT+ people living under the Nazi Regime were heavily oppressed. Paragraph 175 became heavily enforced, and between 5000 and 15000 men were tried and convicted of homosexuality. Many of these men would be placed in concentration camps, tortured, castrated, or murdered. Many Lesbians were also sent to concentration camps usially being prosecuted for crimes such as prostitution, lewdness, and asociallity.

The Pink Triangle

Gay men in concentration camps were forced to wear a pink triangle on them to denote their status as homosexuals. Such status subjected them to particularly brutal treatment from Nazi guards and other prisoners alike. Many were murdered by other inmates. Medical experimentation was performed on these men, including castrations, as a means to identify a way to convert them into heterosexuals. Wearers of the Pink triangle were also segregated in "sissy blocks", away from the general camp population.

One incident in 1941 saw 5 gay men in Sachenhausen taken to a bathroom, have hoses shoved down their throats, and be subsequently drowned.

Murders at Klinkerwerk

Klinkerwerk was a subcamp of Sachsenhausen. People held there were forced to make munitions for the Nazi war effort, and it's conditions were particularly brutal. One incident in 1942 saw 200 gay men were systematically murdered in Klinkerwerk.

Post Nazi Germany

After the war, many men convicted of homosexuality in Nazi Germany were forced to serve their full prison sentences given to them by the Nazi regime, while other prisoners in concentration camps were liberated. LGBT+ survivors of the Nazi regime were not recognized or compensated. Paragraph 175 was not repealed in Germany until 1994. In 2002, the German Government pardoned people convicted of homosexuality by the Nazis.

Conclusion

This is but a small sample of LGBT+ history during World War II. I hope it sparks some of us to continue to learn about the history of LGBT+ people in general, as well as the atrocities committed by both Nazi and allied countries in the first half of the 1900's.

Lest we forget.

Sources https://theconversation.com/lgbtq-history-month-gay-victims-and-survivors-of-the-holocaust-are-often-forgotten-we-need-to-tell-their-stories-154417

https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/education/events/event-items/lgbt.aspx

https://history.washington.edu/research/publications/sex-and-weimar-republic-german-homosexual-emancipation-and-rise-nazis

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-forgotten-history-of-the-worlds-first-trans-clinic/

https://www.dw.com/en/lgbtq-people-germanys-long-forgotten-victims-of-the-nazis/a-64533968

https://www.holocaust.org.uk/News/homosexual-victims-of-nazi-persecution


r/ww2 • • Jul 23 '24

Discussion In Ww2 did the American air force fly directly from America

18 Upvotes

In Ww2 did the some American air force squadrons fly over to Germany directly from America or did they just fly from the uk( I know a few squadrons did from the uk)


r/ww2 • • May 27 '26

They were forgiven and kept in power but not the children in Hiroshima & Nagasaki

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

First guy (Hirohito): I think that Hirohito was as evil as Hitler. He personally suspended all international laws for treatment of war criminals to do such cruel things that even hitler hadn't done. He Initiated the "comfort women"(sexual slavery) system that caused forced enslavement and sexual abuse of hundreds of thousands of women from occupied territories. He Initiated the Three Alls Policy: In China, Japanese forces were ordered to "Kill all, burn all, loot all," resulting in the devastation of countless villages and the deaths of millions of civilians. Allied prisoners of war (POWs) and Asian laborers were forced into slave labour under brutal, starvation-level conditions to build infrastructure like the Burma-Siam Railway. Tens of thousands died of exhaustion, disease, and abuse. He Enforced Mass Civilian Suicides (1944-1945). He Directly Initiated the Kamikaze Strategy where pilots were forced into Suicide Operations. During the later stages of the war in New Guinea and the Solomon Islands, cut-off Japanese units resorted to systematic cannibalism, which was frequently organized by officers rather than just desperate individuals and were approved by the leadership in tokyo including Hirohito

Second Guy(Shiro Ishii): He perpetrated some of the most horrific atrocities in human history during World War II as the director of Unit 731. Under his command, thousands of Chinese, Russian, Korean, and Allied prisoners of war referred to inhumanely as "marutas" (logs) were subjected to lethal human experimentation. Ishii orchestrated the deliberate infection of victims with deadly pathogens like anthrax, bubonic plague, cholera, and smallpox to observe the progression of diseases and test biological weapons. He forced public plague outbreaks by dropping infected fleas on Chinese cities. His unit performed brutal vivisections on fully conscious patients without anesthesia to study the effects of disease on living organs. Prisoners were subjected to frostbite experiments where limbs were frozen solid and thawed to test treatment methods, forced into high-pressure chambers until their eyes popped out, and exposed to lethal doses of X-rays. Ishii also supervised forced pregnancies to study mother-to-child disease transmission, tested flamethrowers and chemical grenades on tied-up captives, and drained victims' blood to test animal blood substitutes, ensuring none of the thousands who entered the facility ever survived**.**

Third Guy( Prince Yasuhiko Asaka): Prince Yasuhiko Asaka, an uncle of Emperor Hirohito, served as the temporary commander of the Japanese forces during the 1937 capture of Nanjing. He is primarily responsible for authorizing the systematic atrocities during the Nanjing Massacre (Rape of Nanjing) by issuing a notorious secret order to "kill all captives". Following his order, Japanese troops engaged in a six-week rampage of mass executions, rape, and widespread looting. Death toll estimates range from 40,000 to over 300,000, with an estimated 20,000 to 80,000 women and girls sexually assaulted. Tens of thousands of Chinese prisoners and civilians were rounded up and machine-gunned, beheaded, or used for bayonet practice

There were several more Japanese leaders like this.

None of the above leaders were persecuted as they were given immunity from persecution by America for various reasons. Hirohito and Prince Yasuhiko Asaka were given immunity as the whole royal family was given immunity. Shiro Ishii was secretely given immunity by America in exchange for the data of all the research by his team.

They were given immunity but the civilians including children in Hiroshima & Nagasaki were punished with death. America also secretly bought 1600 Nazi scientists to America after ww2 under Operation Paperclip.

Imagine being a 2 year old kid and they drop a solar system on you while they take to America the people who did horrific experiments on living humans.

I dont understand why this bias of punishing kids with death but saving war criminals who did unspeakable horrors to people


r/ww2 • • Jul 21 '24

Discussion Are there any good memoirs in English from the r***-victims of the Wehrmacht?

1 Upvotes

“A Woman in Berlin” is an important example of a memoir about the experiences of German women under the Red Army-occupation.

Are there similar books written by Russian women about their experiences of the Wehrmacht? And what happened to these women after the war in general?


r/ww2 • • Sep 14 '25

Why didn't Germany send troops to East Africa during World War II ?

1 Upvotes

Why didn't Germany send troops to East Africa during World War II ?


r/ww2 • • May 26 '25

Erich Hartmann is a little bit overrated

2 Upvotes

Basically what the title says, I know some people will want to kick my dogs and rob my family but I do not think Erich Hartmann deserves the love he gets.

I’m not saying he was a terrible pilot, he was onviously incredibly skilled. However he is most likely not the larger than life figure he is portrayed to be, and furthermore not even really a good person like people portray him to be. I mean, he claimed to have shot down planes that wouldn’t have been NEAR the area he claimed to shoot them down in and you want to tell me he isn’t a liar?

Besides, he flew around 1400 sorties which means he came back with nothing 3/4 of his missions. Comparing this to men like Gunther Scheel who shot down 71 aircrafts in 70 missions before he was killed, doesn’t it seem like Erich was not that efficient?


r/ww2 • • Aug 28 '24

Discussion Did Alan Turing stop Germany from being nuked and all out nuclear war?

0 Upvotes

Recently watched the Imitation Game and putting two and two together.

Turing shaved two years off WW2. Oppenheimer’s bomb was used four months after the Nazi’s surrendered.

If Turing did not crack Enigma, how would the events have likely played out?

In my head, would the Nazi army have not weakened, and therefore they would’ve been nuked (and not Japan) had they been strong enough not to surrender earlier? Also, had they been nuked, would that have pushed Hitler and his nuclear scientists to speed up their work and retaliate?

Did Turing save the world?

Or is this all gobbily goo with my head over simplifying a hypothetical?


r/ww2 • • Feb 08 '25

Casualties

0 Upvotes

How come even being on all fronts of the war at one time, the us only lost 500k troops in the span of 4 years compared to other countries that were in the millions, additionally fighting the japanese who were known to fight till the death?


r/ww2 • • Oct 08 '25

Tiktok is filled with neo nazi propaganda

64 Upvotes

So I use tiktok a fair amount but for about the past year the nazi propaganda i have seen makes me sick to my stomach and I will share some with yall. So the first one is 271k and this a dog whistle for the amount of people who died during the holocaust as many believe that 6 million could have not been killed. Another one is 88 and this is a code for heil Hitler and this is a comment that many use to spread there message. The next one is videos showing Germany during the 1930's before the war under nazi rule, showing children playing and people walking and cheering and many in the comments say if Hitler had won he would have saved europe. The next one is the sun will rise again showing neither Hitler or the nazi swastika in the sun and many say Europe is waking up. The final one is many saying that europa the last battle is a insite to what the great world would have looked like if Hitler had won and how he would have saved europe from the migrant crisis that faces the continent now. All in all its sick and sad that our ancestors fought the nazis just to see there grandkids reposting and making this shit. And when you try to talk to them they call you a jew as they have been using the war in Israel and Palestine to fund there narrative. What can we do about this.


r/ww2 • • Jul 14 '25

This Is a Bad Book Listening to the audiobook of Malcolm Gladwell's The Bomber Mafia and I am surprised how good it is.

Post image
75 Upvotes

I had an impression that Gladwell was going to take a shallow pass at the topic, or turn it into the usual "the allies were so evil for bombing cities" we see all the time. But he actually has made the best distillation of the history of the air war- the thinking behind it and the people making the decisions- that I've read. You can see he steeped himself in it and distilled exactly what he wanted to say and he follows the thread from the origins in the post WWI radical thinkers in the US Army working against the grain to prepare for all the new factors modern bombers would bring to strategy and tactics, through the early stages of the war over Europe and lessons learned there and then into the Pacific. Like many authors he is fascinated by Curtis LeMay and he includes him in enough of this book to satisfy everyone- and the audobook includes many recording of his and other postwar speeches on the topic. For the first time in any book I have read, we get a great look into the Norden Bombsight's development and the hopes it inspired and it's problematic inventor and IT'S COST which I had NOT KNOWN was about half the cost of the Manhattan Project. Anyway I am running long and I want to encourage people to read this one you will NOT be disappointed it is so well done.


r/ww2 • • Aug 08 '25

Which theater was the "Best" and which theater was the "Worst" for American Soldiers during WW2?

7 Upvotes

During WW2, American soldiers had fought in Europe, Africa, Asia, Oceania, the Americas, etc. However, which location did the American soldiers face the most hardship and which location did they face the least hardship?


r/ww2 • • Mar 14 '24

Despite Imperial Japan being far worse colonizers, why didn't Indonesians welcome back the Dutch with open arms and quickly rebelled upon World War 2's end? Esp when Filipinos saw how far better things were under the Americans and absolutely loved the USA for liberating the Philippines from Japan?

0 Upvotes

I saw this post which provoked the question up.

I mean meaning to ask this for a while at Dutch and history subs but haven't had the time.

​As you pointed out the Japanese occupation was far worse than the centuries of Dutch rule. But as a neutral bystander with neither East Asian/SouthEast Asian nor Dutch ancestry, I ask. Why did the Indonesians immediately choose to rebel against the Dutch after the war? To the point as early as the first half of 1945 Indonesian insurgents were already killing Dutch civilians *DESPITE THE PRESENCE OF THE BRITISH ARMY* (who defeated the Japanese in Indonesia)?

​I mean shouldn't the horrific occupation of the Japanese means Indonesians be happy they're back and at least hesitatingly let them resume the colonialism? I apologize if this was offensive but I been wondering for a while. As the Japanese were literally using similar Nazi style policies minus full genocide, I was surprised the Dutch were not welcomed back with open arms.

Really I'm quite curious because its pretty much a universal cliche that 4 years of Japanese rule was far worse than 5 centuries of Dutch rules is an often stated maxim when you read about Indonesian history or even not anything specific to Indonesia but just read about the Japanese campaigns of the Pacific Theater focusing on Japan. So why did the Indonesians responded automatically with armed rebellion as the quoted texts state when the Dutch came back rather than seeing them as heroes to be respected or even welcomed with open arms? Unlike the Philippines here despite American colonial abuses, the Pinoy people didn't simply welcomed America with open arms and were releived at the end of Japanese occupation, but loved the American army so much that to this day even as relationship is more strained in recent years, even the most anti-American Filipino will speak about the American army's liberation for the Philippines with fondness and see America during this time period as noble heroes who saved the Philippines. So why the opposite in Indonesia esp since everybody in the history community absolutely agrees the Japanese were 100 fold X worse than the Dutch ever were? Why were the people not alleviated their far less brutal colonial rulers returned over the Japanese unlike the PH islands?


r/ww2 • • Oct 02 '24

Image Am I the only one who thinks that the Chinese uniform during WW2 was underrated?

1 Upvotes

r/ww2 • • Jul 03 '26

USSR unprepared for German invasion

1 Upvotes

History always taught us that the USSR was unprepared. But how can they be unprepared when there are millions of German troops and weapons on their border?

It doesn’t make sense that the USSR was unprepared.

How unprepared were they?