r/writingcritiques • • Oct 31 '20

Meta Rule 2 is now suspended.

40 Upvotes

As mentioned in the previous post, /r/writingcritiques will be suspending rule 2 (Posts cannot be longer than 1,000 words) for the month of November in celebration of National Novel Writing Month ("NaNoWriMo").

Good luck to everyone giving NaNoWriMo an attempt and I look forward to seeing your progress!


r/writingcritiques • • Apr 15 '20

Tool to critique your writing

37 Upvotes

I posted this in r/writing, but they banned it. Hopefully people here are interested in a tool that gives them feedback.

I'm terrible at writing. Well, I used to be. Maybe I still am, but it's getting better. I learned that writing sentences of the same length is the prose equivalent of speaking in a monotone voice. It bores people. They drift off and you lose them. So I wrote a tool.

musical-sentences.com

It's free. Everything runs in the browser. Nobody else sees or reads your content. It won't make you Shakespeare, but it may make your content more engaging. Best wishes.


r/writingcritiques • • Feb 06 '26

Looking for Writers!

33 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I hope you are doing well?

I am looking for writers to join a new discord server I have set up. It is a place for people to share their work, give each-other feedback, enter monthly writing competitions and generally hang out with other writers!

  • Genre/s: Any and all!

  • Goals/expectations/commitment: Regular contribution and providing feedback for others

  • Writing/experience level: Any, we're all here to learn (18+ only)

  • Meeting place: Discord

  • [Writing groups only] Max size: Any

Who I am: Based in UK, full time geek and huge fan of all things fantasy and sci-fi. I'm currently studying a degree in English Literature and Creative Writing whilst working on my first novel (currently 60,000 words through).

If this sounds like it could be for you, please drop a comment below or send me a DM!

Thank you and happy writing!


r/writingcritiques • • Mar 22 '20

I wrote this from the prompt “God’s been trying and failing to end the world since 2015. Clearly something’s made him indecisive”. How did I do?

28 Upvotes

“Can’t you just… think it out of existence?” the new angel Gregory asked. His furrowed brow was one of confusion and slight concern.

God looked up from the table he worked upon, still not directly facing Gregory. “No.” The voice of the almighty being had a calm yet forceful timbre. His head dipped back to the table, again both unaware and uncaring to the knowledge that anyone shared the room with him.

Gregory’s finger jolted into the air. “Lord, if you want to destroy the humans, you at least owe th-” God abruptly snapped his fingers, and the angel was gone, worlds away. He began again, speaking to no one: “If you want to destroy the humans, you at least owe them a quick death”. Gregory knew that explaining this would be a failed exercise. Though he knew God could hear him, what does it matter? To him, even his own angels are prokaryotes: short lived, unthinking, and unimportant.

But a flash overtook him; for a moment, he saw all and knew all. But this moment was not all he saw: he witnessed every second from the birth of the universe to its end, from the perspective of every atom.

Gregory writhed on the ground until it was over. After the fact, he thanked God, for he understood: a story has no value without the right ending.

God was a thespian


r/writingcritiques • • Mar 17 '20

First chapter of my book on mental illness - "The Slash Room" - feedback please!

22 Upvotes

"Reality is malleable;" I scrawl in a fresh page of my notebook, my frantic handwriting jumping through the lines. "And things are not as they seem."

The menacing walls of the psychiatric ward are closing in, with teeth. My eyes widen on the bed and for a brief moment, I think I see her face in the white swirls of paint.

It's been ten years since we last spoke. I've been banging my head against the wall ever since. Not a day goes by where I don't check her social media. Not a night passes where she doesn't grace my dreams.

In reality, she wants nothing to do with me. But what's reality, anyway?

Modern science suggests that humans only perceive of a small sliver of what's going on around us at any given time. The field of metaphysics also suggests that we are living in multiple, shifting realities. Perhaps even infinite realities. I find comfort in these thoughts and I like to play with them. It lets me think that maybe, in some other dimension, she's still here with me.

I used to think mental illness was a choice and after being diagnosed with Schizophrenia, part of me still does. I think mental illness chooses you and you choose back whether or not to accept it. A proposal of sorts. But by the time the abyss has swallowed you whole, you've already said yes and there are no divorce papers.

So here I am. Thinking, writing. I like to think about time, space, spacetime, and all things existential in my spare time. When I don't have spare time to think about the big questions, I create time. "You'll always have time for anything that's a true priority," is one way to phrase it. "Time is a construct of your imagination and ego" is another.

After our break-up, I made a promise to myself to follow the truth wherever it leads. To stare down the abyss until it quivers. I said "yes" to the proposal. I took the red pill. Critical thinking leading to truth - that is life's ultimate goal when you lose the ability to love, right?

I find myself lying here between these four breathing, white walls. I'm lying on my assigned bed in my assigned room: "The Slash Room" as the other patients call it. There are slashes all over the door's Plexiglas screen from the previous occupants. It's the only single-occupancy room on the whole unit and the only one monitored twenty-four-seven by CCTV camera. "For high acuity cases," Nurse Dane had explained on my second day on the ward.

Here I am, confined. Here I am, without her. Here I am. I think, therefore I am. I am, therefore I think. I think too much. Get me out of here.


r/writingcritiques • • Sep 14 '20

Satire about Indian Immigrant Family - please give feedback (excerpt only 264 words)

21 Upvotes

Hi I have been toying with this idea of a satire on the life of an Indian immigrant and working in IT (I myself am Indian so I don't mean anything bad by this, just meant to be funny). It's influenced by my life so It's a bit of a difficult concept to explain and I'm not sure if this would be an interesting/funny story for anyone else to read so I'm looking for some feedback. Please let me know what you think.

My interest in Engineering/IT/Technology/(Your buzzword of choice) began with a declaration from my mother that I took after my brother. He was on his way to becoming an engineer and was doing it with style (large thick glasses and tucked in short sleeve shirt if you can even believe it). I couldn’t give you an exact age but this was probably when I was around 13. My mother can’t be wholly blamed for pushing this on me though, as I was also certain that this was what I was interested in. I mean I loved watching my brother tinker away on circuit boards for hours and watching him play video games. If that’s not a true interest in a field, I don’t know what is. From there on it was off to the races, everyone knew that I was going to be an engineer! That meant all the aunties could take a mental note to put me down as a potential wife for their son in 10-12 years time.

If all this sounds mildly insane, that’s because it is. However, this is how it was for an immigrant Indian family in the early 2000s. This was before all the tech bros dropped out of high school and made an app to become rich and famous. So for us back then it was all good grades (focus on Math, English you can flunk), Sunday school, and Don’t Even Look at The Opposite Sex. Reader be aware: I tend to have a salty tone, bear with me, it’s my idea of a sense of humor…


r/writingcritiques • • Oct 06 '25

Other I wrote this first paragraph and need your feedback. Would you keep reading?

20 Upvotes

The world we knew died three years ago, and from the silence, something human was born. It wore the skin of memory and spoke with the voice of the dead. Doppelgangers. The threat beyond infiltration is the burning question: if the imitation is perfect, what is the value of the original?


r/writingcritiques • • Aug 03 '24

PSA - Don't ask for help then delete your thread after one critique

19 Upvotes

It happens, I'd say, at least half the time someone asks for help. They don't even bother to thank the people who spend time out of their day to lend free advice. Absolutely infuriating.

If you can't take the slightest criticism, even when asking for it, you will never survive releasing a book into the wild.


r/writingcritiques • • May 29 '21

My beautifully terrible work

19 Upvotes

Can someone critique my probably terrible maybe good writing. I made the first version with a friend at his house during a sleepover

The Story: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PZtoqCRh13dAYKqwasNk1FxEF2EFzhaiBzD0RVnjIs0/edit


r/writingcritiques • • Jan 15 '21

Just wanted to check if you think my poetry is good enough to pursue. I did post it in poetry group but it died in new. Thank you guys.

17 Upvotes

When told to join hands,

some lifeforms

comply.

when life is at its most dire we ponder our saviour.

Our hostility can be what forces people to fight for our

Obedience.

We put faith in those who often do not have our best interests at heart

Votes align views and views create standpoints to make us

Agree.

Complete me. So, I can complete your society.

Tell me how I can

Serve.

I will work to give you credit. It’s the least I can do while you unite us.

Let me create and destroy as you see fit.

Allow me to abdicate my responsibilities in search of adventure.

The driving force for humanity has always been exploration

this is what will continue to drive us,

the blasé and pessimistic nature of the many will not stifle the drive and optimism of the few.

When told to join hands

We look for those we know, it’s those we don’t know whose hands need holding.

It’s those who don’t look for the familiar that suggest it.

Unite us.

Listen, as I pray I’m standing next to you

When told to join hands.


r/writingcritiques • • Aug 11 '14

[MODPOST] To ensure a functional community, give a few critiques while you wait for a critique

17 Upvotes

Leaving a critique or two or more is the best way to ensure critiques for yourself. As this community grows, it will be harder for the moderators to ensure that you get a critique. But if we help each other, we all win!

Plus, it's just 1000 words or less (currently.)


r/writingcritiques • • Jan 21 '26

Story of my life ( I feel like I've lived one hell ofba life for 37 years) ** Trigggernwarning ** may cause upset.

16 Upvotes

If you are wondering if I am alright,

Walking up from nightmares in the middle of the night.

Can't eat a meal without it mostly being a fight,

Barely was in school but yet I am so bright.

The truth of my youth will it send me to a heaven?

Almost stolen on holiday when I was eleven.

Took by a man who thought he could have me,

Thankfully with banging on the door I finally got free.

Only turned fourteen, before things got so mean,

Bulllied at school, wish that I'd never been.

Lost all this weight at a rate so obscene,

I had become one very fragile ill teen.

They put me in hospital, for 'bad kids' may I quote,

Force fed me meals or shoved tubes down my throat.

It happened a lot, i felt like a bloated bloody shoat,

If only this part of my childhood could be rewrote.

But ofcorse I got out, after time and weight gain,

Hey I'm okay mum, promise there's no pain.

I can't go back there, I am well, I am sane,

As if that place could have healed my brain.

I hid things well then, for a further three years,

Changed my whole image, masked all my fears.

When beaten to a pulp and raped, I hid my tears,

No food, just drinking and drugging, everything disappears.

Including myself, seventeen, skin and bone,

Admitted to a hospital, weighing only four stone.

A medical ward, a safety zone,

But I couldn't get better all on my own.

I had no fight, I had no will,

Everything had gone down hill.

I was so weak, so gone, so ill,

Given days to live, that is until..

Doctors, they came, 2 or 3,

After many distressing media pleads from my family.

But there was no place here for my E.D,

So off to London for a year they sent me.

Therapists to heal, talk about the past,

Doctors, dietitions, nurses all were vast.

Made friends, felt better, 'recovered', ammased,

And when I felt I was ready at nineteen, I walked free at last.

I've worked years in banking and had the odd relationship.

Life was okay, but always drunk and I was still being sick.

Binge purging had become an addiction every single day,

It consumed my life and over the years debilitated me in every way.

And here we are now, 17 years on,

Life's thrown so much, and I've been so strong.

I haven't drank in 8 years now

Still I haven't recovered and I will explain perhaps how.

As reflecting on my life, even blows me away,

Age 29 another hospital stay.

I was in hospital the same time as my dying grandad,

They wouldn't let me visit him and it was beyond sad.

So I escaped my ward, ran and fell through the door of his bay,

I'll never regret it, as seeing him alive-  this would be my last day.

The very next year age 30,  I had a bad fall,

I broke my back badly and couldn't walk at all.

More months in hospital, physio, tried weight gain and willpower,

Finally my legs started working but left me with bad mobility meaning I can't walk that far.

I got home for Christmas, Anorexia still consuming me,

My weight was still so low, every bone you could see.

It's a miracle I survived and learned to walk again,

I had an amazing home physio alas now live in daily body pain.

I became even more so a hermit, never went outside,

Only to visit my granny to whome I always could confide.

Sadly, my weight and bloods were again too bad to operate,

Back to hospital where I was subjected to disgusting hate.

Another patient bullied and had fixated on me,

I begged staff for safe guarding plea after plea.

They ignored the constant harassment and things being thrown at my head,

Until a horrible night, the patient held me down and sexually assaulted me in my bed.

SELF DISCHARGED, My family came and took my home,

As I was not safe there being ignored and left alone.

Now my head was fully screwed this time,

My family had to call the police as the hospital blind sighted the crime. 

I've never had justice or trauma help to date,

That hospital is now a place that I hate.

Age 32, still a hermit, my granny moved in,

It was short lived with the unknown cancer growing within.

I lost my hero, my world, my everything,

She was the most special person, the wind beneath my wings.

With all this pain, my health still in shambles and weight dropping more,

I was functioning below 5 stone, something never done before.

Refusing hospital as the trauma is still with me,

I decided to try church to see if whilst there, healing could be.

How wrong I was, what's next is absolutely crazy,

They were a CULT and stole everything from me.

With weight so low my heart gave in at home and paramedics came and took me away,

The pastor and a church member stripped my bedroom bare and stole over £1000s to my dismay.

So depression, paranoia, anger, anxiety kicked in as I returned home, still very ill and distraught,

Then 2 weeks in bed I spent because somehow, covid was caught.

I dropped to 28 kilos - under 4 stone,

And still, I have not received any help for it or barely left my home.

Pure skin and bone ,  I severely feared for my health,

With many thoughts and an attempt to end my life  myself.

But I promised my Granny I'd get better on her death bed,

So I must remember this and keep fighting the diabolic demons my head.

My hermit life now alone- has ups, downs and everything in between,

My anxiety and health curently excruciating,

I am fully debilitated from a life , it's worse than it has ever been.

I'm trying to not give up though, and I constantly tell myself so,

With all my strength i've left,  I try not to just let go.

And to keep fighting and endure this rollercoaster ride,

If anything happens to me, at least you'll know I really tried.

I spend my life in my room,  my bed, alone and that's no way to live,

Something needs to change, something's gotta give.

It's been like 6 years now that I've been a prisoner in my own home.

I don't think anyone else would still be here , so unwell and feeling so alone.

To make matters worse my weight is at its lowest and mobility completely gone after this decline,

As I sit in my room, missing the sunshine.

Tics and spasms are progressing through my body and i have so much torture in my head.

Medicated fully now , bound to my bed.

Yes, I'm constantly in bed now, that I've been put on pallative care ,

Here in my zen den

I eat sleep repeat all day , all night

With my little gang of fur

Frankie, Meg, Villanelle and beautiful Thor

We are a little,  gang of 4

My pets stay with me, give cuddles and love galore.

I really couldn't ask for more .

And I wont give up though. EVER. I need you to know.

No matter what,  I promise not try and not let go.

And keep fighting and endure this rollercoaster ride,

If anything happens to me at least you'll know I tried.

I wake each day and do what I can to cling to a P.M.A  (positive mental attitude)

After 24 years of suffering there has to be a way.

My illness is SO misunderstood and a living hell,

But i'm a warrior and I MUST survive so my story I can tell.

Renzi

2026


r/writingcritiques • • Oct 15 '26

Other How do you stop yourself from over-polishing the opening chapter?

15 Upvotes

The opening chapter is a trap. It's the thing agents see first, the thing readers judge the whole book by, so it gets rewritten twelve times while chapter four sits untouched in first-draft form. By the time the opening is "perfect," the rest of the book has moved on and the opening no longer matches it.

I tried the advice to just write the whole draft and come back later. Doesn't work. The opening still ends up getting disproportionate attention, usually because the first few pages keep getting read during any pause in writing.

Curious if anyone has actually solved this. Is there a rule, don't touch chapter one until the draft is done? Write it last? Just accept that the opening will always be overworked and move on?


r/writingcritiques • • Jan 09 '21

Fantasy Steampunk Action Scene - Does this inspire emotion or does it just come across as melodramatic?

15 Upvotes

Hi. Would someone mind critiquing this action sequence for clarity and emotional stakes? I'm not an expert on action and would appreciate a more experienced eye!

Background to the scene: Emmett (the MC) is an autistic aeronaut with a lifelong fear of heights - ironic, he knows - who has just escaped being killed by a magical storm and is trying to rescue his mentor and best friend, Sixsmith, from being kidnapped by Sixsmith's most feared enemy.

Word Count: 655

Emmett got up, ears ringing and head spinning. Every limb trembled as he clawed his way to his feet, the red-tinged emptiness burning behind his eyelids every time he blinked to clear the rain from his lashes. His knee ached and buckled on his first attempt to stand. He was battered, bruised and bleeding, but he was alive. Somehow, alive.

The sweet, burning smell emanating from the destroyed roof above him indicated that Norris hadn’t been so lucky. Emmett swallowed convulsively, sour spit rising up his throat as he spotted one charred hand hanging over the edge. All the veins were still glowing ever so slightly green.

He stared, trying to hold himself together while his mind cleared when the situation dawned on him.

“Six,” he said.

He spun, adrenaline-pumping once again. The airship – The Obelisk – was still there, still moored to the tower. Figures moved swiftly about the decks: five, six, maybe more.

Too many to fight, a voice inside him supplied.

But Emmett was already running.

He dashed across the tiles, slipping and sliding in the rivers of rainwater gushing like waterfalls to the ground below, throwing his abused body into the walls.

Knees screaming, lungs protesting, he crawled up the bricks. He could hurt later. He’d have time to hurt later.

Please, please let him have time now.

He heard it when he was only halfway up: the unmistakable rumblings of arcana firing. Horrified, he saw the airship shudder, the balloon expanding in the ways his lungs could not, and it slowly began to rise.

“No! No, you bastards! Give him back, you bastards! Give him back!”

Emmett hooked a leg over the edge of another section of the roof, swearing and screaming every threat he knew, dragging himself onto the flat. He left bloodstains on the tiles, streaks of red swirling away into the gutters.

The airship was lifting faster than his legs could carry him. Already, it was a good three metres above his head and, as he skidded to a halt on the edge, he saw with sharp despair it was too far for him to reach.

“Six!”

His voice was lost in the crash of thunder. Black lightning stole his vision. He staggered, clasping soaked hands over his ears.

Movement caught his eye. A trailing rope snaked past his feet, hissing against the slates. Emmett looked down.

Beyond the roof was infinity.

His stomach clenched.

And Emmett’s mind locked.

He took several steps back, eyes fixed on the rope moving too quickly to grab.

One chance.

He charged.

The final knotted coil flicked off the edge.

Emmett leapt.

The whole world went silent. He flew. Rain drove knives into his face and eyes. The wind dragged at his flailing limbs.

Everything was extraordinarily peaceful.

Then his fingers closed about the rope and life crashed back in wild, deafening colour. The rope swung wildly, and he slid down it, screaming as his hands burned. His heels caught on the bottom knot and he halted so abruptly his arms wrenched in their sockets. Emmett clung on for dear life, tasting blood and rain in his mouth, strands of his hair sticking between his teeth.

“Don’t look down. Don’t look down, don’t look down –“

And he did.

It was only a glimpse of distant trees and winding roads before he retched and tightened his grip, eyes squeezed shut with enough force light popped in front of his eyes. His skin felt frozen to the rope, the weight of his body sending him swinging through impossibly thin air.

The fading thunder made him curl even more inwards, terror seizing his bones in its jaws.

“Climb,” he whispered. “Come on, Emmett. Climb!”

He forced his eyes open and inhaled deeply, coughing as the blood caught in his throat. Then slowly, like some great creature had wrapped his body in weights and was dragging him towards oblivion, Emmett began to climb.


r/writingcritiques • • Jan 05 '21

A random fight scene I wrote short and to the point.

15 Upvotes

His feet sank into the ground as he blocked the hammer strike. A second blow sank him even deeper, his body barely withstanding the force. As the third swing came in he stumbled to the right, his feet catching in the loose earth, a resounding boom from the hammer hitting the ground where he just was, within seconds Balaril was standing sword in hand ready for the barbarian.A roar followed by a charging sideswipe of the hammer came crashing into him his blade breaking under its weight sending him sliding across the ground.

“come on you bastard thought you said you'd have me dead in three blows” mocked Balaril.

“your're barely standing but you dare to mock me?” growled the barbarian

He charged forward again hammer held high,Balaril dodged to the side and another boom filled the air as the blow struck the ground. With what was left of his sword Balaril dived in as the barbarian went to swing at him, the sword found itself buried in his ribs. The barbarian growled in agony as pain shot up his body.

“you bastard”

Balaril stabbed and stabbed again hoping this monster would go down, A fist took that thought from him smashing him to the ground. His vision went black as the barbarian roared again.

Balaril awoke to the sight of stars, remembering what happened he scrambled to his feet to fight the barbarian but for naught, the monstrous man was on his back dead.

“thank the gods”

A wash of relief came over him as he stared at the barbarian, as his body relaxed he realized how much damage hed taken during that fight, his muscles hurt from what he could tell atleast one cracked rib and a hell of a headache.


r/writingcritiques • • Mar 10 '22

My Opening to My Novel :) Could really use a critique!

14 Upvotes

Hi! I am super into writing and I'm thinking about submitting this to some publishers so I was wondering if I could get some feedback on it? Does it make you want to read more of the first chapter?

-----

Sammy was a really good kid. He was 5 foot 7 inches which was pretty tall for his age, but he was also nice. Basically, he always shared his chicken nuggets at lunch. But also he had a really mean mom, who always yelled at him and made him share with his little sister, Bessie. Bessie was also nice. Basically, the whole family was nice.

Anyway, Sammy was really into playing hopscotch and he believed he was the best hopscotch player in town. There was a bully who totally disagreed with Sammy, but Sammy figured he could probably take him. Bessie also said that Sammy could take him, so that really helped Sammy think he could take the bully. One day, Sammy and Bessie were hanging out at the park where there was hopscotch and then something BIG happened...


r/writingcritiques • • Apr 24 '21

Fantasy I've no clue what genre this story is tbh. This is the first few pages of my latest short story. I probably messed up the dialogue, I rarely use dialogue in my writing

14 Upvotes

980 words

    “Did I do well?” I asked, staring into the blank, lifeless eyes of Death.

    “Yeah, you did. You did real well,” Death replied, his attention straying away from me. He admired the room, paying special care to the photos of me strung about the walls.

    That room was my pride and joy, I spent hours every day there. An ancient futon sat in the center, two tables on either side. A thin layer of dust coated most surfaces.

The majority of my life was contained here, and despite knowing my slow crawl towards death was nearing an end, I never thought to consider it may all end within the confines of these mahogany walls; my personal, custom casket.

    I’ve never been particularly afraid of Death, the Grim Reaper. He was only there to guide me along. It’s rather nice, I think, to have a friend by my side in my descent from one life to the next.

    Death began to rise, drifting towards my photos. “These photos, they’re of you?”

    “Yeah, my entire life, just on display. Every big moment’s up there,” I replied. Dozens of photos were hung, though it was painfully obvious which ones meant particularly more to me. A special few were framed behind perfect redwood. Seeing them always took me back to when I was in the prime of my life, running around the old redwood behind my childhood home with my brothers. From dusk until dawn, when my mother would shout for us to come inside for supper, we would play by that tree.

    “Tell me about this photo,” he asked. His voice had become soft, caring, even. A stark contrast to his depressing, colorless outfit. I wouldn’t call it a dress, but it almost resembled one. Fabric trailed behind him, occasionally catching on something in the carpet.

    In his hands lay a personal favorite; a photo of me and my siblings on my first day of school. My sepia-toned smile held joy and promise I no longer had. A pained sigh dripped from my lips as I realized I had no more chances for redemption.

    I remembered that day well. Ma’s old voice played in my head, telling my sister to be quiet so they could take the photo before we had to leave.

    “Anne, hush up and stand by Jamie,” she’d said. Anne promptly stood beside me and flashed her signature smile. It was a sad smile, though; she hated when Ma got upset. The paisley wallpaper behind us seemed much dimmer there than I’d chosen to remember.

    Death’s voice pulled me from my daydream, from my family. “Well? Are you going to tell me?” he asked. I didn’t much want to, but, given the circumstances, I didn’t feel I had a choice.

    I took a deep breath, taking the photo from his grasp. I pointed to the smallest child, admiring his joyful expression and messy brunette locks. Childhood innocence. God, how I missed it.

    “This one here, that’s me. I was just about five, I believe,” I pointed out each of my siblings in order of our age. “Anne and Michael, they’re twins. Kathleen, Gwen, Jack, and Anthony. Dad never really believed Kathy was his, though. Always was suspicious. Said she ain’t his kid, that Ma was sleeping around.”

    Death pointed to a girl I hadn’t pointed out, the girl locking hips with Anthony. “And her?”

    “Right. That’s Debra; she was dating Anthony. A year older than him, she’s a senior here. Got knocked up by some random kid, claimed it was Anthony’s. Real piece of work, that girl. Prob’ly stinking up some ditch nowadays. Took off after she graduated, never saw her again.”

    As I told Death about Debra, my mind wandered to Anthony. He never had great taste in women, but eventually the right one came along and scooped him up. Jane, that little angel. Not once have I understood what she saw in the rat bastard. He was the average picturesque-looking character, a little cruel at times but never too bad. I’d say he was the human equivalent of sweatpant drawstrings. Unreliable the majority of the time, yet you still expect him to be there. Eventually you give up on him, though, and toss him aside.

    “Anthony was a good guy, just made some bad choices, I think. Like that rat,” I muttered.

    “Jamie, what’s this photo of?” Death asked, glaring at a small photo hung near the corner. My eyes strained trying to see it clearly. My heart sank when I finally caught sight of it.

    “Michael’s funeral. Poor kid caught some sickness, I don’t even know what. Couldn’t handle it, died a week later. I wonder if he spoke to you, too. He’d have had an awful lot less to tell.” My heart yearned for my lost brother, moreso than it did for the rest of my family. He was a gentle soul, he’d cry at the sight of a dead ant.

    Death opened his lips to speak, but no voice came out; only a faint groan. Him and I were one in the same, having nobody left to love. Everyone I cherished was gone, and as for Death, well, I could only assume he had nobody.

    “I see,” Death replied. I continued showing him photos throughout my childhood, some I hadn’t acknowledged in years. My first school dance, my first girlfriend, my graduation.

    My father was never the type to enjoy being in photos. A photo with him was like a fine pastry; sweet, but a rare delicacy.

    “My dad, here, he drove me to my first day of college when my car broke down. He wanted a picture of me and him in front of the building. Said he was proud of me.” My words felt like blisters on my tongue. It was the only time the old man ever showed an ounce of compassion.


r/writingcritiques • • Jan 02 '21

Fantasy Untitled Story Beginning - does this create a sense of intrigue or is it too cliché?

14 Upvotes

This is the opening to a fantasy mystery story I had a bit of inspiration from. I'd love some feedback on the style and whether it is compelling as an opening to entice the reader to continue. Thank you!

Word count: 695

They called him far earlier than expected.

Oil glimmered on the walls as he put aside the can and sat down on the bed to answer the summons. The face which appeared in the water bowl wasn’t one he recognised, but the clipped greeting was familiar enough.

“Greetings, child of my brother’s second partner. May the one true star guide your hand.”

“And may darkness follow in your wake, sister of my father.” He tugged at his collar, grotesquely glad that the hands did what he commanded. “You’ve changed.”

“It was necessary.”

“The plan’s changed?”

The head in the water dipped in an affirmative. “Destroy the dwelling as directed,” they said, “But we are not sending you south.”

His stomach clenched as his left hand twitched. Instinctively, he grabbed the wrist and held it down. “Where am I going?”

The face didn’t appear to notice. “To the east. We feel you would be better served there now that… complications have arisen.”

“What sort of complications?” The hand was getting stronger again, he could feel pain shooting up the arm. The teeth gritted by themselves.

“Are you having difficulty?” The face looked sly.

“No,” he lied.

“If you cannot complete this mission, we will come to fetch you. We do not want to have to do that, child.”

“I know. I know. I… I can handle it. I will handle it.” A burst of anger spilt up his throat and he blurted, “You told me he’d be easy to take! Yet it has been a whole week and - !”

Unsympathetically, the face in the water turned away. “Gather strength. Follow your training and all will be well.” They paused. “All must be well.”

“It will. Where in the east?” The hand was weakening again. He forced himself to breathe evenly and let his heart settle. Easy… easy… touch the glass and don’t let it break.

“Sarimai. I expect it will take a week. You have funds?”

He looked towards the far wall where a pair of bulging bags were placed far out of harm’s way. “Yes.”

“I expect two weeks of travel. I will call again then.”

“Thank you.”

“Do not thank me yet,” the face said. “And get control or else you will be collected.”

“Yes, thank you. May the one true star –“

“Do not fail me.”

The water rippled and faded back to normalcy. Shaking a little, he sat back on the bed. “I won’t let you do this,” he said to thin air.

His finger twitched.

“You will fall, eventually.” His heart sped up as he lied. “I’ve done this before.”

A second of stillness and he smiled, thinking that the threat had done the trick.

Then, of its own volition, in a sudden, jerking whirl of pain, his left hand flicked the bowl across the room. It soared in a perfect arc and shattered against the wall.

“No!”

Inside, he thought he heard laughter.

Fury made him strong. He forced the body up and stalked across the little attic room towards the bowl.

“Did you think that was funny?” His left hand began to gather the pieces, porcelain shards glimmering with droplets of both water and oil. “Was that worth it?”

He’d left one mirror unbroken. Carefully, he went towards it, still shaking, still clutching the shards.

“Was that clever, do you think?”

The reflection was still odd to him: a man in his mid-thirties – thirty-four to be exact – with an angular brown face, mop of black hair, and neat beard and moustache. He had improved the body's dress sense considerably. And his grooming habits too. So many people lacked the discipline, it seemed, outside of the Lochland Circles.

“Let me show you how clever that was,” he said.

A few hours later, the attic was ablaze. The newspapers reported it as a tragic accident. The artist, Mr Pierre Lorenzo, must have left his combustible oils uncorked and had a smoke, they decided. He had been working very hard and throughout the night of late. A tragic accident made by the sleep-deprived.

Understandable.

Unfortunate.

No one found the writings on the walls.

HELP ME might have changed the story, somewhat.


r/writingcritiques • • Jan 29 '20

Would seriously love some feedback on this poem that i wrote - it's a bit of work in progress right now

14 Upvotes
The Asian Mother
Also known as:
the tiger mom.
the dragon lady.
Imagine the ferocity and untamed passion of Oriental exotica
Exiled to a suburban neighborhood in the American Midwest 
Domesticated under dominion of the white man 
Divorced from the homeland 
She has gone the distance 
Thousands of miles
Past mountain, valley, and sea 
Only for her children to go even farther. 
An entire world away
When a mother’s love language 
Becomes lost in translation
Her warmth is the steam from a rice cooker 
Her heart on a platter of freshly-sliced fruit 
“I love you” 
Is something rarely said. 
I wish I better understood my mother tongue
So I knew how to say
I love you, too.

r/writingcritiques • • Mar 16 '22

Fantasy Trying to get back into writing so I wrote a small prologue, and I was hoping to receive some feedback on it.

13 Upvotes

It's just a prologue into a fantasy story based on different Gods, and I wanted to get unbiased feedback on it. Thank you!

It was a clear night, the night of the burning. The sun had long hidden away from sight, and with it the sweet comfort it brought, and instead, the moon came to greet his people. The humans chanted to the Gods above as they dragged the faithless into the clearing, deep in a forest, with trees that swayed gently, as though waving to the faithless. onto the platform they were shoved, high above the people, their bodies bare of any clothes, white painted markings on their bodies as they struggled.

The cold wind nipped at their bodies as they struggled to escape their binds before they meet their ends. Nails were hammered into their hands, and blood splattered onto the people below as they continued chanting. The faithless’ cries echoed through the village as flames ruthlessly swallowed them, burning their flesh, and their sins. The crimson glow from the fire hid the faces of those who betrayed them, simply for being different.

“Cleanse him, cleanse her, cleanse them. Free them of their sins and the flames of hell. Let them fly to Valhalla, let them Float to the heavens, let them be reborn into a sprout, to grow, to learn, to believe.”

The unmistakable smell of burning flesh wafted into the air, it was a familiar smell, a comforting smell. One that the whole village knew well, from the elders to the babes, and it was cherished by many, but not all. The chants grew louder the flesh burned off the faithless, hair set aflame, and bubbling blood covered the platform below them. Their bodies, weak from malnutrition struggled to try and curl into themselves in a meek attempt to protect themselves. Smoke burned their lungs as the people wafted it away from the faithless, wanting them to die from the ‘flames of hell’ rather than the smoke.

Time dragged on for what felt like hours before finally one by one, they all lost consciousness, then their lives. The stars burned brightly to guide them through the darkness, helping the mother moon to move them past the pain and be guided to a new life of love and prosperity.


r/writingcritiques • • Mar 01 '22

Keys to the Kingdom by Garth Nix

13 Upvotes

One of my favorite series growing up was "The Keys to the Kingdom" by Garth Nix. I recently reread 2 of the 7 books in the series. As my point is to highlight the positive and negative features of different books, I won't be including many plot details. Only the barebones. The series follows the adventures of a teenage mortal and his accidental quest to wrest control of the universe from its corrupted super-powerful leaders, who are each named a day of the week and take various forms. It's a quick-moving series, and the books lead into each other. Nix does an excellent job varying the obstacles the main character faces and writes in a smooth, unassuming tone that reads easily. Though the world depicted is clearly different from real life, you encounter anything new from the view of a human and adjust to them with him. The number of books in the series was clearly designed to prompt comparisons to the seven days of creation and the potential meaning and allegory behind the setting of the story. The names of several of the books lend strength to theorized connected themes woven into the story. The villain/holder of power in each book controls a different domain that fits with their unique power, and each book showcases the consequences of the corruption of their power. They each also happen to be human-like creatures that lack the full range of human feelings. The last book ends with the protagonist confronting a reflection of his own self and facing the idea of near omnipotence. This potentially refers to the Christian savior, as the book is called Lord Sunday. The week ending on a Sunday also infers Christian parallels. The basic material of everything in the books' world is Nothing, a toxic substance that can be made into anything, but lacks a divine spark. This also reflects Nix's desire to depict the various aspects of humanity and evoke thoughts of divinity and celestial beings.


r/writingcritiques • • Jul 20 '20

I really just want to know if the beginning of my story interests anyone other than myself

13 Upvotes

Miri’s hair is short, straight, and deeply black. After its most recent cut a rectangular gap materialized just above her shoulders so that her neck now seems framed by a neat little stage, one that I choose to stare at all throughout class. I stare because it is right in front of me, but also because it is the hair of my dreams, glistening, dangling before me under the harsh white lights of the second grade classroom.

I invite Miri to sleep over for the weekend. My family celebrates the Sabbath by the literal letter of the law, as do all of my schoolmates’ families, and so if she says yes it will be a long commitment, two whole days and a night, and therefore a huge achievement on my end. I invite her again, and again and again. The weekend she finally comes my cheeks hurt from grinning. We stay up past eleven and she tells me all about her family and her after school program and then at my request describes how to write in her handwriting, with the delicately crossed T’s and elongated S’s so on and so forth. I show her off to my unimpressed sister. She sleeps in my bed and I in blankets on the floor, and we eat so much candy that at one point I find myself watching her trying to fit six large gumballs between her cheeks. I remember watching her closely, the slow pained movement of her jaw. I remember watching her closely. She leaves on Sunday morning with a friendly wave and a big proper thank you, and on Monday morning she doesn’t show up to school. On that same Monday it is dull and grey and in my dread I float above the classroom, a gloomy overcast.

On Tuesday she walks into class and my heart drops two feet down into my bright red loafers. Her lips are protruding more than usual, and when she opens her mouth to tell us we can already see her brand new braces. I think it is my fault -- because of the too much candy and all -- and so I cry in a stall in the bathroom and then at lunch seek her out to apologize. She takes the apology without registering what for, and from then on I think often about how happy I would be if I could get braces. If I could be a person who has braces. In class I sneak peeks at the way they make her lips look puffy, the way they somehow complete her face and those thin square glasses with the glossy blue rims.

On Wednesday I go for my third eye exam in two months. I don’t need glasses but I say that the D E F look like other letters in the alphabet and when this doesn’t help me achieve my goal I resort to begging for a pair. My mother, a friend of the optometrist because the optometrist is the mother of a girl in my class and also because my mother becomes ‘friends’ with everyone due to her welcoming smile and pan-compassionate ways, asks the doctor while I’m not in the room to prescribe me a prescription-less pair of glasses. Her friend the doctor obliges with a knowing smile.

They take forever to arrive but then they come in their long velvety box with the little silky napkin I am overjoyed. I sit at home on our felt-like couches and feel them on my face. My little brother takes note and soon asks my mother for a pair too. Two months later we are both proud owners of sleek new shades, useless ones which don't even protect our eyes from the sun, and about five months later our shades are long forgotten, my mother having secretly returned them and us having given up looking very soon after.

The years pass and my mother’s friendliness never lets up. But inside -- in the house and in her body -- she recoils whenever the phone rings or the doorbell dongs.

“I’m not home” she mouths.

“She’s not home, can I take a message?”

Often but not frequently there is a friend who somehow makes it through the door, who finds their way to the table where my mother sits with her milky, fragrant coffee, with her eyes wide and her head nodding along to the lamentation of her peer.


r/writingcritiques • • Apr 21 '20

Stranded On An Island

13 Upvotes

Writing a version of something that happened to me as a kid, wanted to make it dramatic with some humor. I have no idea if it's interesting.


“It’s like looking at heaven, from a corner of hell,” I thought to myself, as I stood by the water and gazed upon the vast sight of nothingness. It was day 824, and as I looked above, a cloud shaped like a middle finger drifted across the sky. This was my reality as a mere 12-year old, stranded at sea.

It started with a seemingly harmless question, as many catastrophes at sea have. "Do we really need this many lifeboats?" asked the captain of the Titanic. "You think we can make it through that hurricane?" said the Spanish Armada. With the ambition of Columbus, I asked myself one of those questions—one that nearly killed me: “Why don’t I borrow dad’s kayak without telling anyone?”

I set sail late in the evening under clear skies. But in just hours, Zeus and Poseidon started a fight over dirty dishes and summoned a biblical thunderstorm. As a rogue wave hurdled me out of my raft, my life flashed before my eyes. From stealing $20 from my mom’s purse to blaming my sister for accidentally killing the hamster, all my regrets and failures flickered by. As I plunged into the sea, I prepared to meet my maker.

I knew when I’d arrive at the fiery gates of hell, I’d have a lot of mistakes to answer to. God would have all my bad decisions neatly printed out, spanning the potato incident to Christmas 2003, and ask, “Where do I even start!?”

But upon opening my eyes, I peered upon a sandy beach along a dense forest. Somehow I cheated death, only to wash ashore on a deserted rock aptly named “Charles Island,” after King Charles was beheaded. It dawned on me that, “here I am, trapped on an island, miles from civilization and not a single human in sight…

Ah, finally. I'm sick of people anyway.”

However I now declare that people are no longer wired to survive on their own. No Burger Kings, mega-gigantic insects, and the frighteningly high chance of being eaten alive by animals are basically the dictionary definition of “GET OUT!” So it was a rough start. Mother nature has no mercy—she’s like an evil step-mom who regrets tying the knot to a guy with three kids and mortgage debt.

And my lack of survival skills were a severe disappointment to my ancestors. I discovered which plants were poisonous only after using them as toilet paper. I once got lost in the forest and stepped on my own trap, falling into a hole that took 34 days to climb out of. I even lost three toes in a fight against a pack of rabid wolves.

It wasn’t until I got in touch with nature, did I find the will to survive. My loneliness led me to befriend a gigantic rat. I named him Whiskers. Whiskers was my rock, I leaned on him in times of hardship and struggle. He provided compassion, listened to my woes, and ultimately brought me salvation.

As the years passed, I learned to spearfish, hunt wild boars, and collect rainwater from plants. During the day I would roam the forest to gather coconuts, and at night I would lay on the beach, counting the stars, with Whiskers by my side.

But much like this story, all things must come to an end. The final day had arrived when I awoke to a horn blaring in the wind. I opened my eyes to the sight of an enormous ship, proudly waving the flag of America. Like a true patriot, I saluted my saviors. But in that moment of ecstasy, I forgot all about Whiskers.

I was saved from my purgatory and returned to civilization. But only then did I realize I left my best friend behind, without even a proper goodbye. I cried that night, as I knew we’d never see each other again.

To this day, I’m not entirely sure what became of Whiskers. I imagine he’s still out there, or possibly dead.

In truth, I was only stranded for eight hours. But I vividly remember it feeling like eight years.


r/writingcritiques • • Aug 03 '25

Fantasy Would love thoughts on this prologue for this book I’ve written about the seven deadly sins, sin of lust.

12 Upvotes

They say monsters don’t cry.

But they never saw me on the floor of that stone chamber, blood crusted under my fingernails, her scream echoing like a curse inside my skull.

There’s no redemption for what I did. No glory. No justification. I was not drunk. I was not broken. I was not possessed.

I was simply… me.

And that’s the part that never lets me sleep.

I am a Berserker. Born in the fire-ravaged cities of the great desert, where storms steal children from their beds and men are measured in the bones they break. I grew up among warriors and beasts, the line between the two so thin it might as well not exist. Our race was made for brutality. We aren’t raised to love—we are raised to conquer.

I was good at it. No, I was great at it.

By eighteen, I had command. By twenty, I had power. And by twenty-two, I had already crossed the line that no man can return from.

Her name is gone from memory. Her face, faded. But the moment remains.

That was the night I became Lust.

Not in poetry. Not in prophecy. But in pain.

They branded me, as all the Sins were branded—one from each of the great races, and one from the Demon bloodline, long thought extinct. We were the warning signs the world ignored until it was too late. Symbols of ruin. Living proof that no kingdom, no people, no soul is immune to rot.

They cast us out.

And we made a new name for ourselves. The Seven Deadly Sins.

But unlike the others, my sin wasn’t a quirk of greed or laziness. My sin was violence disguised as desire. Hunger dressed in seduction. Lust — the hunger that takes, no matter who bleeds.

I wear it like skin now.

I wandered for years after I was marked. The desert no longer welcomed me. Even monsters have lines, apparently. So I moved through the fractured lands—past the poisoned seas of the Pirates, through the haunted forests of the Fairies, up to the fractured cliffs of the Elves, and into the realms where even the wind held judgment.

The Dividing War split the six nations over a century ago, but the hatred never left. It soaked into the soil. You can feel it under your boots if you stop long enough.

No one trusts anyone anymore.

And yet… somehow, they still believe in prophecy.

The Goddesses, high above in their floating palaces and sanctified clouds, speak rarely—but when they do, the world listens. One of their Seers, a Visioned One with moonlight in her voice, once whispered a truth that trickled through the world like venom in honey:

“Under the crimson sky where twilight swallows virtue, The Sin of Lust shall meet the Woman of Love. He, a wanderer bound by desire, And she, a soul who embraces all without chains.

When passion and purity collide at the edge of dusk, fate shall tremble. For in her arms, he will taste devotion, And in his gaze, she will glimpse ruin. If she tames his hunger, light may yet endure— But should he consume her heart, night will reign eternal.

Thus, beneath the dying sun where good fades into evil, Love will either save or damn them both.” They say she walks the world even now. This Woman of Love.

They say she’s human — the weakest of the races, the only ones without magic, without bloodline powers, without divine blessing.

But she can change everything.

They say she can look a Sin in the eyes and not flinch.

That she can give love without price, without fear, without control.

That she would choose even me.

I’ve never met her. Don’t know her name. Don’t know her scent or her voice. But I dream of her. A shadow cloaked in sunlight. A laugh that reaches where even guilt can’t cling. A softness I’ve never known. One that could break me in two.

And yet… every dream ends in the same way.

I ruin her.

I devour her.

And the world falls.

Some part of me still wants to find her. Maybe to prove the prophecy wrong. Maybe to find out if there’s still a single shred of humanity left inside me.

But deeper still—under the rot, under the shame, under the bone-crushing silence of my exile—I want to believe she exists.

I want to believe that love can reach even me.

But if she does exist…

Then she should run.

Because if I find her—if fate truly binds us together—

It won’t be a meeting of lovers.

It’ll be the start of the end.

For her.

For me.

For the world.