r/writingadvice • • Nov 10 '24

SENSITIVE CONTENT I’m writing a book right now and the Main Character is trans, how do I introduce that into the story

1 Upvotes

I am transgender and I’m basically telling the story of my life, and I’m stuck on how to introduce the characters as trans. It needs to be one of the first things that’s set up in the story because it’s the catalyst for a bunch of things that happen in the book. It needs to be an explicit character trait or else the book won’t be that easy to understand why the character ends up doing the things that they do, And struggle with the things they end up struggling with.


r/writingadvice • • Jun 16 '26

SENSITIVE CONTENT How do i write trans male/female, agender, bigender, and intersex characters in a respectful way?

0 Upvotes

How do i write trans male/female, agender, bigender, and intersex characters in a respectful way? For example, can a trans female character still dress as a dude and enjoy sex with their..'part' or does it still have to go or something? not that it matters or anything, i was just curious. They're all people that should be portrayed as such. i would like someone to tell me what NOT to do when writing them since that would be faster. I hope nobody takes this the wrong way. I genuinely want to know. I'm not publishing nor earning commission for this book.


r/writingadvice • • Sep 06 '25

GRAPHIC CONTENT At what point does a romantic/sexual age gap become creepy?

2 Upvotes

I’m working on a fantasy horror erotica book where the “male lead” is a creepy villain who’s older than his “love interest” (victim), so I’m purposefully trying to make this age gap look creepy af independent of all the other creepy things going on. Creepy is basically the theme word for this project.

The villain, a serial killer who passes as a respected member of society and is a noted war hero, is at least in his late 30s but could easily be in his late 50s. His victim, a trans woman who he coerces into being his lover, is about 24-26. Now, it might be because of where I’m from (middle America), but a 10-15 age gap isn’t that unusual, especially if the younger member is out of college age. In the fantasy setting I’m using that’s sort of based on the 1950s, it’s definitely not of particular note unless there’s a major class difference.

So I’m looking for an undeniably eyebrow raising age gap for a culture that thinks nothing of older teenagers getting married.

(And for your relief, this guy’s victims do band together and bring him down at the end. Also, I am hella trans.)


r/writingadvice • • Jul 16 '24

GRAPHIC CONTENT Need a name for a Serial Killer that's targeting S*x Offenders

0 Upvotes

So yeah, there's a Serial Killer that is just looking up the Sex Offender registry, finding the "Red" guys (the REALLY bad sex offenders) he goes to their door, knocks on it, and when they open he blows their brains out and just leaves.

My novel is about the cops trying to find him, because we can not tolerate vigilantes, but the legend about this guy is growing in the public and he's regarded as a hero and everyone is cheering him on, tweeting, vlogging, saying this guy is a hero.

I can't use "The Punisher" or "The Avenger" I even considered having him wear a punisher shirt as a little nod, but decided against that (cause I don't want the mouse on my ass) I also thought of "The Guardian" but he's not really "Guarding" anyone.

One of the cops calls him Kid Diddler Killer but that doesn't exactly roll off the tongue and it doesn't sound epic enough. I want something iconic, by the third act this guy is a national hero and icon so he's got to have a great name. Could use some suggestions


r/writingadvice • • Oct 30 '24

Advice Can someone please clarify what "just read books" is supposed to mean?

0 Upvotes

I've heard people say as writing advice that you should "read books to get a feel on your style or to get inspiration" but I have two problems with this advice:

  1. The tern "books" is so vague. What kind of books? Books that lean into the genre of my book? Books that I personally find entertaining? Books that fans of a series I enjoy would recommend? Or just books in general? If the answer is the last question, then this is a perfect time to present my next problem

  2. I have bad ADHD. If you present me with something that I find boring or unengaging I'm not going to read it. In other words a VAST majority of books out there will probably not make it very far chapter-wise for me.

What does this tip mean and what am I supposed to do with it?


r/writingadvice • • Sep 17 '26

Critique I wrote a short story, posted it on r/nosleep, am a bit disappointed over its lack of success

0 Upvotes

Today, I wrote a short story and decided to do what I’ve never done before: I was going to upload it on Reddit so people outside of friends and family will actually see it!

So I did just that and while it was viewed by other 2,600 users, it only got one upvote and one response. I’m disappointed, of course, but more than that, I want to see where I went wrong and wish to improve.

So the story I posted on r/nosleep is my attempt at folk horror; it’s about a guy whose friend went missing after their hike in the mountains and his search for him in the forest, despite his fears and superstitions about the wilderness. I want to know how I can make the next story I write be a lot better. I want to know what I’m doing right, what I’m doing wrong, what I should keep doing, what I should stop doing, and finally, what new things I should start doing.
Thank you in advance!

https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/3IlrZqgtcA

The link above is the story in question


r/writingadvice • • Aug 04 '25

SENSITIVE CONTENT How to write Female Characters?

0 Upvotes

I think I have as a Male (20) a pretty easy time to write Male characters, but I really have a hard time writing female ones. I don't wanna fall into the Trap of making a Male Character with boobs or simply making someone as a sex/romantic Plot device. I really wanna write someone who is believeable. Who feels like real person. It's not like I cant do that, I'm just afraid that its not believeable for a woman. Am I overthinking this and should just write female characters like as I normally do?


r/writingadvice • • Oct 10 '24

SENSITIVE CONTENT What should I use to replace the N-word?

0 Upvotes

I'm working on a memoir and in one of the scenes my racist father is accusing 13 year old me of lying about my whereabouts to go fuck a black boy except he uses the N-word. I'm white, not my place to include that in my writing but I'm stuck on what to say instead. Using *** or --- to bleep it out could be in play but I don't know how that would read and I don't want to accidentally offend someone. What are my options?

Edit: should've phrased it better. I was mainly asking about whether I should censor it or not and what the best way to go about it would be. You guys, I was not looking for a different slur to replace the N-word. I can see how the title could be misleading though.


r/writingadvice • • Nov 18 '24

GRAPHIC CONTENT Writing SA stories without making it smutty: TW! Rape NSFW

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to write a story about a girl who gets raped and then the aftermath and how she recovers, but I'm struggling with how to write certain moments without making it seem like smut. A huge point of the book is that it's NOT a smut book and it's NOT supposed to be something that people find attractive or sexy. The problem is that I want to give enough detail that it gives the full effect of how it effects my character, and I don't want to just skip stuff because. I don't know if the best answer to this question is just to not go into detail but I'm hoping someone can give me some tips.


r/writingadvice • • Dec 06 '25

Discussion The Myth surrounding Good Writing

0 Upvotes

There is no such thing as "Good Writing"

We spend a lot of time obsessing over good prose, but one day when I was Writing About Writing (WAW) it occurred to me that there is no universal good. A good lab report would make a bad romance novel - wrong rules.

Instead of trying to write well, I’ve started focusing on the unique needs and expectations of a given genre. I ask myself: Who is this for? What are the rules of this specific writing? What is the goal of this text?

Since I stopped trying to be universally good and focused instead on art of being rhetorically effective in each given piece, my tonal inconsistencies have basically vanished. I also don’t have to wait for inspiration in a writing task; I just analyze the requirements of the genre.

What rules do you change when shifting gears between genres?


r/writingadvice • • Sep 11 '24

Advice How do you write stupid people and make sure the viewer KNOWS they're stupid?

0 Upvotes

HI there writers! I've been back up and kicking in the writing community once more, and I have a problema. My MC is meant to be a goofball. The type of idiot to think anthropology is the same thing as social studies. My issue, however? I don't know how to write stupid people. All writing reflects the author, and as you can already tell from my complex knowledge of the English lexicon, I'm an absolute genius (sarcasm if you couldn't make mud with my dirt and water.) And I'm not too sure on what traits I can give these characters to resemble their personality and put their academic level into their character. Small info rant: his one relying trait is being funny---like that one guy that's married to Jessica rabbit--- and even then his cartoonish sense of dunce-ness does occasionally fail to be funny. He believes he's a natural leader-(he's not)- but not too egoistic, and over the coarse of the story he does learn responsibility and planning. Thanks for any advice, it means a lot! Edit: Why are people downvoting- its a question..? Edit.2: thank you for the feedback from the people who told me ways I can improve. To the people who took a random sentence and talked about that, thank you for at least trying to make me more educated. To the people who think I'm actually narcissistic, I'm a comedy writer, went to therapy for my narcissism, and try to use it as comedy because me and my friends find it funny. Thanks!


r/writingadvice • • Sep 27 '26

GRAPHIC CONTENT Would foul language and discussion of suicide, self harm, and SA make my book unpublishable? NSFW

0 Upvotes

So I would like to clearly state that I am nowhere near getting a publishable story, nor am I crazy good at writing. However, I'd like to know for future reference. My current novel has an abusive dad that says things like "that fucking snowflake ass bitch" and the like, it has a suicide and a self harm scene, and it also includes that the dad tried to SA one of the characters, though doesn't describe it in detail. Are any of these grounds for my book being unpublishable? Should I even include these themes in the story, or is that too much? (Fyi, this is supposed to be a tragedy, written mainly for younger adults, like 18-25 year olds range)

Edit: I see that a lot of you are calling me out in the replies. I understand. You guys are completely right about me not reading many books, I'm sorry I didn't get more experience before getting into writing, I really need to. I realize now that this question was kinda dumb, but still, thank you to those who gave feedback.


r/writingadvice • • Aug 14 '26

Advice I have an 18~ year old character, what age should his love interest be to be odd but not too weird?

0 Upvotes

Bear in mind that this is a shitty fanfiction so the stakes are low.

The 18 year old character has been in university for three years (I'm trying to make the 'former child prodigy thing' not too unrealistic so this might get cut to 2 or 1 year), while the older (maybe 25 years old) character is in his first year at university. So they're in the same stage in life, making things a little less weird.

Now, I'm 18 and have never been in a romantic relationship, so I'm not certain how things work. A plot point is that the older character had to delay his high school graduation due to health problems, get a GED pretty late, spent a few years too depressed to function, and then decided to go to college.

With all of these life events and the tone of the story, he should be somewhat older which may cause issues. But I don't want him to look like a predator (it's the younger character who fell in love first, and it took a while for the older one to agree to a relationship).

What's an age where it would be a little awkward, but not super weird?


r/writingadvice • • Nov 28 '24

SENSITIVE CONTENT What would a world where women had power over men be like?

0 Upvotes

Our society is often seen as a patriarchy where men generally have power and privilege over women and people who are non binary. How would a world that is a matriarchy differ than our world and how would things change compared to the way things are in this dimension? Would it be a more peaceful world than ours and how would the men be treated? I bring up this question as I feel I would be happier in a matriarchy over a patriarchy.


r/writingadvice • • Apr 08 '26

GRAPHIC CONTENT Is a protagonist that sold women into sexual slavery a bridge too far?

0 Upvotes

Even if he's being set up for a redemption arc, even if he has a tragic backstory that pushed him into this trade, even if he regrets it and acknowledges that he's a monster, even if he switches sides and rescues a victim....would your reaction be, "nope, can't follow this guy, he's a piece of shit"?

Can such a protagonist be a viewpoint character that the reader can/will follow?

Keep in mind this is an intentionally dark story.


r/writingadvice • • Jul 13 '25

SENSITIVE CONTENT How do fantasy writers write about events not lived through by them?

0 Upvotes

So i'm a multi-times failed young fantasy writer, i just can't write even a chapter because of how weird and limited the writing looks to me, and i haven't even had the courage yet to show it to anyone.

But when it came to writing about personal spirituality or philosophy tho i was writing pages without looking back and erasing too much. I just can't for know write worlds becaude i don't think i have the level to create literal politics in a world and it's DEFINITELY not what i am inclined to write.

How does a writer write something that they haven't personally lived tho? Like how do you even fill the pages of a story about a boy's move or his family not being ok with his religious choices? These are tiny examples just to say that:

  1. i don't think i can write non-experiential related things.

  2. i have no clue about how a writer can usually write about fantasy if they haven't lived the thing or have never had a spiritual experience about it.


r/writingadvice • • Jun 14 '25

GRAPHIC CONTENT Am I doing an inappropriate age gap?

0 Upvotes

(reposting flavored with graphic content since the last time I tried to add it it got removed for it )

I have a couple of characters who are going to be the romantic leads of a story I am writing.

-Carrier Osrun

“She is not just a girl on the road. She is a memory in motion.”

Age Appearance: 21

True Age: Centuries old, though she does not remember it

Osrun was once a creature of sorrow who consumed grief to give others peace. The moment she changed was born of an encounter with a dying child who touched her face and called her kind. She gave up her monstrous form and all of her memories to walk as human, but the gods have not forgotten her. Her past, erased by choice, begins to echo back in dreams and sacred places.

-Seda

“The one who was saved, and built a life on the echo of that moment.”

Age: 28

As a boy, he was saved by Osrun’s monstrous form though he never knew her name. That moment became his lodestar; he’s shaped his entire life around honoring lost things and quiet gods. When he begins to suspect the truth about Osrun, it shakes his spiritual foundation.

His internal conflict: Can he love her for who she is now, or will he always chase the myth of what she was?


r/writingadvice • • Apr 13 '26

GRAPHIC CONTENT Okay, I'm just going to rant since i doubt many people will see this.

0 Upvotes

I'm in the brainstorming phase of writing my novel and I've hit a wall. One could say its an opportunity but i don't know how to make use of it. Originally, I had a why-choose in mind, where the mc was an eldritch concept of death itself and the love interests all immortal. That didn't work out. Then I came upon my current idea which is to get rid of the mc and just have those seven be in a polycule together, ruling a fictional kingdom together. The kingdom is crumbling and with juggling that your telling me their also supposed to yarn for each other? I did do my research in polyamory and have talked to some polyamorous people so its no problem in that respect. I just can't get over the mindset that unless they get married or end up together with each other, its not "serious". Like I even planned some sort of marriage-agreement situation between the seven but then realized not all of them will be dating - so that just makes it confusing as hell to figure out whose dating who and who isn't. They are in a closed polycule and have known each other for a while. There are some themes I'm circling around namely death, cults, grief, and religious ideology. I have this reoccurring bit about how gods are made in humanities image and not the other way around. And so when humans pray to them, they become mad gods. I also love visual novels - I know very well a novel and visual novel are different. Maybe its childish, but i want to experiment a bit with structure since I'm not selling. I just don't know how the two mediums could ever overlap but it would be fun. Okay, I'm just going to rant since i doubt many people will see this. 


r/writingadvice • • Oct 28 '24

GRAPHIC CONTENT Does this truly count as using AI?

5 Upvotes

Ok I have heard a lot about AI being crackdown on in the use of writing, but I'm not sure how I use it counts or not so need some outside advice. I find for myself the hardest part of writing is the beginning. I will plan everything out. My characters ans scene and what I want to happen and the general order. Then I will get ready to write but end up staring at a blank screen for an hour. So I use AI by putting in the general outline of my story and then using the page it writes to form my own start. I never actually use what it writes but it gives me ideas. Like the story I am currently starting has magic mutating animals in the modern world. I was thinking of mutated bears and wolves and such. But using what it wrote I am starting with dogs and cats and him stumbling on an attack instead of being attacked himself. But the scene I wrote has nothing in common, except for me using dogs and cats, to the AI generated page. would it still count as using AI even though its more generating a prompt for me then actually helping me write?


r/writingadvice • • Apr 01 '25

SENSITIVE CONTENT Don’t want to be disrespectful

0 Upvotes

Would it be disrespectful for myself, a straight cisgender person to include characters that identify as gay or non-binary? I recognize that I myself do not have lived experience and therefore might not be able to accurately capture romantic relationships with these characters, and I would rather omit them completely, than portray them in an incorrect way, on accident. Thoughts?


r/writingadvice • • Jan 12 '25

GRAPHIC CONTENT Writing a book about Greek mythology and unsure how to make it clear I don't approve of incest. NSFW

0 Upvotes

So this will be my first book and it's about Kronos rising up and becoming the king of the titans and his downfall from the "underdog hero" trope.

I learned very fast from writing test scenes in my notebook that I get very uncomfortable writing his relationship with his future wife, Rhea.

This is because Kronos and Rhea (his future wife) are siblings. Now I knew this of course but I'm worried that when releasing this it'll come off like I myself support incest (which I don't btw).

There's no sex scenes or anything of the sort so it's pg when it comes to their scenes and I do plan to use the Rick Riordan explanation that says "Gods don't have DNA so it's not AS bad" but still.

I don't want to change Rhea's parentage because I want to remain as accurate as I can to the source material as possible (as close as you can with mythology).

Any advice where I can make it clear I don't support incest?


r/writingadvice • • Mar 03 '25

Advice What happens when someone who is malnourished eats too much?

1 Upvotes

I'm writing a story in my free time to beat writers block, and I'm writing about a child who is homeless and gets a lumpsome of money, so the first thing she does is go get food. When someone is in that condition, what is the reaction of the body when that happens? How do I describe it?


r/writingadvice • • May 09 '25

SENSITIVE CONTENT Can I write bible inspired angels without offending Christian/catholics ?

3 Upvotes

Im writing a story that involved a mix of biblical angels, demons, humans, and some other fantasy creatures inspired by other mythological pantheons all in one word. I’m not religious but I’m worried about my inclusion of a reimagined heaven would cause some controversy to those who does follow that religion. The angels are a big part of the story and I wanted to include them because they don’t get explored as much in media and it’ll be an interesting perspective to focus on them as their own species rather than an extension of god as they’re often described in biblical text. (I tried to post this earlier but mods flagged it cause i didn’t tagged the post as “sensitive content”)


r/writingadvice • • Aug 18 '24

SENSITIVE CONTENT How do you write a trans character who doesn't have body dysphoria?

10 Upvotes

Basically I want to write a story about a man whose AGAB was woman, but the actual thing that bothers him isn't his body, but people getting it wrong? Obviously I'm not posting this anywhere, but I still don't want to write it in a way that comes across as insensitive to Trans people. Whilst I AM AWARE that Trans people can realise their gender identity without dysphoria, I would like advice on how to write it. (For reference, the character is the reincarnation of a male character in a womans body, he doesnt really remember it, but thats why being a man feels right to him.)