r/write • • Mar 18 '19

⬇️

Post image
1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

4

u/desquire General Fiction Mar 18 '19

wut.

1

u/honeicutt Mar 18 '19

Do you like this poem?

2

u/desquire General Fiction Mar 21 '19

As an exercise in alliteration and phonetic flow, it's a good start.

Though, beyond that, I struggle to grasp what exactly the poem is about. The word repetition seems to be an effort towards percussive emphasis, but it ends up just being more confusing then not, because I'm lost on what you are trying to emphasize in the first place.

Also, somebody else posted that more rhyming may help, but I'd also like to point out that forcing rhymes can detract further from the clarity of what you're trying to communicate. For example, your first stanza, you make a decent indirect rhyme with shirt and smirk. The problem, though, is the second half of the rhyme seems forced to match up with the syllable count of the first half.

Appear grin grin alright for others a smirk

What are you trying to tell me with this? Something about the embarrassment of being in public with a tear-marked shirt? That you don't care about the other peoples perception, hence the, "grin grin"? Is it sadness? Apathy? Both? Neither?

Rhyming is a great tool to connect segments of a stanza separated from each other by creating a common denominator. But connection of the first half of this rhyme and the second is muddled and confusing. As a reader, I'm lost.

What are you trying to tell me? Start with that, then introduce the rhyme, if you can. If you cannot, that's OK. Rhyming is only as valuable as it can contribute clarity and weight to the emotion or principle you are trying to convey.

It's a great start, and keep practicing. In editing, try taking the Hemingway approach to literal purging. If a word doesn't serve a purpose, you don't need that word. If a literary tool or methodology doesn't contribute to the clarity and meaning of what you are trying to illustrate, don't use it.

Great writing starts with the basics. Remember, the point of writing is to communicate anything with somebody not you. Poetry is both the message and the context, and if it's missing either, it isn't finished.

2

u/MonikaTheBitch Mar 19 '19

I think you could defiantly have a future with writing, though at the moment you seem to be lacking many things needed for poems.

Firstly, it's difficult to pin point the subject of your writing. This is one of the most crucial things when writing. If your reader can't clearly define what the piece is about it will be considerably less enjoyable. Try picking a topic that you know a lot about, and write a short poem about whatever that topic is. Make sure the topic is clear in the poem, and repeat until you have it down.

Secondly, the repeating words. Repeating words can work beautifully in some poems, but the way you are using them is out of pace, and feels unnatural when reading. To improve this look up poems that constantly use repeating words, and figure out how and why they work in the poem. By doing this it should help you use them more fluidly in your writing.

Lastly, I fell as though this poem would be a thousand times better if some words rhymed. With the way you've laid it out, and just the flow overall, would work fantastically with a few rhymes here and there. This is only a suggestion, but try creating poems that rhyme! Of course, not all poems have to rhyme, but your writing style may go well with rhyming.

This was all just a few tips, so I apologize if you take offense. Keep up the great work, as I can see you going places if you practice your skill!

2

u/FlourishedCass Mar 19 '19

Well you've definitely improved since last month with the sex poem

2

u/davelabyrinth Apr 02 '19

I really like it :)