TL;DR I am no longer working on a classless server project I have been on for the last 2+ years. I share a brief history of how it got started, share some ideas I wanted to put in but never got to, and a closing thought.
Hey there,
I started helping on a project called Frostforged about 2 years ago. It wasn't my project at the start; my friend from Ascension (while it lived) quit that server and wanted to make his own classless project. It was different from Ascension for sure, being free pick with none of the limits on what abilities you could or couldn't choose, but it did lack a lot of the options Ascension brought in (such as Demonic Leap, as well as many custom spells).
It was the first time I had ever done any kind of project, let alone any kind of development on a game. It was exciting! He and I were on every day, pushing new features (my partner made an instanced housing feature before Blizzard had launched the official version, rudimentary features notwithstanding). I worked on items, learned MPQs, DBCs, and SQL. I found item sets that were incomplete or not added and added them in. It was eye opening to see how much Blizzard left on the table for 3.3.5, but it was very exciting to bring them out of the folders and into the players' hands. I even came up with a custom Sheet tool that let me filter items to find what existed in the DBCs and what I needed to add. I even developed a workbench to quickly convert items into new colored versions to add into the game (beyond simple HSV alterations).
But, alas, all was not well in the world. In spite of a strong following from a handful of players, my partner had his own woes in life, and lost his passion for the project. I had always wanted to build my own game, even an MMO, so this was the first time I came close to doing something along those lines. I stay dedicated, but without the ability to pay for the VM and server, it eventually went offline. I continued adding new content with my local files, and kept in touch with my partner to try to add things in. But the writing was on the wall.
I eventually downloaded AzerothCore on my own and restarted the project. Not a month later, and my partner came back. Things were looking up again, and I resumed the previous project, but it never had the same energy. Over the course of this year, it slowly dwindled back down to dead, and eventually the burnout of working alone caught ahold of me too. We both ended up trying out a new server, but left that. He went on to yet another server as a player, but I never could get the itch to build out of me. I went back to Frostforged, alone, but not forgotten by a few of the fans.
With the announcement of the decompiled 3.3.5 client, I had hoped to get my hands on it and start customization, but I became involved with another personal project. Now, my passion for server work is gone, yet I still want to build something. So I'm going to build something, but that's not the point of this post.
I wanted to share some ideas, because I had always envisioned making heavy changes through the flexibility of AzerothCore, and the newly decompiled client, but since I am moving on the best thing I can do is just... talk about the ideas. Ideas are only ever ideas until implemented, but I wanted to test things and see how players would take to them. I write this post as a sort of closure to Frostforged, something that meant much to me, but I won't return to.
Initially, Frostforged was a freepick classless server with crossfaction having been enabled, along with the ability to choose talents freely (no trees, no prerequisites). Alongside custom items, a housing system (again, rudimentary but functional), and some custom world bosses and quests. It had the start of a new story, where players faced consequences with the timeline for being involved in Mt. Hyjal, but it never fully developed. The rest was up to us.
Ideas I had, but never got to making:
A level 255 server; regular xp rates, items that scaled with level by giving % stats, flat stats came from the level itself. My idea was to have higher growth be rewarding, and remove level requirements from most content so players could roam and try things out.
Build tied to items; Ascension is the best example of classless I can compare to, and you chose your build based on the REs, the modified glyph system. I wanted to try something where you chose armor sets that had set bonuses that combined 2 spells from 2 classes, and gave a different interaction. I have a google doc with some initial ideas written down, but never was able to finish it and do everything else.
Engraving system; a custom system that allows the player to add set bonuses to an item. Did you like having the 4p bonus from a certain set? Engrave it! Now you have 2 set bonuses. I will never know how broken it could have been, but I'm sure it would have been great (and a nightmare to balance!)
Competitor vs Specialist; the last thing going along with items and spell choice: if you as a player liked a more traditional approach to a class, be a Specialist. The idea of the Specialist sets were that you would play like a single class with modified spells from that class to use in your rotation. More docs have some of my notes on it. Competitor was the hybrid class mashup.
Weapon choice matters; I could never figure out this one, but my initial thought was that weapon choice should be more meaningful than a stat stick. I also have a doc with my notes on where to take it, but it mostly revolved around gaining certain stats or bonuses based on position + weapon type. Daggers would deal more damage from behind, Fist Weapons gave you damage reduction when face to face with a target. It's something I still want to solve one day.
Action style combat; a larger change I dreamt of implementing, something kind of like Kingdom Hearts x Monster Hunter x World of Warcraft. It was a system that needed to be implemented and tested to really know how well it would work within the parameters of WoW 3.3.5, so it will live on in the hypothetical until some future date.
Revamped professions; new crafting materials, lots of cross-profession crafting, and I even toyed with the idea of raids and dungeons dropping materials instead of loot. Craft the gear you want, farm the materials instead. No more rng, nor weekly grinds to be disappointed. It just meant that it was a matter of time instead of a matter of luck. All materials and gear would be BoE. I would have loved to have seen this one tested.
In addition, permanent buffs to the player for making grueling crafts. One idea I pitched at my partner was a health potion that required every other health potion to make that permanently boosted your hp.
4 raid difficulties, new bosses and mechanics and raids, world bosses galore, and the new storyline to tie it all off; I wanted to play off the idea my partner started with an alternate timeline. The idea was that the scourge won, and we had to fight to claim Azeroth back. Later, I changed some notes to say that the Lich King wasn't Arthas, who had died to Sylvannas' ambush in WCIII, but was the stillborn daughter of he and Jaina (I have to say it for the lore nerds, none of this actually happened, this is still the hypothetical). Kael'thas and Jaina end up together, she's the last boss of TK. Kael is there at SWP, KJ is somewhere else, crazy stuff. More ambitious than I could ever manage alone. Stormwind is a raid, you have to take it back from the Defias. Orgrimmar is overtaken by the cultists. Etc., etc., etc.,
There's likely a few more ideas I had, but this is pretty much all the main things I wanted to try. I was determined to keep going at first, but as time went on, I realized that the truth was that I wanted to make my own game. A lot of these are cool concepts, and I wanted to use 3.3.5 and this community as a way to test things to eventually make my own IP, something safe from Blizzard and their relentless C&D/lawsuit wave. I think the nail in the coffin was losing my partner. It's hard to develop alone. I acknowledge scope probably played a big part in how unfinished this was, but scope definitely didn't kill this. I just... am moving on to do this a different way, in a space where it can truly be my own.
Regarding private servers, I think this is an incredibly innovative and fun community. It's not perfect, it definitely has its own troubles with legality here and there (rip TWOW, Ascension, Epoch, and more), but it has opened my eyes and taught me things I only ever dreamt of doing my whole life. I am grateful to my partner for helping me start out and try new things. I learned a lot about myself, learned about how I learn best, and learned what I really want to do in life.
I am sorry to the very few Frostforged fans that we could never make it work in the end, and sorry to the several individuals that somehow trickled into our server in hopes of a different classless experience. However, I am very grateful for your support and love for the project.
I write this in hopes of getting some sense of closure to a project I dumped hundreds of hours of personal time into, as well as hundreds of dollars in helping the server stay up and developing some tools. Obviously I didn't have to, but it meant something to me then, and my point is that it will always mean something to me.
I probably won't be doing any Q&A, it's really hard to see what impact the system changes I wanted to implement would have without being able to test it. If you are doing a project and want to use any of these ideas, I say go for it! If you've read this far, thank you for your time.