r/wmnf • u/redfalresearch • Aug 14 '22
Unpopular Opinion: Presidential Traverse Overrated!
Just did it. The Madison to Washington section shouldn't be called a trail. Just epically brutal rock scrambling and unfun. Dangerous if you get weather.
Views were amazing when I was out of clouds of course. I just think the traverse is over-marketed -- with many of the ultra runners and extreme hikers doing it in a day and saying "oh it's easy!" It's one of the hardest trails out there!
This is getting people into trouble on a route that is very hard to bail out on. The 6 mile rock hop to Washington is a knee and ankle killer. I'm sure many newbies sign up for this route and are turned off from hiking forever.
Very cool ridge, but I don't look forward to hiking it again.
**Edit: I totally get that the sufferfest is the fun of it for some people. But it is not advertised as a top hike for being a sufferfest (not just a hard effort, which is great! I'll take the vert and distance - but just miserable scrambling over sharp boulders sucks.) Again, this is just my unpopular opinion. In general I think the East Coasters have got Stockholm syndrome and don't know what good looks like. Like how everyone thinks US is amazing but you go to Europe and there is actual public transportation, free healthcare, cheap college, etc.
***Edit 2: The comments below have clarified the root of my dissatisfaction. Obviously this hike should be a challenge given the distance, elevation, and weather. But we New Englanders seem to be too willfully prideful, stubborn or lazy to actually create a proper trail on what should be the absolute jewel of the Appalachian Trail. Other places make proper trails with 8% grades, significant work to smooth or route around obstacles, etc. We choose to ignore what good trail design could be out of a (I believe) misplaced sense of history and stubbornness and are left with something that is much less pleasant than it could be.