r/wma • • Jun 09 '25

Epees are martially valid. Fight me.

6 Upvotes

Stiffen the blade, sharpen the tip, and what you have is an objectively better smallsword. In fact, from my understanding (I admit I could be wrong here, but still fairly sure this is accurate), the Epee evolved from the smallsword as a weapon specialized into dueling, whereas smallswords sacrificed effectiveness for comfort when worn in a scabard.

You wouldn't be able to do flicks, of course. But flicks are a pretty minor part of Epee fencing. The only ones that are actually good and not just a meme to do when goofing off are to the hand, and those can more or less just be replaced with regular hand snipes with no major changes to the fencer's style. A flick basically sacrifices some range to make it harder to parry relative to regular hand snipes, but its not that big of a difference, and in most tactical aspects they are more or less interchangeable.

Pistol grips may look wacky to HEMA fencers, but in a practical sense they are the final form of a finger ring. The whole idea of a finger ring is to make the sword more aligned with the arm to increase point control. A pistol grip takes this to the extreme, turning the sword essentially to an oversized push dagger and making the sword align perfectly with the arm for even better point control. Conventional static parries against cuts are a little more awkward due to the way you need to angle your hand, particularly cuts to your non-dominant side, but still doable. But why the hell are you parrying a cut with a static parry when you could do a lock out thrust? And against thrusts, you get so many new kinds of parries that aren't just either push their blade to the left or to the right. Pistol grips also allow you to threaten your opponent's hand from more angles by allowing you to angle the blade around the opponent's guard in various different ways. Also, if you get into grappling, it is easier to get your point in line with a pistol grip than conventional historical grips because of the way you can shift it in your hand.

I unironically believe that, if you were in a duel to the death, a sharp, stiff epee would serve you very well. I fenced people in HEMA with an Epee in my club before, and they absolutely shut down sabers, and go fairly even against rapiers. They do get hard countered by anything two handed, though, as the extra levarage kinda means you can't ever do anything from the bind.

If you were curious to see what a duel to the death with Epees would look like, just go watch Epee bouts in the Olympics. There would only be three differences. Firstly, flicks aren't a thing, but read above. Some of the lighter hits would be insuficient, but at least in my experience, most hits you get would still be valid in, say, HEMA smallsword. And leg hits would be kinda ass. This one is unironically the biggest difference. And while leg hits are very powerfull in Epee, there are still many incredibly good fencers that never do them, with many first to fiften bouts never seeing a single leg hit.


r/wma • • Aug 18 '25

Longsword Where did the "telephone" style vom tag come from?

0 Upvotes

I recently learned something that turned my world upside down: this position is nowhere in any of our historical sources. Specifically, a guard where the crossguard is between your shoulder and ear, with the point up and slightly back, and the edge facing your opponent. Despite being common in HEMA nowadays, there seems to be no source that ever depicts a guard held quite like this. Historically, vom tag is almost always shown one of two ways: held high above your head, or with the flat of the blade resting on your shoulder. I'm not an expert, but a brief look says this isn't even a guard from Fiore that got cross-pollinated or something like that.

I'm aware that you need to take art from this period with a hefty grain of salt, but the consistent lack of depiction suggests this position is unusual and, likely, ahistorical. So where did it actually come from? Is it an artifact of early HEMA that's carried over? And has anybody here played with different vom tag positions and found a significant difference in their fencing?


r/wma • • Jan 27 '25

Longsword The Art of The Modern Longsword

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/wma • • Sep 29 '21

In light of recent events, reposting Guy Windsor's post about naming his book after Historical Martial Arts rather than HEMA

Thumbnail
guywindsor.net
1 Upvotes

r/wma • • Apr 15 '19

[META] Can we please move the memes somewhere else?

0 Upvotes

Many subs do this. Funny skeleton pictures are definitely a thing people might like to look at, but perhaps this is not the place.


r/wma • • Nov 09 '23

As a Beginner... is HEMA or idk what it's called...good for self defense?

0 Upvotes

so.....as u may have noticed i'm a beginner, and i don't know much about weapon martial arts, and i don't just want to hit with my hands/elbow/knees, but i want to try like daggers, bows, and of course THE CLAYMORE, and i want to ask.....is it good for self defense or rather if i went to the wild and i just had weapons.....would i be effectif?


r/wma • • Dec 21 '25

Surprised by lack of grappling in the practice of Western Martial Arts

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/wma • • Dec 04 '24

is it too late to start fencing?

Post image
0 Upvotes

this was my original post but i was redirected here when i said that i would like to try hema (double edged sword are so cool)


r/wma • • Jul 12 '25

HEMA has right of way and it's based

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/wma • • Nov 13 '23

The most accurate safe simulator is... the modern epee.

0 Upvotes

There's a multitude of factors that lead to what constitutes a quality training weapon. Commonly people, especially people very invested in the martial art concept and who believe the best training is the most accurate simulation of a real fight, want the most accurate sparring safe replica possible, and the qualities relevant to that essentially come down to weight (and by extension the factors influenced but not defined by simple weight like point of balance) and the interactions the simulator has with another simulator (such as in regard to issues like blunt swords not being able to replicate the supposed "bite" that the edges of sharps can, among others). The epee, specifically with the historically accurate grips (I actually think this is still mostly true of the pistol grip in a weird way but that's a whole other topic) has the best combination of these. My point in this is to essentially demonstrate that the pontification about super accurate simulators is silly and while its nice to be close, historical training tools were varied and people who used them did fine, and we will too.

So regarding weight, its important to note that even historical training methods often dont reflect full weight training swords. Some do, such as British gymn sabres and rapier foils which were roughly in the ballpark of the weight of a rapier, but the British gymn sabre is arguably the exception to the rule when much of evidence for sabre fencing the content in the era where we have a great deal of sabre sources (the 18th and particularly 19th century) use sabres far lighter than service swords. Radaellian sabre is often credited to have been the main influence of this, but even before Radaellians like Barbasetti started influencing other cultures, most of them were using fencing sabres lighter than the 850g british stuff. A lot of continental training sabres would not pass anglophone HEMA weight requirements. And despite what many might argue, these practice weapons were used and promoted by military men for military service. They allowed, and still allow, a lot of safe fencing at intensity, and anecdotally arent less accurate than heavy gymn sabres by most of the people I know I know whove used varying weight training sabres and also handled sharps. Even broadsword and backword were trained with single sticks, which are certainly lighter than many broadswords at least. I just wanted to note this before I go on to say:

Epees weigh the same as epees de combat. Like exact, the rough range is the same. If anything the upper limit of a modern epee of 770g is excessive (though you'll find most of the heavier epees end up around 550-600). feders will rarely weigh the same as the heaviest longswords, true weight cavalry sabres are unsafe to spar at intensity, if we are being honest rapier trainers used competitively are predominantly on the lighter end, with the heavier side of the spectrum near unviable and very hard to make truly safe to fence with competitively. All the polearms and greatswords are of course pretty inherently unsafe to train at full weight by modern standards, or without modifications like telescopic retraction for spears or bayonets that certainly make them less accurate simulators (and even these had sparring safety concerns historically). Smallsword trainers, both foils and the foil-with-an-epee-blade design, are of course fairly accurate to weight, but keep in mind foils still tend toward the lighter side.

Now of course many will point out that weight is not the sole, arguably not the primary factor in handling. this is correct. However, it is a factor that inherently limits the movement of the hand/s to varying degrees, but significantly enough that it is noticeable. Thrust from a point forward guard with a 700g sabre or a 1.2kg one, you will feel a disctinct difference, and thats one of the least weight affected movements (try parrying into quarte and then to tierce if u really wanna feel the difference). All that said this is actually where the epee really shines. Unlike many of the other samples you can, and usually will have a safe epee that is accurate in weight, point of balance, centre of percussion and all other factors to an actual epees de combat. All but the lightest HEMA weapons will simply struggle to have this.

Now if we look into blade interactions, it becomes very clear that the epee is king by really any possible metric. Its blade is an accurate triangular epee blade with fuller, of the right length. It will engage other epee blades pretty much exactly as sharp epees did. the only issues are the flex, which is present in all training safe weapons and isnt even ahistorical if we consider the practice of literally sharpening practice epees, and the tip on the end adding some extra weight which by all accounts Ive heard does change the nimbleness of a sword a bit a bit but again, universal for fencing safe swords. Compare this to cutting weapons. If you believe in the "bite" of cutting edge on cutting edge (Ive heard mixed opinions on this), this is an issue epees simply cannot have. But fundamentally, only thrusting weapon simulators can have the exact correct blade geometry minus the tip. this is also something that inherently effects issues like CoP, because the mass distribution is harder to make more or less the same. However, even with thrusting weapons, many both historically and now today (modern foils) have square blades. I believe there are some variations of rapier that had something like this, but they are the exception rather than the rule. That means that no matter how small there is an inherent difference in blade interaction. Finally, this leaves the smallsword practice weapons that arent foils. The ones that arent literally french or italian grip modern fencing pieces with a foil guard and epee blade (which are kind of also just early epees unless they are very short) are probably the only ones in the running to compete with the epee, and even in that case they are slightly more affected by the tip and its mass changing the mobility than the longer epee.

So what can we learn from this? Firstly, the car antenna meme was always dumb. Secondly, epees are cool and accurate to a weapon used in one of the peaks of French duelling culture (the late 19th century) and based (even the pistol grip is a historical training and fencing tool nearly 3 decades older than sliced bread), and thirdly, and most importantly the people who trained with all these weapons did fine with imperfect simulators and we will too.


r/wma • • May 04 '17

Lightsaber combat gaining mainstream traction and recognition as a weapon based sport

Thumbnail
nerdist.com
0 Upvotes

r/wma • • Feb 25 '24

A Fiction Author Wonders... How much of an advantage is super speed in a duel?

0 Upvotes

This has been a personal wonder of mine for a while. I haven't ever practiced HEMA with other people, but I have studied some of it here and there. I also read a lot of superhero stuff, and it always seemed to be that super speed is way weaker than it should be in its portrayal in fiction.

Ok, so you're probably wondering what I mean by super speed. Think of it like this, if you have 2x super speed, everything but yourself is moving twice as slow. Including your opponent! Let's ignore stuff such as the extra forces imposed on your own body. Your super speed power also grants you enough friction so you wouldn't just slide everywhere, making it very easy to make tight turns while traveling fast.

So, how deadly is this in an actual duel? At what point does it grant a clear advantage? At 1.25x-1.50x Super Speed? What level of Super Speed does a HEMA novice defeat a HEMA master at? 3x? I am very interested to hear everyones opinions.


r/wma • • May 21 '24

As a Beginner... A bit scared to get into HEMA because of a...certain YouTuber...

257 Upvotes

So, not gonna name names but a while back one of the biggest hema YouTubers and the one that introduced me to the concept was revealed to be a massive incel, bigot, dumbass and generally terrible person when he stopped making martial arts content to focus on his right wing podcast where he just complains about movies he hasn't watched. Among other things such as his really gross power fantasy book, sexist undertones in his videos and suspected child abuse have me feel kinda bad for liking hema and very distrustful of any and all martial instructors. Is this normal in the community or am I just paranoid because of one bad egg?


r/wma • • Mar 13 '25

As a Beginner... HEMA outside of Europe?

1 Upvotes

I’ve done some research into HEMA and the format is appealing but not the sources. I have very little interest in learning to fight in the European styles, my interest is in Umayyad or Abbasid era styles of combat. Is there a martial arts organization for MENA historical martial arts akin to HEMA? Where could I look for these groups?


r/wma • • Jan 15 '24

If you do HEMA learn foil! basics of European martial art- Uncomfortable truth for historical fencer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Spoiler allert; if you are a longsworder and got offended you probably did not watch the video 🙃


r/wma • • Mar 03 '25

Realistically how would you defend against a guy whos doing backflips and acrobatic stuff with a sword

3 Upvotes

Like ive seen those videos with some guy whos doing backflips and cartwheels really fast at someone with a sword and how do you defend yourself against that


r/wma • • Sep 17 '18

Antique replica i found what do you think? (New to HEMA and beginning blade collector)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/wma • • Aug 06 '20

To those who say: "Always put some gear on!": Shut up

5 Upvotes

I see this thing constantly these days and it is starting to become obnoxious.

Yes, safety is paramount when doing HEMA and if you see someone post something that is blatantly unsafe, make a note of it. That's important, as such a public forum is often visited by newbies and people just starting their own groups, who may not know any better.

However, there are thousands of HEMAists around the world that regularly practice with light or no gear without any injuries.

There are plenty of top-level fencers, well-known and respected instructors, who demonstrate or drill without gear or with light gear all the time.

I know that many of you are Americans, and your health and insurance systems make such practices ill-advised or impossible. I am sorry for your situation, but for most of us such issues don't exist. We have free healthcare, and no one requires special insurance for such activities. In fact, in some countries, such insurance is impossible to get for what is a fringe amateur sport.

You can spar and drill with light gear, or no gear, and remain safe. Such practice has its artefacts, like any other, and if that is the only way you practice, you will develop bad habits, and you won't interpret the sources well or have any functional martial arts system. But as an additional mode of practice, it has many benefits, which is again the reason why a ton of top-level fencers and instructors do that.

Those of you who scream "PUT GEAR ON" without any respect towards context, intensity and goals of the fencers involved should shut up. If you are unsure of those, ask respectfully, don't jump on people.

Here are some examples of sparring and drilling from my school:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYU6KUHXLUI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QLlCuNOh8s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltt-NAQ3qiQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCj6Yvh6lCk

"Motus" has been around for 17 years and in that time we haven't had a single injury while doing drills and sparring without masks and/or without jackets, and with light gloves. All (of the few) injuries we've had were with full gear, and usually when people increase the intensity to a dangerous level due to inexperience. This has been achieved with a very well-defined safety protocol and training control. Anyone can do this. Of course, some of the videos above show people with decades of combined experience and a level of control you won't have after, say, a year of practice.

TL;DR: Stop screaming at people for not wearing enough gear for your comfort. They don't have to provide you comfort, and training with limited gear or none at all can be perfectly safe.


r/wma • • Mar 28 '23

Sporty Time The effects on emphasis of rules on fencing, or how I learned to stop caring and love the double

1 Upvotes

Ive had some thoughts on the inherent nothingness of this rules discussion that commonly comes up regarding doubles and I'm going to first start off with a few examples and then go into how I don't think obsessive tweaking with doubling rules makes all that much sense. The reason I think its important to look at this is so much myth has been built up around what the effects of rules are, and I think people like Mr Easton have popularised ideas of seemingly simple obvious effects rules have without much experience playing under them or writing rules, when their effects are in reality deeper. A lot of it is similar to how World Rugby, in an effort to make phase play attacking rugby easier and cut down on kicking, clamped down on contesting the ruck but the result ended up being attacking teams couldn't hold on for it as long without getting penalised and so started kicking shit ball away more. So without further ado heres my exploration of the concept:

So I was rewatching the matt easton sport fencing series of vids for a laugh and one thing that stuck out to me was how he seemed to think right of way was a better deterrent to double hits and afterblows than the epee short lockout time. This could make some level of sense re: old right of way from the 70s or earlier, but current foil and sabre have way more double hits (even if we aren't defining them by the lights but by the blade physically hitting the opposition within say 1 second) than epee. hell early to mid 2010s foil heavily rewarded being hit so then you could finish your action afterwards as the attacker without having to worry about being parried. This demonstrated, I think, a fundamental misunderstanding of systems he isn't really familiar with.

The second thing I think is misunderstanding what doubles in epee actually do. This idea of epee "rewarding" doubles to both fencers except in the most literal sense of awarding a point to each fencer is nonsensical. reward in a competition has to come at a cost to the other fencer, if it maintains the status quo it isnt reward. Now obviously in epee this is true, there is a slight reward for the fencer currently in front as it reduces the touches they need to score to get to 5 or 15 while keeping the margin the same. But fundamentally this is true for all doubling/afterblow rules that arent an elimination. Simply not awarding points does almost the same thing in a timed HEMA bout, despite the lack of theoretical gain there's little reason for the leading fencer not to end any pressure with a double if they can reliably time it. Subtracting a point to each fencer again more or less maintains the status quo (though its interesting more on that later). Indeed the only variation of consequences that outright discourages doubles are double elimination for one or multiple double hits, a system that for a dedicated fencing competition or set of rules is usually considered very harsh (not for modern pentathlon though).

The third element is criticising the 0.025 second lockout. Now this ones way more understandable bc it seems it would encourage trying to pull the trigger earlier and back your pace to get that first. And there is a limited amount of this. But in terms of playing for doubles, its the mechanic that makes it bloody hard, and by extension creates a lot of situations where a fencer chooses to parry or otherwise try to secure a single or just not getting hit over a potential double even if they are leading the risk just isn't worth it. The .025 lockout is actually what makes defence worth anything in epee. If you were in the lead and had .5 of a second you'd just be landing out of time counters for days if your own hit never came to fruition.

So all in all lets look at the results. You have, in epee rules, a system that requires you have to hit first at least once more than the opposition (inherently the same as any timed hema bout) and you can't afford to hit late, where doubles are next to meaningless with some niche tactical applications usually towards the end of the bout, and rarely match deciding unless its 14-13, and where its unreliable to either actively look for them or even use them as an insurance policy. As an epeeist who competes for my country I only really have a couple uses for doubles, if I'm ahead in the early or middle to keep momentum on my side and if I'm ahead in the late game to finish the bout. Even then I don't want them, every double I gain I'd've preferred a single. Even at my most incentivised, I want a single and would shrug at a double. Other fencers, especially lanky stophitters will have more stomach for them but fundamentally its still true, every double they've ever had they'd still prefer to be a single. You really aren't "incentivised" to double, you would much rather a single and when you are down you cant afford all too many of them.

Now lets look at some of the primary hema rules regarding what times you have to land afterblows/doubles, and what the consequences are.

Now first I want to sing the praises of the single step rule. Fantastic, gorgeous, if you can get out after scoring a valid hit, or stay in and give them no means of hitting in a footwork tempo that's good fencing and you deserve a single. This is far and away my favourite timing for HEMA afterblows/doubles. I think its a much better alternative to the 1 or 2 second systems I've seen, bc frankly once you've been hit, you have a whole second to score a valid hit, you should be able to finish that in at least a couple weapons. If I'm hit in smallsword, what is stopping me from running the other bloke down? I know for a fact I can cover half a fencing piste in 2 seconds with no starting momentum, HEMA circles are often much smaller. and smallswords are fast enough that you can draw the parry and remise easily so while this wont happen all the time it seems a nightmare to stop. Ive been hit in foil taking two steps after my counterattack landed with a .3 lockout time (less than a 3rd of the 1 second rule), and while while obviously a smallsword is slightly heavier, not so much that this would be difficult. Light cut and thrust swords also seems very exploitable with these approaches, its hard to know as so far I've only trained smallsword but from when I've felt and used them to play around with it seems the case. 2 seconds is frankly ridiculous, 1 is more understandable but again the loose time actually gives the hit fencer recourse to actively look for an afterblow or double with no repercussion.

Now if we were to look at the rules for consequences in HEMA, I've usually seen no hit awarded, subtraction, or elimination. No hit awarded is functionally very similar to epee, especially if the bout is timed. Subtraction is the interesting one, in a timed bout again basically the same, but in one that isn't a leading fencer is losing sight of the goal score by letting them occur, and the losing fencer has to climb more too. The lead stays the same, but its definitely a more unpleasant prospect for both fencers, though arguably it again does create incentive for the losing fencer in particular to secure an afterblow out of time if they're technically within their step/1second or w/e (though very arguably especially in shorter times). Elimination is definitely a deterrent, but its also kind of unhinged. Certainly I think any tournament running this rule without some space allocated for fun sparring for eliminated fencers is doing itself a disservice, especially if this is applied in a preliminary poules system. first offence elimination is particularly harsh, but I think even after multiple infringements its just such a massive penalty for what's almost always a safe accident.

So in HEMA we have a combination of rules that run the gamut from I think very good (single step with no hits awarded in timed bouts or subtraction in untimed bouts), Quite poor (1 or 2 seconds no hit awarded in a timed bout is so open to abuse with lighter swords) to insane (2 seconds and double elimination would be very fun for a silly club comp but who in their right mind would sign up for that as a serious tournament). The best combination of these common HEMA rules are barely, if at all (I think its a matter of taste), better than epee, and what can we learn from this?

I think at the end of the day, so long as doubles are at best "okay", arent so long they can be actively sort after to nullify a score from the opposition, and that their biggest advantage if any is a minimal one for the fencer in the lead who would still very much prefer a single anyway, I say let the boys play.


r/wma • • Nov 30 '24

An Author/Developer with questions... What seemingly inferior sword would, with sufficient skill, make a surprisingly good match-up against a zweihander-style sword?

2 Upvotes

I’m writing a story with an underdog main character who was bullied and ostracised because he did not fit in with the knightly traditions of his culture.

The character finds that he is very skilled in a style of sword fighting that is generally considered to be inferior (maybe even unmanly) by his people, but he proves skilled enough that he can competently counter opponents using the traditional weapon of his people - a large, well-engineered longsword.

In my mind I was thinking it would be a one-handed sword.

I’m aware that comparing wildly different styles of sword is reductive, but would love to hear some experts’ thoughts…


r/wma • • Jan 24 '20

My first post into the community.. So I liked it and hope you You will like.. And wish a beautiful Friday to all community members..

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

r/wma • • Sep 26 '15

Trans*gressions: the struggles and victories of trans athletes

Thumbnail
academieduello.com
0 Upvotes

r/wma • • Aug 19 '19

ARMA guys cutting a deer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/wma • • May 28 '26

I built Hilt, a management platform made specifically for HEMA clubs.

7 Upvotes

Hey r/wma,

After helping run our club for a few years and noting some patterns, I decided to build HILT (hilt.my). It's a management platform made specifically for HEMA clubs. I built it from the ground up around how our clubs actually run. Already had some feedback from local clubs and have greatly improved it since then.

Most clubs I've talked to are running on some unholy combination of a Facebook group, a shared spreadsheet for dues, a Messenger chat for attendance, a Google Doc with the curriculum, and a whiteboard in the training hall for who borrowed which feder. In my experience, it works until it doesn't. And always became a mess to manage

HILT handles all of that in one place: attendance, member dues and finances, equipment loans and maintenance logs, curricula and rank progression, tournament organization, and event scheduling.

Right now it's in open beta, which means two things:

  1. No subscription needed. Bring your whole club over, run your dues through it, track your gear, or whatever you need, really

  2. If you decide to subscribe during the beta, you lock in a permanent discount on your plan for as long as you stay a customer

If you run a club of any size, tradition, or in any country, give it a try at hilt.my. Happy to do a walkthrough call if that's easier, or you can just create an account so you can poke around at your own pace + I created a "demo guild" where you can explore the platform and see how it'd look like when lived in

And if you do find things that could be better or workflows that don't fit how you run your club, I want to hear it. Feedback is always useful 🙏 But the platform stands on its own and I truly believe you'll get real value out of it from day one

Btw I'm curious to hear in the comments: what's the single most annoying admin task in running your club?