r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jan 28 '26

Discussion Should all wild animal suffering be abolished?

3 Upvotes

Because of nature they are born into extreme suffering in the wild non-consensually. Shouldn’t we end this cruel system of throwing innocent lives into the most extreme conditions where 99.9% die during childhood according to global stats if you include R species.


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Feb 19 '20

Insight Most people don't like to believe we have an intended purpose, but I think there's a reasonable chance our purpose is to end pain & suffering on this planet, but we've lost our way terribly

6 Upvotes

I think there's a reasonable chance that we were deliberately given extraordinary mental & physical capabilities coupled with a strong ability to empathize.

We may very well be the intended stewards of this planet but, as Graham Hancock puts it, we're a species with amnesia; we no longer remember our purpose or what gives us our greatest sense of accomplishment.

It seems a small percentage of sociopaths, and their grip on our societies & institutions, is the only thing keeping us from being this planet's stewards; its guardians against pain & suffering.

If we could, perhaps through genetic engineering, prevent any more sociopaths from being born, maybe we could get back on track and use our ever-advancing abilities to do enormous good for the inhabitants of this planet.


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jul 11 '20

Question Should we kill predators to preserve their prey?

7 Upvotes

One of the predominant causes of suffering to wild animals is predation. Most animals are killed in brutal and painful ways. As a result of this, would it be truly the most ethical thing to painlessly kill animals that are highly likely to cause more suffering to others?

I'm very interested to hear your thoughts on this.


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Feb 09 '21

Video How a Vegan World Might Contain MORE Suffering

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Dec 20 '21

Question Which game animals are the cruelest to other beings?

0 Upvotes

Im trying to figure out what kinds of hunting are most ethical


r/wildanimalsuffering • • May 07 '22

Article I asked GPT3 to write "An article on the most effective strategies for addressing wild animal suffering from the perspective of an effective altruist". These are the results:

8 Upvotes

From an effective altruist perspective, the most important thing we can do to address wild animal suffering is to focus on interventions that are most likely to improve the lives of animals in the wild. This means identifying which animals are most in need of help, and then working out which interventions are most effective at helping them.

There are a number of factors to consider when identifying which animals are most in need of help. First, we need to consider how many animals are affected by a given problem. For example, if a disease is decimating a population of wild animals, then it is likely to have a much bigger impact than if it only affects a small number of individual animals.

Second, we need to consider the severity of the suffering involved. A disease that causes animals to slowly and painfully starve to death is likely to cause more suffering than a disease that causes animals to die quickly and without pain.

Third, we need to consider how long the suffering is likely to last. A disease that kills animals within a few days is likely to cause less suffering than a disease that causes animals to suffer for months or years before finally dying.

Fourth, we need to consider how likely it is that the suffering can be alleviated. If there is no effective way to treat a disease, then it is much less important to focus on than a disease that can be easily treated.

Finally, we need to consider how much we can realistically expect to achieve. It is important to be realistic about what we can achieve, and to focus our efforts on interventions that are most likely to be successful.

With all of these factors in mind, we can start to identify which interventions are most likely to be effective at alleviating wild animal suffering.

One obvious intervention is to try to prevent diseases from spreading in the first place. This can be done by vaccinating wild animals against diseases, or by culling diseased animals before they have a chance to infect others.

Another intervention is to provide food for animals who are struggling to find enough to eat. This can be done by feeding wild animals, or by planting food crops that animals can eat.

A third intervention is to provide shelter for animals who are suffering from exposure to the elements. This can be done by building shelters for animals, or by creating artificial environments that are more hospitable for them.

Each of these interventions has the potential to make a real difference to the lives of animals in the wild, and so they are all worth considering. However, it is important to remember that we must be realistic about what we can achieve, and to focus our efforts on the interventions that are most likely to be successful.


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Mar 05 '23

Insight On the predation problem and the 'benefits' of predators

5 Upvotes

Who controls the predators ... a version of Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

People argue that predators are beneficial because they control prey populations. Without predators, prey populations will reproduce too much, beyond the carrying capacity of the ecosystem, thereby decreasing populations of other species. And concerning animal welfare: without predators, prey will overpopulate the ecosystem and eventually will starve to death due to lack of food.

But these arguments apply also to predator populations. If there is no predator species controlling a predator population, the uncontrolled predator population will also grow beyond the carrying capacity. There are not enough prey, so many predators will starve to death. We need a predator species to control a predator population. But than that higher level predator also has to be controlled by another predator species, and so on to infinity. We need a food chain of infinite length: predators who eat predators who eat predators… Every level has to be controlled by a higher level. If you believe that a finite food chain is optimal for ecosystem health, that there is a level in the food chain that does not have to be controlled by predation, there is no reason why the length of the food chain should be say four instead of two trophic levels. An ecosystem with two trophic levels consists of plants and plant-eaters (herbivore animals), without predators.

Source

Blatant contradictions in the argument that predation benefits ecosystems - Stijn Bruers


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jan 25 '18

So I brought up wild animal suffering with /r/vegan and /r/veganarchism.

5 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jul 31 '21

Question Does veganism help or harm overall net animal suffering?

5 Upvotes

the argument that veganism would allow large amounts of rewilding and massive increase in wildlife if most people were vegan, and thus arguably introducing more animal suffering than current by introducting even more animals suffering in the wild than in factory farms? So lets say if most people being vegan caused such an increase in wildlife, that more animals were being born and killed in the wild than in present day factory farms, would that actually be less suffering? And then for extinctionist vegan antinatalists it poses the question, obviously consuming animal products is not an ideal choice.

But how to be vegan whilst opposing rewilding from the consequence of veganisms enviormental friendliness?(edited)This is perhaps the best argument against veganism i have ever heard, purely from a negative utilitarian consequentialist viewpoint How to both oppose factory farming, and rewilding of natural habitats?

Another example with fish: by not killing and consuming wild fish, they will continue to populate and populate and cause more net suffering than if you culled their population. Of course, most consumer fish is not wild caught, but artificially bred, so buying those fish do not count as suffering reductionMessage #veganism


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jul 29 '25

Discussion Stop sorting garbage, to reduce wild life?

2 Upvotes

Now, this may sound schizo, but what are pros and cons of fueling ecocatastrophe for reducing amounts of wild animal suffering? for example, sizes of wildlife decreased by 60% globally between 1970 and 2014 — i.e. we've already succeeded to reduce ALL wild suffering more than twice! (source: https://scre.ws/wwf-r)


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Sep 23 '18

Video The orgasm of one sea turtle justifies the tragic death of 10 000 baby sea turtles (sarcasm)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jan 06 '20

Question Why are vegan anarchists so horrible?

6 Upvotes

I posted on another account a year ago about wild animal suffering, in r/vegan and r/veganarchism. While the content of the posts was exactly the same in both subreddits, there was a major difference in the response I received. In r/vegan, there was some disagreement, but no outright hostility. In /r/veganarchism, there were multiple instances of name-calling and other personal attacks, including one use of a slur. The post may have been too pushy but none of that was justified and I feel the need to work it out.

What’s the difference here? What I’m seeing demonstrated is that vegan anarchists are more set in their ways than other vegans. It looks like vegan anarchists feel this way because they are more correct than other vegans who are not anarchists and other anarchists who are not vegan. Additionally, veganism is specifically out of concern for animals, while vegan anarchism is also linked to ideas of “liberation”, seeing animals as free in the wild.

Regardless, this seems a problem with anarchists in general. There seems to be a lot of difficulty dealing with disagreement among all the different kinds of anarchists, to a degree I haven’t seen in any other philosophy. If the movement wants to push its message, there needs to be a better way to doo this.


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Nov 07 '17

Insect Suffering

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Aug 21 '17

Wild Animal Suffering Research mentioned in SSC article on Effective Altruism Global

Thumbnail
slatestarcodex.com
3 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Apr 09 '20

Video Humane Hancock: Responding to Wild Animal Suffering Apologists | Reading My Hate Comments

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Aug 11 '19

Image Blatant speciesism towards nonhuman animals in the wild on PETA's website

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Dec 21 '21

Discussion Is it wrong to take unnecessary walks?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • May 23 '21

Discussion Two arguments for respecting wild animals right to breed and live full lives in wild habitat + Some FAQ &As.

9 Upvotes

-

Index

1. Debate Prop

2. Natural Language Arguments

3. Formal Language Versions of The Same Arguments

4. Frequently Asked Questions

-

1. Debate Prop

In Short - We should for the most part & for now respect wild animals' right to breed, kill other animals and live full lives in wild habitat.

In Depth - We should hold the preference of desiring to grant collective legal rights for non-human animals to have a refuge in dense wildlife habitat in terms of our relationshiip to them, where they aren’t subject to human cruelty. So where they can for the most part breed, kill other animals, and potentially live long lives in wild habitat uninhibited by humans. With the few exceptions where for example animals have been domesticated and so it would be cruel to release them into the wild and so where ideally we should let them live out their potentially long lives before a natural death/euthenasia, or where the law is overridden by right to self-defence or by special dispensation from the government for example to practice some scientific testing to cure diseases or a compulsory purchase act where suitable provisions are made for the wellbeing of the animals being relocated or where it would be good to breed and keep guide dogs for the blind, etc.

-

2. Natural Language Arguments

2a. Virtue Ethics - Respect for Animal Capabilities

If the wonder that we experience in viewing wild animals is not 'how similar to us they are', but their 'real opportunities to do and be what they have reason to value' and one sufficient reason we grant this freedom at least to a basic extent to humans is they have a desire to achieve what they find valuable then; the fact non-human animals experience this desire too means we ought to extend these freedoms to animals.

So a holistic worldview of not wanting to reduce both the quality and quantity of positive experiences humans can have with animals, as well as animals with other animals.

2b. Existentialist Ethics - Property Rights for Animals

If you desire the ability to live a full life on your property because it satisfies a desire you have to meet your basic needs and you’re in favor of guardianship laws to protect this ability for severely mentally disabled people in court because they can't defend themselves then; you should really desire non-human animals who also have these needs have a legal right to their wild habitat as property and should enjoy guardianship laws which protect their legal rights in court through the appointment of a guardian to represent the case of one or a group of animals unless another reason is specified on pain of living in bad faith.

This centers the discussion on how you may be excluding other groups because it's the social norm. If there's one on average norm that unites existentialists in their rejection of universalist ethics, it's that of the desire to live authentically, so not acting in a way you don't believe due to outside social pressures, like that acting without compassion is necessary to what it means to be a man.

Everyone has some values they were brought up with that inform their meta-ethical system. It’s up to us to test out those values as we go along against new ones we discover and decide what kind of world we want to live in. We are meaning-seeking creatures innately, we can if we chose to, seek the happy flourishing of ourselves and others in the process, instead of living a life predicated on taking from others happy flourishing unnecessarily.

Getting to a stage in human civilization where we are able to derive meaning from compassionately caring for the basic needs of every person could be a great thing, just like we could find meaning in getting to see more land freed up for wildlife, where animals are able to express all their capabilities.

-

3. Formal Language Arguments

3a. Virtue Ethics - Respect for Animal Capabilities

P1) If the wonder that we experience in viewing wild animals is not 'how similar to us they are', but their 'real opportunities to do and be what they have reason to value' and one sufficient reason we grant this freedom at least to a basic extent to humans is they have a desire to achieve what they find valuable THEN the fact non-human animals experience this desire too means we ought to extend these freedoms to animals.

P2) The wonder that we experience in viewing wild animals is not 'how similar to us they are', but their 'real opportunities to do and be what they have reason to value' and one sufficient reason we grant this freedom at least to a basic extent to humans is they have a desire to achieve what they find valuable.

C) Therefore the fact non-human animals experience this desire too means we ought to extend these freedoms to animals.

3b. Existentialist Ethics - Property Rights for Animals

P1) If I should desire the ability to live a full life on my property because it satisfies a desire I have to meet my basic needs THEN I should desire guardianship laws to protect this ability for severely mentally disabled people in court because they can't defend themselves

P2) I should desire the ability to live a full life on my property because it satisfies a desire I have to meet my basic needs

C1) Therefore I should desire guardianship laws to protect this ability for severely mentally disabled people in court because they can't defend themselves

P3) If I should desire guardianship laws to protect this ability for severely mentally disabled people in court because they can't defend themselves THEN I should desire non-human animals who also have these needs have a legal right to their wild habitat as property and should enjoy guardianship laws which protect their legal rights in court through the appointment of a guardian to represent the case of one or a group of animals unless another reason is specified on pain of living in bad faith

C2) Therefore I desire non-human animals who also have these needs have a legal right to their wild habitat as property and should enjoy guardianship laws which protect their legal rights in court through the appointment of a guardian to represent the case of one or a group of animals unless another reason is specified on pain of living in bad faith

-

4. Frequently Asked Questions

Q: If a human child were about to be attacked and devoured by a lion, wouldn't stopping that be the right thing to do? Why then should we be obligated to allow the lion to devour the gazelle?

A: Hearing about any human getting killed by a predator reduces most humans' quality of life because we know most of our interests are to be separate from wild animals. So putting in infrastructure and training with guns to prevent avoidable loss of human life brings us meaning.

If you put up a wall around half the planet to separate carnivores and herbivores and just chucked the carnivores lab-grown meat, herbivores would just be frustrated they couldn't roam in the way they want to & carnivores would experience a worse quality of life for not being able to express their capabilities, so there would be less pain in the world in the case of animals eating each other, but there would be much less happy flourishing, which is suffering animals gladly take on to get to experience, like putting up with annoying offspring in order to have offspring, so a worse state of affairs.

-

Q: If a group of humans who couldn’t experience empathy chose to live in dense wildlife habitat, hunting and being nomadic... and aliens who similarly couldn’t empathise or understand ethics came down and started living among them hunting only those humans who couldn’t empathise... but not to extinction, and serving an ecological niche, would you try to stop them?

A: If the humans had been seperate from modern society for 150 years I would have nothing inherently against the aliens doing that, but I would still be tempted to kill off the aliens out of simple symbolic loyalty to my own kind.

-

Q: Does having no strong arguments against amoral aliens coming down and killing amoral humans hurt the case for veganism?

A: No, it helps keep the legal animal rights movement stay focused on preventing the harm that we are responsible for. So it helps people understand:

  1. The really clear timeline of how we destroyed wild habitat and domesticed prey animals to live these lives of confinemnt and desires with no abiility to express them. &...

  2. How now with modern technology we can restore wild habitat and free up land for the animals common wild ancestors to express their capabalities in.

If aliens capable of understanding ethics came down and had interests to kill any sentient life where they could just eat plants, of course that would still be unjustifiable under the ethical system I advocate for. And that situation relates to almost everyone on earth.

-

Q. Don’t you have a double standard where you’re willing to see animals harmed more than humans, why wouldn’t it be okay to set predators on a human society which was overpopulated?

A. We can reason with people, get them to use birth control, and drown them in gifts to get them to see the error of their ways. The reason to re-introduce predators is so you can maximize a net global calculus of happy flourishing in the world, where animals are getting to express their capabilities in dense wildlife habitat as opposed to the mono-culture environments lack in species diversity causes.

Art, science, roads, houses, and hospitals bring humans happy flourishing, it's what most people desire to put their mind towards to improve on the humble jungle shack.

-

Q: But even ideally, wouldn’t you want to see us give lab-grown meat to carnivores?

A: No, humans accept suffering to get to continue living in their habitat. No impoverished community would accept being helicoptered away from everything that makes them them to live in some sky rise. It's the same for animals and their ranges being reduced or being chucked lab-grown meat rather than getting to chase down prey. I'm not arbitrarily discriminating against animals here, hence not speciesist.

-

Q: What if Venus flytraps evolved into massively complex slaughterhouses to confine and kill large mammals in nature, would you not intervene?

A: For sure I would, I can accept many interventions, like rescuing injured wildlife, curing animal viruses, etc. The reason to allow predators is they preserve a more complex ecology where more animals can experience happy flourishing.

And if people accept my arguments, then they are obligated to be vegan and try to alleviate the pain of any large animals they come across where the consequences for one’s self isn’t dramatic, the same way you should get your shoes wet to rescue a child drowning in a canal.

-

Q: How is letting carnivores kill other animals vegan?

A: I define veganism as simply “an animal products boycott.”

I make the point of saying it’s one campaign tactic among many, aimed primarily at achieving the end of animal agriculture.

And that personally I see the principle behind the action as being grounded in the legal animal rights movement, seeking collective legal rights for animals to have a refuge in dense wildlife habitat where they aren’t subject to human cruelty. In a similar way to how the act of boycotting South African products or the act of boycotting the Montgomery bus company was grounded in a larger civil rights movement.

The concept behind veganism has roots going back as far as ancient India and the vegan society didn't even bother trying to come up with various definitions for 20 years or so, they just knew they wanted to start their own society after a series of debates in which they voiced their concern that we should also be advocating the boycott of the dairy and egg industries, for both consequentialist welfare concerns and deontological rights-based concerns.

For further reading check out: How to simply explain what veganism is and argue for it

-

Q: Aren't you using happy flourishing in a weird way here?

A: Maybe, I'm still developing my virtue-existentialist ethics. For further reading check out this essay by Martha Nussbaum called Beyond Compassion and Humanity; Justice for Non-human Animals. I think she contradicts herself when she denies the entailments of her philosophy are that one should not kill animals for taste pleasure & that we should respect animals' right to bodily integrity, play & control over one's environment. But otherwise, it's a great essay sketching out the case for valuing all animals' autonomy to seek meaning on our own terms to a basic degree:

It goes beyond the contractarian view in its starting point, a basic wonder at living beings, and a wish for their flourishing and for a world in which creatures of many types flourish. It goes beyond the intuitive starting point of utilitarianism because it takes an interest not just in pleasure and pain [and interests], but in complex forms of life. It wants to see each thing flourish as the sort of thing it is. . .[and] that the dignity of living organisms not be violated.

-

Q: But don't conservationists typically re-introduce predators for selfish aesthetically-driven reasons or out of the fallacious belief that nature is good in itself and should be maintained?

A: Yes, that's fair, which is why I don't promote terms like rewilding and just use the term managed wildlife habitat.

-

Q: Isn't the natural world full of suffering?

A: Suffering is a necessary part of happy flourishing.

-

Q: This all still just reads as speciesism, no?

A: I see it as speciesist to not let animals express their capabilities in their wild habitat. Most people who raise the issue of wild animal suffering want to treat non-human animals like infant humans who if they were as intellectually capable as us in adulthood would want to separate themselves off from wild habitat also. It's fanciful.

If adult humans want to risk their life living out in the middle of nowhere in bear country, they're welcome to. We can still protect our young and disabled, knowing most of us grow up to have interests to be separate from wildlife habitat, other animals simply don't.

-


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Oct 04 '19

Insight Assuming that animals care about nature / are okay with suffering

9 Upvotes

I've noticed a lot of people projecting their views onto animals. They assume that animals have the same feelings as them regarding veganism, environmentalism, and nature itself. A lot of vegans seem to think that because they're vegan and love animals, animals must love them back. Environmentalists think that animals are their allies, because environmentalism protects diversity of animal life. Some even think that animals voluntarily accept their place in the ecosystem and are okay with being killed.

In reality, this is not true, as far as we know. Animals are not vegan. They regularly kill and hurt other animals, even if they don't need to eat them. They also do not speak out about the destructinon of their habitat. And they especially don't show respect for most other animals. Predators don't respect prey, and prey don't respect predators.

These views are very common, and I believe it's because of the fundamental difference in speaking out against speciesism compared to other forms of discrimination. Victims of racism speak out about racism, victims of sexism speak out about sexism. But no non-human animal has ever told humans about speciesism, since it's an idea humans made up.

Additionally, it's a coping mechanism. People have difficulty dealing with suffering, and one way to cope with it is saying that it's necessary and "part of life", therefore it's good. Similarly, they see animals suffering, and come up with ways to cope with it. They make up stories about animals having the same values they do.

I believe this is one of the main reasons why people accept wild animal suffering. Has anyone else noticed this?


r/wildanimalsuffering • • Aug 10 '18

We have an ethical obligation to relieve individual animal suffering – Steven Nadler | Aeon Ideas

Thumbnail
aeon.co
79 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Feb 16 '17

On terraforming, wild-animal suffering and the far future - winner of Sentience Politics essay competition

Thumbnail sentience-politics.org
5 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Dec 01 '16

The entire Bee Movie but it's an audio reading of The Importance of Insect Suffering

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Jun 30 '18

How Does Vegetarianism Impact Wild-Animal Suffering?

Thumbnail
reducing-suffering.org
6 Upvotes

r/wildanimalsuffering • • Mar 19 '21

Discussion Help me workshop an instagram post to Australian vegan influencers to raise awareness of wild animal suffering

6 Upvotes

I'm thinking something like:

u/morganmitch u/djtigerlily u/elissasursara u/jamesaspey u/nikkivandijk u/liamhemsworth u/georgeats u/itslizmiu u/emily_hunt you're invited to Australia's first vegan eating competition in 2021! Let's create great a great experience for your followers, raise awareness of vegan options u/nakedfoods u/beyondmeat u/acaibrothers u/grilldburgers u/topdupdonuts with 100% of ticket sales going to reduce wild animal suffering Who's in?

Those are Australia/NZs top Insta influencers. And, 2021 is better for waiting out COVID-19.

Frankly, I'm a nobody and NOT the best person to post this. Does anyone else have ANY profile in the vegan community (or even have lots of vegan friends) and can share this instead? Happy to support in the background to organise the actual thing.