r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Ye_untaken_username • Nov 12 '13
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/[deleted] • Sep 21 '24
Unpopular(?) opinion: Jonathan Magnum is the weakest fourth chair of the Aisha series...
Don't get me wrong, he has some funny moments, but doesn't feel he's as quick witted as the other cast members and he feels abit forced / over the top.
Maybe it's nerves? I have spotted him in the audience of a few Drew Era shows and so maybe he feels overshadowed by the others he'd watched ; although saying that, Wayne said he felt the same (COVID videos) when he was invited to join in the UK and early Drew series because he had watched WLIIA and been blown away by Ryan and Colin (aswell as Greg, Brad and Chip) who were more experienced than him.
Saying that, I'm only comparing him to the other "new" fourth chairs who blew me away and honestly I didn't realise Gary Anthony Williams was Stevie's dad from Malcolm in the Middle for agggeesss. 🤣
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Miss_Aviya • Aug 08 '13
My thoughts on the new season of WLIIA.
I am new to this subreddit so please excuse me if these things have been brought up before, but I felt like discussing with people the new season of Whose Line. Since I don't really know people that are into it I figured it was worth posting here.
I guess the first thing most people notice is the new host, Aisha. I've seen a lot of people kind of bashing on her as a host and as a part of the Whose Line crew. I do agree with most people that she doesn't seem to fit the flow of the show. She almost seems to rush it. Also she does not take part in the games herself. Why I liked Drew so much was because I didn't feel like I was watching a tv show as much as it felt like I was just watching a bunch of friends be funny together. Their banter and jokes with one another was part of what made the show so special.
Secondly, the celebrity guest appearances are every episode and personally I do not like that. I miss the crowd interaction, the awkwardness and pure gold of normal peoples reactions.
Another thing is the new games. I do like some, like the "special mat" game.. I forgot it's actual name, but they lay on the ground and perform a scene. It is a great concept and it's a ton of fun to watch as Colin looks like hes performing intense physical stunts.
However, games like "What's in the bag?" that game is just horrid. Ryan took a womans purse from the audience and literally threw her pills on the floor. Nothing about that game was entertaining to me, but perhaps others liked it.
I am extremely happy to see Whose Line back on tv. It is truly a delightful show that I love. I feel with some minor tweaks it could easily be another hit tv show. I do kind of worry that they won't make the much need tweaks and will continue to run the show as is. I don't know if it will last if they do that.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Nickdude5 • Jul 17 '13
Season 9 Episode 1 (Full Episode)
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/12Medbe • Jun 13 '15
Whose Editing CW's series Anyway?
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/JuanIgnatowski • Jul 09 '14
How about BARBERSHOP instead of WEIRD NEWSCASTERS?
Weird Newscasters is mostly a lame premise for a game. Its rarely about news and just an excuse to take off with the characters.
I suggest BARBERSHOP. The four players sit together like customers hanging out each with their own assigned characters and go off discussing a topic picked from the audience.
You could set it in different cities or countries for even more variety.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/caboose1984 • Aug 04 '13
Whose line not completely on the spot?
It seemed like during the last 2 episodes when it was time for sideways scene the actors knew where to go for their parts. Ep04 Colin went outside the door before she announced where they should be. And ep05 Wayne went outside before knowing his role. Discuss!
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/bobbydarling58 • Nov 01 '25
"voiceover personalities" in alisha's introduction to the song compilation infomercial segment
When Alisha introduces the song compilation infomercial game she refers to Colin and Ryan as two "voiceover personalities". Why? Voiceover artists add thier spoken voices to previously shot video or radio commercials. Why does that have to do with the music industry? Colin and Ryan are obvious doing a parity of an "on camera" infomercial with barely known celebrity personalities pitching a CD compilation. Therefore, something like "former music personalities" seems much more appropriate IMHO. Has anyone else noticed this? Does it bother anyone else?
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Corrie-luv_ • Jul 05 '17
Jeff Davis Fanart: Bruised But Beautiful
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/olivofreddie • Jul 17 '13
Did Ryan Stiles eat a real goldfish last night on WLIIA?
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Stunning_Structure73 • Sep 18 '23
A Question About The Drew Era Whose Line
I'm re-watching the Drew era, and up to season 6. I love this show, and always will. But I'm wondering amongst all you fans, specifically for the Drew run, how much did or do you think was actually funny?
I'm thinking in percentages. I'm thinking of three main areas. Like how much % was actual smart humor/improv, how much % was silliness/over the top, and how much % was it just them making fun of each other?
And from those categories, how much did you really laugh per episode, or every 3 to 4 episodes?
Just wondering your thoughts on the actual humor of the show. Thanks.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/monty2 • Oct 03 '14
Found some WLA fans over in r/gifs!
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/jamasie • Jan 08 '26
My joke fell flat
I work in a restaurant, and today we were heating soup for lunch and we decided that we would let it run out. I said “Let them eat liver!” Not a single person knew what I was talking about.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Linone • Aug 29 '13
Ran out of WLiiA, help!
Hey there. I've watched through all whose line and releated shows (GSS, improv-a-ganza etc). Are there any other good improv shows for me to watch?
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Imrustyokay • Apr 26 '16
A Whose Line Prop Experiment I made.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/ItsPronouncedGorDahn • Apr 26 '14
Aisha Tyler > Drew Carey
Yeah I said it.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/blacktuxedobrownshoe • Nov 28 '23
Where was Chip?
I did a search online and here but couldn't find the answer, so does anyone know why Chip Esten didn't return to Whose Line in the Aisha era?
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Jambi95 • Jul 26 '13
Is there anyone here who actually enjoys Aisha Tyler as the new host?
In my opinion she is not anything like Drew Carey and is not nearly as entertaining.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/JackLiberty0 • Dec 12 '25
Should they have blurred Melissa's underwear on the broadcast?
I'm surprised they could show that.
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/Rob_Saget • Sep 18 '13
I recently talked to WLIIA guest Heather Anne Campbell. Here is our discussion!
r/whoselineisitanyway • u/ZeroViSiBiLtY • Aug 03 '13
Problems with the new format...
I really don't like some of the changes they've made to the new show.. First off, I'm not particularly fond of Aisha Tyler as the host, I really don't think she's all that funny. Secondly, I find that it reduces the quality of the guest stars by having one EVERY single episode. I liked it better when it was more audience involvement and an occasional guest star. Thirdly, I like some of the new scenes, like sideways scene, but they need more variety. I'd also like the old Irish drinking songs and the hoedowns back. Dont really care for up votes just wanted to let off some steam.