r/whoop • • May 13 '25 Take My Energy Helpful Wholesome Seal I'll Drink to That

Discussion Former WHOOP CPO: Summarizing What I Heard and My Honest Reflections and Forward-Looking Thoughts

36 Upvotes

This is my second and final post about the Whoop 5.0 launch. I appreciate so many people reading and responding to my previous one, including those with whom I disagree. The high engagement and even vocal criticism from some reflects an intense passion for the brand and the product. There were so many comments on the previous post that I got lost trying to read and respond to them all. Given the overwhelming volume, I will instead share here the general themes that I heard and respond to each of them here.

Before jumping in, I’ll address questions about whether I am who I say and what my motivations are. First, everything I express is my opinion and my opinion alone. I do not speak for Whoop and I have not collaborated with anyone at the company or any intermediaries.

To confirm that I am in fact the former CPO of Whoop, I just made a post on LinkedIn (handle = benfoster) that says, “Yes, I’m the one posting on r/whoop.” You can scroll back to see that that same account also posted as the Whoop CPO July 2020 - July 2022. Yes, it’s me.

My motivations are, in rank order:

  1. Maximizing positive impact on performance and health of this community and hopefully a larger one

  2. Knowing the hard work I put in as CPO was worthwhile and impactful (that’s selfish, but it is what it is)

  3. Setting the record straight about how Whoop operates and the intentions of the people who work there

  4. Financial upside as a shareholder (yes, I have stock and yes I want to see it go up like any rational person, but it’s nowhere near my primary motivation here and I would never say something I didn’t actually believe for the sake of financial gain)

I spent hours yesterday reading, responding, and trying earnestly to understand. I would summarize what I read as four different frustrations, with different people being focused on different ones. They were:

A. “Whoop was dishonest, saying one thing but doing another.”

B. “I should get a free hardware upgrade without needing to re-up my subscription.”

C. “I’m entitled to get MG for the same price as I’ve been paying for 4.0.”

D. “Whoop changed the form factor just so they could make more money selling replacement accessories.”

Here’s my take on each:

A. “Whoop was dishonest, saying one thing then doing another.”

Clearly, there is a big disconnect between what this community was expecting to get and what they got with 5.0. Whoop should have communicated their plans ahead of time to transparently set expectations better. That said, there are many more people who DON’T feel cheated than DO. Reddit skews more critical/negative and even with that, there were 3 upvotes for every downvote. There are real people behind Whoop, people like you and me, and they are good people with good intentions. I know them. I’ve been in the trenches with them and seen how much they love and respect this community. Should they have communicated better? Yes. Were they intentionally misrepresenting the upgrade policy? I am confident the answer is no.

B. “I should get a free hardware upgrade without needing to re-up my subscription.”

Any new customer has to commit to 12 months before being given a new device. The same is true for existing customers being upgraded with a new device. This is generally consistent with how it worked in the previous 3.0-4.0 upgrade. It would be wasteful and a poor business decision for Whoop to proactively give devices to people whose contracts were ending soon and who were unwilling to extend their contract. The cash flow implications are untenable, and the company would have to fund the resulting losses from wasted hardware somehow, specifically by raising prices for those members who were committed to sticking around longer term. I asked previously whether anyone could name a single company that does this and I got zero responses. So anyone who was expecting this was expecting Whoop to do something no other company does, something it has never done previously, something that would have resulted in higher subscription fees for all, and something that would be totally impractical from a business perspective. It seems that at some point Whoop had inaccurate messaging stating that all that was needed having been a subscriber for 6 months and that was taken down as soon as it was brought to the company’s attention. I wonder what percent of people here actually saw it and were actually swayed to join specifically because of that point and that point alone to buy a Whoop membership, vs. are just piggybacking on what they’ve heard from other community members given an opening to do so.

C.  “I’m entitled to get Life/MG for the same price as I’ve been paying for 4.0.”

I don’t know the numbers, but I am familiar enough with the business and the underlying tech to know that the cost for Whoop to manufacture MG is simply too high to be supported by the current $240/year subscription. Whoop has been investing in the tech for years and wouldn’t have known the true costs (especially as they may be affected by the idiotic tariffs of the Trump administration). If they could have made it available at the same price, they would have. So, what happens when Whoop works on the tech, investing many millions of dollars on bleeding edge tech only to discover that the manufacturing costs aren’t sustainable with the current pricing?

- Whoop could commit “business suicide” by providing at a loss anyway, but no one wins in that scenario.

- Whoop could raise the cost of a subscription for all members including those who don’t care about MG features whether they upgrade or not. But then this community would rightfully note that it’s not free and the members who don’t want the upgrade MG would be particularly upset.

- Whoop could pare back the features of MG so that it can work under the current pricing. But that would mean artificially slowing innovation to meet a lower price point. The only path to providing “the latest and greatest” tech would have been to reduce how “great” it actually was. Whoop could have done this, but it’s the community that would have lost.

None of these options are viable or reasonable. Put yourself in their shoes. What would you do? I think Whoop made the optimal choice, which was to give members the OPTION to increase their subscription level to get MG and to ALSO do the best they could to make good on their commitment by offering 5.0 Peak for the same price as a current subscription. Whoop isn’t nickeling and diming here. It is finding the best path to keep the membership cutting-edge while giving consumers choice when it comes to pricing.

For all those who claim that Whoop is just a money-grabbing company that doesn’t care about its members, remember that the last price change was to proactively LOWER prices for members while competitors were raising them. And, they just offered a new plan that provides an option to save $40/year from what members have been paying. Credit where credit is due.

D. “Whoop changed the form factor so they could make more money selling replacement accessories.”

There are a couple strong reasons for the modified form factor. My understanding (though I am not sure of this) is that the mechanism for ECG required a change to the form factor. At least that was an issue we were contending with at the time I was there. That may have influenced this decision. Many of you have questioned whether the 7% size difference matters. It does, particularly for women. Every bit counts more than you would expect. The device needs to be as streamlined as possible. And women will not get the benefits of all the amazing investments the company has made around female physiology if they’re not willing to wear Whoop in the first place.

But yeah, there’s the other reason, too. I’ll be honest: they make money selling more accessories. Yeah, it’s annoying. OK. It’s also capitalism. You can choose to buy accessories or not. You can choose not to upgrade to maintain compatibility of your current accessories, if that’s what you want to prioritize. Whoop never made a promise that accessories would be forward-compatible. Bands really shouldn’t be used for years, anyway. I change mine out every 3-6 months because they get grungy. If compatibility is a big deal to you (or if paying in advance to extend your membership to get an instant upgrade is a big deal to you), then just be patient. Keep your 4.0, continue using your bands until they need to be replaced anyway, keep your current 4.0 until it’s time to make your next annual payment anyway, and upgrade then. Personally, it doesn’t bother me that my old grungy 4.0 bands won’t work with 5.0.

I hope this community appreciates an alternate interpretation, the peek under the hood, and the nuances involved in the decisions that seem simple on the outside but are quite complex in reality. I dare those reading this to put their pitchforks down for a moment and really ask themselves what they would do when faced with the dilemma of how to fit a square peg (expensive manufacturing cost of MG) into a round hole ($240/year subscriptions, which are only that low because the company proactively lowered them previously). If you cannot think of a better option than what Whoop did, then have the courage to change your point of view, and consider explaining your rationale to others. If you decide to pick the pitchfork back up anyway, then do it. That’s absolutely your right, but I think you should have a solid answer as to what the company should have done differently given the likely circumstances I described.

I also hope you’ll think back to why you became a Whoop member in the first place. It wasn’t because of free hardware upgrades. You joined Whoop because you wanted to improve your fitness and health; hardware upgrades were icing on the cake. Before the 5.0 launch, you were improving your fitness and health. After the launch, you are still improving your fitness and health, and now you have several options for how to improve them further. That’s great news.

I welcome further comments and discussion but I probably won’t respond to them as I have other responsibilities that I need to attend to. Again, I hope that people find these insights, nuances, and new perspectives helpful. I also hope I was able to directly address as many of the questions and rebuttals that came from my previous post as possible. Thanks for reading. Thanks for considering.


r/whoop • • May 13 '25

Discussion Unhappy? – Open up the App Store / Google Play –> Give Whoop one star – These are critical to getting featured by Apple/Google and developers depend on these ratings.

0 Upvotes

Just as the title says, if you're unhappy, give your feedback where it counts: the App Store or Google Play.

Not only will you be sure Whoop sees your feedback, but also anyone else considering getting a Whoop will see helpful information from the community.


r/whoop • • Jul 24 '24

Discussion So close to cracking the 200HRV mark! 🥲

Post image
6 Upvotes

At some stage I will break through!! 😂 Still an all time high for me which is pretty unexpected after a big training day yesterday. Started off averaging in the mid 70s for HRV when I first got Whoop approx 3 years ago. Big strides can indeed be made


r/whoop • • Jan 24 '25

Discussion Doctors have no idea what Whoop is.

0 Upvotes

I went to my doctor yesterday and had a bit of an elevated heart rate (I’m not much of a caffeine drinker but I had a coffee a couple hours before, was on medication that can elevate HR, and generally have a higher HR than others).

The nurse mentioned it so I showed her my Whoop data and she was like, “Oh, you’re fine,” but had absolutely no idea what Whoop was. Same thing with my doctor.

Have others ran into this too? I’ve worn my Whoop non-stop for over five years. Feels like this data would be extremely beneficial to health professionals and they’d at least be familiar with one of the leaders in wearable tech.


r/whoop • • Nov 07 '24

Good by Whoop

0 Upvotes

I have cancelled my subscription after 2 years of usage.

I liked:

  • Sleep monitor

  • Stress monitor (a lot)

  • Analytics

  • Recovery vs. strain

I did not like:

  • Heart beat not accurate at all when running (this was the worst)

  • Yoga strain not accurate

  • Chatbot

  • Steps

  • Battery life at the end

  • Band wasn’t tight any more

  • Feature creep (things I don’t need)

  • Poor support (way too much noise vs solutions)

  • Too expensive after 2 years

Whoop has a really good concept, but there is way too much focus on investors.

I would have thought about continuing, if they’ve offered me to renew at half the price.


r/whoop • • Jul 17 '25

Reviews Just returned my Whoop. Waiting to see what Polar does next… because Whoop just isn’t it.

1 Upvotes

I gave the Whoop band a real shot… two-month trial. I train like a hybrid athlete and thought this would help me dial in recovery and performance.

But the more I used it, the more obvious it became: if you already know how to listen to your body, this thing is pointless.

  1. It’s all built on wrist HR… and it’s not accurate Whoop uses wrist-based optical heart rate to calculate everything: HRV, strain, recovery, sleep. Problem is, wrist HR is unreliable during lifting, intervals, or even daily movement. If your base data is off, everything else is noise.

  2. Step tracking is garbage Some days I moved nonstop and it barely registered anything. I compared it with my phone… it wasn’t even close.

  3. The “insights” are just common sense Drink less, sleep more, recover better. Wow. Groundbreaking. It’s all surface-level advice packaged in a pretty UI. If you’ve got even a basic understanding of health, this isn’t helping you improve… it’s just repeating the obvious.

  4. I don’t need a wearable to tell me how I slept I wake up, I know. That’s it. I don’t need a color-coded score or sleep breakdown to tell me whether I feel good or not.

  5. You don’t own anything No subscription? No data. No use. You’re paying monthly to rent access to your own biometrics. That’s wild when you stop and think about it.

Right now I’m using my Polar H10 chest strap for accurate HR tracking during training. No subscription, way more reliable. And I’m waiting to see what Polar’s new band offers… if it gives recovery data backed by real HR accuracy, I’m all in.

Whoop has great marketing and a slick app. But it’s not built for people who know how to train, eat, recover, and listen to their bodies. It’s a shiny distraction with a subscription fee.

Anyone else hit the same wall with Whoop?


r/whoop • • May 13 '25

Reviews She’s stunning 😍

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/whoop • • Aug 07 '26

Reviews This was my WHOOP verdict before the Bevel integration. Does it still hold up?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

A few days ago I asked here whether anyone had actually switched from WHOOP to Fitbit Air after 900+ nights with WHOOP.

I didn’t expect that post to get nearly as much discussion as it did. Reading through all the comments actually pushed me to order a Fitbit Air, so I’m going to wear both and compare them side by side.

Before all of that, this was the WHOOP review I had already made after roughly a year with the 5.0.
My conclusion was pretty clear: I’m still choosing WHOOP, mainly because of the app and the way it turns the data into something I can actually use.
But now the Bevel integration has arrived, and that’s potentially the exact part of the equation that mattered most to me.

So I’m genuinely curious: does this change the WHOOP vs Fitbit Air argument for you?
I’ll find out for myself over the next few weeks since I’ll be running both in parallel.


r/whoop • • May 09 '26

Discussion Why jump to an unknown ship?

0 Upvotes

Why would you move to a Gen 1 Device and User Interface? Good luck with Google Support.

I assume the FitBit air will be the screenless equivalent of a Pixel Watch paired with FitBit Premium. Anyone testing that against Whoop?

Don't think for a minute that next year there won't be a tiered subscription.

I'm not here defending Whoop. Their support sucks and they lied to original customers, like myself.

Are we expecting perfection from a non medical grade device?


r/whoop • • May 10 '26 LOL

Discussion Everyone's going to keep their membership, drop the illusion

0 Upvotes

Yes, Google launched a new product, cool, guess what? No one cares.

I've had an iPhone for 10 years. Every time a new Samsung/Google phone comes out, people are like "wow, that's so much better, better screen, better battery, etc." But guess what? I love my iPhone even with its 60Hz screen, because I love the OS, I don't want to migrate all my data, and the price is fine.

Same thing with Whoop. I have 1k+ recovery streaks, I use it every day, and their app is insanely good compared to Garmin, Apple, etc.

Now let's be honest, I'm still glad competitors are showing up because it'll push Whoop to step up their game and improve.

Take their MG model for example, it's a complete joke. I actually got it, don't do the same, it's useless and I'll definitely downgrade because the added value is zero.

So hopefully they'll just stop overpricing premium (lol) products and things will keep getting better.

Bottom line: ecosystems win, hype doesn't.


r/whoop • • May 12 '25 Take My Energy

Discussion 🥳For those excited about their new WHOOP (5.0 or MG ) let’s celebrate the upgrade together.

113 Upvotes

This thread is for the excited ones, haha. The ones who see WHOOP not just as a wearable, but as a personal evolution tool. Whether you’re waiting on your new 5.0 or stepping into the future with MG (like me), you’re in the right place. This space is for the optimists, the health investors, the ones who are curious about what’s next and grateful for what’s improved.

Sure, the subscription model sparks debate, but for many of us, it’s an investment that pays us back daily in awareness, insight, and better decisions. WHOOP has come so far since I started in 2022. The features, the metrics, the support… all of it keeps leveling up. And I truly believe this next step will only widen the gap in what we get out of it. So I see MG as an investment into the future metrics that they will develop for MG.

Let’s celebrate that. Let’s talk about what we’re loving, what we’re looking forward to, and why this upgrade feels like a win.

Excited energy only. You’re welcome here.


r/whoop • • May 12 '25

Other Whoop is buying upvotes for their ex-CPO

0 Upvotes

In 2020, Whoop changed my life, I got my BF to 14%, my RHR to 43 when I was 26. I had day time abs for the first time. I had enough more swipes on dating apps for my first STI. What they're doing is crazy right now.

Very anomalous rise, unless a large swath of the members that's been active since he posted voted for him; these are faked. Here's the link to report them: https://www.reddit.com/report https://www.reddit.com/r/whoop/comments/1kkfg8a/thoughts_on_50_upgrade_from_ben_foster_former/


r/whoop • • Oct 23 '25

Discussion Whoop is nearly useless at this point

12 Upvotes

I’ve been using the MG since it came out a few months back and it really feels like a waste of money. The two features that are different for MG are the blood pressure monitor and ECG. Both of these features never seem to work right or work at all. The blood pressure monitor won’t show blood pressure lower than 90/60 which is useless for me because my diastolic is lower than 60 most days. The ECG barely works at all and when it does work, it just tells me low heart rate detected as it won’t even work if your heart rate is below 50. What is the point of these features if you can’t even use them?

Also the new updates that whoop keeps doing to the app seem to be making it extremely slow. The app was way better a year ago and it seems like every update has made it slower and less user friendly. My app constantly crashes and my whoop never seems to be up to date, even though the app is open.

Another point that I’ve found is that my recovery doesn’t correlate at all with how recovered or how rested I feel the next day. Anytime it shows a green recovery, I feel worse than when it shows a red recovery. What is the point of a recovery metric if it is completely useless?

The whoop age is also another useless metric and is almost completely dependent on your sleep consistency. Even if you get less than 6 hours of sleep per night it will show great sleep and decrease your speed of aging by a lot. If you vary your wake and sleep times a little bit and get adequate sleep as in 6-9 hours per night, it will increase your speed of aging. The age also doesn’t correlate with the speed of aging multiplier because even when at a 0x or 0.3x multiplier my age was still going up in a week.

For the insane price per year I think that it is completely not worth buying an MG and I’m contemplating just not renewing at all at this point. Why is whoop just getting worse every month? Is it ever going to get better or will it keep getting worse as time goes on?


r/whoop • • Oct 16 '23

My Whoop group has almost ruined my life.

0 Upvotes

What started as a playful endeavor to increase my health, fitness and longevity has become a dark path into destroying my life.

After discovering whoop, I told my friends about the free trial and how Whoop was this neat thing that tracked your bio markers, gave you advice about your sleep and generally just aided one's attempt at a better life. They all signed up and all was great, I got the referrals and they got access to whoop. We would casually talk about our sleep, ways to improve health and other athletic benchmarks. That's when the "team" was made or group as you might know it. We created a group amongst us where you get ranked daily about your sleep, strain and recovery. Cool right? We could see where we ranked amongst ourselves and there was some very minor playful competition - for the greater good.

What happened next became a spiral of events that has left me broken. Initially, I was scoring somewhat below my peers, struggling to get above an 80% sleep score, recovery lacking. Often waking up. My friend's on the other hand were smashing it, 100% most days, strain 12+ daily - killing it. I get laughed at every morning when everybody wakes up and sees my sleep score. Not only that but as far as HRV went I was the clear runt of the group, struggling to get it above 50 while they were crushing it with one particular guy cruising at ... 140+? Before you comment telling me "Don't worry, HRV is individual just use it as a relative marker for yourself to improve" - I know already, but it kills me to see my friend's lifestyle where he can manage to score so insanely well. For context, he drinks 3 monsters a day, takes vyvanse like candy, plays league of legends 12 hours a day, smokes like a chimney and sometimes does all nighters to reset his sleep schedule. And that is the motherfucker that out scores me EVERY SINGLE DAY? Meanwhile after getting my whoop, I've had to give my cat to my brother because it wakes me up before 100% sleep score every day and I couldn't take the meowing at 6am because I KNOW it was messing up my sleep badly (I miss pickle more than anything). My girlfriend and I don't sleep in the same bed anymore because of how poorly I score when I share a bed with partner as told by the whoop. I take all these weird fucking supplements for sleep now; apigenin, L Theanine like what is this shit I'm even putting in my body? All for a crappy 82% sleep score at BEST. Meanwhile now I've got no cat, no sex, liver probably destroyed by these supps, can't perform well in the gym due to low recovery as per the whoop AND I'm consistently bottom of the leaderboard, I'm now known as the loser of the group despite trying everything I can, I've been following Bryan Johnson's blueprint for about 6 weeks now to try and boost health and perform better. Now everyone at work thinks I'm a fucking freak when I take out my super veggie/nutty pudding for lunch every day. Not only that but the guys at my local tennis club take the piss out of me for drinking pepsi max instead of beer after matches. My quality of life is at an all time low. Whoop has fucked me badly.

This is a cautionary tale to anyone thinking about creating a custom group in whoop. Please think twice about the consequences before you do it.


r/whoop • • Feb 07 '26

Advice For Others Read Before You Buy Whoop. FR!

0 Upvotes

Why I’m Leaving WHOOP After ~420 Workouts

TLDR: I know it's too long. Full confess. Bottom line: Test the whoop during trial against an ECG CHEST STRAP before buying the subscription. Decide for yourself. Everyone has different results. Don't rely on opinions. Sorry for the rant, but I wish I would have read something like this before I bought into the Whoop ecosystem and gear.

For those that have a lot of time and are deep diving:

WHOOP isn’t bad for the average person — but the metrics are all based on inaccurate heart rates and strains. If you are obsessive about having accurate metrics, this device is not what you want. If heart rate is not accurate, strain is not accurate, therefore recovery is not as accurate as it could be, and Healthspan is not accurate.

Essentially, the information you get...is not wrong…it is just not accurate

It’s just not the right tool for a performance based mindset developing strength, endurance, vo2max, and mixed sports. After ~420 workouts of side-by-side testing, I am switching to Polar H10 + Oura Ring + Strava, with an AI layer to interpret trends across all of it.

If you are debating, do the Whopp trial and be patient, unlike I was able to be - just buying the subscription. Do the trial and do side by side comparisons with an ECG chest strap heart rate monitor - not another PPG sensor. Anyone that says Whoop is accurate because it matches their watch…is not doing a proper comparison. Also, the accuracy is noted to be different for different people. I'm an avid watcher of quantified scientist and love his work. But my real world comparisons had different results for my body.

Be diligent.

Why:

WHOOP HR accuracy is directionally OK but consistently flattens peaks and short intervals vs a chest strap. It misses your hardest efforts.

Even with Strength Trainer, strain is still based on inferred effort (HR + volume), not true mechanical load. I know you are going to refer me to Strength Trainer. Mechanical load and volume are two different things.

CNS/HRV signals are downstream and inconsistent for managing strength or rehab. Whoop is good for trends and if you pay attention you can alert yourself to potential slides, but Whoop does not. You have to do the thinking for yourself.

Sleep and HRV rewriting hurts long-term data integrity. I have taken screenshots every morning for about 2 months and uploaded to an LLM for deeper analysis. I saw whoop change the data a few hours later, combining sleep and nap. It has also, multiple times, mistaken a nap for sleep and vice versa, but has not once allowed me to correct it. The buttons are there, but always resulted in an error, try again later.

Subscription model without hardware ownership didn’t make sense long term for these shortcomings.

I have used it during weightlifting, running, mountain biking, surfing, and BJJ. I have worn it on both biceps, both anterior and posterior, just below the deltoid. I have tried both wrists. I have even tried it around my calf muscle while doing upper body workouts. I have tried the boxers. I literally ran a spreadsheet that tracks all the deviations. (I have another post about that). Whoop is often over 50bpm low and only catches up 30 to 45s and only during rest intervals. This is commonly noted amongst users.

What I use now:

Polar H10 → authoritative training heart rate

Oura Ring → daily metrics, clean sleep + HRV trend tracking

Strava → neutral activity log

AI interpretation → integrates signals + context instead of collapsing everything into one score. This is also the only way I found to monitor mechanical load, as there is actually no device I've ever heard of that could monitor it without a professional lab. It's done through subjective input (RPE) but has to be tracked long-term to be correlated with any kind of cause and effect.

As much as I tried, there is no one device to infer everything; I now separate measurement from interpretation.

Less flashy — way more trustworthy.

Happy to answer questions or compare notes with others who’ve tested multiple systems.

Edit: I was actually going to post this a few days ago but decided not to. We didn't need more Whoop rage. However….

After submitting a customer service inquiry about some post-surgery Zone 2 treadmill walking with constant observation of both the pH 10 and whoop heart rates, and then receiving their email...I'm posting this. Now I am canceling after being insulted by Whoop customer service.

I already submitted a request after the first month and experienced similar results shown here in Paul Sklar YouTube video: https://youtu.be/Kidcot8_ksQ?si=jbOOT2QEa9cEKRbQ. How is 50bpm low acceptable for a premium subscription model?

I have been trying for six months to go with the “good enough” HR measurements in hope of overall better health assessments. After a shoulder surgery, and doing just super light lower body weight calisthenics and treadmill walks, I started seeing absolutely unacceptable results. It was actually doing low intensity conditioning that revealed a huge gap in Whoop algorithms. Air Squats and Crunches at a 10.8 strain!? Z2 walks that have the same strain as z2 runs? Whoop HR drops during a treadmill walk!? None of this is “good enough.”

As requested by whoop, I submitted photos of the bicep position of the whoop strap placement as well as screenshots of the PH10 and Whoop heart rates and customer service STILL denies any issue with Whoop and implies, through their response, that I do not know what average heart rate is, I am not experiencing what I know is happening, and their equipment is not faulty. OK. Got it.

I am uploading a quick video of tonight's z2 walk and some screenshots. Whoop is on the bicep. It was consistently 4 to 5 bpm low until it just dropped off to 40 to 50 bpm low on a sustained and consistent effort.


r/whoop • • Oct 14 '21

Little rant

4 Upvotes

Just need to drop this but can anyone stop bitching about their order status. Probably 90% of you guys ranting have a subscription for the 3.0 and are getting a free upgrade to the 4.0. Who gives a flying fuck that you are still waiting, still contacting customer service (why?! They will just tell you the same thing), that you are the unluckiest person in the world since one of your friends did receive it and yeah he ordered it half a second later than you. Yes, whoop is experiencing issues with shipping and delivering the 4.0. We all already know this! Keep using your 3.0 what you have done for some time. You all are probably only messing up your recovery with all the stress. And let’s be honest, looking at the world there are worst things than waiting for a recovery monitor for some time. You might be lucky and get it around Christmas, wouldn’t that be a good surprise to be thankful for!


r/whoop • • May 15 '25

Discussion Switched to Garmin

2 Upvotes

After this whole debacle. I switched to garmin fenix 8. Yes wayyyyy more expensive than whoop but extremely happy with it. Compared data on both and garmin have better heart rate tracking during workouts and more features if you’re in hiking and running. Had Apple Watch Ultra 2 for a while but I’m 100% sold on garmin. If anyone have questions regarding garmin im happy to answer. Battery life in smart watch is about 15 days with always on display it’s about 5. I do miss being able to wear mechanical watch but health tracking wise I couldn’t be more happier.


r/whoop • • May 09 '25

Advice Reminder: Negativity always outpaces positivity in news and internet

3 Upvotes

Founding Member of Whoop here. Typing that made me cringe, lol. Seriously though, bought into Whoop for lifestyle change metrics that allowed me to make changes based off of trends in data. All the way back in 2016/2017.

Story time:

Promised back then, pay in (500$?) and you’re in. Then they upgraded us to the 2, 3, and 4. Eventually they gave-in and had to move us to a discounted yearly membership rate.

Thinking back to the original whoop, and the data I’ve grown to love - the data that’s evolved - and the changes I’ve made with whoop since: 305lbs to 180lbs to 270lbs to a ‘healthier’ 225lbs… so much. Sleep increases, consistency in diets. Looking at trends of meal timing, macros and how they affect recovery, stress over the day and how it affects recovering, alcohol consumption and timing more importantly, and recently the trend in steps and how it affects recovery over a given time… has improved and been an added value over the last 8?!? Years:

With the announcement of the 5.0/MG… I was excited. I’m even more excited for the continued advancements, the extra battery life, the integration with the labs and vitals, and more. They’re a company. They’re a healthy fitness brand. Their goal is to make you control your health, and if 200-300 a year isn’t in your budget or “affordability” to help you gain that, then you are leading towards a more unhealthy expensive medical bill sooner than later anyway.

Company -

1st and foremost. Company. Sales. They must make money. If they don’t. They die. If they die. They close. If they close, most likely they sell the data they’ve made to the highest bidder which = more anger. So what do you all want to complain about? Sales strategies or the above?

No one, and I mean no one is forcing you to buy in or pay the price. Don’t want to, cancel.

Internet -

Final point here. The internet allows for so much more NEGATIVITY in an easier way over positivity. Half of the posts here about canceling and crying wolf. Guarantee you are all upgrading and snickering because of FOMO.

CANT WAIT FOR MY MG to arrive next week.

One wish - ECG AND BP to be usable on the bicep.


r/whoop • • May 11 '25

Advice Holy Cow....

0 Upvotes

Enough with the melodrama: "Betrayal," "lies," "class action lawsuits," "checkout c0de: Judas." Geez. Don't renew, go buy a Garmin, and move on with your lives. This is just a consumer product. Looking forward to getting my old r/whoop back. Edit: lol spelled whoop wrong.


r/whoop • • May 10 '25

Discussion Ima get down voted to hell but yall annoying.

0 Upvotes

Nothing but complain - if you don’t want to get 5.0 then fine. If you feel you were scammed, fine leave.

Excited for 5.0 and have the MG coming next week. Go buy your Apple Watches and garmins and join that sub Reddit


r/whoop • • Jan 09 '26

Discussion Keep announcing your departure

10 Upvotes

Whoop should know why customers are unhappy and that’s a net positive for everyone. Also, potential buyers should be aware of the shortcomings so they can make a more informed decision. Cheers!


r/whoop • • Aug 04 '26

Reviews Whoop as a company is a pos

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

i know its 4 months old and what matteres is the content

Copying bevel and suing them. Mediocre sensor quality. Ludicrous prices. They just pay influencers money to pull you in to their gimm ick. They only think about the money they are getting from you. I just canceled my whoop membership. Bunch of🤡 working on whoop.


r/whoop • • Oct 20 '25

Reviews I don't think whoop is worth it.

3 Upvotes

I tried whoop peak free for 14 days, and sincerely I don't see any difference between the other HRV and HR monitors. The only difference was the software but honestly, that too is subpar considering the amount of money we have to pay to get access to it. While I see that HR tracking is spot on, it doesn't understand naps, doesn't understand weightlifting by itself, even though I kept a consistent time for weight lifting, and my HR went up.

And after all these the biggest red flag was when I tried to return - they are charging money TO RETURN, and in case it doesn't come back to them in 14 days there will be a "restocking fee". WTF! Why didn't they say all these when they offered "free" (which I still had to pay 10 dollars for) 30 days? I sincerely don't get why whoop is getting all these attention and why no one is calling them out for unfair business practices.


r/whoop • • Sep 25 '22

We get it! Covid makes recovery scores low. Please for the love of god can these posts go somewhere else?

19 Upvotes

Since joining this thread, I swear I see no fewer than 5 posts per day showing low recovery with Covid. I think the relationship between Covid and low recovery is more than clear at this point. I honestly just don’t understand why people keep posting these when there is no difference in each post from the probably hundreds before it.