r/whitesox • • Aug 16 '22

Opinion You shouldn’t be able to wear flashy gloves and cleats if you’re hitting under .200

0 Upvotes

You all know who I’m talking about. Looks incredibly JV, especially when coupled with no hustle and his general malaise.


r/whitesox • • Apr 23 '22

Opinion Stop telling us "it's early." Downvote me all y'all want, but this is 100% evidence for how shit of an offseason it was.

5 Upvotes

Our best addition was an aging injury prone OF to play out of position. We added an injured set up man. Two below average SPs, one of whom isn't even here yet. And signed two utility infielders.

Terrible team defense, roster full of injury prone players, very questionable SP depth, and a manager who doesn't seem to help in any regard. This doesn't change overnight, or over a week. Division got better and it's not really debatable that we got worse.


r/whitesox • • Aug 06 '23

Discussion Everyone seems to ignore that Ramirez was the one who started it

25 Upvotes

The narrative I'm seeing is cocky Tim Anderson looking for a fight against the innocent Jose Raminez then getting knocked out when in reality it was Ramirez who started talking shit for no reason after sliding into the bag.


r/whitesox • • Aug 21 '23

Discussion Bring Back Ozzie

0 Upvotes

I know he says a lot of stupid stuff, but he cares and lights a fire in players. Hell make GM if he wants. Let him hire his whole family.

We need a spark, and Ozzie can do it.


r/whitesox • • Jul 21 '24

Opinion Drew Thorpe is on fire. What can we trade him for?

0 Upvotes

Like that's what we do right? We get a good player, then trade them for prospects. So who do you think we can get for him? Anyone know of some good Little League players we can get? Maybe they'll be cheap enough we can hang onto them for a while. I heard about a kid at SunnyTime Preschool who is already heralded as the Micheal Jordan of duck-duck-goose.

/s


r/whitesox • • Oct 11 '22

Opinion Ozzie is a better option for manager than Schildt, Bochy, and Washington.

0 Upvotes

drops mic


r/whitesox • • Aug 07 '22

Opinion Whats the point of winning the division??

1 Upvotes

I don’t get why I see a lot of people saying “oh just win the division then we’ll get hot”. when at any point this season have we proven that we can get hot on a consistent basis? and even if we did win this horrible division, why would we want to go out there just to get stomped by Houston or New York?


r/whitesox • • Dec 14 '24

Discussion Don't let the Cubs signing Kyle Tucker distract you from the fact that the White Sox are Chicago's true baseball team, and won a World Series before the Cubs did.

0 Upvotes

And seriously... y'all really think Kyle Tucker is going to suddenly make the Cubs World Series contenders?


r/whitesox • • May 19 '22

Meme 5 years since the rebuild started and we still see shit like this

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/whitesox • • Aug 22 '26

Opinion Stop doing the wave

0 Upvotes

For the love of god, stop doing this


r/whitesox • • Dec 29 '23

Discussion Considering the circumstances, GM Chris Getz is off to a good start

0 Upvotes

This is probably a slightly unpopular opinion, but Chris Getz has done a great job so far in my estimation. The facade that Reinsdorf deployed for the past couple of decades has obviously worn off; this isn't a middle-market team that occasionally spends, this is a bottom feeder team that almost never spends. There is a significant difference between the two and we need to accept that we are, quite literally, a team that has chosen to be poverty.

Dan Bernstein brought up a good point in May on 670 The Score. His point was, while it is not ideal to be non-spenders in baseball, it is certainly possible to still win. We don't need to go through the examples of teams that play moneyball for the 100th time, but the main idea is that the skill gap of these players is not as pronounced as some people lead you to believe. Just because the Cubs spent $180 million on Dansby Swanson does not mean he is $178 million better than Paul DeJong, it just means the Cubs chose to spend that much money on a shortstop in an inflated market. Would it be great for the Sox to choose to spend money? Of course. Is it going to happen? Absolutely not, so we have to deal with it.

I am in no way assuming that Getz isn't a shill and/or bootlicker of the Reinsdorf family. In fact, I would bet that he is. However, the moves he has made are objectively good baseball moves. He purged Tim Anderson, flipped Bummer for multiple major league players, drastically improved the outlook of their team defense (DeJong, Lopez, Maldanado, Stassi, etc.) and come front and center to acknowledge the ineptitude of this team's play of recent years. The truth is, in order for the Sox to sustain any success under the ownership of Jerry Reinsdorf, they NEED to dial it in ASAP in respect of the baseball side of things. The Middleton fiasco in August was no joke and, so far, Getz has been objectively smart with the resources at his disposal.

Edit: many people are commenting that Getz is a shill to Jerry. Yes, I know. Nowhere did I say he wasn’t. Getz can be an absolute shill to Jerry and also make some decent moves - both worlds can coexist.


r/whitesox • • Dec 14 '24

Opinion The Kyle Tucker trade reminds me of the White Sox

0 Upvotes

Full disclosure, I'm a White Sox fan so yes, I am biased. The Cubs recently traded for OF Kyle Tucker. They gave up 3B prospect Cam Smith, RHP Hayden Wesneski, and 3B Isaac Paredes. I won't spend much time on 'the return' the Astros got for Tucker, because you can't seriously analyze it until about 3-4 years have passed. The Cubs get an obvious upgrade to their lineup/team in 2025, even when you subtract MLB contributors in Paredes and Wesneski. I do think, on paper, the Cubs should be NL Central favorites before this season begins. Keep in mind the Cubs were favorites before the 2024 season as well and did not come close to winning the division, which is largely due to how well the Brewers have done developing young and unproved talent at the MLB level.

The Kyle Tucker trade is eerily similar to the moves Kenny Williams made post-2005 on the south side. Post-2005, the next 10-12 years of White Sox baseball was a flat circle. Since Reinsdorf was unwilling to improve the team by outspending other franchises in free agency, and with the massive pressure to continue succeeding, the Sox were forced to gut their farm system in return for uncontrollable rental players. James Shields, Edwin Jackson, Jeff Samardzija, Nick Swisher, Kevin Youkilis, Orlando Cabrera, and Todd Frazier are a few examples. Not every prospect traded away ended up being a hit, but we did send away two perennial all-stars in Tatis Jr. and Semien. Daniel Hudson and Frankie Matas have also enjoyed decent careers, as well.

When you look at the Tucker trade objectively, you can see why Jed Hoyer is making this move. There is a narrative that the Cubs lack of success is due to their lineup's lack of star power (which is fair). Because of this, Hoyer is likely on the heat seat. He has not delivered any playoff success in his tenure. However since Ricketts, much like Reinsdorf, is unwilling to dish out $300 million+ for a star player via free agency, the only choice Hoyer has right now is to trade the future for a rental. This is the same exact situation Williams and Hahn were forced into 10-15 years ago with the Sox. There is a chance the Tucker trade works (i.e., he has a career years and multiple players outperform expectations to make a run at a world series). This is a huge ask though, as they will likely be dumping Bellinger and/or Suzuki in the coming months, which likely offsets the boost you will get from Tucker unless a prospect or low-hanging free agent steps up big time.

I have also seen some MLB and Cubs fans suggesting this gives the team access to extend Tucker before any other teams, so the move is justified on that alone. This couldn't be more untrue in today's modern MLB, as the league functions uniquely to the other major sports right now. There is zero incentive for Tucker (or any player) to negotiate with any team prior for his impending free agency because of the current market and bidding wars among the big spending teams. Juan Soto just got paid $765 million dollars by the Mets and looks like a genius for denying the $350 million offered by the Nationals in 2022. Juan Soto is fantastic - and Tucker is more of the same. In fact, their WAR numbers are similar since 2021 (26 vs. 21.6). Basically, Tucker is in line to be paid next year in free agency. He'll be 29 years old and I'd imagine the AAV will be ~$50 million per season for at least 8 years. This is a conservative guess, considering Soto is making $51 million per season for double the length. It would not shock me if Tucker surpassed a $500 million mark after bidding wars. If history tells us anything, Ricketts and the Cubs will not come close to this number (have already been burned on Swanson, Heyward, and Bellinger contracts).

In summary, Hoyer has paid what seems to be a high mark for a great rental player who will be placed on an otherwise slightly above average MLB team. Unless they win 90+ games in 2025 and make a postseason run, Cubs fans will be asking for Jed Hoyer's head on a silver platter and call out Rickett's penny-pinching tendencies after Tucker walks in FA, which is what Sox fans have done to their team for the past 20 years. I do think it is in the range of outcomes that the Cubs outperform expectations, but it's also possible we have two dysfunctional baseball franchises run by the lousiest owners in pro sports.


r/whitesox • • Apr 14 '21

Original Content Fire LaRussa

0 Upvotes

I’ve done it before. I can do it again.


r/whitesox • • Jul 12 '26

Question Base loaded, no outs, right?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/whitesox • • Feb 19 '23

Opinion I've never seen a sadder group of baseball fans

0 Upvotes

Nobody's saying you shouldn't be upset. We're all pissed at the team(even me!). But this sub rides that as 100% justification to be absolutely miserable, and the subs inability to laugh along at ourselves is straight up sad. We're a miserable bunch of folk in here, where doom rides popular, and any comments that aren't about overt negativity gets blasted into the sun. What a sad bunch of mopes


r/whitesox • • Jul 28 '26

Opinion Noah Schultz

0 Upvotes

is not a competitive pitching option right now

and the haters were right on the bullpen


r/whitesox • • Jul 29 '22

Opinion what's with all the negativity in this sub?

0 Upvotes

I get the Sox are playing well below their potential but all the negativity and nonstop "we suck, this team is done" and "why am I even watching this" and all the other whining gets so old. this place is one big negativity circle jerk.

yes the team is playing like shit but come on, we have one of the easiest schedules coming up, we're not that far out of the race, teams go through good and bad streaks....there's still time for the team to find their footing and make the playoffs. so drop the nonstop floods of negative bullshit and let's turn this shit around


r/whitesox • • Aug 12 '26

Opinion Schriffin is doing his best to ruin another great game

0 Upvotes

Twice tonight, he’s been badly fooled along with the crowd on a deep fly ball. You’d think he would have a better idea of what’s going on with the best seat in the house.

Can’t even listen to the radio instead after the storms took out the signal. What a joke this hiring was, have to feel for Steve. Looking forward to Ishbia sending him anywhere else but here


r/whitesox • • Aug 25 '26

Discussion Castillo and Doyle trades were longterm acquisitions. Give Getz and the org time to fix them before dooming all over the trades

2 Upvotes

These guys are under contract for more than just this season. The organization saw something that can be fixed in both these guys. We've seen them do it with Vargas and others. Getz is cooking this season, and you just need to let him roll.

Give the team time to fix these guys before going full doomer on the trades.


r/whitesox • • Jan 05 '24

Opinion Why the Sox should trade Cease AND Luis Robert this season

0 Upvotes

We'll start off with Cease, the 2 previous statements aside, I like Cease, I wouldn't mind if he was extended and stuck around. He's probably the only Sox player left that I do like. My biggest issue with Cease is I don't think he's ever going to be a top of the rotation arm again. 2022 was a fluke and one that was insanely driven by luck. Everything pointed to that not being sustainable and what he did in 2021 was more what to expect. He did regress hard in 2023 and actually was a bit unlucky, however it wasn't all unwarranted. You know Ceases problems, so I don't have to tell you that his control is what is keeping him back and until he figures that out, he's at best a #2 SP, which isn't a bad thing, that's still very valuable, but I just don't think he's consistent enough to build around. Especially because he does end up taxing the bullpen because he tends to only go 5 innings each start. 

Cease has some of the best stuff in baseball, but when you are walking 10% of the batters you face and going to full counts on many others it's going to be hard to maintain success. Cease is very much like Blake Snell. Snell won the CY Young last year and was a beast, he also lead the league in walks and that's never been done before because stranding that many runners is more luck than skill. There's some skill to it, but it's very hard to repeat that from each year. 

If Cease was a bit more consistent I probably would be more open to keeping him, but that combined with the shitty sox front office and ownership, I just don't see the point. The main good thing about higher-end talent is it's not just 1 team valuing that player highly, it's a lot of smart publications and other teams as well. So say the Sox dealt Cease for KJerstad, Norby, and Povich for example, I would honestly trust that deal far more than the Sox doing anything else because they seem to only want former Royal players that they knew and know are bad. Yes, prospects don't always pan out and the Sox could absolutely ruin them, but otherwise Cease is just rotting away on the leagues 2nd worse roster in baseball, might as well get something for him. If they let him walk full well knowing they aren't going to compete, it would far worse than trying to take a chance on a few higher end prospects. Now the return has to be right, they shouldn't just move Cease for the sake of moving him, but SP is so weak that I don't think that'll be a problem. 

--

I do legit think they should trade Luis Robert this year. They won't and I get why, but I still think they should if not now, at the deadline. I don't think Luis Robert's value will ever be higher. Coming off a monster season w/ 4 yrs left on his contract would net a massive return to where it can in my opinion make the return to being at least decent way faster. 

The reason I think they should trade him is 2 fold, I don't trust him to ever stay as healthy as he was last year, he almost had 600 PA, which is awesome, but do you trust him to get that every year? I certainly don't. But lastt year he hit .265 with 38 HR and 20 SB right? Every definition of the word he was a super star last year. Health aside, most of the numbers actually back up what he did. He was a bit lucky in SLG and wOBA, but nothing that would make you think he's in for a down season in 2024 like a player in Cody Bellinger. The biggest concern is this. 

You know who this looks exactly like? Baez before he fell off a cliff

Players like this, similar to Tim Anderson, simply do not age well at all, it's because they don't learn how to hit, they are just able to make up for their lack of plate discipline with bat speed. So once that bat speed starts to dip even just a touch, it can drop off real fast and I think Robert is on a similar path. I do think Robert is an overall better hitter than Baez, so it might not be so drastic like him, but I don't think Robert has the skillset to keep up what he did in 2023, for 10+ years. 

He's likely to keep it up for the next 5 though, which then means you have to ask yourself, do you think the Sox can get back to being good within the 4 year window that the Sox have him. Say Robert repeats this for the next 4 years. He's going to command a 10 year $400-500 million contract based on how salaries are rising. Do you think the Sox are going to pay him? We all know the answer to that question. 

So that leaves the Sox needing to win within the next 4 seasons. 2024 is out, this team is hot dog shit. Let's look at what 2025 might look like:

  • C: Edgar Quero - This assuming he improves his play calling, he's likely to be a slightly above average Catcher

  • 1B: Andrew Vaughn - He's fine, I think he's a solid major league that just will never live up to his ceiling in large part cause the Sox suck at developing players

  • 2B: ¯_(ツ)_/¯, they do still have Jose Rodriguez in the minors, but he profiles to be an average player at best

  • SS: Colson Montgomery, he's one of only 2 players in the Sox whole farm system that is actually exciting...

  • 3B: Bryan Ramos - Profiles to be an average hitter, nothing exciting here, but he could be at the very least decent. They also could pick up Moncada's 25 mil option, but the only way that's happening is if he takes off this year.

  • OF: Luis Robert - stud

  • OF: Andrew Benintendi - Such a joke of a contract. I mean he's fairly cheap given the market, so I guess it's fine? He was 0.2 WAR player, so you're paying him 16 mil to be very very slightly above replacement, bravo sox.

  • OF: ??? - Colas, maybe? I kind of wonder if they didn't fuck up that kids mental with what they did last year. 

  • DH: Eloy, though I think he gets moved as well and honestly, I don't know that he's worth the 16 mil club options anymore. Sure he hits, but he can't field and can't stay on the field to hit.

  • SP: Erick Fedde - I still think this was the right move to see if he can break out. Chances are if he's on the team for 2025 though, he sucks

  • SP: Michael Kopech - Yeah he's done too, he needs to be moved to the pen, I just don't think he stuff is good enough for the SP role especially now. He was one of the worst pitchers in all of baseball last year.

  • SP: Noah Shultz - This might be a year too early, but he's the only other prospect to be excited for

  • SP: Jake Eder - I still have some hope here too

  • SP: Jake Nastrini - Electric fastball, but I think he ends up in the pen

  • Other SP Option: Cristian Mena - He rose quickly in prospect rankins in 2023, until he hit a wall and fell off the face of the earth, there's some talent there if they can unlock what he did at the start.

This is also assuming the Sox trade Cease. If the Sox trade Cease, especially with a team like the Os, they could easily upgrade that lineup at multiple spots, like if they got Norby and Kjerstad, that fills in 2B and OF instantly.

So all this to say, does 2025 look that much closer to competing? A bit, but it's also quite young and the rotation is basically a bunch of lottery cards with Schultz being the only one that has a good chance at being an ace. 2026 they have hardly no money tied up besides Robert, Benintendi and Eloy (Club Option), so then it's just arbirtation for a lot of guys that will be off the team by then (Like Gavie Sheets, Tanner Banks, etc). 

So this huge ass thing to say, I just think the Sox are so far away that keeping both Cease and Robert is a mistake because they'll just rot on horrible teams. 2026 is at best the soonest they could even be somewhat decent and even that is a long shot since they would need everyone to pan out and we all know that won't happen.


r/whitesox • • Aug 28 '20

Discussion I think the White Sox shouldn't play tomorrow (Friday)

0 Upvotes

Solidarity with other teams, and solidarity with this larger political/cultural moment, is more important. Baseball can wait!


r/whitesox • • Dec 17 '19

Meme When the FO doesn't sign top free agent pitchers last year.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/whitesox • • Apr 17 '24

Original Content Vaughn the Untouchable

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/whitesox • • Aug 28 '24

Discussion People are always on about “Jerry doesn’t spend money” but is that really the problem?

0 Upvotes

There are 13 teams in the league with a lower payroll than the White Sox in 2024 and they are all performing better. Amongst those teams are the twins, royals, brewers, orioles, guardians. Those are some of the best teams in the league.

How is it that we still blame Jerry for not spending money when all of these other teams can figure out how to develop winning teams on a lower budget?

And how do these teams figure out how to succeed???

Player development and analytics. The white Sox have infamously been behind on new technology, analytics, and proper development. They still operate on a very old school model.

This leads to all the blunders and “White Sox moments” because every good team in the league is one step ahead of every single play. This could also be a result for all the injuries seen every year.

The point is that money doesn’t need to be allocated to the players, it needs to go to new scouts, coaches, internal staff and front office, facilities, equipment, and as much knowledge as possible.

The sad news is that Getz before becoming the GM was head of player development for the white Sox… so a failure like him is not going to have any understanding on that issue

But anyways it’s not all about money. The dodgers and Yankees have a lot of money and yes it helps but the reason they are dominant every single year is because of the fact that they have the best coaches and staff in the world. Mets are leaders in payroll every year and yet somehow always struggle to get in the playoffs.

What do you guys think?