r/wheeloftime • • Dec 17 '23

Show: Latest Season & Adapted Books Unpopular Opinion - The WoT show is really really good.

40 Upvotes

So I follow a few subs having to do with fantasy, and I have yet to see one saying the show was a good show. Honestly, the level of hatred that this show has accumulated is really astonishing. I was expecting (based on the flame posts raining down) to see a garbage, crap acting, crap directing, crap CGI snore fest. Read the books when I was a teenager, reread within the last 10 or so, and consider them one of the pillars of why I love fantasy books.

So going into the series, I (and told the wife based on these posts) told her to not expect much. We planned to bounce right off this and onto something else, but here we are on s2ep6 and she loves the series. I point out occasionally where the series has deviated from the books, but for the most part the deviations don't make the series worst, just a little different (and slightly surprising to me).

What is really sad, is I don't expect this series to come close to finishing. Based on the venom and bile it has created, I would hope no other group even attempts a book to show adaptation. Having spoken to several people who watched it and recommended it to me, only one of them read the books. I feel like its a lost cause, seeing as you will either enrage the neckbeards who worship the holy scriptures or bore the average show watching public.

Being a huge Drizzt fan, I always wanted to see an adaptation. After seeing how this show was received, I rescind that wish. My hope now, leave the books to the readers and let every person pitching a book to show adaptation be booted onto the street, period. Shame really, cause I would have likes to see this finished, and I just don't see how it could in the face of such controversy.

Update: seeing as this post has over 100 replys AND I got downvoted to oblivion, my estimation of the shows popularity among the scripture lovers is spot on. Here’s hoping your ability to influence this show ends at my post!


r/wheeloftime • • Feb 07 '24

Show: Latest Season & Adapted Books Unpopular opinion: I like the show even more after reading the books. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Now, before you come for my head, hear me out. I love the show. It’s what introduced me to the books. So far, it’s one of my favorite book series. I am into The Shadow Rising right now. I am trying my hardest to keep the two stories separate in my head, while understanding that they’re in the same universe. I never expect a visual adaptation of a book to come close to its source. I’ve seen it too many times to expect any different.

There are things that the show changed that made no sense and seemed to make more work for the show and the viewers. We can beat that dead horse until the sun stops shining. And there are things that the show changed that I’m ok with for time and content purposes. Some of these are hills I will die on. Lol! But some things that were cut were part of the added detail in the world building. The show, on more than one occasion, left me scratching my head, wondering why someone did something or why something was happening the way it was. The most immediate example to come to mind was the Red Ajah. The show just paints them up to be angry man haters with no cause. Why would the other Ajahs work with them? Why are they so mad at men? The books go much further into that detail and that their entire job and purpose is hunting down male channelers. They’re not just angry at men, they are hunting them to prevent further death and damage. They are one of several tools in the toolbox that keep everyone safe. There are many examples, but to keep from writing a book of my own, I’ll just use this example.

Knowing those details now, a lot of holes are filled in on the show leaving a more complete story and a better understanding of what happens in the show. At least, now, I can explain these small details to the wife to fill in the holes for her as we’re watching.

You may have my head now.


r/wheeloftime • • Oct 04 '23

No Spoilers Season 2 feels like a flop

31 Upvotes

Hands up, Ive read the books. I know a lot of book readers were disappointed with Season 1 but I understood that the TV show cannot be a word for word clone of the books and there were even some bits that weren't in the books that really worked (looking at you S1E4) but it seems that the writers and producers have missed the criticisms they got and doubled down in S2.

Game of Thrones was there as a perfect example of why sticking as close to the books as possible works better, use the language, conversions and plot devices that a skilled author has spent years cultivating and trim only what you have to. As soon as the writers on GoT ran out of book material the TV show suffered.

It feels the same here in S2, which should never happen when you have an abundance of material to use. The scenes with Egwene as Damane were great, Nyneave testing was good, the rest has been largely irrelevant filler. Lots of short scenes of people not saying very much to each other and not advancing the story to any serious plot point (to a book readers eye)

Perrin and Mat largely left to walk around for a bit until they get a few seconds to remind us they stil exist and what conversations they do have are throw away and forgettable

Im not saying they need to completely follow the book but they have moved so far away from the written story and replaced it with a lot of........ nothing really.

Feels like they are deliberately trying not to use the source available and come up with their own adventure to the detriment of the story. TV viewers who haven't read the books may not be entirely disappointed ( but my kids who watch it with me are already beginning to get bored with it) but they wont understand what the show could have been.

Like the title says, I had hoped this would be a step up from season 1 by going back to the books and using the source more but it hasnt and if anything its divested further leaving it feeling like a flop to me, personally.

I just want to make it clear, I think the cast are doing a great job, especially when they actually get a scene with some emotional acting required and not some random conversation for 10 seconds but they are being let down by writers and producers who seem intent on pushing the story away from the books to make something of their own that just isnt near the standard thats been set

Edit to replies:

Lot of interesting replies. Thanks to everyone who took time to chip in. This was always just my opinion and it probably is tainted with the counterstrike of having read the books. But the discussion here is not just about my opinion, it never was, its about us all!

Seems like most people who haven't read the books are enjoying the show and that's great. Im not trying to take anyone's enjoyment away, I couldn't. If you are enjoying it, brilliant, you have soooo much more to enjoy, the show has only scratched the surface and hopefully like the books it just gets better and better.


r/wheeloftime • • Dec 19 '23

ALL SPOILERS: Show only Just discovered this show and I think it is by far the best storyline of any fantasy show.

0 Upvotes

I haven't picked up a book in ages, but I'm a fantasy nerd who loves good v. evil shows and a friend of mine recommended this show.

Just finished the last episode of season two and I can't believe how good this is. I'm 35 years old and gushing over all 7 of the characters. The 5 + Maraine and her bodyguard (forgot the name).

It's almost making me want to read the books, is there any other media for them? Has this show been adapted before? Any merch for it? Preferably action figures?

My other question is something I feel the show does not address:, What do the five represent? Rand is The Dragon Eguane is The Shield and then we have a wolf, legendary hero and wisdom? Is that what they are portraying?

Reminds me of Power Rangers, Mariane = Zordon ..etc

Glad to have found thus community.


r/wheeloftime • • Feb 10 '24

Latest Nielsen data per @TVGrimReaper has WoT as the most popular show behind Reacher (even above The Boys)

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/wheeloftime • • Nov 14 '23

SHOW ONLY The racial diversity in the show bothers me Spoiler

622 Upvotes

Now, I get that I am probably going to get down voted into oblivion and this is probably a very unpopular opinion. However the racial diversity in areas like the Two Rivers and among the Aiel makes no sense. These are people that almost never introduce new blood into the gene pool. I don't really care what race would have been selected. But they should have all been the same race. At least in my opinion.

I am very much enjoying the show. However this view I hold that certain groups should be made up of the same racial background is breaking my emersion. Can anyone help change my point of view here because it bothers me. Also I feel like I'm partially in the wrong because in a way I am arguing against racial diversity.


r/wheeloftime • • Apr 14 '25

Show: Season Three Show wasn’t half bad Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So season 3 honestly wasn’t half bad. It’s an acceptable adaptation of a series that I never thought we’d see. Why is Ruidean still covered in a dense fog, also fuck yeah Rand going back in time? Does Mat get his staff, but fuck yeah he still puts down Gawyn and Galad. What the fucks going on with Loial? I can’t be the only one happy with some of this right?


r/wheeloftime • • Sep 05 '23

All Print: Books and Show After a great deal of thought. I'm loving the show.

29 Upvotes

After watching the first episodes of Season 2, I have to say. Honestly.

The cast, writers, directors, showrunner have all done the impossible.

I started reading this series in the early 90s. It wasn't completed until 2013. In the before time, after every book there was The Longing. The Longing was filled with speculation. Who is a darkfriend? Who is a forsaken?

We had no idea what was going to happen, but after every new book we had answers . . . And more questions. Longing and speculation again. Rereading. More questions. Arguments.

This is where, legitimately, they have all absolutely done the impossible.

They have recreated that experience without destroying the world we've lived in for so long. There's enough there for book readers to identify with, while changing the story just enough so we have no idea what is really going to happen.

What's going to happen in Episode 4? Not a clue. But I want to know and I'm looking forward to Thursday.

We didn't get what we wanted. We all eagerly looked forward to seeing Exactly the books, or as close as they could get, on screen. There's scenes we really wanted to see that we won't get.

But what we are getting is another turn of the wheel. Legitimately another turning. Where we can once again debate, argue, watch and rewatch to pick out details. Speculation, ponder, guess.

After a great deal of thought and watching a lot of comments and reviews and conversations. I'm glad to lean back in my recliner and watch the new kids get to experience what I did as a youngling.


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 14 '25

Show: Latest Season & Adapted Books The Wheel of Time Season 3 Keeps the Series Rolling Along Nicely – So Long as You’re Not a Robert Jordan Purist [Review]

Thumbnail
escapistmagazine.com
5 Upvotes

r/wheeloftime • • Aug 01 '24

NO SPOILERS Does Perrin ever become interesting?

2 Upvotes

Currently reading Shadow Rising and I've never really liked Perrin past the first book where his first interactions with the wolves and Elias was kinda cool, but now he's easily the most boring character for me.

Even his whole subplot with returning to and helping the Two Rivers folk is just so meh with him there imo (if it were literally anyone else I'd like it like 10x more).

Is this something that ever changes? I'm very new to the story and don't know how the fan base views him.


r/wheeloftime • • Nov 02 '23

All Print: Books and Show Q&A

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve seen people do this on other fantasy fandoms and it was hilarious. I’m taking a sick day and need something to do, so here I am, ready to give deep literary insights, character analysis and so forth.

Moderate spoilers are ok. I mean, don’t spoil the best plot points just for the sake of spoiling them, but if you think of something funny to ask or comment, don’t hold back.


r/wheeloftime • • Dec 05 '21

All Spoilers Allowed - Books and Show If Amazon wanted to create the next Game of Thrones... Spoiler

85 Upvotes

Then why didn't they follow the model of Game of Thrones and simply trust the source material and put it faithfully on the screen?

Obviously the last 3 seasons of Game of Thrones left much to be desired, but aside from the most minor of details being changed and a few plot lines being excised, it was an extremely faithful adaptation.

What's the point of getting your hands on an extremely successful and popular IP if your intent is to disregard pretty much everything about it when creating an adaptation?

Does anyone actually believe that Rafe Judkins is a massive fan of the books when you see this turd of a show and how it disregards basically everything that made the books special?


r/wheeloftime • • Oct 09 '23

SHOW ONLY So sad season 2 is over it was great, roll on season 3 Spoiler

31 Upvotes

Season 1 wasnt great so I didn't have high expectations for season 2 but it was incredible! Everything seems to have been maxed out, the writing, the performances, the amazing set and costume design. It became my top series. Can't wait to see the gang take on the Forsaken. BTW I haven't read the books so don't know about changes from them.


r/wheeloftime • • Sep 07 '23

SHOW ONLY The WoT TV series was NEVER going to truly appease avid fans of the book series, and I'm fine with that Spoiler

0 Upvotes

We are talking about translating 4.4 million words / audiobook 461.5 hours to an extremely abbreviated format. I don't think any showrunner is capable of doing this unless given an unlimited time and financial budget. Even then, it would not likely be palatable to a mainstream TV audience. Cuts are made. Stories change. Characters are modified and merged. Plotlines are shorted or lengthened. Character arcs shift in trajectory. Casting doesn't fit the ideal of our imagination, or changes mid-show. It is a wholly different medium. This has even happened with some of my favorite book/TV series like The Expanse (read / watch it if you have not), which was much easier to adapt.

The WoT TV series is a good example of exposing a new audience to the worldcrafting of Robert Jordan. Since he is not able to weigh in on the development of the show, we would expect more departure and license to be taken with the source material. This isn't Game of Thrones or Handmaid's Tale, where the license is in consultation with the author as EP. We can only rely on Brandon Sanderson's positive inside take, since he arguably knows Jordan's vision better than anyone else, and I agree with him. The source is an immensely difficult work to adapt to screen. Anyone believing the adaptation would be faithful had insurmountable expectations. Everyone can find flaws and things they would do differently.

I feel the same way for shows like Foundation. Very difficult to adapt. Very entertaining to read. Very entertaining to watch, even if I did not respect the huge lift it would take to do so. I am just getting into season 2 of both Wheel of Time and Foundation, and I am enjoying the shit out of both. I'm even looking forward to The Rings of Power season 2. There is simply a dearth of good fantasy / sci-fi series on TV to nitpick and whine about what will likely be the ONLY OPPORTUNITY to see these worlds in another medium than print. I'm here for it.


r/wheeloftime • • May 26 '25

NO SPOILERS Even if the show would had been a success still wouldn't had been made a second more faithful adaptation of the books anyway.

7 Upvotes

I keep seeing the fans of the show saying that because it failed that means there are no chances of a faithful adaptation anymore. So people that didn't like the show lost also. But I would argue that is a fallacy because of a several reasons:

  1. If the current show would had been a success there would not a point in retelling the same story, especially since it would had been hard to top the budget. More likely we would had received a bunch of spinoffs in the same "universe" by the same creators or team even less faithful to Jordan's vision.

  2. The very success of the show would had signaled to Amazon and the producers that they don't NEED to be faithful the the books. And that would only lead to other Fantasy IP's suffering the same treatment as Wot, RoP or Witcher

  3. If the show would had become a global success for many people, especially the ones that did nor read the books, then the show would have became the "Canon" story.

So at the end, what did people that didn't like the show loose in the end? A show that they stopped watching anyway, and a the promise of a more faithful adaptation the would have never came, at least not in the next decade anyway.


r/wheeloftime • • May 27 '25 Polished Gold Turd

Show: Season Three The Wheel Weaves as the Wheel Wills. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

“The Wheel of Time turns, and Ages come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legend fades to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Age that gave it birth comes again.”

What a perfect way to begin. And how true it is. The Wheel doesn't spin one story. It spins many. Each turning offers a new weave, a new chance to witness familiar patterns told in unfamiliar ways.

That is why I’m writing this as a love letter to the Wheel of Time TV show.

Imagine how much of the fandom missed out on fully enjoying this beautiful turning of the Wheel. So many were focused on whether the show matched the books scene for scene. They were caught in the expectation that it had to be an exact copy, rather than letting themselves enjoy the story as it unfolded in a new Age. They couldn’t see what the rest of us saw, a faithful spirit wrapped in new threads.

While some were upset about what changed, we were caught up in the incredible performances, stunning visuals, and emotional arcs. Moiraine’s opening monologue set the tone perfectly. Logain's terrifying charisma and quiet sorrow added a new layer to his character. Nynaeve's explosion of power was a breathtaking moment that stayed true to who she is. These moments didn’t take away from the books. They gave us something new to love.

Some fans said the characters felt different, but look deeper. Rand still carries the burden of destiny with quiet pain. Perrin continues to wrestle with his inner conflict between violence and peace. Egwene is driven, determined, and powerful. These are the same souls, just shaped a little differently by the Wheel’s current turn.

Other critiques focus on pacing or rearranged storylines. But Robert Jordan himself wanted his world to feel alive. The show builds that living world in its own way. It is not perfect, but it is bold, heartfelt, and full of potential. It condenses some things and expands others. It takes risks, but never forgets the heart of the story.

And here is the truth: Robert Jordan believed in different versions of the story. He was open to adaptation and variation. He once supported an animated project. Harriet, his widow and editor, has supported this show. Jordan knew that the Pattern allows for change. He knew that every turning of the Wheel tells the story in a new way. And he trusted the Wheel to do just that.

So for those of us who embraced this version, we didn’t miss out. We got to see the Wheel spin again and reveal new beauty. We got to feel the old magic in new ways. And while others were stuck counting changes, we were watching the Pattern unfold.

This is another weave of the Wheel. Not a replacement, not a mistake, but another thread in the great Pattern.

And I’m so glad I got to witness it.

The wheel weaves as the wheel wills.

 


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 26 '24

Book: A Crown of Swords I am losing my patience with Rand Spoiler

8 Upvotes

I am on Book Seven now, and have been patiently waiting to like Rand again, and well… it’s just not happening. What once was the arc that I looked forward to the most is now my least favorite by a wide margin. I now dread his sections and impatiently wait to be back in the shoes of literally any other character. He has slowly become the most humorless, arrogant, unreasonable, clueless and abrasive character in the books.

I understand all the plot contrivances that require him to be a brooding, troubled, misunderstood jerk, struggling with his sanity and his power, but it doesn’t mean that his chapters need to be such a chore to get through. His entire identity has been boiled down to not trusting any of his friends, blindly trusting obvious villains, and whining. He has done next to nothing meaningful in like 3 books, except chasing away everyone that wants to help him out of some misdirected and completely ineffectual desire to “keep them safe,” complaining about being surrounded by nobles while doing nothing about it, and being mind-numbingly oblivious to all the women throwing themselves at him (for what reasons I cannot fathom). Currently he is whining about deserving the gallows for having consensual sex with Min despite her being, clearly, the one to initiate. His entire arc with Avienda made me want to pull my hair out. Like, girl, why do you even like this guy again?

It’s also hard to ignore that if he spent half as much time as he does whining about Lews Therin in his head, just having open and honest conversations with his supporting cast, 90% of his problems would evaporate. I get the drama has to come from somewhere, but it’s so counterproductive that it seems forced. Unfortunately that’s an issue that plagues every character to some extent, but given his position and goals, it’s especially exasperating.

Clearly I have some pent-up frustrations over the character lol, but I really would love to start enjoying his character again. Does Rand ever stop being insufferable? Does he ever redeem himself?


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 21 '25

Show: Season Three Too well groomed?

1 Upvotes

Does it bother anyone else how well groomed everyone is? It keeps taking me out of the show when the guys have perfectly shaved faces, everyone’s hair looks like it was professionally styled and then messed up a tiny bit. Everyone is a bit too good looking, etc.


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 27 '25

Show: Season Three The show is amazing!

0 Upvotes

As someone who read the books 20+ years ago, isn’t the show amazing? I feel like they’ve added so much nuance and humanity to the characters, and brought the world to life.

Selene is such an interesting character, which in the book was kind of 1 dimensional and then just disappeared.

Love the show. They’re doing a great job.


r/wheeloftime • • Oct 08 '23

All Print: Books and Show Okay, so hear me out.... Spoiler

49 Upvotes

I just watched the last episode of season 2 and let me be the first to admit that I was too hasty in my earlier criticisms after watching episode 2 of the 2nd season.

Now, I'm sure there are things we can still be picky about (visions of Lan in sandals and flowing robes) but I will not sully the incredible efforts of all those involved in creating this 2nd season with my coach potato "critical insights". My unadulterated opinion of the 2nd season is that they nailed it. They flaming nailed it! DOVIE'ANDI SE TOVYA SAGAIN!!!

I think as fans of the series we don't want a play by play of the books. We know this is not possible. But you want to see a television interpretation of your beloved series that evokes feelings similar to the books. At least that's what I wanted. I knew season 2 was looking to be good in episode 3 with the clever portrayal of Nynaeve's accepted test. In episode 5 with Egwene's damane journey I was like okay, these folks are not playing around! By the 7th episode I was content and enjoying the series for what it was. It wasn't perfect but I thought to myself that, given the inherent challenges of translating the series to television, they had done a very good job. Suddenly it was clear how Covid-19 and one actor quitting truly had undermined them.

Then the season finale happened. BLOOD AND BLOODY ASHES!! It wasn't just one or two moments I enjoyed. There was layer upon layer of appreciation and enjoyment. I can't remember when last a TV show had me leaping from my coach in delight. I'll save my specific praise and opinions for a later post. My biggest highlights include Mat's redemption, Egwene's final confrontation with Renna, Hopper's death and how Perrin ends up killing Bornhold Sr., Moghedien's appearance and more, so much more! It really felt so layered, interconnected and well crafted. And the way they tied it into the books high points.....flaming well done man, well done!

There is so much more I want to comment on but I'll leave it here for now. Pretty excited for what's coming next!


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 19 '25

Show: Latest Season & Adapted Books i really can’t stand nynaeve

12 Upvotes

might need to be re-flaired, but pretty much the title. i haven’t yet picked up the books, but i love the overall story so i think i will soon. anyways, idk if its on purpose or smth but i genuinely hate her character. she’s been nothing but selfish, prideful and a self-proclaimed know it all. she’s also shown no humility (in my opinion). i know that she’s supposed to have a character arc in s2 but i couldn’t tell the difference in her personality between s1 or s2. i also think her relationship with lan is stupid, but that’s another personal opinion. if anyone can change my mind i’d be glad bc idk how much longer i can suffer through her scenes.


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 18 '25 This

Show: Season Three WoT Show I actually looked forward to S3 then... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

For context: fan of the books, fan of Tolkien. Despise the travesty of RoP. But, after watching s1 and s2 of WoT, honestly I had been enjoying the series. I have always felt like the books just went on too long, were too dense, and the project of distilling the best of the books into 7 seasons of 8ish episodes might actually make the series more digestible.

I watched the first episode of S3 and I'm sorry. The honeymoon is apparently over.

I could take Rand and Egwenes relationship being consummated in s1. They aged up the characters so fine. But I knew their paths were going to diverge so fine. Then she stands up to the tower so decisively but falls into his arms one last time for what reason? It just served to undermine her independence and decisiveness. There was literally no reason other than "duhhh people like sex so give them sex".

Then there's the shoehorning LGBTQ content into the series. Again, was fine with what they did with S1 and 2. Moiraine and Siuan? Ok, it could be argued that subtext from the books became more overt, given our culture today and representation. Fine. But Aviendha and Elayne? Look. Book readers already know Rand is going to be in a throuple (quadrouple?) with Elayne, Aviendha and Min. But the women don't have to be "into" each other that way too. In fact it steals from the slow burn and confusion of the women as they wrestle with their love for Rand while knowing their friends love him too. I don't think it adds agency, it just adds raciness for no good reason other than promoting pan polycules. The characters aren't pan. Nothing in their characters speak to that. There are other characters that would have suited that interpretation much more easily if the writers really wanted to bring that in.

Now I guess I am finally recognizing the show runners are just flailing. It's still not as bad as the horror of RoP but the story is on its way to becoming unrecognizable. Is the Last Battle just going to be a huge orgy before or intercut with the fight scenes? Geez.


r/wheeloftime • • Jan 13 '22

SHOW ONLY I might get hate for this, but as someone who never read the books I thoroughly enjoy the show. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Unfortunate most of what I see on this sub is just hate that doesn’t give any credit to the writing, acting, or production value in general. I admit it’s far from perfect, but it’s also unrealistic to think the books and movie will be one in the same. Books are almost always better than TV/Movie adaptations because of the limitations of filming, production, budgets etc. Any adaptation suffers from this whether it’s LOTR, the Witcher, or even Harry Potter with it’s infinite budget.

I admit it’s also unfair of me to make this post without reading the stories, as it’s quite possible they did a poor job portraying the characters from their original versions. However I think they did a lot of things right with the show which is quite enjoyable in my opinion. They had a ton to cover in 8 episodes and they did a good job of getting a noob like me invested in the characters, interested in the story, and enthralled in the World of the Wheel. I may be way off base as a casual fan, but I think a little positivity might do this sub some good?


r/wheeloftime • • Mar 31 '25

NO SPOILERS Are my hardcovers of The Eye Of The World pirated or legit? And if they are legit, what edition are they/when are they from?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

So my hardcover copies of book 1 and 2 arrived a few days ago but I have a few doubts. The quality of the books overall was a little disappointing compared to the other Tor hardcovers I have (Stormlight Archive). The print quality isn't the best and it doesn't come with endbands too. And I've seen videos of book 1 having different art for the endpapers. But at the same time, the quality is too good for pirated books and I have never seen a pirated hardcover before. Also, if it matters, the list of all the WoT books includes everything up to A Memory Of Light on both books.