r/whatsthatbook • • Dec 01 '21

SOLVED help solve a fight with my girlfriend - book with monster clown that can turn into fears but NOT king's IT???

6.1k Upvotes

i say it's not king's IT she says it is. we've been disagreeing about this on and off for a year because she keeps bringing up scenes and going on about how good they were in the book but i've read IT and those scenes aren't in it. she says i read IT too long ago to remember. fair. it was a while. but she read it over five years ago too!

scenes she remembers that i don't remember in the og book: it was set at a school camp during the kid bits and there were adult scenes too 20-something years later but she doesn't remember them because they "weren't as good". the kids are different ages ranging from 5 to 20. there's a demon clown thing hunting them and it keeps turning into the things they're scared of to try eat them.

she remembers a scene where there was a rabid bear and one of the teenagers set it on fire using hairspray. at the end the clown is a female and there's eggs, and every kid in the camp ends up ganging up to try beat the clown to death with rocks. there's also a bit with some weird rapey werewolves but she's less certain about that.

she remembers some scenes that are definitely from IT too like the fridge and bill's bike and the bullies lost in the sewers so im pretty sure she's mixing up IT and some other book. i need to find the other book or we're both going to die mad about this. we need closure

sorry if this isn't the right place i don't use reddit but i'm desperate to solve this i need to be validated

she asked me to add this edit of things she also remembers even though she said she wants nothing to do with my search since she knows shes right - these are all quotes:

  • "the little guys died first and it was dreadful"

  • "there were so many horrible scenes in the camp bathroom king(she says)/the author as of yet unknown(i say) must have something against public bathrooms and by the time i was done reading i did too"

  • "someone died so enthusiastically they painted the wall with their insides"

  • "at least one person maybe more was described as 'unzipped' by the time the clown was done"

  • " there were at least two horny scenes" <-- look how can she say this and still think its king the man is like 80% horny scenes 70% scary scenes and theyre usually overlapping


r/whatsthatbook • • Jan 13 '20

Discussion You all are awesome.

1.4k Upvotes

I am constantly in awe of how someone can write the vaguest of details about a book and somehow, someone knows exactly which book they’re talking about. This sub is so important and you all are awesome.


r/whatsthatbook • • Apr 01 '21

really tricky one Book about a boy who lives in a cupboard and later finds out he is a wizard

1.2k Upvotes

I read this book around 2001 or so. The plot details I remember were that the boy was an orphan living in a cupboard in his aunt and uncle’s house. He had a really spoiled cousin but the main boy wasn’t really liked by his family. He was told his parents died in a car crash. One day the boy receives a letter from some school but his uncle doesn’t let him read it (I believe the letter was delivered by some type of bird, perhaps an owl). More and more letters keep arriving until his uncle snaps and makes them go to some shed on some island. Then someone appears instead of a letter and informs the boy he is actually a wizard and the letter was admittance to a magic school. Also he finds out his parents were actually killed by a dark wizard. I believe the man who picked him up was some kind of giant or something. Anyways the boy goes off to school and on the day he leaves he has to go through a wall of some sort at the train station. He ends up meeting two friends at school - a redhead and a girl who’s really smart. Also I think the school sorted students into four different groups and he and his friends were all in the same group. Anyways they go about their first year and I think at some point at the end they have a series of trials they go through and the boy has to fight the dark wizard that had killed his parents (the dark wizard had been attached to one of his professors all along). Oh and they fight a troll at some point and also in the trials they have to play chess.

Edit: thanks for all the responses everyone! Still haven’t found the book but maybe next year


r/whatsthatbook • • Oct 14 '21

Discussion I ONLY COME HERE BECAUSE SEEING PEOPLE FIND THEIR BOOK MAKES ME HAPPY

944 Upvotes

I don’t have a book title but I’m hoping this doesn’t get removed because this sub is so wonderful and I was curious if anyone else does this.

The happiness in people’s responses to a correct answer always makes me smile and feel relief. Even those that just say “Yes, that’s it” give me a solid sense of satisfaction. When a person says they’ve been trying to figure it out for so many years or they have only minimal snippets of details, and someone nonchalantly posts the title, the feeling is indescribable and incomparable. It may seem like I’m exaggerating here but it kills me when I can’t remember something, ESPECIALLY a book or story, and when it goes on for years it becomes painful each time it rears it’s head. I guess this sub is strangely therapeutic for me. Also, I have a master’s in library science so this is in my wheelhouse.

Anyway, thank you and carry on with ending the suffering!


r/whatsthatbook • • May 08 '20

Who else comes to this subreddit just to find book recommendations? lol

889 Upvotes

I always just read the summaries to see if there are any interesting novels based on the vague plot details haha


r/whatsthatbook • • Aug 28 '25

SOLVED My father read me some deeply racist sci-fi as a child, and I want to find the book.

829 Upvotes

My father read me some deeply racist sci-fi as a child, and I want to find the book.

TW: extremely racist plot, characterizations and just general awfulness.

My Dad loved sci-fi, and loved to read me old stories from when he was a kid. Since he grew up in the 40-50s, some of the old compendium he had contained some impressively racist stories. Apparently, 7yo me had no idea about any of it, but loved all the stories, so he just... went ahead and read them to me while feeling mildly horrified.

There's one that - years and years ago - he told me was a particularly "holy shit" moment. I also remember loving it, because it had ancient underground societies with crumbling archeotech, a surface world overrun by hordes of scary monsters, technological wizards fighting in multi-armed power armor, and hell, a quest to rescue a beautiful princess in a post-apocalyptic future!

Unfortunately, the halogen-lit tunnel complex the protagonist came from was the (last?) hidden refuge of white people on Earth, the scary monsters were supposed to be the mutated descendents of black people, and the tech wizards were (literally?) yellow yellow-menace-style Asians. I don't know if the protagonist needed to find the princess because he fell in love with her, or if it was some more insanity, probably involving eugenics.

I'm not sure why I want to find it. Maybe because it's so surreal remembering it, that I want to reassure myself that it actually existed? Maybe just to really fuck with my Dad? Also I can't recall how it ends, and that's deeply bothering me for some reason. I dunno.

If you know the title, please drop a comment.

Edit 1: You'll know you've got the right story if you come across multi-armed suits that have different powers, based on the number of arms. They're used primarily by the literally yellow-skinned tech-wizard ruling empire, but i think the white protagonist gets his hands on one to fight back.

Update: HOLY SHIT u/adsfuse, YOU'RE A GODDAMN GENIUS!

The anthology was Before the Golden Age, which contains Tumithak of the Corridors and Awlo of Ulm.

I'd blended the two stories from youth and time-worn memory. Credit to u/adsfuse and u/Maxinburra in r/scifi for getting it!


r/whatsthatbook • • Apr 07 '20

Discussion Going through this sub is wild if you read the titles as newspaper headlines

761 Upvotes

Not trying to find anything rn just a fun observation.


r/whatsthatbook • • Feb 05 '21

Problem with this sub!

746 Upvotes

About 99% of the time I read synopsis on this sub, I end up putting the book in my Amazon list. And frequently I buy it. I am drowning in literature and debt.

Seriously, I love this sub, I have read so many great books I would have never thought to try. Thank you!

EDIT: Thank you to everyone who had suggestions for getting books for free!

DOUBLE EDIT: Thank you for the awards!


r/whatsthatbook • • Dec 04 '24

SOLVED YA novel where the dad lies to trap half of his family in a bunker and impregnates his wife so they can eat the children.

674 Upvotes

When I think about this book I read in middle school it sounds so ridiculous considering it's most definitely a ya book, but I promise it's real.

It starts with this super rich family on Thanksgiving I think (they were talking about turduckins if I'm remember correctly). There's a Mother, Father, Older sister, teenage boy(Protagonist), twin brother, and grandmother(I think). And all of a sudden the dad gets his family into his underground bomb shelter because of a nuclear attack or something, but he leaves the protagonist's twin brother and the grandmother behind.

The family spends years in this bunker because it isn't safe to leave and they start to run out of food. Dad decides it's a good idea to start impregnating his wife so they can raise children to eat. I think they also drink the mom's breast milk, but I might have imagined that part.

After a while I think the Dad decides that his daughter could be contributing more and tries to get her to also start having children they can raise in a special room so they can eat them later.

The protagonist avoids the food children room until one day he decides to go in there and ends up bonding with one of his little brothers and starts to question why his father thinks it's a good idea to be eating these children.

In the end I think the protagonist uses an old laptop that was in the bunker for some reason to communicates with his twin and he realizes that his father is actually insane and a liar because there was never any sort of attack or threat.

There was also a second book, but all I remember about that one is that the protagonist falls in love and grabs the Girl's elbow.


r/whatsthatbook • • Feb 21 '25

UNSOLVED Woman accidentally kills ex-husband with incorrectly cooked rhubarb pie & then takes cooking classes so as not to kill anyone else.

661 Upvotes

All details are coming secondhand from my mom. She knows not the author, date, publisher, or cover art.

Potential details include a male neighbor with a new puppy. Man smells something foul & believes his nieces are boiling the puppy.

The murderess opens a bakery.

Paperback romance novel set in the "wild west."

No time travel.

Published prior to 2015.

Good luck!

ETA: If you're thinking "wild west" and "rhubarb pie murder romance" might narrow down the google results, I assure you it does not. Lol

ETA2: Allegedly not part of a series (I suspect it is part of a series, but she's unaware of that bc the book was lent to her as a singleton.)

ETA3: I'm back with fresh deets! Mom says the story is NOT a murder mystery; everyone in town knows who did it and it was accidental. The murderess was a new bride who was just trying to do something nice for her new first husband. She does get re-married after his death, making him technically her ex-husband. After that, she learns to cook, and then opens a bakery.


r/whatsthatbook • • Aug 30 '22

SOLVED Women can't fight in a war so a woman disguises herself as a man to fight in the war, meets a bunch of other secret women soldiers and finds out that her whole society is run by women pretending to be men

625 Upvotes

this was a book that was I was told about by my hairstylist 2+ years ago, all I know about it/remember are the plot points listed below. however the war I think was a fictional one so it's not historic fiction.

book that is about a girl who disguised herself as a man to fight in a war, she ends up in a platoon of all women who are also pretending to be men, then they get discovered and are sent to the high council who are all also women pretending to be men.


r/whatsthatbook • • Nov 05 '24

SOLVED (presumably) A middle age woman is depressed because her husband left for a younger girl, so she plans a dinner with everyone who hates her in hopes of being murdered by one of them

581 Upvotes

I've never read this book but I came across its synopsis around 2011/2012 in a magazine and it never left my mind;

I thought it could have had the perfect dark comedy movie adaption, but when I went to look for it two years ago I couldn't find it anywhere so Reddit is my last chance, otherwise it probably means that I imagined it and might write it myself (wish me luck) or that I remember it incorrectly.

I have asked ChatGPT, looked online, asked book lovers friends and yet nothing came up.

If it can help I am Italian so maybe the book was Italian and never got translated into other languages, I am not sure.

EDIT: 90% sure it is Invitación a un asesinato by Carmen Posadas, and, funnily enough, a Netflix adaptation just came out. I had a few different details in my mind and I don’t like the look of the adaption because I already set it in my mind with different actors and locations, but I think this is as close as we’re gonna get. I honestly lost all hope after over a decade but Reddit never disappoints.


r/whatsthatbook • • Mar 11 '25

UNSOLVED Raunchy, problematically colonial book about girl brought to England or other Western country from "primitive" island to live with a family, where she proceeds to have sex with pretty much everyone, but in an innocent this is my culture way NSFW

552 Upvotes

This book was in my primary school library. The cover was of The Wonderful Flight to the Mushroom Planet by Eleanor Cameron, but the book inside was completely different. I'd wager though that it was from a similar period as the misbound cover, so maybe 19th or 20th century pulp erotica? Very very smutty.

I never found out what the real title was and curiosity is eating me alive. I think the main character's name started with a T and was a princess of some sort back on the tropical island. The approach to sexuaity was possibly inspired by the Trobriand islands.

It was all very born sexy yesterday- she was constantly wearing very little clothing and unwittingly seducing people with no mind to how that was considered in 'polite society.' She has sex with most of the family I think. I remember that the family had kids, older teens or young adults, at least one of whom was a girl. I remember primary school me visualized her as Velma😭 so maybe she was described as shy or bookish or just brunette w glasses?

I think the parents or just the father were adventurers or anthropologists or colonial administrators or something. I may be wrong but either they or the whole family stayed on the island for a bit before returning with the girl.

Iirc the novel is not too long and either ends with the island princess returning to her people or assimilating to English society. Leaning towards the former.

I know how batshit this all seems but this has been killing me for well over a decade now. Appreciate the help.

Update: going to visit my childhood home in the summer, I'll let you know if it's still there (I never took it back)


r/whatsthatbook • • Oct 19 '20

(Meta) Telling us you forgot the title of a book on the post title is redundant

546 Upvotes

I usually do Reddit on mobile, so only a portion of a post's text appears below the title.

Why's that a problem?

Y'all. We know you forgot what a book was called. That's why you're in this sub. Giving us that in the title is wasted space. Telling us you're "trying to remember a book name!" is like saying "I'm posting on r/whatsthatbook". We know.

Give us details in the title. Genre. Year read. Plot or characters. I have no idea if I can help if you've "been trying to find this book for years" but I can pick my brain if I know literally anything about the book. It's in the rules of the sub. Please. Help a sleuth out.


r/whatsthatbook • • Oct 10 '20

Title OK ✓ Help finding my grandmother's pen name

527 Upvotes

Hi there. Not sure if there is a better place to post this but I was curious if anyone could help me with a bit of a mystery.

My grandmother wrote books under an unknown pseudonym in the mid-70s that were big enough to support a family of four and send all of them to college and grad programs on her own. We believe that she wrote 3 fictional books (possibly more) that she described as "controversial and disputatious but marketable". She is cryptic about the specifics and at one point revealed that "well read individuals were likely to have read her works", but that what she wrote wasn't "Pulitzer worthy".

We believe that she wrote under a masculine pseudonym and is still making royalties to this day (40-50 years later). She is very religious and refused to include sex scenes and was annoyed at her publisher requesting her to include sex scenes following the success of Bridges of Madison County in 1992.

When she wrote the books, she was located in Indiana and we have no information regarding who the publisher would have been or where they would be located. Aside from that, we know that she communicated with someone in Scotland, potentially about location details, along with a visit to Australia that may have been to look into location details for a book. She was a huge fan of Faulkner and Hemingway but was extraordinarily well read so I have no idea what all would have been influences.

Does anyone here know any relatively famous authors who published in the 70s and 80s, with work maybe more recently, and has never been identified?

[UPDATE] for those still following this post, my grandmother passed away surrounded by her four children a week ago. She was a remarkable individual who signed a last letter to the family as "THE CRAZY LADY", and who could probably have beaten me at chess at 91. She left all future proceeds of her books to Lutheran World Relief but provided no evidence that could link her to a specific author. All in all, she was a really cool lady and she will be deeply missed.


r/whatsthatbook • • Jul 30 '24

SOLVED Did you read this short story in school and get traumatized?

510 Upvotes

Trying to identify this short story I read in school. It was about two brothers on a walk. The younger one has a bad heart or something. He runs to keep up with older brother but collapses and i think he dies Older brother carries him home. Still traumatized by this story.


r/whatsthatbook • • Oct 29 '20

SOLVED Horror Book. A man hires a woman to read to his wife who cant speak, she starts to lift a finger at certain words to leaver messages, turns out the man has deliberately kept her drugged and unable to speak.

496 Upvotes

I thought it was a dean koontz book but i cant find it anywhere.

Edit: more info, I read it when i was a teenager so, 15 years ago maybe more. I remember the messages she is trying to give the carer/reader is that she is being held captive by her husband and needs help escaping. Also, i am pretty sure the husband either has a camera or listening device so he can see them and monitor them.


r/whatsthatbook • • Apr 28 '20

ANNOUNCEMENT Subreddit Rules & Help

481 Upvotes

Hi friends! It's been awhile; here's an updated announcement for the What's That Book? subreddit.

PLEASE FOLLOW THE RULES. There are only 2!

1. Post titles must have at least one book detail.

2. A post cannot have more than one book/series.

Please consider these points when writing your /r/whatsthatbook post:

Your Post Title

  • Briefly the book, not your situation. Avoid titles like "Help, I can't remember this book..." or "I read this when I was a kid..." or "I NEED HELP"

  • Include the overall genre of the book in your post title, such as "kids book" or "romance novel" or "scifi"

  • This is an official rule now and posts with vague titles will be removed

The Book

  • Fiction or non-fiction?

  • Describe the plot.

  • Describe notable characters.

  • What genre is it?

  • Physically describe the book -- Hardcover/paperback? Book cover color?

  • When was it set?

  • How long was the book?

  • Anything notable about the original language? Did you read it English? If not, what language?

... And You

  • When (what year) did you read it?

  • How old were you when you read it? Was it age appropriate?

  • Where did you get the book? School library, book fair, book store selling new and/or used books, flea market, borrowed from a friend, given as a gift from X person who is about Y age, or from an online store?

  • Was it new when you read it?

  • What age range was it for?


r/whatsthatbook • • Jun 29 '19

Discussion I just want to say how much I love this subreddit and how the descriptions all sound like the most awesome/terrible blurbs ever and I would absolutely read all the sought after books just based on the vague blurbs alone lol.

462 Upvotes

Seriously though, published books should have regular dramatic blurbs on the back but also casual blurbs like “two kids found a civilization in their attic but also WWI times???”


r/whatsthatbook • • Oct 20 '24

UNSOLVED Book I read in 1999, woman gives birth to twins while trapoed in a mine, then dies

459 Upvotes

The mum inititially gets trapped, births the twins and raises them to toddlers before dying. The twins survive by eating waste leaking in to the mine from a nearby factory, grow up feral and start leaving the mine for some reason. I'm pretty sure the cover was black, I've googled this for years because I remember I loved this book, and would love to see if it was as good as I remember, or whether I was just young 🤣


r/whatsthatbook • • Sep 24 '24

SOLVED Girl disguised as boy, never misses with her knives or I think arrows can’t remember which.

444 Upvotes

Read this long time ago but can’t remember title or find anything on google. Basically a girl disguises herself as a boy, she is great at either knife throwing or shooting arrows(can’t remember which) and never misses. She comes across a group of men (knights, mercenaries or something) who take her under their wing, I think they use her as a squire or something, they don’t know she’s a girl. Anyway main character picks on her a bit but finds he’s becoming attracted to her which confuses and frustrates him because he only likes women, He even has her wait outside on a doorstep while he spends time with a prostitute but leaves angry and unsatisfied and she doesn’t understand why he’s so angry. She also gets teased for being a pretty boy and gets hit on by women in a tavern with the guys. Can’t remember all that happens but I do remember she becomes known for never missing her shots and becoming a bit of a legend which the guys utilize to help rally support for their cause and the leader they support. I think there was some kind of war between two leaders going on. I also remember at the end they need her to dress as a girl using “him” of course because he’s the most feminine and can pull it off and it becomes evident to most that she is female but main male character is still oblivious. I think his brother or friend or something says to her that deep down MMC knows, he just hasn’t realized it yet. I believe this is a standalone book, I don’t remember there being any kind of sequel but I could be wrong. Definitely not fantasy, it takes place in medieval times I think but not for sure. Please help me find the title, I have tried everything else to track it down.

SOLVED SOLVED Just want to give everyone my appreciation for all the suggestions and help, I am happy to say this has been solved! A shoutout to cactusjude and illusiveGamerGirl, The book is ‘LADY OF THE KNIGHT’ by Jackie Ivie, thanks again!


r/whatsthatbook • • Apr 04 '21

You should know: You need a descriptive title and text to find a book.

408 Upvotes

Hello dear people in search of lost books. Here is some help how to get help finding your book.

  • You need a title that reflects the book

"I can't remember the title of a book" well, so does everybody else here. Describe the book. What genre does it have? What does the protagonist do? Is a wolverine fighting a joghurt? The thing that stood out for you most likely also did for other readers.

  • Describe when and where you read the book

"I was a junior in highschool" nobody knows when that was. It doesn't have to be exact, but a time-frame helps. So does the country you were in whilest buying (or borrowing) and reading it. Also, what language was it in?

  • Write what happens in the book

The most obvious one. What do you remember about the book? Did Medusa fall in love with the Grim Reaper? Was the grandmother from Little Red Riding Hood the Witch from Hänsel and Gretel? Had the protagonist cake for breakfast every day? Just write up what you know. Don't be shy. Write everything down. Every detail helps.

  • Who is the protagonist?

How old are they? Are they biting angels for a living? Do they have a cat? Are they PoC? Is their hair blue with orange dots? This person is so important, a whole book was witten about them. Tell us what makes them themselves.

  • What else do you remember?

Was the author a man, woman or non binary? What country did the story take place in? What year or century is it in the book? Did the narrative change between characters? Was the writing style overflowing with imagery or short and to the point? Are there pictures? We want all the side notes.

In short: Please help us helping you. You don't need to cross off every box, just the ones that you can. And now go and have some fun finding your lost book or make somebody happy with a forgotten title.


r/whatsthatbook • • Mar 07 '20

SOLVED My wife passed away in October, she and I listened to an audio book series. We had to wait for one more book to come out but I can't remember the name. I think it's urban fantasy about the rise of magic. Please help me remember so I can listen to it for her.

395 Upvotes

The books were set in modern day and magic came back to the world, or just got stronger? I believe it starts out with a man and woman in an apartment, when some cosmic event or flash of light happens, I think technology dies and magic rises. The world is in chaos, they leave the city and are on a trek across country, they have to fight evil and non magic people along the way. At one point in the journey the woman has to use a subway tunnel to get across a river or something, she runs into flying demons that she feels are pure evil. She has to lay down and hide beside the tracks and when she gets up realizes she is covered in rotting human flesh and goo. They finally end up in a small town that people rebuilt who are tolerant to magic and live peacefully together. They even got a radio station to work. Then the town gets attacked by evil people and the man dies in a cornfield in the battle. I will add more if I can remember something else important, it is hell getting old and senile, then losing the only other person that could tell you. Again Please help and Thank You!


r/whatsthatbook • • Apr 24 '25

SOLVED Book about wild children who are allowed to play until the girls get their period

385 Upvotes

YA book The children play wild in the summer. Camp out on beaches etc. Their families leave food for them. But the play stops once the girls have their period. I think someone tries to starve themself to prevent their first period. There is a wasteland somewhere.

SOLVED: GATHER THE DAUGHTERS and sorry not YA I just had a very hazy memory

Sorry I can't see how to change the flair


r/whatsthatbook • • Aug 15 '20

SOLVED Book written in English but slowly shifts to being written in an alien language.

384 Upvotes

Science fiction novel Starts in English but gradually transitions to an alien language Lexicon/translation guide for the alien language in back Originally published before 1970 (probably)

My father remembers reading a book when he was younger (born in 1948) that started off being written in English, but as you read every so often a word would appear in a alien language. There was a lexicon in the back where you could look up what the alien word was. As you progressed through the book, it gradually shifted from English to the alien language so that the last chapter(s) were written in it entirely. He thinks he read it in his late teens or early 20s, but isn’t sure. Have tried many different googles but can’t find anything approaching the correct answer.

Thanks in advance for the assistance.