r/whatif • • Nov 06 '24 Polished Gold Turd

Politics What if Democrats did a proper primary and came up with a better more qualified candidate

3.6k Upvotes

This is what happens when you try to jump the process. Harris currently outspend any candidate within the last 2 months. Got most billionaires to endorse her. Yet it wasn’t enough. Better luck next time.


r/whatif • • Aug 03 '24

History What if the U.S. abolished political parties and each candidate had to run on the issues alone?

2.6k Upvotes

Imagine we finally listened to George Washington and did away with political parties. Suppose we banned PACs and overturned Citizens United.

What would it look like if Americans actually had to study up on each candidate’s positions and each candidate had to actually have real policy positions?


r/whatif • • Feb 05 '26 Helpful Bravo Heartwarming

Politics What if Mackenzie Scott (formerly Bezos) and Melinda Gates hired all those laid-off WaPo reporters and started newspaper that's run by a different kind of billionaire?

2.0k Upvotes

Is it too late? Could it have any positive effect? Has the ship sailed on journalism?


r/whatif • • Feb 18 '25

Politics What if we all say we’re transgender to avoid military draft?

2.0k Upvotes

Since Trump and Trump supporters want to invade Canada, Greenland, Panamas, Gaza, etc, We should avoid it at all costs.


r/whatif • • Feb 06 '25

Politics What if Trump’s plans to overhaul government has the opposite effect of what the left thinks?

1.6k Upvotes

This is purely hypothetical please don’t attack me.

Edit: I knew I would be attacked for this post so I am not surprised but I am editing to reiterate and clarify, I am not saying I believe this will happen and I’m saying plan as in whatever that plan may be.

Edit: I had a feeling this would blow up but not this big. There have been a ton of great answers on here from both sides and I appreciate them. Those who are not answering the question but immediately calling me names and attacking me simply for asking the question, be better. This has become too big for me to be able to comment much more. I cannot keep up.


r/whatif • • Oct 27 '24 Helpful This Take My Silver

Politics What if Trump wins....

1.5k Upvotes

And things actually do get better? No mass camps, no dictatorship, no political rivals jailed, but cost of living goes down, and quality of life goes up.....

[Edit: this is a pure hypothetical, not asking anyone to vote any which way, just want to legit know what people would do assuming all things listed came true]


r/whatif • • Oct 24 '25

Foreign Culture What if they don’t open the government back up?

1.1k Upvotes

We’re all watching the news about the United States having their government shut down, but what happens if they don’t open it back up? I.e the government just simply doesn’t undo the decision. What then?


r/whatif • • Oct 24 '24

Politics What if the Harris campaign spends a Billion dollars and she doesn't win?

920 Upvotes

She's set to be the first Billion dollar campaign and they are still neck and neck. Dead even. How could it be that she has so much to spend, 2 to 1 over Trump and may still lose.


r/whatif • • Sep 08 '25

Science What if NASA announced tomorrow that in one year, Earth will be hit by an asteroid that can’t be stopped, and will kill all life on the planet?

695 Upvotes

“You’re listening to 90.9 WBDG. If you’re just now joining us, the President of the United States has announced that Matilda, a 200 mile wide asteroid, is on a direct course with Earth, and will strike this planet within 12 months time. NASA has already confirmed that Matilda is simply too big to be destroyed, or even deflected, with mankind’s current technology. Humanity has one year left until the end of Humanity. Stay tuned as we keep you updated and count down to the end of times. This is WBDG, your station for variety.”


r/whatif • • Aug 29 '25

Science what if you took a baby from 2,000, 10,000, 40,000 etc years ago and raised them in modern times, would there be a discernible difference?

687 Upvotes

in terms of behaviour, brain, intellect, and physically, biologically, etc.

edit: what about neanderthals and disnovians?


r/whatif • • Nov 06 '24 Diamonds are Forever

Politics What if people would stop hating each other for different political views

631 Upvotes

We can all see right now that if someone did not vote exactly how they voted they hate them. Why? I don’t get it? It’s okay to vote for other people doesn’t make them a bad person. I don’t care who you voted for as long as you’re not shoving it down my throat. I have friends that voted differently than me and that’s ok! I don’t care. We move on with our friendship our friendship is not about politics anyway. I really hate this “you vote for opposite I’m not talking to you how dare you!” What if we just acted like adults? What if we worked together like adults and as Americans? The more we hate each other about views the more divided we get and that’s not good. Honestly even if you voted opposite there is a good chance a lot of things you can agree on. Just… what if we all act like normal adults.

Edit: 3 things. Yea know what? People have said things that made sense. For one. Your right sometimes the political views are to much to be friends.

For two. Someone in the comments said they were trans and are iffy about someone in a full trump getup. I understood that because those are usually the far righest and the far right is the ones that hate trans people. Key word here FAR RIGHT which I’ll admit is usually in the full get up. I can’t say anything about it either to be honest. I have been hated on for being a housewife and my husband being Asian from the left and if I see a full get up I’m gonna be kinda iffy. So I will defend that.

For three. You guys calling me names is not gonna do anything. I’m not upset at you, I don’t hate you. I hope honestly all of you get off this post and have a good lives. I’ll keep telling you that too.

You guys are fucking ridiculous at this point. I vote for trump I support trans and lgbt rights. you can not be going around claiming love for all then hating on Hispanic wishing abortions on people and deportation. You guys shot yourself in the foot. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ I am done reading comments. You guys can call me any name you want but it doesn’t mess with me at all tbh.


r/whatif • • Oct 01 '25

Other What if humans vanished tomorrow, what’s the one thing on Earth that would prove we existed 10,000 years later?

597 Upvotes

Not fossils - I mean something else. Imagine Earth 10,000 years after humanity suddenly disappears. Nature reclaims cities, buildings crumble, but what’s the single most undeniable piece of evidence that screams “we were here”? Would it be nuclear waste buried underground, satellites still orbiting overhead, plastic that refuses to decompose, or something we haven’t even thought about?

Curious what everyone thinks would outlast time itself as humanity’s final signature.


r/whatif • • Dec 06 '24 Heart of Silver

Foreign Culture What if the UnitedHealthcare CEO Assassin gets away with it?

586 Upvotes

Edit: apparently they found him

Luigi Mangione

He could still get away with it in court


r/whatif • • Feb 21 '25

History What if Ukraine WINS? The people are still for their president: Ukrainians rally around their president after Trump seeks to denigrate him

573 Upvotes

r/whatif • • Jan 13 '25

Non-Text Post What if someone published a fake news saying Trump, Elon Musk and JD Vance ordered an arsonist to start the wildfires in LA?

570 Upvotes

r/whatif • • Sep 11 '24

History What if the US Government didn't bail anyone out in the 2008 Recession?

550 Upvotes

r/whatif • • Feb 20 '25

Politics What if Canada in the near future begins offering asylum for people being persecuted by Trump?

529 Upvotes

r/whatif • • Aug 16 '25

Politics What if a Head of State just bitch slapped Trump?

517 Upvotes

A head of state from a country that is not on fire just back hands Trump at an event. Right across the face, in front of press and everything and then mocks him.


r/whatif • • Jul 30 '24

History What if Chris Farley never died? What if he sought help and lost weight?

498 Upvotes

Just curious here to learn of what could have been. I know he was doing voice work for Shrek at the time before he passed. I am curious to know just what if he did seek help for drugs and did lose the weight? How far you think he may have gone? Or could it have been one of those fizzled out actors (what I mean is that they were big in their time, but lost their spark or not doing a lot of work anymore). I could have thought he would have gone on to do a whole lot more and possibly stand up. Let me know your what if!!!


r/whatif • • Dec 30 '25

History What if every modern American was somehow transported back to 1775 America and they are located in the exact same spot there were in in 2025?

468 Upvotes

For example, a California dude was busy eating tacos but now finds himself in 1775 California. Same for a Boston man. And a Georgia man.


r/whatif • • Feb 24 '25 Thanks

Politics What if this sub stopped talking about Trump?

455 Upvotes

Fair question. Seems like 9/10 posts are about Trump and what people think about him. If the sub was forbidden from talking about Trump, what else would you talk about?

Would you be able to talk about anything else or is that it?

Would the sub implode because they would have nothing else to think about that they could post up?


r/whatif • • Mar 03 '25

Other What if instead of donating to a politician all these billionaires helped people with their money?

421 Upvotes

r/whatif • • Jul 29 '20

Lifestyle Still waiting to have my movie moment in a library

Post image
414 Upvotes

r/whatif • • Dec 10 '24

History What would happen if everyone collectively in the U.S. dropped their insurance provider

411 Upvotes

Like a mass exodus from all the major insurance and unsurance providers including companies

Edit: I was genuinely curious not suggesting anything by the way. Just wondering how the turmoil would play out chronolically