TLDR: Content creators are NOT wedding planners!
Iâm the Director of Sales at a reputable wedding venue in NY, and I also run my own wedding planning business on the side. Iâve been in this industry long enough to know what Iâm talking about.
I just wrapped up my last wedding of the season, and I need to get something off my chest: There is a serious difference between a wedding planner and someone who owns a camera, has a social media following, and planned their own wedding.
A lot of venues, including the one I work at, require couples to hire at least a day-of coordinator. If you can afford a full-service planner, even better. But please, PLEASE do your research before hiring someone.
New York is absolutely saturated with people calling themselves wedding planners who are actually content creators, hobbyists, or people who decided that planning their own wedding qualified them to start a business.
Let me give you two examples from my last few weddings.
I had a Halloween wedding where the planner was essentially MIA throughout the entire planning process. I worked exclusively with the mother of the bride because apparently the planner wasnât interested in communicating.
When deadlines came around for the floor plan, final headcount, and timeline, the MOB was doing all the work because the planner was unresponsive. Three days before the wedding (when all of this was due TWO WEEKS PRIOR), the planner requested a video call to finalize everything.
I ended up creating the timeline myself because the planner clearly didnât know basic reception logistics. She didnât know when speeches should happen, how long dinner service would take, or how to structure the evening. She actually showed up on time the day of, so I thought, okay, maybe thereâs hope!
My team and I had the venue set, but we do NOT handle decor setup. Thatâs literally one of the reasons we tell couples to hire a planner. Their job is to handle decor, vendor coordination, ceremony logistics, and generally make sure the couple isnât running around trying to manage their own wedding.
This planner arrived with her husband, who immediately set up an iPhone on a tripod. She then proceeded to film herself giving a monologue about wedding day planning.
Meanwhile, nothing was getting done.
She tried handing me the place cards for the dining tables. I politely told her that wasnât something I handled. She looked genuinely confused. About 30 minutes later, my coordinator came to me because the planner was trying to get HER to set up the escort card table. I told the planner my coordinator was busy with her own responsibilities. Decor setup was HER job. She actually argued with me that she had assigned my coordinator to handle it. I explained that MY coordinator have specific responsibilities and that doing HER job wasnât one of them.
Fifteen minutes later, I walked past the escort card table and found our bridal attendant setting it up with the mother of the bride and the maid of honor. The bridal attendant was supposed to be assisting the couple with transportation around the property for photos and other wedding-day needs. I asked her why she was setting up the escort cards.
âThe planner told me to.â
I immediately told her not to take any more instructions from the planner and went back to have another conversation with this woman. At this point, I had to explain that my staff were not her assistants (nor was the mother of the bride or maid of honor), and she needed to actually do the job she was hired to do. She threw a complete hissy fit.
A week later, I came across her wedding video online. And wouldnât you know it? Sheâs a content creator. A good one, actually. The video was beautiful, and thereâs absolutely nothing wrong with being a content creator. But she was NOT a wedding planner. She was clueless, disappeared throughout the wedding whenever we needed answers, and seemed to actively hide so she wouldnât have to do any actual work.
Fast-forward to the following Saturday. I was working with another planner who initially seemed great. We had done a walkthrough weeks before the wedding, she asked all the right questions, and I genuinely felt comfortable working with her. Then the final details were due. And suddenly, she disappeared.
I was chasing her for basic information like a final floor plan. FYI, sending me a picture of a floor plan you took on your phone, with no table numbers or guest counts per table, is NOT a final floor plan.
A timeline, rental information, etc. Another FYI, Sending me a screenshot of a rental order confirmation is not helpful if you donât include delivery dates, delivery times, and pickup information. She also neglected to tell me that the couple had rented shuttles. I had already charged the client for our in-house transportation, which was an additional $1,500 that could have been avoided. She knew about the shuttles and never corrected me.
But the real disaster happened on the wedding day. This planner somehow thought the wedding was contracted until 11:30 PM. It was contracted until 10:30 PM. She didnât realize her mistake until my captain asked her about the shuttle pickup times. At 10 PM, we gave her the option to extend the event for an additional fee. She declined. Didnât even bother presenting the option to the couple. So we proceeded with the contracted end time.
When the bar closed and the party started winding down, the father of the bride absolutely LOST IT. He had no idea the wedding was ending at 10:30 and started screaming at our staff to keep the party going. Unfortunately, by that point, we had already packed up after allowing them an additional 15 minutes with the music and dancing.
My staff and I watched this planner hand out gratuity envelopes to all the other vendors. Then she skipped our entire team. My staff was really disappointed. Now, I want to be clear: I NEVER expect a tip. Neither does my staff. Gratuity is appreciated, but itâs never something we demand. However, the couple had specifically asked me for recommended gratuity amounts, and I had provided them with that information.
My captain approached the planner before leaving and asked if the staff needed to wait for anything else, including gratuity. Her response?
âNo, I had a tip for you, but I was told not to give it to you anymore.â
I told her she was absolutely not welcome back at our venue after that stunt.
Apparently, I made enough of an impression because I received an email from the couple afterward apologizing that our gratuity hadnât been handed out that evening. They explained that it was a mistake and not something they had intended or even knew had happened. Theyâre coming back to drop off the tip this week.
So, hereâs my point.
PLEASE vet your wedding planners. Ask for references. Ask how many weddings theyâve actually coordinated. Ask what their responsibilities are on the wedding day. Ask how they handle timelines, vendor communication, setup, and unexpected issues.
A pretty Instagram feed is not a qualification. A beautiful wedding video is not proof that someone knows how to execute a wedding. And please understand that the vendor recommendations your venue provides are usually there for a reason. Weâve worked with these people. We know who shows up, who communicates, who anticipates problems, and who can actually execute an event.
Iâm not saying you need to spend $10K on a planner. Iâm saying hiring someone inexperienced just because theyâre cheaper can end up costing you a whole lot more in the long run.
You donât want your mother setting up your escort cards, your bridal attendant doing your plannerâs job, or your father screaming at the bartender because nobody bothered to read the contract.
A wedding planner should be making your wedding day easier, not creating more work for every other vendor involved.