r/webdev • • Oct 18 '18

Angular 7.0.0 released

/r/Angular2/comments/9pbn4f/angular_700_released/
223 Upvotes

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '18

I don't like Angular's policy a bit. Too many releases, too much confusion.

7

u/A-Grey-World Software Developer Oct 19 '18

Why is it confusing?

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '18

Too many breaking changes, libraries that need to catch up, documentation that works for angular 5 doesn't for angular 3, same for stackoverflow questions, etc, etc.

Of course if you know any of Angular 2+ it's not a problem to catch up with what are generally minor api changes, but it doesn't change the fact that for people (either devs or management) looking at Angular it's not really motivating. By the time you started developing your product on Angular 7 everything's already moved on Angular 8.

I just don't like this release policy and it's pretty obvious it's not just me and it's biting Angular's popularity.

6

u/A-Grey-World Software Developer Oct 19 '18

The only time I've ever come across anything that was out of date is when I've stumbled upon some stack overflow answers on the beta. I've followed tutorials for Angular 2 before and not had any issues doing it in Angular 5.

To be honest, I'd rather the framework doesn't stagnate like AngularJS did being too afraid to make any change.

Also, it seems exactly the same with React. Except it's instead of Angular 2 or Angular 6 or whatever, you're actually dealing with Redux version changes (that's had breaking changes), or is it MobX people use these days? Or which version of React Router are they using Because version 4 is a lot different from version 3? What form validation library are they using?

React is a rendering library. To cover the full capabilities of a full framework like Angular you're dealing with a load of libraries for routing, state management, forms, animation etc. All these not only have different versions but completely different choices.

With angular, you look up a tutorial or SO post and there's a good chance everything will still apply. With React, that's only the DOM stuff, god knows what combination of other libraries and what versions they are using. And it's even more opaque because with Angular you just have to look at the "I'm using Angular 4" and you know exactly what they're using. With React, it's "I'm using React with Redux v3 and React Router v 4 with Redux-form!".

Ultimately both look to have similar churn, when you compare Angular to the React ecosystem, which is what it should be compared to.

5

u/Lauxman Oct 19 '18

There is no Angular 3 lol. Perhaps you don’t like everything you are ignorant about?