r/wealth • u/LoudInteraction1761 • 10d ago
Question Why Does Tech (Software/Hardware) Create Wealth Faster Than Finance?
New York (or Manhattan) is a global center for about 200 years, yet Silicon Valley has reached a market value nearly equal to it in just 50 years.
Moreover, New York draws its strength not only from finance but also from a wide range of other sectors, such as media, law, fashion and healthcare, as well as from global elites (politicians, celebrities, global business people from all around the world..)
Silicon Valley, by contrast, reached a valuation in the trillions within just 40–50 years, focusing exclusively on tech. So rather than relying on multiple industries as New York does (media + healthcare + finance + law), Silicon Valley achieved this primarily through tech.
Most of the 10 most valuable companies in the U.S. are either software or hardware firms, both of which are branches of tech. There is either no financial firm among them, or at most, only one.
And because finance is an older sector, it has a higher total number of billionaires. However, tech creates billionaires much more rapidly, and the average wealth per billionaire is significantly higher.
What is the reason for all of this?
2
u/Little-Somewhere6076 10d ago
New York got expensive. Now that California is also expensive the next hot spot will likely be somewhere cheaper with a network effect (like Miami or Dallas)
1
1
u/10001110101balls 8d ago
Miami is already overcrowded and expensive. It is one of the worst major cities in the US to live on an area median income.
58
u/Teilzeitschwurbler 10d ago
Finance doesn't create anything?
9
u/Free_Elevator_63360 10d ago
As someone who works in finance and development, specifically housing, this is it. There is far more profit margin made by the plumber than the bank. The only reason finance looks good is because it is essentially passive, relatively risk free, and the scale is so much bigger. A few percent on $100m is a lot of cash. Versus a 30-40% markup on a $100k plumbing scope.
Plus I’ve never met anyone in finance that actually knows anything about anything. I think it is one of the problems with the current tech market. We see a bunch of finance bros throwing money at AI tech, without understanding the actual business use. They are so desperate to get in on the “next” tech craze, they pumped money into anything that shows up.
8
u/PlayfulRemote9 10d ago
Please do not get your takes on finance from this person who works in housing and development finance
4
u/Free_Elevator_63360 10d ago
I’ll take criticism, but I don’t hear any.
3
u/PlayfulRemote9 9d ago
Ok, sure
Finance is not relatively passive, risk free. The whole point of the industry is to take on risk for returns
Plus I’ve never met anyone in finance that actually knows anything about anything
Checks notes, in your… real estate job?
3. > We see a bunch of finance bros throwing money at AI tech, without understanding the actual business use
Oh you’re in vc now too? Understand how the power law works, I see
Your comment basically calls everyone dumb and lacking knowledge, which is really fucking funny. There’s Wall Street, there’s Sandhill road, and there’s everything else. If you don’t directly interface with one why are you larping on internet as if you understand either industry?
Now, keep in mind I’m in tech. But I know and have worked with both sides enough to know basically 0 of what you said is true
1
u/sleepystaff 9d ago
Damn, take your unhappiness elsewhere techie. Take a walk before submitting, sheesh.
1
u/PlayfulRemote9 9d ago
I’m very happy with my life but thanks for the concern. OP asked for me to correct him
1
u/randomlydancing 10d ago
Finance bros get rich because it's scalable in a similar manner to tech
2
u/Free_Elevator_63360 10d ago
Only if people need to borrow money…. Without an underlying business. There is nothing to finance.
0
8
u/Little-Somewhere6076 10d ago
How could retirement exist without finance?
Or housing? Do you think every homeowner should have to pay the full cost without credit ?
8
u/Teilzeitschwurbler 10d ago
Finance just manages money/wealth which comes from somewhere else.
3
u/Little-Somewhere6076 10d ago
If thats true then explain how a pension works, or debt
-1
u/Teilzeitschwurbler 10d ago
Pension was saved previously or is paid by taxes.
With Debt it depends a bit on where you come from.4
u/Little-Somewhere6076 10d ago
So how can payouts exceed contributions if finance doesn't create anything?
4
u/Teilzeitschwurbler 10d ago
You need to invest in something (Company, Real estate etc.) then you can get a return on it. Finance itself just manages wealth and charges for it.
1
-2
2
1
1
u/AftyOfTheUK 10d ago
How would companies fund new factories or offices or new teams airport finance?
5
u/ExactArugula6821 10d ago
Software can iterate and scale to meet customers needs much faster than any other industry
Which also is how multi billion dollar corps can disappear overnight
2
4
u/adultdaycare81 10d ago
Creating things vs Financing them? I’m good with creation being rewarded more
4
u/Primary_Excuse_7183 10d ago
Scalability and intellectual property. Not that finance doesn’t have those but tech is rooted in those.
If you can solve customers problems on different sides of the planet at the same time without human intervention, that greatly increases the ability you have to grow and how rapid that can be. Finance can do that too but it’s enabled and made easier by tech.
1
u/Warm_Assumption9640 10d ago
Money goes where there is money, right now there is a lot of money in tech
1
u/LoudInteraction1761 10d ago
You're right. Wealth attracts wealth. Seems like when the wealthiest business people invest in a particular sector, currently tech, others tend to follow the same path.
2
2
2
u/DM_me_ur_PPSN 8d ago
Tech brings the smartest and most driven people on earth to one place to innovate and create value. I think a fairly obvious side effect of that would be wealth creation.
1
u/the--wall 6d ago
People in tech bring value (generally speaking), people in finance basically just trade with each other all day and then profit on retail market to hold their bag
People in finance provide zero value to society at large in comparison to a software engineer or mechanical engineer who help get your package to you with 3 hour delivery.
2
u/Lumpy-Blackberry-718 8d ago
If I'm a tech investor and I want to buy into the anthropic IPO, some financier in NYC might help me find where I can buy shares. They're just a broker. Why should the broker be worth more than the thing they're brokering?
1
u/ReadingBudget4091 10d ago
Tech harnesses the energy of electrons.
Nowadays even money grows on electrons.
1
u/Embarrassed-Fig-578 10d ago
I think finance is much more competitive and tech, mainly SaaS companies, specially after AI are on boom.
1
u/tobias_kleinen1 10d ago
Software can scale globally without costs growing at the same rate as revenue. Finance tends to face more regulation and capital requirements, which can limit how quickly firms expand
1
u/uncoolkidsclub 10d ago
Finance is a soft good only - for tech you’re looking at hard and soft goods. Finance creates more distributed wealth, where tech is more focused wealth.
1
u/CryptographerNew3609 10d ago
Tech is much stickier. If you don’t like your brokerage or investment banker you can just switch. But most people are buying phones from the same company year after year, using the same operating system and websites.
1
1
1
1
u/ReplacementFar2185 10d ago
Inherent value creation, tech is like the car that’s going to take you somewhere, finance is the gas the car needs to get there. Both have value, sometimes there are cars that get you there that don’t use “gas” most still need it.
1
u/Fantastic-Moose-7934 10d ago
Tech creates new things in the world and has faster winner take all (monopolistic) tendencies than other industries given network effects and how fast distribution can occur
Finance rearranges the pieces on the board, financially engineers outcomes with debt, and asset management fees (2/20) are an aberration of capitalism. These things don’t scale exponentially like tech and have backwards pressure on them over time
GDP is basically driven by population growth and productivity. Finance influences neither , tech influences the latter
1
1
1
u/melbournelollipop 9d ago edited 9d ago
Tech creates things that normal people buy and use, and buy it repeatedly. What kind of innovation Finance provides? Digital banking and budgeting apps at most
1
u/NorCalGuySays 9d ago
Tech has a larger and faster reach. You can make 1 Netflix company. Now scale that online to millions on millions of people around the world who are paying a few dollars a month.
1
u/Logical_Mix_4627 6d ago
Software scales extremely efficiently. An engineer can build you something that you can sell an infinite number of times. This leads to fantastic margins on the businesses that are built around this scalability.
1
u/ETP_Queen 5d ago
Market value, billionaire counts and wealth created for typical investors are three different measures. A sector can dominate one and look very different on another, so it helps to be clear which one you’re using.
1
u/MathematicianAfter57 5d ago
Marginal cost of scaling tech products is close to zero because of software commodification. Tech is a product. Finance is a service.
1
u/atonale 4d ago
A classic and reliable way to accumulate wealth is to position yourself in the path of a flow of some kind and scrape a small percentage off it. If you can make the flow larger or more narrowly direct it through your hands your cut gets bigger and bigger. Something like building a dam and running a power station off it. Software takes a lot of diffuse, labor-intensive activity of this kind, standardizes and automates the processes so they can be done by machines, then concentrates all such flows in the entire world into one or two massive flows. Hotel rentals, auctions, taxi rides, etc. Software allows you to do the process thinking for one such business and then apply it to the whole of humanity, concentrating all the profit in as few hands as possible. Though in principle for publicly traded companies, ownership of that one mega-business can then be shared by anyone who wants to buy a piece of it.
0
u/Cloudy_Crane3559 9d ago
The funny part is comparing Manhattan after 200 years to Silicon Valley after 50, then acting surprised Silicon Valley has a bigger tech-shaped number.
1
u/LoudInteraction1761 9d ago edited 9d ago
The point is, both regions are worth trillions of dollars and their market values are quite similar.
Manhattan achieved this in 200 years, while Silicon Valley achieved it in 50 years. Furthermore, Manhattan relies not only on the finance but also on many other sectors such as law, healthcare, media, and the luxury housing market for the global wealthy, while Silicon Valley achieved this solely through tech. So it's not just Manhattan vs SV, we are also talking about tech vs finance.
0
u/Square-Conclusion454 10d ago
Finance got competitive.
The days of PE fueled by junk bonds printing 40% annual returns are gone. Low hanging fruit was picked, competition arrived.
Hedge funds got more competitive too. Citadel could not be run from a dorm room in 2026. Firms still get high returns, but cannot scale.
Tech is the opposite. New technology (internet , mobile, social, crypto, AI) expanded opportunities faster than competitors eroded margins. There’s enough profits and cash flowing, that you can pay a lot of 27 year olds 1M/yr.
1
u/iforgotmypen 3d ago
You're right about that, Fintech has grown by leaps and bounds despite the fat pedophile in the white house.
7
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/LoudInteraction1761 10d ago edited 10d ago
Source? Look at the largest companies and the wealthiest individuals; most of them are in tech. Or consider why Silicon Valley has grown so rapidly over the last 50 years, while New York has existed for over 200 years, yet the two are arguably on par with each other.
As for what you said about venture capitalists (VCs), that is a good point, however, the vast majority of these investors primarily fund tech ventures.
1
u/Low-Passenger6357 10d ago
Largest companies by valuation and wealthiest individuals meaning networth, right?
The wealth question comes down to venture capital.
SF captures over 50% of VC money in the US vs NYC with 13.3%
SF has a better startup ecosystem. There are more startups there.
VC info: https://venturecapitaltracker.com/nyc-vs-sf-startup-ecosystem-comparison-2026
Wealthy individuals mainly have their assets tied to a business. https://www.visualcapitalist.com/chart-assets-make-wealth/
1
u/LoudInteraction1761 10d ago
Yeah, SF has more VC. But I don’t we can compare San Francisco and NYC, because one is a city with a population of one million, while the other has a population of eight million. It makes more sense to compare the Bay Area with NYC; although the Bay Area consists of many different cities, its total population is still smaller than that of NYC.
That said, it is true that there is a much higher concentration of venture capital in the Bay Area. My take is that when startups go public, they generate wealth very rapidly. While hedge funds and private equity firms in finance can also generate significant wealth, they aren’t starting from scratch like startups, so their leaps in growth tend to be smaller.
2
u/Low-Passenger6357 10d ago edited 10d ago
Generate wealth is weird phrasing.
Yes, there is a difference in going into VC vs HF vs PE.
Yeah, there is more risk tolerance in SF. Hence, more VC.
It might be helpful for you to learn more about Venture Capital. That’s what your question is actually about.
1
u/Janul3 10d ago
While hedge funds and private equity firms in finance can also generate significant wealth,
A lot of finance bits (hedge funds, prop firms, PE, etc) also have limits to how much they can scale and still make the same crazy levels of profit.
Hedge funds will close their doors to new money above a certain size often. A prop firm doesn't take outside money even.
Which comes back to that other root comment's original point - finance doesn't build new stuff. It can take a slice off of things (trades, transactions, loans, whatever depending on the subset of finance), but it kinda ends there.
24
u/scottdxxx 10d ago
Innovation vs service.