DISCLAIMER:
I am not arguing that legion is a good game, in fact in this very post i say things that are not me praising the game unconditionally, i am arguing that a critique i am about to share had been used to dismiss the game's content in what it was trying to do, no matter how flawed it really became in practice, and i wanted to make my point clear since i wasn't. also something to note is that i don't have the same level of experience or what was even lost during the development of legion and i am not using this post to dismiss that claim, thank you.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch dogs legion released with extremely mixed reception a 50/50 split you can say, but an argument i repeatedly see is always the same, because yes the game is flawed in a ton of places but you'll never hear me say its terrible because it doesn't have a main protagonist, that is the wrong argument and is derived from emotion rather than logic.
Emotionally i get it, watch dogs was a series that had 2 protagonists in their games in WD1 and WD2, they were good for what story they were involved in, however WD3 or Watch Dogs Legion had a different approach, the play as anyone system the assumption i kept hearing coming in that was the crux of the argument for the game being bad was it had no protagonist with a diverse backstory or supporting cast, this critique of no protagonist its starting to piss me off, honestly
I came into legion as my first watch dogs game, and then played Watch Dogs 2 (I tried playing 1 but for some reason i couldn't play it), i knew what i was getting into going into Legion, emergent gameplay narrative, and no central protagonist, and its funny because i had more enjoyment with the game than i probably would have if i had expected to be anything else
While yes legion is weaker on these mechanics/systems described, and i am not saying its perfect it is not, but the main, common critique is about the lack of protagonist, not the system itself. Its always about the plot of the game and never about why the play as anyone system failed as a concept.
It almost feels like people latched onto that as the crux of the argument, to put it in perspective: you don't see me saying State of Decay's story is bad because the character has to rescue an hostile enclave from a horde of zombies and doesn't say a catchphrase when he breaks through the door, you can say that yourself
You don't see me saying XCOM's story is shit because they got a 1 percent crit and they didn't say some cringe inducing line if they had more to say, you can say that yourself and that is the problem, critics of WD:L do not meet the game half way, they see the game as a whole experience so of course the experience would be sullied, because they didn't treat the game with the same level of respect that emergent games require to flourish
Speaking of XCOM, XCOM did the same experimental move with The Bureau: XCOM Declassified, it had a central protagonist, it did away with the emergent gameplay fans loved, and people were upset, with the same mixed reception, it feels like fans of WD before Legion clicked with Bureau, and it feels like the people who liked XCOM clicked with Legion The rigid expectation was the cause for the critique, and rightfully so, but i keep seeing people argue that it failed because of the decision, not the execution because they were both poorly handled
So if you still believe Legion would work better with a protagonist, and can still keep the thing that made legion unique so here's a challenge: without breaking the system legion created, try and put a protagonist in it. That's right you can't, bloodline DLC had to remove the play as anyone system to make the traditional narrative coherent, what does that tell you? Not that Ubisoft messed up and apologized but that the critic's assumptions didn't align with the intent, and no because they had to change it doesn't make the play as anyone system incoherent, Critics did by making the game about the story instead of the experience
In essence the critique should've been to make the story work with emergent systems, it needs to match the same systems to justify no protagonist, Legion didn't, State of Decay, and XCOM, didn't need to lean too hard on the plot because they emphasized that this is that character's story, not some badass protagonist that mows through opposition, and that is why i am not saying the game is perfect, but when i mention critics or people like the critics, they often stop at no memorable characters, you make them memorable, not the game.
My personal issues, too are of the story and how it was handled but not in the way you think, emergent gameplay requires the characters you find for the player to inject their own story, give it a plotline and suddenly it matters less, this cannot be fixed, but what can be fixed and is actionable is the pointlessness of the play as anyone system, because so many characters can be recruited with absolute ease it makes them matter less, and makes them all feel same-y, the sameness could've been fixed if they introduced scarcity, XCOM did this, State of Decay did this, and that is a real critique right there, so you might be wondering, how did i go about fixing the latter?
Simple answer. Attempt a challenge run, like a nuzlocke, Most of my personal issues with the game do begin to fade with doing that, So it could show you, that meeting a game half way is not hard, it just requires a bit of an open mind.