r/voidlinux • u/rohshall • Jan 14 '21
Is void linux being actively updated?
When I go to https://voidlinux.org/download/ to download the latest live image, I see they were updated last on Nov 2019. That does not inspire a great confidence that void linux is being actively worked upon. Arch linux releases live image every month. If it is getting the love it deserves, what is the reason for publishing such old live images?
11
30
u/drake-newell Jan 14 '21
This question gets asked almost every week. Void is constantly and regularly updated, and since you can do a netinstall from the iso, it makes absolutely no difference how old the iso is.
8
u/i8088 Jan 14 '21
But it kind of does. For a netinstall you need working network hardware, which needs drivers, which can be missing from an old kernel. So on somewhat recent hardware (e.g. mainboards with the RTL8125B ethernet chip), you've got a problem with the old ISO.
0
u/drake-newell Jan 14 '21
Then it's pretty easy to build your own iso with void-mklive. But super new hardware is kind of niche imo.
7
Jan 14 '21
Not everyone has a spare Void installation sitting by; people may not be Void users at all (yet).
3
u/drake-newell Jan 14 '21
As far as I know you don't need void to use it it, just git and any linux shell.
4
Jan 14 '21
Well, not everyone has a Linux box around, or uses Linux already.
6
0
Jan 14 '21
[deleted]
7
Jan 14 '21 edited Jan 15 '21
Sure, but I got a new laptop a while ago after my old one broke, and building a new image would have been a bit of a mission for me as I just had the pre-installed Windows. I mean, I could have used a VM or whatnot and it's all solvable, but if you're looking to, say, transfer from Arch then it's all rather inconvenient just to see if this Void thing is any good in the first place. There's load of situations where building an image is not exactly convenient, even though you know what you're doing.
5
u/gbrlsnchs Jan 15 '21
I see your point, I think the solution should be the handbook to at least cite the existence of recent ISOs but make clear they're not THAT tested yet, always suggesting people to try the current ISOs first.
3
u/1369ic Jan 14 '21
I agree not a lot of people are going to come at Void on a spanking new machine. That said, perceptions matter, and telling somebody with a new machine or an odd wifi card or whatever to build their own ISO is classifying your distro as not friendly. That propagates through the Linux community. I don't care if Void gets anybody who might have gone for Manjaro or Ubuntu or Debian, but it puts the distro in a niche category. If the Void team is fine with that, then fine. If not, making a new install iso doesn't seem like a major muscle movement. Of course, I say that as an average user who doesn't have to do any of the work.
5
u/drake-newell Jan 14 '21
If people really need new isos, voidbuilds.xyz makes them.
1
u/1369ic Jan 14 '21
And that's what I used. But I've been on Linux since 2003 and have recovered from accidental hard drive wipes during an install. Other people aren't going to be so open to using an iso that's not clearly marked stable. Again, it just comes back to how you want people to view the distro. That's not up to me, but I work in public affairs and I can tell you everything matters. Every decision adds up over time to a reputation. In a Linux world full of Ubuntu clones having an out-of-date install iso and telling people to use a daily build from a site with a xyz domain makes Void a geeky distro.
2
u/drake-newell Jan 15 '21
Whatever, from my point of view as an intermediate user, it works fine. Would it be nice to have a newer iso? Yeah, but for something users will only use once or twice it's clearly not a priority.
4
u/i8088 Jan 14 '21
One year old hardware is not what I would call "super new". Since it is so easy to build images with void-mklive, it would be nice to have new images available at least a little more frequently. Even if an official "current" image is only created once per year, having quarterly images (even if not well tested and marked as such) would be nice.
7
-1
u/tymophy76 Jan 14 '21
Can't stress how much I agree with this. If you don't release images that will install on newer hardware (and agreed about 1 year old isn't NEW, it's newer), then you must want noone to use your distro? That's the only assumption I can come to as far as the devs complete unwillingness to even release a new image every year, at the least.
6
u/electricdrop Jan 14 '21
Yeah, except when you try to run a graphical session on a modern hardware. Kernel is old and doesn't support my 5500XT for example, so X doesn't work.
2
u/drake-newell Jan 14 '21
What does running a graphical session have to do with the old isos? You can just do a network install and then have the latest kernel on the new system.
4
u/electricdrop Jan 14 '21
They have live isos with different DEs, which doesn't work on current hardware. I think many people use them as installation base. It's easier and you can check how the distro is working on your hardware. Well, most people will just boot into a broken X and will think the distro is crap.
3
u/i8088 Jan 14 '21
Since there are several different live ISO images with various desktop environments (which I really appreciate, btw.), one has to wonder what they are for, if you aren't even supposed to run X with the live image.
1
u/drake-newell Jan 14 '21
An update should fix those out of date packages though, yeah?
5
u/i8088 Jan 14 '21
If the live ISO doesn't boot in the first place, how am I supposed to update any packages?
I can only speak for myself here, but I'm usually fine with the simple netinstall ISO for actually installing new systems, but I like the ISOs with desktop environments for quickly testing it out on computers to see if it works nicely on that particular hardware, before actually installing it. With those old images it is not telling all that much on newer devices unfortunately.
If it is too much work or it is taking too many resources to create all those different versions, I would rather like to see more frequent updates of just the netinstall, and drop the other ones, than having all of them, but each updated only rarely.
4
10
u/SunkenStone Jan 14 '21
Why didn’t you search the subreddit to see the last thousand times this question has been asked?
4
3
u/gbrlsnchs Jan 15 '21
I think the handbook should cite the existence of newer ISOs but suggest people to use the current ones and only fall back to newer, untested ones if the previous step failed.
2
2
u/SystemEarth Jan 14 '21
When you have installed it run sudo xbps-install -Su and you're up to date on a more stable rolling release than arch.
Because vois is more stable there is less need for frequent new iso's. Updating from a system that's over a year old is way less of a problem
3
u/NightH4nter Jan 14 '21
It's a rolling release distro. Why care about how the iso is?
6
u/1369ic Jan 14 '21
For example, I just bought a new laptop. I had to download a daily build because I got so many errors on the older kernel that I wasn't confident about installing with it. So the age of the software matters to some degree.
1
u/datenwolf Jan 14 '21
what is the reason for publishing such old live images?
Because it doesn't matter. When you install, you're installing directly from the voidlinux repository servers, which always give you the latest versions.
The installer image works, and there's no (good) reason to keep bumping the release data, other than just increasing that number.
0
u/tymophy76 Jan 14 '21
But it does matter when you're trying to install to a machine that has hardware that's not yet supported by the antiquated kernel in the installer...
0
Jan 14 '21
[deleted]
4
u/gf3 Jan 14 '21
This is very much not the case for everyone. Installing void from the ISOs on a Threadripper build in early 2020 was an enormous pain in the ass which has been entirely mitigated in newer kernels. The ISOs still haven’t been updated.
If creating new ISOs is as simple as everyone claims in this thread then why is it not the job of CI?
2
u/i8088 Jan 14 '21
Unless you built a system with hardware that was just released last week, they will boot at least to a console prompt, which is as far as you need to install the OS.
As mentioned elsewhere already, this is simply not true. Just because your hardware happened to work okay, doesn't mean that this is always the case or that anyone is trolling. I specifically mentioned a pretty common network adaptor that's unsupported with the "current" live CD kernel and that piece of hardware hasn't been released in the last week, not even close.
-13
u/tundrabase Jan 14 '21
all the maintainers were btfo after seeing that blm endorsement on voids twitter page
36
u/aedinius Jan 14 '21
Those are the 'current' ISOs, meaning they've been thoroughly tested. They'll have no problem installing the system despite their age.
There are newer ISOs, but they haven't been fully tested yet enough to be marked as 'current' default.
It's a rolling release, you can see things are getting updated quite often.
Arch is notorious for requiring constant updates; Void handles long periods between updates much more gracefully.