r/voidlinux • • Apr 26 '20

My view

I don’t know who, when, where and how. But it is utterly stupid to prevent the creator of void to work on his own project. I’ve seen that he can have no temper. But I would have been in the same position if I went through what he did. It’s not relaxing to come after a long time seeing that you’re not very welcome to the project considering that some maintainers are ignoring your suggestions. While I do believe void has the legs to keep moving without Juan, I’d like to see some respect to the man who created it. Maybe some of you assuming he’s a piece of shit with no respect towards others should try to understand how disrespected he feels after all that’s happened. And yes I do agree that the repos have obsolete packages and it could benefit from sending them to hell. I’m not on anyone’s side but let’s have some brains and realise that software is something to be developed and maintained by handfuls of stressless humans. Void was Juan’s idea. And unless he told someone to continue and do whatever the hell they want with it then you could do whatever the hell you want. Let’s not forget he may be out of his nerves because there’s people preventing him from working on his on idea. I think that is disgusting. Again I’m not on anyone’s side but let’s have some brains. Also, I’m not entirely on par with everything that happen so forgive me for any mistakes (I don’t think I’ve made any).

1 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/NightH4nter Apr 26 '20

I really don't understand why does the team do what it does. It would be more correct to either reveal nothing and just tell people that Juan left the team or just to reveal everything from when this all has begun up until now. It would've at least prevented all this garbage discussion full of assumptions, guesses and misunderstanding.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

I agree and disagree. It’s just frustrating that a lot of people are shit talking about him for no reason or whatsoever.

5

u/NightH4nter Apr 26 '20

There is a reason. His behavior is unacceptable by any means. But so is the teams' one.

Once again, it's all from what I know, so it's far from being the final opinion I think.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

Precisely. We can’t be on one’s side like I said but I think it’s pretty crazy that they had him stuck a crappy welcome

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

And I’m glad Juan has at least Duncaen and a few more not against his will.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

When the devs hand't heard from Juan for ages, they started discussing what to do. People tried for months to get a hold of him to no avail. There were open discussions on the forums, there were newsposts about it and most likely a lot of discussions on IRC and social media. This was not a decision taken as an afterthought. They waited and they waited for a long time. Many of us simply thought he was dead.

I have no clue what's best for Void. Imho Juan is an amazing dev and Void is his project.. but.. yeah.. I don't know. Afaik Juan is working on xbps and if the two can coexist I hope it'll work out. It's just sad with all those hurt feelings and the most beautiful distro hanging in the balance.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

Couldn’t have said better myself. But the least someone could do is have empathy towards the person who made the distribution who happened to have a little of their lives taken from them. And now taking him from his own idea is just frustrating. And that’s why I made myself write that comment. I cannot understand how inhuman some people can be. Juan is forgiven for having his time away. It’s not like the distro didn’t survive without him so I don’t know why make it a deal at this point in time. And now that he’s back, the main idea will remain and the project can head where it was headed. So I think they should just let him have his place in here. Although I think he’s too frustrated to even come back.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

I've only followed the headlines and don't really know the technical details. I just hope everybody will find a good solution. I clearly remember people going "If we take over the distro and juan comes back, he's gonna be pissed". There really was a lot of talk about what to do, so it must have been a decision about what was best at that time. I'm just sad his return had to be dramatic instead of happy :/

Btw do you have the same username on IRC and the old forums? I think you helped me out a few times :)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

In my opinion they should have forked the whole thing. Would take extra work but it wouldn’t be this huge mess of different interests

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

I thought it was more about moving it away from one dev to a community? As in something the devs had been wanting to do for a long time - also to avoid the issues if somebody dissapeared.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '20

[deleted]

1

u/zinsuddu Apr 29 '20

Keeping the name was respectful to the creator. Nothing that he owned was taken over. Taking up the work of developing Void and building upon xbps was respectful to Juan's wishes as expressed in the manifesto that he wrote which defined Void as an open-source project to which anyone was welcome to contribute. I myself encouraged those who were trying to continue to develop Void after Juan "died" (he was so long-gone and completely unreacheable -- I thought he must be literally dead) to keep the name to honor him. I am so glad to hear that he is in fact alive and ready to carry his ideas forward. Void has succeeded in becoming about as useful as OpenBSD for me. Long live Void Linux! And long live our genius Juan! And godspeed to everyone trying to figure out how to sail this ship whose former captain has come back from the deep.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '20

I don't know what goes on behind the scenes, but at least from my POV Void as a project has been great ever since I started using it to end my distro-hopping habit since February. And since then XBPS has quickly become my favorite package manager, which is also the brainchild of Juan so I clearly see what he's done for Void is pretty significant. I wish the best for him and honestly all I'm doing right now is sitting back to see what happens soon.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

Sometimes a talented Dev is the most fragile part of the project. I plan keep using Void as its features are rather unique. And I want it to grow and evolve as a project. From this point of view the earlier it gets rid of the single point of failure the better.

1

u/zinsuddu May 06 '20

Juan owns the very well-conceived and developed xbps package building and management system. He wrote it, it is his code. He says that he still wants to develop it and has resumed work on it!

It is normal practice to call him the owner of his code. He should guide its future and determine which commits will go into public releases. If he fails technically and there are bugs or missing features, if he is a bad owner and refuses to accept good patches THEN the "Void Linux" team can decide to fork xbps and go their own way with "our_package_system". Since he is vastly superior to others in his knowledge of this code, his commitment to it, and his vision for developing it, it would be a mistake to stop using the real xbps.

p.s. Juan may have said something rude about some of the developers. So what!? We don't need happy egos, we need great code. I would like to use whatever linux distribution is built around Juan's xbps.

His handling of the situation is exactly right -- he is asserting his love of his code and his commitment to it.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20

[deleted]

3

u/Duncaen Apr 26 '20

Maybe don't spam my notifications with this stuff, all the hidden and blocked users have never interacted with the repository in any way before and were just trying make more issues.