r/voidlinux • u/imalwaystired89 • Jan 14 '24
is void a minimal distro?
Not saying it's not slim and simple and clean. But is it minimal? Arch is not minimal as it has large packages. Debian is minimal, as it splits binaries. Gentoo is minimal, of course. How about void?
11
u/GENielsen Jan 14 '24
You can opt for a base install. Is that minimal? I'm not sure what you mean by minimal.
8
Jan 14 '24
What do you mean by minimal? Void does split development files and debug symbols into separate packages from the binaries (like Debian, unlike Arch). If that's what you mean by minimal, then it is a minimal distro.
5
Jan 14 '24
OP what are you doing with your life where you're questioning if Void is a minimal distro. And calling Arch, what, bloated? Because it has "large packages"?? Please. Also, while Gentoo may be minimal in most regards, it's maximal in the amount of time you're going to waste configuring and maintaining it
5
u/Known-Watercress7296 Jan 14 '24
It's all relative.
I would not say Gentoo is in any way minimal, it's a massive complex beast, portage & python alone don't feel very minimal at all....granted you can use Gentoo to build custom systems.
Void offer the base-minimal package if you wanna start smaller. I'm not certain but I think Debian still splits packages a little more than Void.
I find Void a nice balance. It's not cluttered and runit, xbps & xbps-src do a lot.
Rob Landley's mkroot has been merged into toybox, it makes it quick and simple to build minimal systems. Running:
./mkroot/mkroot.sh
sudo chroot root/host/fs /init
and you will have a freshly built minimal root to play with.
Kiss is pretty minimal, designed to be maintained and understood by one person with no infrastructure.
5
u/ahesford Jan 14 '24
The
base-minimalpackage was never recommended for interactive use, and has since been renamed to better convey its purpose.
2
u/Mackery_D Jan 14 '24
I’ve run both on a very old 32 bit laptop that struggles to keep up with modern anything, and Debian is the opposite of minimal by any metric that matters to its performance. Void by far performs better.
2
u/bytheclouds Jan 15 '24
Interesting, I am currently running 32 bit Debian on a single core Pentium M laptop fom 2005. It's as usable as one could expect it to be. Haven't tried Void, though.
1
u/Mackery_D Jan 16 '24
I have a duo core, CF19 tough book, it’s has a custom driver I have yet to get working on void, so I’m on Debian currently. I guess “by far” is relative…it’s a noticeable difference on my system.
1
u/mr-ow1 Jan 14 '24
At one point I thought void was minimal but when I installed debian via debootstrap. I was like wow ! I did not even have ping. So yea...
sudo debootstrap --arch amd64 --variant=minbase bookworm /mnt [http://ftp.us.debian.org/debian/](http://ftp.us.debian.org/debian/)1
Jan 20 '24
for more fun add these:- in /etc/apt.conf/99_norecommends
APT::Install-Recommends "false";
APT::Install-Suggests "false";
APT::AutoRemove::RecommendsImportant "false";
APT::AutoRemove::SuggestsImportant "false";
1
u/mwyvr Jan 15 '24
I've heard others make that comparison between Arch and Debian but never ready any details. Do you have an example comparison or two between the two distributions?
-7
u/no-name-user Jan 14 '24
Void is not minimal because it requires some effort to read and understand its documentation in order to setup and maintain a running system.
27
u/paper42_ Jan 14 '24
I think Void is minimal because it only has 4 letters in the name.