r/visualnovels
•
u/tropeguy
•
Mar 30 '26
Self-promotion I was wrong. VN hybrids have been added back to Kaguya.
First, I want to address the timing of Kaguya's relaunch.
My post announcing Kaguya went up on March 21 at 12:59 PM GMT.
u/KagaYume found out about Yorhel's passing through a now-deleted comment on my post.
They then posted this news at 1:56 PM, which was 1 hour later.
My post was not planned around it. The timing was just truly unfortunate. I'd been silently building the site for 80 days since New Year, and right after I posted on this subreddit that Kaguya was finally ready, the news came out.
The thing I do regret is the tweet. Yorhel had been more generous than most would have in his position. He created VNDB and maintained the site's code alone for 18 years, mostly funding it himself. On VNDB's 17th anniversary, he wrote this: "I've noticed that the community can be oddly protective and territorial around VNDB at times, strongly discouraging potentially competing projects. But having competition is a good thing, we need more of it! I have no ambition to take over the world, so you have my blessing and my support: Go forth and build databases."
He helped me by adding reviews to the VNDB export file when I requested, and fixed a spoiler bug within hours of me reporting it. He even recommended Kaguya directly to someone who asked for a personal list-making feature on the forum.
He didn't have to do any of these things. The least I should've done after I learned of his passing was to step back and give time for the community to mourn. When Ange asked me if I wanted anyone to tweet about Kaguya, I should've declined and taken down my Reddit post. I didn't, and I'll really wish I'd done things differently for a long time.
--
It seems I've messed up both of my updates so far. -.-' At least I'm learning each time. Constructive criticism like Bruce's video, this & this really helped.
Scope changes:
It's now obvious to me that the exclusion of VN hybrids from Kaguya was a mistake. I realize that most people don't think it's a problem for them to be included on a VN site. Imposing the previous strict inclusion criteria for Kaguya prevented it from serving the very community it was made for, and it would be stupid to double down after hearing the clear feedback. A lot of people in our Discord also said they'd like hybrids to be on Kaguya even if they don't personally track them. I do think there's some value in distinguishing between gameplay hybrids and VNs; see the highest-rated title on VNDB right now, a JRPG. But there are far better ways to do that than just removing them from the site altogether so nobody can track them.
The easiest and best path is just to let people choose for themselves and respect that decision.
There are two toggles now in settings: hybrid and nukige. Switch them on/off according to what you want to see. Your preferences will apply across the site.
Some that were added: Danganronpa, Ace Attorney, Baldr Sky, Utawarerumono, Rance X, VenusBlood, 999.
I'd like you to try Kaguya once again with the changes and tell me what you think. Feature requests are welcome, as always.
Link: https://kaguya.io | Discord
TL;DR: You can now import your full VNDB library without losing titles. Toggles for both hybrids and nukige in account settings. Choose as you like.
