r/virtualization • u/dyllll • Dec 24 '19
Windows 98 Virtual Machine
I have a mass spectrometer that must run on windows 98 with a required PCI board. Is it possible to run a windows 98 virtual machine and it work with the PCI board?
Edit: I was wrong, it’s an ISA board. Will anything work with that?
3
Dec 24 '19
I doubt you will be able to get an ISA card working with any computer that supports PCI passthrough as anything with a ISA slot will be too old to support virtualisation, I believe. You are probably best looking for an old computer with an ISA slot and just run it on that.
2
u/mikeroySoft Dec 24 '19
You might be able to use an ISA to USB adapter. Any virt software will do. You probably want virtualbox or Vmware player, something that runs from a desktop that isn’t Hyper-V.
Then just install Win98 in a VM, and pass the USB device through. Ymmv, like others said this is somewhat uncharted, it I’ve had customers do similar stuff with serial ports before. (I’m the product manager for Player, Fusion and Workstation)
2
u/nroach44 Dec 25 '19
Only issue with ISA > USB is that either the HV needs to understand that some of the bus needs to be shoved over USB, or the OS in the VM needs to understand USB enough to be able to talk to the device and use it.
I'd say the best way would be an FPGA with a custom build of QEMU, but best of luck getting that sorted
2
u/jadedargyle333 Dec 24 '19
You're probably going to have problems with the board. Finding a motherboard that supports PCI vs PCI-E is the first issue. If you do find one that supports PCI, you'll also need it to be 64 bit to support a modern OS. If you find one of those, the last issue is DMIO grouping. You may end up with a box that runs a hypervisor and this single VM.
1
u/Drwankingstein Dec 24 '19
I would use a isa to pci bridge I guess. (I dont know of any) someone sid finding a board that supports pci and virtualization would be hard, however I believe gigabyte has their d3h boards that may support passthrough. I am not too sure I can probably test in the next few days assuming i can somehow find a working pci card.
But IMO that would probably be your best bet aside from just buying an old pc and installing a win98 on it
1
u/unquietwiki Dec 25 '19
https://www.qemu.org/ might be your best shot at this. http://bochs.sourceforge.net/ is also an option, but more focused on emulation.
http://arstech.com/install/ecom-prodshow/usb2isar.html per what others suggested on getting the card to connect.
1
u/sendme__ Dec 25 '19
I recently had to deploy some servers especially for windows 2k with passthrough.
The best option for us was VMware. Hyper-V doesn't support any os below W10, the others like xen, proxmox were working but way too much to fiddle with and unreliable.
Hope it works for you.
1
u/mastachaos Jan 07 '20
Hyper-V supports Windows 2000 Server, and pretty much every version of Windows after that. Definitely not 98 though, sadly.
1
u/sendme__ Jan 08 '20
Discrete Device Assignment is supported for Generation 1 or 2 VMs. Additionally, the guests supported include Windows 10, Windows Server 2019, Windows Server 2016, Windows Server 2012r2 with KB 3133690 applied, and various distributions of the Linux OS.
1
1
1
Jan 06 '20
So many questions:
Does the original manufacturer still exist? They may have made a PCI interface board at some point in their history. The machine may even speak an industry standard protocol that a USB converter exists for...
Is Win98 strictly required? Would DOS or an NT based Windows, e.g. XP, work? Consider both the user program AND any driver(s) that may be involved.
Do you have a physical machine connected currently? Do you have an image of the hard drive?
1
Jan 06 '20
Looks like you can buy a brand new PC with ISA slots and Win98 SE preinstalled. Might be your best bet https://www.rampcsystems.com/product/3-isa-slot-pc-p4
1
1
u/TheFishToldMeSo Jan 06 '20
i know this is a very basic question, but what is a virtual machine?
1
u/Shanteva Jan 12 '20
In this context, it's a program that emulates another computer with compatible architecture. Let's you run Linux on Windows or Windows XP on Windows 10 etc.
1
u/Shanteva Jan 12 '20
Since you are learning Java, the JVM that Java runs on is like a VM for a fictional machine that never existed, that lets the same compiled code run on Windows, Mac, Linux, Android
1
u/polypagan Jan 07 '20
A new mass spectrometer, pricey as that is, will be cheaper (and better) once all is taken into account.
0
Dec 24 '19
[deleted]
1
u/dyllll Dec 24 '19
Any recommendation on software?
3
u/PatrioticStripey Dec 24 '19
VM-ware has always been a reliable virtual machine software for me. I'm not sure if VirtualBox supports what you're trying to do, but it's free and tends to work most of the time, but it's not quite as stable or well supported as VM-ware in my experience.
1
u/dyllll Dec 24 '19
Thanks!
1
u/normandantzig Dec 27 '19
This is a cool issue.
To add to the Linux comment. If you use Linux, you might be able to use WINE with Linux too. Tell us how your project goes.
2
1
u/dyllll Dec 24 '19
I was wrong, it’s an ISA board. Will that still work?
1
u/thatwombat Jan 05 '20
I do not know if this will work AT ALL, but here’s a possibility. There’s a lot of weird legacy compatibility hardware out there...
1
Jan 06 '20
I didn’t have the best luck with this product when I used it about 10 years ago. We ended up using a PC with onboard ISA. This was the only machine in our entire plant that I could not convert to virtual (including DOS and Win3.1 machines!)
1
u/thatwombat Jan 06 '20
I kind of had a feeling it would come out like that.
I guess the only thing they can really do in this case is find a cheap PIII board with an ISA slot, or some other weird board for industrial or cash registers that has an ISA slot. Those are not uncommon on ebay for sure.
1
Jan 06 '20
You can go a little newer, e.g. https://adek.com/products/atx-motherboards-isa, but it depends on how new OP can go on the OS. If he really needs Win98, he doesn’t have a lot of options.
1
4
u/Gotxi Dec 25 '19
I think the easiest would be to use a ISA to USB adapter like this: http://arstech.com/install/ecom-prodshow/usb2isar.html
Then install a hypervisor (vmware player, virtual box, hyper-v... pick your poison), enable USB passthrough on the VM and install win98.
Dont't guarantee to work, good luck with that.