I'm a senior in high school and have been playing violin in my school's orchestra for four years. (this is my ninth year playing violin in general which is the longest out of anyone in my class in case that matters)
For some background, my freshman year we didn't really have formal section leaders. Also our orchestra program is severely underfunded so we had 8 people, including me, in the orchestra. Anyways we never had a concept of "first chair" or "section leaders," it was more so just the seniors who would lead the entire orchestra when it called for that.
Sophomore year was pretty similar, although we did have one senior first violinist who was somewhat of a designated leader of the whole orchestra since he was the only one. Junior year, same thing but there still wasn't an explicit hierarchy, just that everyone knew the seniors were the informal leaders.
Now that we're seniors, there are four of us who have been around the program for varying amounts of time. I'm one of them, along with Ryan (a cellist who has been here since freshman year) and Tyler (a violist who joined junior year). The fourth person in this situation is Ethan, who's actually a junior.
Remember when I said there was no such thing as section leader before? Our orchestra got really big this year. 31 people, the biggest it has ever been. Because of that, our teacher has kind of started treating Ryan and Tyler like the leaders of their respective sections. And it makes sense because they are seniors, right? Anyways last year I was honestly considering quitting orchestra because there were other classes I wanted to take and I didn't even tell my teacher this but she walked up to me one day and practically begged me to stay as if she knew I was considering leaving. She told me she needed a leader for the underclassmen and I'm one of the strongest violinists and of course I felt really guilty so I stayed.
Except when school started this year, Ethan kind of forced himself into this leadership position? Like he had never acted like this in previous years and all of a sudden he is forcing people of other sections to call him "general" and no one finds it funny. The point is, no one listens to him and he is an "aggressive leader" and I've personally never really had a problem with that aspect since people in our class don't listen so its reasonable he would have to act that way. Always our teacher kind of accepted this and now whenever she is absent, she always has him lead and that is exactly the kind of role the previous seniors had. He refers to himself as the leader of the first violins which our teacher never confirmed that. Also this is going to sound really egotistical but he is not a particularly good violinist. I'm definitely not saying he is bad, but he is not better than anyone in our section. Speaking of which, our section is him, his stand partner which is also a junior, and 3 freshmen. and of course, me. To put it plainly, both my teacher and him know I am the best violinist in our section. Again that sounds self-absorbed but I have literally been told that by both of them within these past few years and Ethan used to ask ME for help.
Also my orchestra teacher forgot I was a senior. Like one day she talks about how Ryan and Tyler are such good leaders and how shes grateful for amazing seniors and someone had to remind her that I'm a senior.
Today, Ethan was absent or late, and Ryan and Tyler were also running late. Someone suggested Olivia, another second violinist, as a replacement, but someone pointed out that there weren't any seniors present. I then clarified that I was, in fact, a senior to another peer that asked. Eventually, one of the cellists suggested that I lead, but everyone was talking over each other and it didn't lead anywhere. Then Ethan comes in and finally leads the class. At the end of class, the sub (who is a violin player herself) came up to me and told me I had to the best in the section and she was really impressed and said she was confused on why I was seated at the very back. Anyways this was really enlightening for me?? I mean this whole situation of questioning my worth in orchestra for her to come and tell me that reminded me that I am a good player and I deserve at least some recognition.
I guess i wanted to ask what to do about this situation. I'm a super non-confrontational person but I've considered going up to my teacher to talk about it. I don't know what I would even say though because it's not like I want her to remove Ethans position and give it to me. And honestly, it's not even really about the position, its the fact that I am practically invisible to her when she has to problem praising someone like Tyler who joined just last year or someone like Ethan who struggles a lot with his skill.