r/victoria2 • u/conf1rmer • Feb 17 '23
Discussion I just realized why anarchism isn't an ideology in Vicky
Aside from the devs forgot/didn't have time/it's not very compatible with Vicky's mechanics, it would also be extremely overpowered, as it would instantly do max reforms, have cores on the entire planet causing jingoism to stay at 100% the entire game, have all cultures accepted, if any anarchist rebels won a somewhere you'd insta-annex them and expand very quickly, and you wouldn't need money to pay for anything you'd just need the people and resources to physically produce things. As a trade-off, they wouldn't be able to access the global economy, just what was produced inside the free territory, and the player would have zero control over the economy, it'd be like laissez-faire except factories are opened and run to provide for the needs for pops to get access to industrial goods/to keep the militias armed instead of making money or for industrial score. Maybe also give them max infamy too, since irl in the 19th century and early 20th century that's kind of how anarchists were seen by most nation states? You wouldn't be able to negotiate with them at all either, which would be a major pain in the ass. A unique CB would probably have to be added into the game to allow you to destroy them probably.
Basically, if anarchists were implemented in-game with Vicky 2's existing mechanics they'd be a very annoying "nation" that quickly snowballs into an unstoppable juggernaut the player would have to constantly deal with just because a secondary power half a continent away decided to lose a death war, they'd be like playing with max-difficulty revolts on in CK2 (which are very unfun to play against). Although this might be realistic this probably doesn't make for fun game design. Thoughts?
(Also if there are any Vicky mods that add in anarchism I'd love to hear about them)