A LONG TL;DR: There is a split between users who encrypt their whole drives using Veracrypt or instead encrypt a volume or partition. The risks of full disk encryption seem huge concerning accidental initialization of your drive via the Windows popup that appears if you connect a FDE drive to your PC. A popup which would still appear even if you delete the drive letter in Disk Management if you connect the drive to any other computer. There are also problems with FDE and Windows backup and restore functions. I'd like to confirm my understanding of this is correct, and see if in 2021 there is anything like a near-consensus or majority/plurality opinion on the utility of FDE versus volume or partition encryption.
I'm a novice with Veracrypt and (encryption in general) and I've tried to do my due diligence in researching before posting questions (I've scanned through dozens of posts and guides on Veracrypt) but in this case I'm asking this question because opinions seem to be split on whether Full Disk Encryption is a good idea or not.
It doesn't seem like a 50-50 split but the first group says there's really no point in doing full disk encryption, since you can just encrypt a volume or partition to the full size of your hard drive, and the only potential downside is if some adversary tried to connect the drive, they'd maybe know right away that there's an encrypted partition. And they'd only instantly know this if you hadn't create a hidden encrypted volume buried somewhere. (Though if you did hide the volume there would still be a chunk of storage space buried in there that is clearly used for something).
Many other posters have chosen to encrypt their full disks (FDE), though they and many others warn that you have to be extra super careful at all times to not click the initialize button that will pop up when you connect your FDE drive to Windows, because the OS will think it's a raw drive. And if you do accidentally click yes, you've literally destroyed all the data you've been so careful to preserve.
Further, unless you do a particular tweak in Windows Disk Management, you will actually see this super dangerous data-nuke button every time you connect your drive to this PC and to any other your computer (and you'd have to do the drive letter tweak with every other drive you FDE encrypt).
The pro-FDE posters (or respondents) then say that not to worry, the Disk Management tweak is easy: you just delete the FDE-encrypted drive letter in Disk Management to get rid of the popup. I also read one poster mention changing a Registry setting called Volmgrx:
There is a way to disable this 'initialize disk' message by disabling the volmgrx service which is afaik not required unless you are dealing with dynamic/windows based raid disks. (Not affecting hardware-based raid)
Computer\HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\volmgrx Change start to 4 and reboot.
I stumbled on this by my own processed NTLite image where I try and disable as much useless junk as possible.
AFAIK this is the only way to disable this message from appearing. Maybe it doesnt help you now, but for in the future.
A couple years ago I used Veracrypt to encrypt one external hard drive, and at the time, after reading through threads and seeing the Disk Management tweak, I encrypted the whole drive. This hasn't been a problem, as I got rid of the popup and only ever used this drive with one computer.
Now jump ahead to today, and I've been looking at encrypting my system drive, and a total of 5 total external hard drives (a 8 TB hard drive, two 3 TB drives, a 1 TB drive, and a 500 GB drive). This would obviously be a big project, and whatever Veracrypt decision I make would be what I'd be likely stuck with for years to come.
Initially, after reviewing the posts again, again I thought Full Disk Encryption was the way to. My thinking was:
If I want to encrypt my drives, I should go all the way and encrypt the full disk so any hypothetical adversary would think the disk was raw.
This initialization thing isn't a huge deal because I can do the drive letter tweak in Disk Management.
But then on further reflection I've completely switched my tune. I could be mistaken (I'm a novice at this stuff, and this is why I'm asking), but it seems like the full disk option is actually a terrible idea due to the potential of catastrophic damage due to accidental user error.
Here's my breakdown of the cons (as I understand them):
If I don't do the tweak in Disk Management with one accidental click I could destroy all the data I'm doing all this work to carefully protect.
I could do the drive letter tweak once and that would stop the popup entirely, but only for that drive, and only on that computer (and I'd have to do it on every drive I'm encrypting).
If at any time I connect the FDE encrypted drives to a different computer I'd have to remember to do the tweak again (for all of them, on every other computer).
I know that even if I 'know' I need to delete the drive letter on the drive any time I connect to a different computer, I also know that it is absolutely possible that at some point in the future, maybe when I'm stressed out or tired or in a rush I might connect the drive to another PC and accidentally click the nuke button.
The fact is I'm using multiple external drives and will definitely use different computers in the future, so this risk of accidental initialization increases considerably.
So far the marks against FDE seem overwhelming. Even if the Disk Management tweak is easy to do, and even if 'smart me' knows I need to always remember to do it, I know that it is plausible that 'tired/stressed me' could possibly accidentally click the format button.
Let's say I'm behind on a project, and I've been up for 30 straight hours, and my computer crashes, and I run my precious drive to another computer and in my haste click the initialize button. Or if in a similar scenario, when in a rush, my main drive dies and so does my PC, and they won't respond to any recovery attempts, and then I remember I was smart enough to make an encrypted backup drive. And in my haste I rush that priceless backup to another computer and accidentally click the [YES] button when it annoyingly pops up.
And with further consideration of my actual threat level, this whole FDE option seems even more completely pointless. In that again, the only benefit I can discern is that initially some hypothetical adversary will steal my drive and see that it is 'apparently' raw and uninitialized, and would 'maybe' think it's empty. Yet even this completely falls apart with some analysis:
If some hypothetical adversary breaks into my house, and is knowledgeable enough to steal my hard drives to extract my data for some reason, and he finds a PC and a stack of 5 hard drives which all appear 'uninitialized,' he'll obviously automatically know they aren't empty - because why the hell would any sane person have 5 empty hard drives with 15 TB storage capacity next to their computer?
My threat level in reality is ridiculously low. I'm not a spy, or working in some job that really requires high security. I'm just a regular dude who wants to learn how to follow basic best practices for protecting my big pile of stuff (movies, music, etc.), so I can just do a 'good enough' job of protecting my privacy.
The fact that I'm using external drives and not some RAID or server setup means these drives at some point will be mobile and linked to different computers.
I've read a number of threads stating that full disk encryption absolutely threw a wrench into their process of using built-in Windows automated backup and restore methods to protect their data which is literally the whole point of all of this (i.e. protecting data). And that even though there are some niche backup methods to work around this problem with Windows, it seems like a real hassle to deal with while delivering very little gain from FDE.
Based on these factors, for me, it seems like full disk encryption isn't just some alternate option I'd have to be a bit more careful with: it seems like it would be absolutely a terrible idea that is not worth it since the horrible cons vastly outweigh the miniscule pros.
If the only real benefit to full disk encryption is that my drive will appear raw and some hypothetical adversary - who in all honesty will probably never actually target me (or even exist) - might attack me and might for 2 minutes think my drive is empty, until he checks the other drives, then FDE seems ridiculously terrible.
So I'm hoping I can get some confirmation on this. I am sorry for writing this giant wall of text, but it is confusing to see a split of opinion on this in the Veracrypt threads.
I realize this is super basic stuff, but I also imagine other novices would be confused about this when they are looking into encrypting for the first time, so they might find some benefit to this post. That is especially why I put all this in all this detail, and these hypothetical scenarios, because I'm not actually a 'tech guy', or a 'computer guy' (I've never built a computer or done coding or used Linux), but I imagine many other regular 'non-computer-guys' would wonder about the same things.
The other part of the reason I'm asking for confirmation is because I feel like I must be getting something wrong about the utility of encrypting the full disk. I feel like there must be some amazing benefit to FDE that I'm not understanding, because when I look at all the negatives, I don't really see why anyone would ever do it. So I am fully open to being corrected here.
PS: I know it's weird to put the TL;DR at the top but honestly it makes no sense to me for people to put it at the bottom. As far as I'm concerned it's a million times more useful to redditors if the TL;DR works like an abstract so at a glance they can see if the post is trash or worth reading.
I also wanted to make sure to put a detailed TL;DR at the top because I realize my post is insanely long and I didn't want anyone to waste their time.