Hi everyone! On account of a couple of mums reaching out to me regarding my experience with sleep training, I thought I would turn it into a post so that maybe even MORE mums can get some use out of it.
Perhaps the reason my son was a velcro for the first 7 months of his life had to do with the fact that I damn near refused to put him down when he was born. I laboured for so long and I loved him so much and he was so little, I didn't see any need to! The first week at home, despite having a lovely bassinet, I just couldn't put him in it to sleep, I was so terrified that something would happen if he wasn't in my arms. By the time I was ready to try, maybe the damage was already done. Even when fast asleep, he would be awake within 5 minutes every time. In those first three months, you CANNOT sleep train your baby, no matter what anyone tells you. Certainly some babies just naturally pick up a rhythm, a schedule - maybe by being put down more in the first few days truly makes a difference. But let me stress this:
If your baby is less than three months old, do not attempt to sleep train him or her.
It won't work, it's not fair to your little one, and you will probably go even crazier. Ride out those first three months and then go from there.
Once we made it through those three months of baby M sleeping on me while I dozed upright in bed, I slowly transitioned into bed sharing with both of us lying on our sides, tummy to tummy. It actually worked really, really well for us in the interim before I was ready to start sleep training. In the first month or two of bed sharing, I actually decided that I wouldn't sleep train him, and just let him let me know when he was ready to move. We went to bed around 10 or 11 and would usually sleep until 9 or so, but I would usually wake up once or twice to turn us over.
When he was 6 months old he started tossing and turning. A lot. I woke up every time he so much as flinched or breathed differently, so when the moving around started, my quality of sleep plummeted. Every hour I was waking up because he was trying to roll over or change his position and it was honestly worse than when he was first born. At least then I slept for 2-3 hours at a time because newborns don't move!
One Sunday morning, we woke up after a particularly restless night and thought, "I think I'm over this." I went to visit my friend L and her daughter who is 3 weeks older than my son later that day and she told me about Sleep Sense. I said fuck it, I'm starting tomorrow.
Here is the link to the Sleep Sense PDF.
Our master bedroom is upstairs and the nursery is on the main floor, so we decided to start with baby M in our room in his pack n play. We have a video monitor, but I wasn't ready to have him be that far away just yet. When you read Sleep Sense, you'll find that there are two methods. The first involves you staying in the room while your little one falls asleep, beginning right next to the crib and then slowly over a few weeks moving yourself further and further away until you're out of the room altogether. The other is the leave-and-check, where you put baby to bed, leave the room, and check on him after a set period. We chose the first method.
More than just putting your baby to sleep in a crib or bed, Sleep Sense is about establishing a routine. I'm sure the other systems are too, but I've never read any of the other ones. The book tells you roughly when your baby should be going to sleep. We started the first time around with bedtime routine starting at 7:30, down for sleep at 8. The routine was bath, jammies, stories, kisses, nursing, night night. Obleman (the other) talks in the book about how important it is to BE CONSISTENT. When you decide what your routine will be you, you MUST stick with it. This helps baby understand that the time for sleep is coming! And allows him or her to ease into it.
So we did that the first night. It felt good to start a routine, it felt normal. But then we put baby M into the pack n play and I sat next to him. He wailed for 45 minutes. I asked my husband to come relieve me so that I could go put headphones in and cry because I felt like such an asshole for doing this to my beautiful boy. He cried for another 45 minutes. I was an absolute fucking wreck and told my husband to come downstairs for a minute. He did, and when my husband walked away, my son was asleep within minutes. We stood there with our mouths open in disbelief. It was 9:30 and Miles was asleep and not on me. I didn't know what to do with myself! I watched shows on Netflix and I felt amazing. He woke up in the middle of the night and I think I nursed him, but he was old enough to be going without a night feed so I think I only did that a few times.
We continued on and kept playing with bedtimes to see if one was better than the other. We eventually settled on 6:30 bedtime start, night night at 7. We also had to change the routine itself - baby M was soo tired by the time he was in his pajamas, he wasn't sitting through stories anymore, just squirming and fussing, so we substituted in teeth brushing.
There were a couple of problems at this point though:
He seemed to have plateaued at crying for at least 30 minutes at bedtime. It wasn't getting any shorter.
He was waking up in the middle of the night every single night.
Despite it "working," I was kind of at the end of my rope. It felt like all I did was listen to my kid cry. I was considering looking at other options, until I realized something. In the book, Obleman is very specific about the leave-and-check method. You must choose a period of time to wait in between checks and always be consistent. That's when it dawned on me - I hadn't been using the same amount of time between checks!
It seems arbitrary when using the CIO method, but it is so, so not. Previously in this process, I would go and comfort baby M basically whenever I couldn't listen anymore. I thought the longer I let him cry, the more he would come to understand that I wasn't at his beckon call! I was wrong. After my realization, I decided on 15 minutes between checks.
Day 1, he woke up in the middle of the night for an hour with me going in right when he woke up and then every 15 minutes. Day 2 he woke up for 45 minutes. Day 3 30 minutes. Day 4 15 minutes. Day 5 he slept for 11 hours straight.
Those times aren't exact but it was less and less each night. And when I put him to bed, he started going to sleep very shortly after my first check in. I think he needed that constant reassurance in order to establish his schedule.
My son is a few days away from being 9 months old, and sleeps 11 or 12 hours at night, with a minimum of 2 hours of napping each day. He cries almost every time I put him down, but for about 30 seconds. From 7 pm to 7 am every day I am a normal person again. I get to be a wife and a woman and I have NEVER been happier.
After reading that massive wall of text, here is a condensed list of recommendations I have:
Invest in a white noise machine. The one we bought from Babies R Us was about $70 but it is a godsend. It has a nice blue LED light and has multiple white noise options (we use the waves one), music options, and can have an mp3 player plugged into it. Link to the machine. It's also a great sound buffer if your hangout space is on the same floor as baby's room.
STOP NURSING YOUR BABY TO SLEEP. I know, it fucking sucks. I didn't really touch on that in my humongous blurb but Obleman talks about it in the book, and I can't stress that enough. There is nothing better than having your little one fall asleep in your arms while you nurse them, but that's a big part of why they don't like to be put down and why they wake up in the middle of the night. If your baby is falling asleep while nursing before bed, make sure they're done and then pull 'em off! If baby CANNOT stay awake, maybe try nursing earlier in the routine, like right out of the bath.
Always be consistent. Your bedtime routine needs to be done in the exact same order every night. The time can fluctuate but the series of events needs to be the same (unless you have to change the whole routine for whatever reason), just like your check-ins always need to take place at the same time.
Be strong. It's going to hurt pretty bad at first, you are not going to enjoy listening to your baby cry, but somebody told me this and it made a big difference: Understand that by scooping your darling babe up in your arms when they cry at night isn't rescuing them from anything. It's selling them short! Believe in your son or daughter's ability to do this on their own, because they can. And so can you.
In that vein, try leaving the house when baby goes down. Partners don't have that chemical connection to the sound of your baby crying. Go for a walk or to the market, or even go put some headphones in and listen to something wonderful. It doesn't always have to be you doing the check-ins so let your spouse do some!
LOVE BEDTIME. I look forward to bedtime every night, not just because I am about to get some serious adult time, but because it's so lovely.
I hope you all stuck around for the entirety of this ridiculously long post, and I also hope that some of you feel empowered enough to give this a go yourselves. Please please please feel free to ask any questions or to look me up should you decide to start sleep training and would like some support.
Au revoir et bonne chance!