I finished the game once right after the Bog Witch update and I decided I'd only replay it when 1.0 came out. I did so today using mostly maces and light armor.
First I have to congratulate the developers on this wonderful game. The first one that really took over my life, twice now, in a long time. I really feel it's a timeless masterpiece.
I enjoyed a lot of the things that were added. Some things like bears and trinkets were new to me as they weren't around when I killed Fader years ago. I feel trinkets rarely ever activate and I would rather see them as an accessory, meaning you'd have to take off Megingjord or Wisplight to use them, with either a passive bonus or an ability with a cooldown like a regular Forsaken power.
Speaking of which, the Forsaken powers were reworked but Bonemass is still the best and the one I used most of the time. I used Eikthyr a few times especially in the first half of the game and then Moder when I had a long sea trip. That was it. Maybe if they spread the physical resistances around - Blunt/Slash/Pierce to a different Forsaken each - or if there were a mead that added resistances, like there is for Fire/Frost/Poison, I'd be more inclined to use other powers. Even for Eikthyr's power there is a mead with a related effect (Ratatosk) so there is no need for it anymore.
I enjoyed the forge of potential mechanic, though I preferred it when it was by chance even if it gives room to a little save scumming. Never used it much though because I didn't want to risk getting my stuff broken and dislike looking stuff up.
I really enjoyed the Deep North setting. The petrified trolls you have to blow up were a great idea. Mörkhalla is a great dungeon type, I like them a lot. They add a dungeon crawler vibe that feels really fresh. I like that they brought back the Greydwarfs in a frosty skin. Lore-wise it's very fitting. The boss fight was good, with Kall the Filmburger (as I call him) making a lot of new moves as his health gets lower. The shovel was mostly unnecessary because you can clear the snow by just running around. The casting system for the new gear is okay. I never played much as a mage so I can't say anything to that regard.
What I felt was lacking was the difficulty. I learned to love the constant combat of the Ashlands and honestly the Deep North feels too easy. While the new trolls are much stronger, the Skeletons and Greydwarfs here are just as puny as in the Black Forest. Moose are pretty weak. All the Jotun are also pretty weak. Hexen are just annoying, only have a single very avoidable blast attack with any danger to it. Krigen are easier than Charred Warriors, incredibly telegraphed attacks, slow movement and not a lot of health. Pulps were a joke. The imprisoned dvergr I had to fight after he got in the way of me hitting another enemy was honestly a tougher foe. I rarely ever died in the Deep North - and the first time was to a Fuling I didn't realize had one star and threw a spear at me.
Jotun invasions were incredibly easy too. While trying to get all moulds for a Vanguard set I had to stand there right beside the black ice waiting for more Krigen to spawn. Concept-wise I feel they are a great idea though and I loved it.
So looking at how buffed the Krigen look I think they should have much better stats. Mistlands did it with the constricted visibility and difficult environment, Ashlands did it with enemy numbers, the Deep North should do it with enemy quality. Even in Mörkhallas it was so easy to use the grappling hook - another great addition, I must add - to just ignore the enemies while I Mission Impossible my way in and Spider Man my way out.
The only dangerous enemy was the Barka, especially when you find one in the middle of the woods and can't take a good look at his upper body. The devs shined with this one. But the most difficult enemy was by far the seal. I felt like killing my own pet dog and I'll never forgive the devs for this. Also I won't ever be able to get the Hunter achievement because I outright refuse to kill baby seals.
I wonder how much of the sub agrees with my takes. I avoid coming here too much because 1. spoilers and 2. the builds here make me feel like shit lol.